Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

NHS shouldn't have to treat gang members / criminals

260 replies

Sellias · 19/09/2023 11:52

I live in a city with lots of crime (drugs, gangs, knife crime)

Groups of idiots 'beefing' with other groups of idiots over postcodes, selling drugs on eachothers patch and perceived disrespect over the silliest of things leading to murder.

I recently watched a documentary about knife crime and it got me thinking about what a terrible state our NHS is in and how people like cancer patients, people with heart problems etc are waiting far too long for treatment to the extent that they can and do die before their treatment even begins.

..these gang idiots though, if they stab or shoot one another an ambulance is called and they get rushed to hospital. It's all hands on deck to save them. Seriously ill people have their much needed surgery cancelled because this stab victim (who sells drugs and causes endless harm in their community) is deemed to need treatment more than they are.

AIBU to think if they chose to live that way then the NHS should have no obligation to treat them? Let them pay for their own treatment with their ill gotten gains.

Disclaimer, I'm not talking about children who of course we should do all we can to save.

I know these people make up only a small percentage of those requiring urgent treatment but it really pisses me off that they bring it on themselves by living the life they do and then expect the tax payer (having never paid tax in their lives)

OP posts:
clashok · 19/09/2023 14:02

Sellias · 19/09/2023 11:58

They're not the ones hurting m one another though are they?

You're saying drug dealers don't hurt anyone?

TussleBack · 19/09/2023 13:59

KimKardashiansKarpetKrab · 19/09/2023 13:29

AIBU to think if they chose to live that way

People in gangs don't choose to live that way.

They live that way because they have no other choice.

Try growing up on a sink estate in Peckham with your dad in prison and your mum on crack. See how many options you have when every time you step outside, the police are racially profiling you and the local gangs are threatening to stab you or your family.

Lots of kids are recruited into gangs at 12/13 to run drugs. They're threatened into doing it. It's a case of 'take these drugs to this place or I'll cut your sister'.

If something doesn't make sense to you, perhaps be curious enough to wonder what it is maybe that you're not understanding before you write posts on the internet about how some elements of society should be left to die.

You have a point in some cases.

And I work with young people from this demographic.

But the drug laws we have in this country mean that drug dealing is incredibly lucrative. And you may be exploited into it in the 1st place and decide to stay and exploit others or decide to leave. Or just don't get involved in the 1st place.

But it isn't as simple as poverty-stricken disadvantaged people becoming involved. If it was, then prison officers, Police officers, Dr's etc wouldn't be involved.

It is extremely lucrative. Thomas Cashman who was convicted of murdering Olivia Pratt- Korbel is a white confessed drug-dealer who said he was making 3-5k a week dealing cannabis.

I think it's likely he was dealing class A but who knows? What we do know is he was making money from dealing drugs that affording him a lifestyle where he was not living in poverty and not working but renting a half a million pound house in Liverpool and his partner turned up to court every day in designer gear.

If you're 13/14/15 or even older, not that well educated and aren't ever going to get a job which will give you a gangster/dealer lifestyle. What would you be drawn to?

Willowview · 19/09/2023 13:56

Such a nonsensical approach OP,

Yet, will the distinction between available treatment and bleeding out be so far removed in the not too distant future?

The deciding factor though could be money, not morals and ethics.

Some comments could be applied to the privatisation of the NHS, and the people who could be left to suffer.

Some hilarious replies, especially the brain transplant one.

NowYouSee · 19/09/2023 13:55

Aside from all the practicalities, determining emergency treatment on the basis of moral worth is a very slippery slope.

If I have a broken ankle from falling over whilst horribly drunk should I be denied treatment that I would get it if broke it playing sport? After all drunken behaviour blights many town and city centres late at night.

If I have a heart attack after a lifetime where I smoke, drink heavily and am morbidly obese does that make me less worthy of treatment than a slim teetotal non smoker? Even though I knew I would harm myself by behaving that way and I could have reduced my chances with better health choices? Where do you stop?

but look I get it OP. It is wildly annoying to have resources used up like you’re seeing and I suspect nobody feels that more strongly than the practitioners dealing with it.

