Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend comment on Russell Brand situation...Not sure how to respond

229 replies

Startingagainandagain · 19/09/2023 12:05

I was messaging a female friend this morning

I was a victim of an assault by a male so called friend last year, which she is aware of.

I mentioned in my message that some of what the victims are saying about Brand resonated so much with me.

In her response she said something in the line of ''well he took on the establishment and now they are trying to hang him''...

This really surprised me as I did not have her down for someone who would fall for that type of nonsense and I am not quite sure how to respond to her.

My view is that the man is a creep and I believe the victims 100% and I am going to struggle with staying friend with someone who would put any weight on conspiracy theories. As someone who has encountered this type of predators, I feel strongly about it all.

Do you think I am unreasonable to think this might be reason enough to distance myself?

This is someone who I have known for a year only, rather than a close, long term friend.

AIBU to cool the friendship over this and let it drift?

OP posts:
Ramalangadingdong · 19/09/2023 16:09

Bananaanaana · 19/09/2023 14:12

Personally I don’t cut off friends based on their beliefs or opinions, unless they bang on and become boring. I judge people on their actions. I used to be more rash when I was younger but over time I’ve realised that people are complex and life is more interesting if the people around you don’t agree with everything you say.

For me, that would be one complexity too far.

If you have been the victim of an assault and have to listen to your friend banging on about a rapist’s innocence then it’s time to back out of the relationship.

Begsthequestion · 19/09/2023 16:08

FeigningConcern · 19/09/2023 14:47

This.

Cutting a (presumably) good friend off because of difference of opinion is ridiculous imo. She may change her opinion over coming weeks or you may be able to get her to see another point of view. Or she may continue to hold a different view but that's people and her prerogative.

I have a friend who believes in conspiracy theories. She doesn't bang on about them but when she brings them up I give her an alternative viewpoint. If everyone cut her off that didn't agree with her she'd end up in an echo chamber.

Having friends that only ever agree with you leads to similar and the issues we have currently with entrenched views and people being completely unable to countenance differing viewpoints. Whatever happened to passionate debate amongst friends!

Some of us have better things to do than hang out and "passionately debate" with rape apologists and conspiracy theorists though. And that's ok.

My life is not a sixth form debate club.

anotherside · 19/09/2023 16:08

One thing I don’t get about Brand is that anyone you speak to will describe him as a bit of an oddball and creepy, dirty looking, foul mouthed etc - even people who are/were fans of his standup/channel. And yet the guy has consensually slept with literally 100s of women. So what gives. Just fame/power as the ultimate aphrodisiac?

borninthe80esss · 19/09/2023 16:07

I've been in this situation.. I find peoples
Comments around rape very triggering and the shit I've read over the weekend has been disgusting. I don't tell many people about my experiences with rape but when I've heard comments like what your describing it makes me completely back off.. With me it's luckily never happened with a real friend more work colleagues who before I'd heard there opinions I'd be more friendly but once I've heard it I will be civil and that's it.
It goes to against my own moral code and I don't think I should have to tell my rape story.. More that people should educate themselves on the statistics of rape before they spout their ignorance.
Maybe message your friend and say .. Im aware that you know I'm a victim of SA so why did you think it was acceptable to talk like that around me. Or chalk her down as an insensitive cow and make nicer friends.

Siameasy · 19/09/2023 16:06

I wouldn’t end a friendship over that. Some of my friends have opinions that I consider outrageous and sometimes I’m the outrageous one. Who is to say you’re right? You just have the “correct” opinion on Mumsnet.

Ramalangadingdong · 19/09/2023 16:06

lemmein · 19/09/2023 12:13

Both can be true.

He can be both a predator and a problematic gobshite with millions of followers.

I absolutely believe those women; I also believe if RB was just still telling 'jokes' and not poking his nose into the grubbiness of world affairs we wouldn't know the women's stories.

Interesting. I hadn’t thought of it this way. It makes sense. Very depressing.

However it seems that op’s friend thinks only one of those things is true, so I think op should ditch her.

