Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

NHS shouldn't have to treat gang members / criminals

260 replies

Sellias · 19/09/2023 11:52

I live in a city with lots of crime (drugs, gangs, knife crime)

Groups of idiots 'beefing' with other groups of idiots over postcodes, selling drugs on eachothers patch and perceived disrespect over the silliest of things leading to murder.

I recently watched a documentary about knife crime and it got me thinking about what a terrible state our NHS is in and how people like cancer patients, people with heart problems etc are waiting far too long for treatment to the extent that they can and do die before their treatment even begins.

..these gang idiots though, if they stab or shoot one another an ambulance is called and they get rushed to hospital. It's all hands on deck to save them. Seriously ill people have their much needed surgery cancelled because this stab victim (who sells drugs and causes endless harm in their community) is deemed to need treatment more than they are.

AIBU to think if they chose to live that way then the NHS should have no obligation to treat them? Let them pay for their own treatment with their ill gotten gains.

Disclaimer, I'm not talking about children who of course we should do all we can to save.

I know these people make up only a small percentage of those requiring urgent treatment but it really pisses me off that they bring it on themselves by living the life they do and then expect the tax payer (having never paid tax in their lives)

OP posts:
Anetra · 19/09/2023 15:02

NHS is for everyone. There are no caveats

beAsensible1 · 19/09/2023 15:01

Sellias · 19/09/2023 11:58

They're not the ones hurting m one another though are they?

they're the main culprits. who do you think gives the orders its not the 15 year olds being stabbed and chased.

its the nice quiet guy in cheshire with his kids in private school and mum is a SAHM.

but the young kids in deprivation and poverty who are groomed into violence are the once who should die on the street and don't deserve care.

literalviolence · 19/09/2023 15:00

Should people who don't eat their 5 and and eat enough fibre be treated?

dressedforcomfort · 19/09/2023 14:59

YABVU

In that moment of emergency, how can anyone possibly tell if someone is complicit in criminal activity or just happens to be an innocent person in the wrong place at the wrong time? Plenty of people have been accidentally shot or stabbed... Are first responders meant to make that decision - playing God with someone's life a bit, don't you think?

mondaytosunday · 19/09/2023 14:57

My father worked in a state hospital where the majority of ER patients had gun or stabbing or other violent wounds. Is he supposed to ask were they the victim or perpetrator? Are they a gang member or innocent bystander? If they aren't responsible have they been in the past?
Oh and you miss pregnant - is it your husbands or did you cheat with your best friends boyfriend? And you with cancer - did you smoke a pack a day or just unlucky or live in a high pollution zone or or or...
You treat the patient, you don't pass moral judgements.
You can't gatekeep - not treating a burglar for falling off a roof and breaking his leg does not mean going to mean the little girl hit by a car is going to be treated faster or better.

saoirse31 · 19/09/2023 14:56

Everyone deserves health care

saoirse31 · 19/09/2023 14:55

My personal opinion is that there's something beyond disgustingly amoral about thinking that 'you' have the right to decide who deserves healthcare and who doesn't.

whilingawaytime · 19/09/2023 14:52

Hooplahooping · 19/09/2023 14:32

Very very unpopular opinion : those over 75. 80 at a push should only receive palliative care.

that would save an awful lot of money.

but voters won’t like it.

So we’ll keep spending BILLIONS of pounds on cancer treatment for 80 yr olds instead of spending it on improving quality of early years education.

Edited to add : because I think a better quality ‘start in life’ is actually going to help senseless gang violence much more than refusing to treat people who get caught up in it.

Edited

Practically speaking I sort of agree, or at least don't disagree, but 1) it's a slippery slope - especially with the NHS being rapidly defunded, it's not hard to see the threshold being lowered and lowered to younger and younger ages, till only a portion of the population is considered worth healthcare 2) in practice, my recent experience is that family members are often strongly medically advised to seek the most painless path (ie non intervention, or palliative) for elderly people, even for conditions that would be optimistic in younger people. Treatment risk % is related to age and this is very persuasively emphasised by doctors.

CranfordScones · 19/09/2023 14:50

Question for the assembled minds:
Who poses a bigger threat to decent society:

  • the people to whom OP refers, or
  • people who hold OP's opinions?
GKD · 19/09/2023 14:45

This reply has been deleted

This user is a troll so we've removed their threads and posts.

Drug dealing is what, a few billion pound international industry.

I’m not condoning the drug industry, far from it but it’s wrong/ignorant to write those involved off as feckless guttersnipes.