Begsthequestion · 19/09/2023 13:54

Saschka · 19/09/2023 13:43

I read where you said “You know the only ones who didn't take that oath? Medical students in Nazi Germany”. Which is untrue. Maybe read your own posts before arguing with me?

As in, they didn't take the oath (when doctors elsewhere did in the 1940s).

Sorry I was assuming a level of reading comprehension that would negate such pedantry, but I hope you understand what I meant now.

OneTwoThreeShake · 19/09/2023 13:53

Rhys Jones was killed by a gang member in an area where gang activity is fairly rife.

It wasn't until after the event that the facts were established. So if he hadn't died immediately, he'd have been pushed down the list in A&E because people may have assumed he was related to gangs in some way.

Doesn't sound exactly right or fair to me.

Lemonyfuckit · 19/09/2023 13:53

(But I suppose I do concede you're just venting. I get it, it's frustrating and upsetting when you have family members waiting totally unreasonable amounts of time for treatment, with an underfunded and crumbling NHS, and people making more work/taking up resources because of their criminal activity).

MabelMaybe · 19/09/2023 13:52

You know that convicted prisoners are transferred in handcuffs for medical treatment in hospital, right? Hospital care is for everyone.

If you're saying these are essentially self-inflicted, and therefore not worthy of treatment, you're opening a door to smokers, speeding drivers, alcoholics. Should they similarly not be treated?

To my mind, young men involved in these sort of activities need treatment and rehabilitation, not leaving to bleed.

PinkRoses1245 · 19/09/2023 13:52

YABU, how on earth would this work in practise? Totally impossible, and unethical. Where do you draw the line - do you not treat someone who’s a smoker? Or someone who is morbidly obse?

Nam3chang384 · 19/09/2023 13:51

DoorStopper · 19/09/2023 13:50

Well I imagine that the op would have them all branded with hot irons in case they ever needed medical help. Makes it easier for paramedics to know whose what too.
Like, I don't know...a GM burnt onto their chest for gang member?

😂

Nam3chang384 · 19/09/2023 13:51

Have you thought for a second about how impractical this is?

DoorStopper · 19/09/2023 13:50

MartinChuzzlewit · 19/09/2023 13:27

I’m also wondering how it would work on a practical level OP.

Say a teenage boy come win with stab wounds. Surgeons have minutes to save him. How do they figure out if he’s a worthy save? His skin colour? Wait for a DBS check? Ask whoever he came in with and be ready to have a patient die if that person is wrong?

tell us

Well I imagine that the op would have them all branded with hot irons in case they ever needed medical help. Makes it easier for paramedics to know whose what too.
Like, I don't know...a GM burnt onto their chest for gang member?

Lemonyfuckit · 19/09/2023 13:49

Aside from being ethically wrong, your idea is just completely unworkable (how do the medical teams know who is a naughty gang member not deserving of medical treatment (and have they been tried and convicted yet?) and who is an innocent victim, in the heat of the medical emergency? Also people are treated for stab/gunshot wounds by completely different teams of medical staff to those treating cancer patients. So it's not as if if they refuse this person brought on with a gunshot wound they'll go and start someone else's chemotherapy sooner or operate on your auntie Doreen who's waiting for her hip replacement).

So 10/10 for stupidity really.

OneTwoThreeShake · 19/09/2023 13:49

If a cancer patient is stabbed they'll receive the same treatment as a gang member who is stabbed.

Medical resources for cancer patients by and large don't come from emergency or critical care.

Our health service treats without prejudice, rightly.

And if payment of taxes is your threshold, what about those who don't work, or below the income tax barrier? What about children who are yet to pay a penny in tax?

LostThestral · 19/09/2023 13:48

where do you draw the line?

Should the person who falls off a horse not be treated because they live that lifestyle?

Or the person who is obese not get treatment because it's their choice to be overweight?

How about the alcoholic with liver disease or the smoker with lung cancer?

Ponoka7 · 19/09/2023 13:44

GKD · 19/09/2023 12:29

Do you really think the drug honchos aren’t hurting each other?

They might not be stabbing each other on the High Street but I guarantee they are ordering harm to those who have stepped out of line/recruiting soldiers to protect patches.

Its not unusual for them to get shot every so often either.

or have I watched too many Guy Ritchie films?