Mangolover123 · 19/09/2023 16:06

"Believe all women' sounds great until your son, or husband or father or friend is accused of something they didn't do. I think it's important to keep an open mind, and it doesn't make some a rape apologist, or anti feminist or any of those other terms that are used to silence people with an alternative viewpoint"

I think the above is spot on.
Not all women tell the complete truth unfortunately or have their own narrative.
I am seeing a hounding play out which is truly worrying. Where she hits out at him and screams it is him doing the abusing.

Having said that RB is a sleezeball with very questionable morals. As to a rapist, I think we need to leave that to the police and jury to decide. There have been so many complaints, his life and his career are over, there is little chance of a comeback. So that is a good thing.

Bristolnewcomer · 19/09/2023 16:05

Sorry OP in answer to your question you are perfectly entitled to distance yourself. But if you think she's generally nice and might listen, you could counter what she's said by saying "That's one point of view but I can tell you from my own experience that many men do behave like this and get away with it, so I believe the women who've come forward."

anotherside · 19/09/2023 16:05

Yes he did it but if he wasn't spouting these views on YouTube then this would still be an open secret

Agree. But in the end his own history has come to bite him in the ass - ie he’s always been deliberately provocative, made jokes in terrible taste and obviously slept with literally 100s of women. Even assuming he isn’t a rapist, in order to do all that and NOT one day be headline news for the wrong reasons your behaviour would need to be exemplary. IE no sleeping with work colleagues, no kinky sex, no drug parties, no dumping partners by text or ghosting them when bored. I guess he thought his incorrectly assumed his celebrity and contacts would protest him from the messy fall out. And as others have suggested - perhaps it would have done - had he not set up a fairly high profile Yuotube channel which was growing by 1-2 million subscribers per year, and banging on about the vaccines, Biden, Gates, the mainstream media etc etc

LifeIsPeachy8 · 19/09/2023 16:05

@Gnomegnomegnome I fail to see the relevance tbh. The OPs personal experience is awful but has no bearing on the RB situation.

MisschiefMaker · 19/09/2023 16:05

lemmein · 19/09/2023 12:13

Both can be true.

He can be both a predator and a problematic gobshite with millions of followers.

I absolutely believe those women; I also believe if RB was just still telling 'jokes' and not poking his nose into the grubbiness of world affairs we wouldn't know the women's stories.

This is what I think too.

Maybe the OP wants to clarify with her friend whether she thinks like us - that the concerted effort to have his social media blocked and reputation tarnished is primarily politically driven, or if she also thinks the women are lying. Because that might make a difference as to how she feels about it.

Gnomegnomegnome · 19/09/2023 16:05

@Maddy70 yeah, let’s blame the victims. They had a choice! Hmm

Bristolnewcomer · 19/09/2023 16:03

Ilinaya · 19/09/2023 15:47

This is a good point. Broadcasters don't do it because they 'care'.
They would have known the programme would make them a lot of money, but not enough to fund the research. Who funded it? I would genuinely like to know, and I work in the media and am still clueless. Anyone know?

Really? If you work in the media you should know that investigative journalists/programmes often follow stories for years before being able to publish/broadcast. They work on lots of stories at once because they don't always know when they'll get to a point where they feel they have enough info/evidence/witnesses to avoid being taken straight to court by the person or organisation being accused. Some stories come together quickly and others take a long, long time. Investigative programmes and papers fund their journalists to do this work or they'd never have anything to put on the telly/in the paper.

Gnomegnomegnome · 19/09/2023 16:03

LifeIsPeachy8 · 19/09/2023 15:59

Meh. If I ditched everyone whose opinion I didn't agree with, I'd have no friends at all. Your friend is entitled to her opinion and seems odd to lose a friend because you don't agree with her.

Regardless of how bad it looks, RB hasn't yet been charged/convicted of any crime - that doesn't necessarily make someone an apologist or conspiracy nut, it can just means they are waiting to see the results of a proper police investigation.

It’s a bit different to having a friend that is a Tory for example. Did you read the op? Do you understand that she was assaulted?

Maddy70 · 19/09/2023 16:01

Both may be true. Every single female that went to his place knew what was in the press , knew he was a narcissist and a misogynist but the lure of power and fame is intoxicating. They went willingly by their own admission. What happened after that is subjective and for the courts not speculation He has also put himself in a position in the media where they want him shut down.

