Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

NHS shouldn't have to treat gang members / criminals

260 replies

Sellias · 19/09/2023 11:52

I live in a city with lots of crime (drugs, gangs, knife crime)

Groups of idiots 'beefing' with other groups of idiots over postcodes, selling drugs on eachothers patch and perceived disrespect over the silliest of things leading to murder.

I recently watched a documentary about knife crime and it got me thinking about what a terrible state our NHS is in and how people like cancer patients, people with heart problems etc are waiting far too long for treatment to the extent that they can and do die before their treatment even begins.

..these gang idiots though, if they stab or shoot one another an ambulance is called and they get rushed to hospital. It's all hands on deck to save them. Seriously ill people have their much needed surgery cancelled because this stab victim (who sells drugs and causes endless harm in their community) is deemed to need treatment more than they are.

AIBU to think if they chose to live that way then the NHS should have no obligation to treat them? Let them pay for their own treatment with their ill gotten gains.

Disclaimer, I'm not talking about children who of course we should do all we can to save.

I know these people make up only a small percentage of those requiring urgent treatment but it really pisses me off that they bring it on themselves by living the life they do and then expect the tax payer (having never paid tax in their lives)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Dotcheck · 20/09/2023 21:23

HappiDaze · 20/09/2023 05:28

Well it wasn't for gang members shooting each other in the States you wouldn't have lots of certain body parts to use and most everyday surgeries

Bet you didn't know that

Silver linings

iffyi · 20/09/2023 15:27

my mum worked in a major trauma centre in central london and as a result mostly treated knife crime victims… many of the boys treated have grown up in poverty and been groomed into these gangs and, as i’m sure you know, it’s extremely difficult to get out once you’re in, and as a result, this is the life for many either until they either get killed or put in prison sadly. The frequency that these boys/men go in and out of hospital with no support to leave their situation is a disgrace, but the solution is absolutely rehabilitation rather than leaving them to die! we know that this is possible, just look at the work of martin griffiths and st giles in east london. it’s super important that we ensure that society does not leave anyone behind, and it’s not the nhs’ job to judge anyway!

ManchesterLu · 20/09/2023 12:47

Sparklesocks · 19/09/2023 11:54

I think it’s a slippery slope to deem who is and isn’t worthy of treatment based on morality. The NHS is for everyone. And doctors are meant to treat everyone, that includes criminals.

Yeah, this. Once you start refusing treatment to some, where will it ever end? And who's to decide whether someone with lung cancer (for example) brought it on with their smoking, or whether they'd have got it anyway? It just wouldn't work.

ClareBlue · 20/09/2023 12:38

Maybe you have a point. Johnson got treated for covid caught whilst breaking a law he imposed on the rest of us. So under your regime he wouldn't have got treated. Silver linings and all that.

Cowlover89 · 20/09/2023 12:29

YABVVU

GKD · 20/09/2023 12:15

So convicted of shooting a kid who needed a week in ICU then that fine he gets goes up and some more of that money can be funnelled in to the NHS. If they are really drug dealers on £3k a week then this will be fine.

I’m all for confiscating the proceeds of crime, but the NHS being funded by profits made from drug addicted consumers seems icky.

Considering admin I think it would just be cheaper to get a refund from PPE/Michelle Mone et al.

TeresaCrowd · 20/09/2023 09:31

I do think you are on to a loser here OP I’m afraid as the staff can’t be making moral judgements.

I do sometimes wonder though if there was a way of recouping some costs if/when offenders are convicted. So convicted of shooting a kid who needed a week in ICU then that fine he gets goes up and some more of that money can be funnelled in to the NHS. If they are really drug dealers on £3k a week then this will be fine. The first visit to a doctor after a car crash is chargeable as it’s an insurable event, they send an invoice, so it is possible. This is because shooting someone or stabbing someone is illegal. Currently being fat/smoking/getting pregnant and all those other lifestyle choices that impact the NHS are legal, and that’s where the line could be drawn.

and for those saying it doesn’t impact on other patients, it does if they end up in a higher level ward such that a bed is not available for post operative patient so their operation gets cancelled.

