Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

NHS shouldn't have to treat gang members / criminals

260 replies

Sellias · 19/09/2023 11:52

I live in a city with lots of crime (drugs, gangs, knife crime)

Groups of idiots 'beefing' with other groups of idiots over postcodes, selling drugs on eachothers patch and perceived disrespect over the silliest of things leading to murder.

I recently watched a documentary about knife crime and it got me thinking about what a terrible state our NHS is in and how people like cancer patients, people with heart problems etc are waiting far too long for treatment to the extent that they can and do die before their treatment even begins.

..these gang idiots though, if they stab or shoot one another an ambulance is called and they get rushed to hospital. It's all hands on deck to save them. Seriously ill people have their much needed surgery cancelled because this stab victim (who sells drugs and causes endless harm in their community) is deemed to need treatment more than they are.

AIBU to think if they chose to live that way then the NHS should have no obligation to treat them? Let them pay for their own treatment with their ill gotten gains.

Disclaimer, I'm not talking about children who of course we should do all we can to save.

I know these people make up only a small percentage of those requiring urgent treatment but it really pisses me off that they bring it on themselves by living the life they do and then expect the tax payer (having never paid tax in their lives)

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 19/09/2023 13:34

FloweryName · 19/09/2023 12:02

If they are over 18 and A&E is busy, I think others should be prioritised over people who have chosen to be involved with violence, but that means a longer wait, not refusal of treatment because that would be inhumane.

The delay of treatment could mean complications arise, so rather than a patch up, it's an admittance. Or complications further on. Where do we put those who live with someone who is violent? Do they get one treatment ticket and if they won't leave, bottom of the queue? What about the parent who won't phone the police on their mentally ill child and gets attacked? Why just gang violence, car accidents, burns, should be under the same system.
Two women shot dead on Merseyside, one was involved (by association) in drug dealing, one wasn't. How do we delay treatment finding out?
We need early intervention in most gang members, not second class citizen status. This would turn into a race issue and also a age issue. All it would do is make those young people feel more disconnected from society and get an even more "fuck the establishment" attitude.

PomegranateRose · 19/09/2023 13:32

I am a nurse. My job is not to treat only the people I sympathise with or feel "deserve" it, and if such personal attitudes begin to influence how I do my job, then I will know I need to seek help or step away. When I am at work I don't really "see" what people have done or how their injury occurred etc. beyond the implications for their assessment, treatment and safeguarding. I see a need that must be met and a life that we have to do all we can to preserve and improve.

While I understand the intended rationale in terms of allocating resources to the perceived greatest good, any real entertaining of this idea goes against the principles of healthcare on the ground imo, and such thought processes are why I have no desire to go into management at the level of deciding who gets what funding etc. I did not go into this sector to cherry pick who I treat, nor would I want to entrust the care of a family member to someone with that mindset, regardless of the fact that they have "paid in" and don't "deserve" their illness or injury etc. - it is simply, in my opinion, the very antithesis of what medicine exists for.

KimKardashiansKarpetKrab · 19/09/2023 13:29

AIBU to think if they chose to live that way

People in gangs don't choose to live that way.

They live that way because they have no other choice.

Try growing up on a sink estate in Peckham with your dad in prison and your mum on crack. See how many options you have when every time you step outside, the police are racially profiling you and the local gangs are threatening to stab you or your family.

Lots of kids are recruited into gangs at 12/13 to run drugs. They're threatened into doing it. It's a case of 'take these drugs to this place or I'll cut your sister'.

If something doesn't make sense to you, perhaps be curious enough to wonder what it is maybe that you're not understanding before you write posts on the internet about how some elements of society should be left to die.

MartinChuzzlewit · 19/09/2023 13:27

I’m also wondering how it would work on a practical level OP.

Say a teenage boy come win with stab wounds. Surgeons have minutes to save him. How do they figure out if he’s a worthy save? His skin colour? Wait for a DBS check? Ask whoever he came in with and be ready to have a patient die if that person is wrong?

tell us

Lovemusic82 · 19/09/2023 13:27

I don’t agree with OP.
Everyone should be treated equally, the NHS are not in a position to decide who is a criminal and who isn’t, there’s no time to determine this anyway? If your son/daughter was involved in a stabbing you wouldn’t want people standing around deciding if they deserved it or not? Nurses/doctors and ambulance crew treat everyone as equals, it’s their job.