No way would I have gone back to his room . I was in those circles at the time, But you didn't need to be. Every paper carried stories of his promiscuity and misogyny and he was very vocal publicly about it.

Choices were made there

LifeIsPeachy8 · 19/09/2023 15:59

Meh. If I ditched everyone whose opinion I didn't agree with, I'd have no friends at all. Your friend is entitled to her opinion and seems odd to lose a friend because you don't agree with her.

Regardless of how bad it looks, RB hasn't yet been charged/convicted of any crime - that doesn't necessarily make someone an apologist or conspiracy nut, it can just means they are waiting to see the results of a proper police investigation.

Boomboom22 · 19/09/2023 15:58

@lemmein has it. Yes he did it but if he wasn't spouting these views on YouTube then this would still be an open secret.

MartinChuzzlewit · 19/09/2023 15:56

Oh OP that’s really shit.

Im so sorry.

As a fellow survivor, times like this are very hard - but you can’t control other people’s opinions and, well, as my mum says - when people show you who they are, believe them.

Wanderingowl · 19/09/2023 15:54

lemmein · 19/09/2023 12:13

Both can be true.

He can be both a predator and a problematic gobshite with millions of followers.

I absolutely believe those women; I also believe if RB was just still telling 'jokes' and not poking his nose into the grubbiness of world affairs we wouldn't know the women's stories.

I suspect that this is exactly what is happening.

Orangebadger · 19/09/2023 15:53

I think having a difference of opinion with a friend generally speaking is fine. But you mention that you have been a victim of sexual assault yourself, so it sounds like her views are a trigger for you rather than something you can just ignore and move on from. Maybe ask her to clarify what she means though? She may believe the women but see it as the people industry that essentially enabled him is out to hang him now?

TorqueWrench · 19/09/2023 15:50

Namechangedtoanswerthisone · 19/09/2023 15:17

Rape apologists are everywhere including friends as you have found out. Your friend doesn't understand and because she has heard the 'he's famous and so he is being silenced etc narrative' she is following along with that without actually considering how hard it is for a woman to actually speak up about rape or sexual assault. especially when idiots and vile people assume they are lying.

Is she a rape apologist though if she doesn't believe him to actually be a rapist?

Ilinaya · 19/09/2023 15:47

DoormatBob · 19/09/2023 15:43

I expect the allegations are true but whilst I'm not a 'conspiracy theorist' who funded a 4 year investigation and why?

This is a good point. Broadcasters don't do it because they 'care'.
They would have known the programme would make them a lot of money, but not enough to fund the research. Who funded it? I would genuinely like to know, and I work in the media and am still clueless. Anyone know?

Gnomegnomegnome · 19/09/2023 15:46

Yanbu. I think the best response would be to either block or simply, ‘Goodbye’.

Ilinaya · 19/09/2023 15:44

moneyplantnation · 19/09/2023 15:36

@Startingagainandagain Quite simply he is a well known popular figure and people are blinded by his celebrity status and a lot still fancy him. If this had been some one unpopular like Matt Hancock or Boris Johnson no one would be defending him.

You can call it a media trial all you like but I fail to see how so many women can all be lying or exaggerating going on all his past comments and actions.

Id say dump your friend and let her live out her fantasy with the creep.

I am not convinced either way. I think the chances are these women are telling the truth but I cannot be sure.
The reason for this is because he has openly slept with thousands of women and was known for pursuing women just for sex, so in my mind there will be at least a few, probably more than a few that are angry and vengeful, and also money in it for coming forward with a story.
I believe he was misogynistic (clearly!) And a creep and inappropriate, and lots of other nasty adjectives, but I cannot be sure he is a rapist without sitting on a jury, and even then it isn't easy to know. It certainly isn't possible to know based on some accounts of people whose names we aren't even aware of, without ever hearing two sides to the story.
'Believe all women' sounds great until your son, or husband or father or friend is accused of something they didnt do. I think it's important to keep an open mind, and it doesn't make some a rape apologist, or anti feminist or any of those other terms that are used to silence people with an alternative viewpoint.

bombastix · 19/09/2023 15:44

Your friend is an idiot. To herself and to you. I would just avoid this conversation and think carefully if you like her company

Swipe left for the next trending thread