There are many players who would be excellent employees (logistics, product control, marketing, diplomacy, deal closers, communications, networking) if they had been born into different circumstances.

the drug industry isn’t just a £5 bag on a street corner.

MatthewsMumFromTikTok · 19/09/2023 14:38

@Hooplahooping my dad is 76 and is still working! Nice!

PosyPrettyToes · 19/09/2023 14:34

As an NHS worker, we are there to provide care, free to all at the point of delivery. It is absolutely not for us to make any kind of moral judgement.

cringelibrarian · 19/09/2023 14:33

This reply has been deleted

This user is a troll so we've removed their threads and posts.

Hooplahooping · 19/09/2023 14:32

Very very unpopular opinion : those over 75. 80 at a push should only receive palliative care.

that would save an awful lot of money.

but voters won’t like it.

So we’ll keep spending BILLIONS of pounds on cancer treatment for 80 yr olds instead of spending it on improving quality of early years education.

Edited to add : because I think a better quality ‘start in life’ is actually going to help senseless gang violence much more than refusing to treat people who get caught up in it.

MatthewsMumFromTikTok · 19/09/2023 14:22

OP.....WHERE HAVE YOU GONE...??

whilingawaytime · 19/09/2023 14:21

Isn't it your fault, OP, for living in such a poor area then? Why don't you work a bit harder, and move to a nicer area with less crime and more financially endowed NHS resources?

After all, you believe lifestyle choices and circumstances are mostly down to sheer hard work and willpower. Then morally speaking, it's simply your fault for choosing a lifestyle of poverty, sorry!

Mamai90 · 19/09/2023 14:18

Nearlyspring23 · 19/09/2023 12:27

I could possibly entertain the idea that everyone responsible for bringing the nhs down is deprioritised.
”Did you vote Tory, yes, okay then back of the queue”.

Haha.

Now this I could get on board with 😆

Mamai90 · 19/09/2023 14:11

This is possibly the most idiotic thing I've read on here, and that's saying something. How you tell who is innocent and who is guilty? Mistakes would of course be made.

And it's a slippery slope, how do we decide who is worthy? Are paedophiles more worthy than gang members?

Not only that, those gang members are a product of their environment, they are someones son/daughter. Just be glad you don't have to raise your offspring in an area where this is rife. It's the poor who would be penalised.

Conkersinautumn · 19/09/2023 14:11

Well, being slightly overweight I get very much the "fuck off until you've lost weight" in order to receive treatment, that's taken to be my choice. So it's not like the NHS aren't fine with prioritising over "lifestyle".

SpaceRaiders · 19/09/2023 14:08

A huge part of the prison population are undiagnosed neurodivergent and various mental health issues as a result of being unsupported. There’s an argument that if we as a society provided better MH support services then a vast majority of criminality wouldn’t take place.

Taketurn · 19/09/2023 14:07

viques · 19/09/2023 11:59

Where do you stand on the NHS treating alcoholics, drug users and cigarette smokers OP? Or drink drivers, men who catch venereal disease from trafficked prostitutes, extreme sports enthusiasts, people who have botched cosmetic surgery abroad………

Food for thought....

Hollowgast · 19/09/2023 14:06

This documentary you saw... it wasn't called "Top Boy" was it?

Namechangegardens · 19/09/2023 14:05

Drug crimes and drug related violence would be reduced exponentially if drugs were legal and supply under official control rather than gangs and the black market. Humans always have and always will take drugs, its only their illegality that leads to violence. Drug taking has nothing to do with morality anymore than alcohol does. Prohibition is the real killer.

HoppingPavlova · 19/09/2023 14:04

I suppose you don't believe that any young person would actively choose and aspire to it

I would guess they think that’s their only personal option in order to survive, and for some this may be true.

Irrespective, you do realise that this would not really solve any problems. Bed shortage is complex and often due to lack of staff in various areas, not because gang members are physically laying in beds. The fact one is in a bed won’t matter when there is a gynae shortage and beds are sitting unoccupied in gynae ward, that’s the main reason someone is not getting their hysterectomy, or a delay to oncology treatment etc. Gang members in beds will honestly make next to zero difference.

GKD · 19/09/2023 14:03

@Ponoka7 Precisely.

My point was in reference to someone implying the drug honchos wouldn’t be affected because they aren’t killing each other.

Deciding who is/isn’t worthy of healthcare is a slippery slope. Next step would be pensioners calling for those not working/on benefits being denied care…. (But not the pensioner cos they paid all their lives)