Saschka · 19/09/2023 13:27

What I am mostly getting here, is that people want their own healthcare to be free and easy to access, but don’t want to pay for anyone else’s healthcare, especially if their needs are high 🤔

TussleBack · 19/09/2023 13:25

IMustDoMoreExercise · 19/09/2023 13:09

Yes, definitely heavy drinkers and vapers.

People who don't care about their health should not get priority.

Ah yes. All those people who aren't middle-class, haven't been socialised or educated about health problems in the way that richer people are, and are also not given any financial or educational help to enact healthy lifestyles which can be very directly nothing they've ever been exposed to or known or what can be accessed in their communities.

And every sociological study says that poor/low socio economic status people are disproportionately effected in not only health issues, but health education and NHS health care. And BME communities are more likely to be members of that group.

So you want poor people, including disproportionate numbers of non-white and non- English white people to receive poorer health care because they don't care about their health?

Got it.

Saschka · 19/09/2023 13:25

Doctors have an ethical obligation to treat anyone who needs treatment, based on the Hippocratic Oath.

You know the only ones who didn't take that oath? Medical students in Nazi Germany.

That’s not actually true - very few, if any, UK medical schools make their students swear it. Have you read the Hippocratic Oath? Bans surgery and abortion services, amongst other things, as well as having a weird focus on sharing your income with your bosses, and prioritising the children of other doctors for medical training.

UK doctors follow Duties of a Doctor.

MartinChuzzlewit · 19/09/2023 13:24

YABVU

healthcare is a human right. It should stay that way, always, even for the bad humans. It’s the only way to operate

If we start making a charter about Bad People who Don’t Deserve Treatment then it’s a gateway to an Orwellian world. And before long you could find yourself linked in based on someone thinking your actions or opinion is wrong. Do you REALLY want that?

Hobnobswantshernameback · 19/09/2023 13:23

I sometimes think this place has displayed peak stupidity
And then along comes anything level

JusyBraise · 19/09/2023 13:23

Sellias · 19/09/2023 12:06

Yes I think this is a much less draconian way to put it.

I can see its a unanimous IABU, I will accept that.

My apologies. My view has been coloured by living in the type of environment described in my OP and also having family members health decline terribly in the wait for treatment, leading to death in one case.

As I said, just thinking out loud.

You profess to know about this 'type of environment' - but honestly, if you think people are calling ambulances every time someone gets stabbed etc you are wrong. Only the worst cases end up in A&E, a lot of people involved in organised crime patch themselves up as best they can and try to move on. No one wants to go near the authorities - and this includes hospitals - unless they have to.

You should really be blaming the politicians who insisted on the grinding austerity that has decimated the NHS for your family member's death. But hey - let's just do a little thinking out loud about denying people treatment 🙄

BMW6 · 19/09/2023 13:21

Nah OP, you're over complicating it.

It would be far better if all these drug dealers and gang members were simply rounded up regularly and "disappeared". The local Police know exactly who is and where they are.

Crazy to wait for them to rock up to A&E!

vibecheck · 19/09/2023 13:16

It’s so interesting when people post things like this, as I think the crux of their argument is that there shouldn’t be an NHS. If you think that gang members, or “fat people”, or smokers or alcoholics or people who extreme sports shouldn’t have their injuries or illnesses treated on the NHS for free, you are against the basic principles of the NHS.

Now, I am also of the opinion the NHS shouldn’t be the healthcare model in this country, but often the people posting these things would consider themselves very pro-NHS. It’s just a very interesting contradiction at the heart of a lot of pro-NHS people’s opinions and suggestions for helping the service at the moment.

LetMeEnfoldYou · 19/09/2023 13:14

Don't be daft 🤨

Begsthequestion · 19/09/2023 13:13

Doctors have an ethical obligation to treat anyone who needs treatment, based on the Hippocratic Oath.

You know the only ones who didn't take that oath? Medical students in Nazi Germany.

Seriously.

Your idea is not only astoundingly unethical, it's completely impracticable.

