Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

NHS shouldn't have to treat gang members / criminals

260 replies

Sellias · 19/09/2023 11:52

I live in a city with lots of crime (drugs, gangs, knife crime)

Groups of idiots 'beefing' with other groups of idiots over postcodes, selling drugs on eachothers patch and perceived disrespect over the silliest of things leading to murder.

I recently watched a documentary about knife crime and it got me thinking about what a terrible state our NHS is in and how people like cancer patients, people with heart problems etc are waiting far too long for treatment to the extent that they can and do die before their treatment even begins.

..these gang idiots though, if they stab or shoot one another an ambulance is called and they get rushed to hospital. It's all hands on deck to save them. Seriously ill people have their much needed surgery cancelled because this stab victim (who sells drugs and causes endless harm in their community) is deemed to need treatment more than they are.

AIBU to think if they chose to live that way then the NHS should have no obligation to treat them? Let them pay for their own treatment with their ill gotten gains.

Disclaimer, I'm not talking about children who of course we should do all we can to save.

I know these people make up only a small percentage of those requiring urgent treatment but it really pisses me off that they bring it on themselves by living the life they do and then expect the tax payer (having never paid tax in their lives)

OP posts:
SomeCatFromJapan · 19/09/2023 12:01

That's one hell of a slippery slope you'd like us to start on.

meditrina · 19/09/2023 12:01

I am completely against the NHS treating by anything other than clinical need

TheBarbieEffect · 19/09/2023 12:01

YABU. Where does it end?

Should we not treat fat people because they lack self control and did it to themselves?

Should we not treat alcoholics? Smokers? Anyone who has done something to themselves that then requires a fix from someone else?

iLovee · 19/09/2023 12:00

Sellias · 19/09/2023 11:57

My point is that a ton of people who do need treatment aren't getting it.

Yet if a gang member is stabbed as part of some daft fued they will one thousand percent get the treatment they need, same day, no waiting lists.

How is that fair?

But its an emergency and needs an emergency response - the same as a car accident (even if they are treating the one who was at fault)

DifferentlyMaybe · 19/09/2023 12:00

No the nhs should treat all humans equally.
these gang members are still someone’s son/brother/friend.
Poverty and inequality are some of the main contributory factors behind young people turning to gangs/drugs. Child hood ACEs another contributory factor.
Escaping the gang once inside it is near impossible if you want to live. Punishing these people by removing their right to emergency health care is not right. And where’s your age cut off? 16/17/18?

Sellias · 19/09/2023 12:00

SquashPenguin · 19/09/2023 11:58

You should’ve re-read your post before posting. By your definition people would need to be put before a jury and prosecuted as a ‘gang member’ before being treated. How would your idea ever work?

Might as well refuse to treat smokers/ sky divers/ people who drove a bit too fast as well. They’re all at fault. Off you pop to the pharmacy and sort your self out with a first aid kit sorry.

🤦🏻‍♀️

I'm just thinking out loud.

Obviously I know there's no way a system like that would ever come into play.

The unfairness just irks me that is all.

It's "AIBU to think" not "AIBU to campaign for"

OP posts:
HoppingPavlova · 19/09/2023 12:00

That’s ridiculous. As a Dr you are obliged to treat accordingly to clinical need and priority. That’s it. You don’t get to decide who is worthy and who is not, that’s a slippery slope. Also, what if one Dr has a different opinion to another as to who is worthy? What if a Dr gets it wrong and that person is innocent? What about things such as life-threatening complication post abortion if abortion is against your personal belief. What if, what if, what if. You can’t play God, or judge, jury and executioner - that’s just not how it works

Sparklesocks · 19/09/2023 12:00

Sellias · 19/09/2023 11:57

My point is that a ton of people who do need treatment aren't getting it.

Yet if a gang member is stabbed as part of some daft fued they will one thousand percent get the treatment they need, same day, no waiting lists.

How is that fair?

I don’t think anyone would dispute that the NHS is struggling and the waiting lists are awful. But I don’t see how refusing to treat criminals would change that. It’s not as if all of the resources for cancer patients in oncology are being channelled solely to trauma patients in A+E.

Coffeewinecake · 19/09/2023 11:59

Sellias · 19/09/2023 11:57

My point is that a ton of people who do need treatment aren't getting it.