So the Olivia shooting in Liverpool, quite rightly Olivia got rushed to hospital, but her Mother shouldn't have been until it could be shown that she wasn't involved in drugs/guns?

Saschka · 19/09/2023 13:43

Begsthequestion · 19/09/2023 13:40

Who said anyone swears an oath these days?

Please read my post properly before responding.

I read where you said “You know the only ones who didn't take that oath? Medical students in Nazi Germany”. Which is untrue. Maybe read your own posts before arguing with me?

Ponoka7 · 19/09/2023 13:42

This reply has been deleted

This user is a troll so we've removed their threads and posts.

We all pay tax. Dealers either money launder (so tax is paid), or spend. The spending raises revenue and generates tax.

Begsthequestion · 19/09/2023 13:40

Saschka · 19/09/2023 13:25

Doctors have an ethical obligation to treat anyone who needs treatment, based on the Hippocratic Oath.

You know the only ones who didn't take that oath? Medical students in Nazi Germany.

That’s not actually true - very few, if any, UK medical schools make their students swear it. Have you read the Hippocratic Oath? Bans surgery and abortion services, amongst other things, as well as having a weird focus on sharing your income with your bosses, and prioritising the children of other doctors for medical training.

UK doctors follow Duties of a Doctor.

Who said anyone swears an oath these days?

Please read my post properly before responding.

PomegranateRose · 19/09/2023 13:39

Ffghhhbdbfb · 19/09/2023 13:37

The NHS has to be universal. The problem is with policing. The drug and violence problem is not being effectively countered.

I would argue that the policing isn't the root issue either - it is the societal issues like deprivation that lead to many (most?) drug and violence problems. But that's a whole other thread!

The NHS absolutely does need to be universal and anyone working within it who would like to pick and choose who/what they treat depending on "deservingness" needs to reassess whether they belong in the job imo.

TussleBack · 19/09/2023 13:39

vibecheck · 19/09/2023 13:16

It’s so interesting when people post things like this, as I think the crux of their argument is that there shouldn’t be an NHS. If you think that gang members, or “fat people”, or smokers or alcoholics or people who extreme sports shouldn’t have their injuries or illnesses treated on the NHS for free, you are against the basic principles of the NHS.

Now, I am also of the opinion the NHS shouldn’t be the healthcare model in this country, but often the people posting these things would consider themselves very pro-NHS. It’s just a very interesting contradiction at the heart of a lot of pro-NHS people’s opinions and suggestions for helping the service at the moment.

100%.

The NHS as it was set up does not serve as it used to. Because it cannot. Because there are hundreds of other conditions that did not exist (or were hidden) in the 1940s and on the whole, people died a lot sooner.

But the premise at the time was free healthcare from cradle to grave because previously, poor people couldn't afford to give birth with complications or have very easily treatable conditions treated so people died.

It was a wonderful idea and worked for many years and does need adjusting now

But there are far too many people who think that they've paid tax and therefore they get to have an opinion on who is worthy or not of medical treatment.

And believing in the NHS means you believe in it for all, not just who you think is worthy.

And..paying tax doesn't give you a say that should be listened to about who you think is worthy of healthcare or not. You can vote for a political party that makes those decisions, thats the extent of democracy. You get to vote for a party that you think reflects your views, you don't get to try to impose them otherwise.

ChocolateRaisin09 · 19/09/2023 13:37

🤣 someone skipped ethics class

LolaSmiles · 19/09/2023 13:37

I think it's a slippery slop denying life saving care and health treatment based on whether we agree with someone or not.

It opens the doors for saying "sorry son, you can't have medical treatment free at the point of delivery because you knew the risk of playing football" or "you might have been at the wrong place a the wrong time, but you know what drunks are like so no free treatment for you either. You should have stayed in".

Ffghhhbdbfb · 19/09/2023 13:37

The NHS has to be universal. The problem is with policing. The drug and violence problem is not being effectively countered.

Towdalinenow · 19/09/2023 13:34

You cannot be serious? Don’t be so ridiculous!

If someone is critically ill and near death they jump the queue. It doesn’t matter who they are, what they’ve done, they are human beings first who medics need to save and that’s all that matters in that moment.