I honestly wonder what some people are teaching their kids when I see posts like this. Almost makes me think there should be some kind of mandatory parenting course for people so ignorant of how society works.

therealcookiemonster · 19/09/2023 13:11

err.... are you OK?

any kind of differentiation in providing medical care is a slippery slope

by all means bung them in jail afterwards

but can't deny medical care especially life saving medical care

HateMyRubbishBoss · 19/09/2023 13:10

on a second thought, for child molestors YANBU! But that’s about it ….

IMustDoMoreExercise · 19/09/2023 13:09

GabriellaMontez · 19/09/2023 12:47

Shall we add smokers and drinkers to your list?

Yes, definitely heavy drinkers and vapers.

People who don't care about their health should not get priority.

AgeingDoc · 19/09/2023 13:08

Lots of people present with illnesses or injuries that are the result of illegal, immoral or unwise actions, or at least have been contributed to by their own poor decisions. If you start rationing care on the basis of moral judgment where do you stop?
I've spent many a night up all night in theatres and or/ICU with critically injured or ill people who I know are almost certainly going to go right back to the lifestyle that put them there in the first place. When I was a senior registrar in a big city hospital there was a phase when if you got through a night without dealing with a drugs related shooting or stabbing (machetes were the gangs' weapon of choice at the time) it was an event. There were times when the scheduling of theatre lists had to take into account which gang patients were in so that members of rival gangs weren't in adjacent beds in recovery as that could be dangerous. I have treated people who were in police custody for violent crimes, people who have been attacked or attempted to take their own lives in prison, people where the police have insisted on remaining present until the patient was anaesthetised because they were concerned for my safety, and so on. Not pleasant, but it's not my job to judge who is worthy of care. That's a very slippery slope. Yes, of course I have personal views on patients and their lifestyles. I'm a human being and we all make judgements based on our own values. That's inevitable, but those personal feelings have to stay exactly that - personal. We must treat according to clinical need and to the best of our ability regardless of the individual's background.

User57632678374 · 19/09/2023 13:06

So if someone in the street is found stabbed or shot do you think the paramedics should stand there and carry out an evaluation into if they think it’s gang related or a random attack before proceeding with treatment? If a family member or friend of yours was in that situation would you want that delay in treatment on the off chance it’s gang related, as obviously they would need to treat all incidents the same, right?

And then I guess we should also extend the same to people who have accidents when they are drunk, don’t look before crossing the road, go outside when it’s snowing, ride bikes without crash helmets and jump into rivers during heatwaves….

pinkpanther2023 · 19/09/2023 13:05

Exactly. What about people who take part in risky extreme sport or are speeding in a car and get injured. Impossible to draw the line….

HohiyiKozbevi · 19/09/2023 13:05

We should put "anyone who has ever voted Conservative" on the "doesn't deserve treatment" list.

@Sellias You do realise that it's a totally different part of the hospital, set of doctors and pool of resources that treat cancer patients vs A&E trauma, don't you? On a miracle day where there wasn't one single violent crime or gang incident, there wouldn't be any additional resources available for the chronically sick.

willingtolearn · 19/09/2023 13:04

Some of those people in gangs or criminals have had horrendous lives and are doing what circumstances/decisions when young have led them to.

Being treated with care, respect and compassion by the NHS might be one of the only times that they experience this in their lives.

I don't begrudge them that as long as they aren't abusive whilst being treated or waiting for treatment.

WhiteFire · 19/09/2023 13:00

This argument is age old, I remember in one of my university interviews almost 30 years ago having to discuss about who, if anyone, should get priority for an organ donation.

The difficulty is once you start giving one group less priority or reduce access to treatment it will be evermore extended. Treatment has to decided on immediate need not the worthiness of who is needing it.

It's a good discussion to have, just not on here.

Saschka · 19/09/2023 13:00

NotReallySureWhatToThink · 19/09/2023 11:56

No. Just no.

All the obvious moral reasons aside it's completely unworkable.

How would the paramedics or A&E staff know if it was an actual gang member or just a case of mistaken identity for a start? Or would it just come down to how dark their skin is and how shiny their trainers are Hmm

I suspect this is what it comes down to - saving a young black teenager’s life being seen as less worthwhile than a nice white middle class pensioner’s hip replacement. Abhorrent.