Yet if a gang member is stabbed as part of some daft fued they will one thousand percent get the treatment they need, same day, no waiting lists.

How is that fair?

How would you know whether they are a gang member?

How do you know whether they turned to that life as the main breadwinner of their household could no longer work because they have cancer?

How do you know whether they have been groomed into this life and see no way out?

Stressfordays · 19/09/2023 11:59

I found people coming to a&e with minor, treatable at home illnesses way more frustrating then people with critical injuries, regardless how they got them.

museumum · 19/09/2023 11:59

entirely unfair to put that onto paramedics or doctors to decide not to treat somebody. and what happens to them then? they die in the street? granted I'm lucky not to live in a gang area but I'm not sure seeing dead bodies in the street would make it any better a place to bring up children.

viques · 19/09/2023 11:59

Where do you stand on the NHS treating alcoholics, drug users and cigarette smokers OP? Or drink drivers, men who catch venereal disease from trafficked prostitutes, extreme sports enthusiasts, people who have botched cosmetic surgery abroad………

Whataretheodds · 19/09/2023 11:59

Yet if a gang member is stabbed as part of some daft fued they will one thousand percent get the treatment they need, same day, no waiting lists.

Where are you getting that info from? They get the same treatment as anyone admitted to hospital with a stab wound.

Oysterbabe · 19/09/2023 11:58

How would this work in practice?
Paramedics calling a number?
Hi, I have someone bleeding out, please can I have a background check to see if I can start treatment?

Sellias · 19/09/2023 11:58

TheGrimSqueakersFlea · 19/09/2023 11:57

Never paid taxes? You do realise that a lot of the dealers higher up in the chain have jobs and own businesses?.

Do you think they should be asked to provide a wage slip before receiving treatment?

They're not the ones hurting m one another though are they?

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 19/09/2023 11:58

Sparklesocks · 19/09/2023 11:54

I think it’s a slippery slope to deem who is and isn’t worthy of treatment based on morality. The NHS is for everyone. And doctors are meant to treat everyone, that includes criminals.

This is what I think

SquashPenguin · 19/09/2023 11:58

You should’ve re-read your post before posting. By your definition people would need to be put before a jury and prosecuted as a ‘gang member’ before being treated. How would your idea ever work?

Might as well refuse to treat smokers/ sky divers/ people who drove a bit too fast as well. They’re all at fault. Off you pop to the pharmacy and sort your self out with a first aid kit sorry.

🤦🏻‍♀️

Sellias · 19/09/2023 11:58

NotReallySureWhatToThink · 19/09/2023 11:56

No. Just no.

All the obvious moral reasons aside it's completely unworkable.

How would the paramedics or A&E staff know if it was an actual gang member or just a case of mistaken identity for a start? Or would it just come down to how dark their skin is and how shiny their trainers are Hmm

It's nothing to do with race don't be so ridiculous.

OP posts:
SirenSays · 19/09/2023 11:58

It's not fair and the NHS is a mess, but this isn't how we should fix it.

Desecratedcoconut · 19/09/2023 11:57

What is your alternative solution, they just bleed out on the hospital doorstep? That's going to be messy.

TheGrimSqueakersFlea · 19/09/2023 11:57

Never paid taxes? You do realise that a lot of the dealers higher up in the chain have jobs and own businesses?.

Do you think they should be asked to provide a wage slip before receiving treatment?

OldTinHat · 19/09/2023 11:57

What about smokers, alcoholics and obese people? Also lifestyle choices. Should they not be treated too?

Oysterbabe · 19/09/2023 11:57

You can't leave people to die on the street, whoever they are.

Sellias · 19/09/2023 11:57

Sparklesocks · 19/09/2023 11:54

I think it’s a slippery slope to deem who is and isn’t worthy of treatment based on morality. The NHS is for everyone. And doctors are meant to treat everyone, that includes criminals.

My point is that a ton of people who do need treatment aren't getting it.

Yet if a gang member is stabbed as part of some daft fued they will one thousand percent get the treatment they need, same day, no waiting lists.

How is that fair?

OP posts:
NotReallySureWhatToThink · 19/09/2023 11:56

No. Just no.

All the obvious moral reasons aside it's completely unworkable.

How would the paramedics or A&E staff know if it was an actual gang member or just a case of mistaken identity for a start? Or would it just come down to how dark their skin is and how shiny their trainers are Hmm