Evaka · 20/09/2023 06:55

You are being beyond unreasonable OP.

littlelizzard · 20/09/2023 06:51

the whole point of the NHS is universal free healthcare for ALL, so you ABU

Beezknees · 20/09/2023 06:30

YABU of course and you know it.

How do you check if somebody is involved in gang activity before giving them emergency treatment? Interview them while they're bleeding to death before you operate on them? Many young males who get stabbed are a case of mistaken identity.

And where do you draw the line? If you smoke should you not receive treatment? Drink alcohol? Are fat through over eating?

The NHS is for everyone and that's the way it should stay.

Willowview · 20/09/2023 05:29

@Unexpectedlysinglemum not sure if you're reply was meant for me, but I'm doing a degree in social science in order to try and help lessen inequality, it's social research this year. I hope to make the smallest of differences, so I am trying.

HappiDaze · 20/09/2023 05:28

Well it wasn't for gang members shooting each other in the States you wouldn't have lots of certain body parts to use and most everyday surgeries

Bet you didn't know that

EtiennePalmiere · 20/09/2023 04:55

A 2023 "Modest Proposal" that smacks of eugenics, I hope this is satire

Madwife123 · 20/09/2023 03:21

My job would get a lot easier!

Bleeding to death from a PPH, shouldn’t have got pregnant then.

I can sit and cake all day instead, along with all the other NHS staff that no longer have anyone to treat seeing as they’ve all done something at some point in their life to not deserve treatment.

Or maybe not because we will all be dead as well.

Madwife123 · 20/09/2023 03:08

Can you imagine a society where we don’t treat your heart attack because you are overweight.

We don’t treat your liver failure because you drank too much in your younger days.

It’s a very slippery slope! The NHS treats those who need treatment. It can’t be making decisions about who does and doesn’t deserve treatment

Emz6103 · 20/09/2023 02:22

BoredZelda · 20/09/2023 00:04

My point is that a ton of people who do need treatment aren't getting it. Yet if a gang member is stabbed as part of some daft fued they will one thousand percent get the treatment they need, same day, no waiting lists.

I'm pretty sure if anyone turns up having been stabbed, they aren't put on waiting list.

Would that be a ton of people who smoked all their lives? Spent every weekend drinking and eating junk food? People speeding in cars or cycling in the traffic without a Helmut?

Emz6103 · 20/09/2023 02:15

Either everybody counts or nobody counts.
How about life long smoking idiots? Lifelong drinking idiots? People who have eaten junk all their lives? Idiots speeding behind the wheel of 10 tons of metal? Soldiers who kill for the government? (Well they're not protecting us from invasion) cyclists riding without helmets? Hell why have an NHS at all.....

offenyin · 20/09/2023 02:15

I live in a city with lots of crime (drugs, gangs, knife crime)

Groups of idiots 'beefing' with other groups of idiots over postcodes, selling drugs on eachothers patch and perceived disrespect over the silliest of things leading to murder.

I take it you've been watching Top Boy, OP. Grin
Sounds familiar.

In answer to your question. It's rather ethically dubious isn't it and would never work. You realise that now I hope.

NorthernLights5 · 20/09/2023 01:35

No I think you're totally wrong. I once worked in a professional capacity with someone who had been forced to run drugs for a big dealer in his area. His brother used to run drugs for the same dealer and was shot and killed in front of him. So this individual was forced through fear to sell drugs. How the hell is a medical professional supposed to work that out when he's brought to A&E because he's been shot or stabbed?

TheGhostofLoganRoy · 20/09/2023 01:24

I also live in an area that has a huge problem with gang-related knife crime, and it's almost all under-18s, and mainly under-16s. We average two murders per year in my neighbourhood and not a single one has been older than 16. Which is shameful, obviously, but would hardly work with your policy since gangs recruit and groom minors so heavily.

jswnp · 20/09/2023 01:06

*Yet if a gang member is stabbed as part of some daft fued they will one thousand percent get the treatment they need, same day, no waiting lists.

How is that fair?*

Nobody who has been stabbed, shot, or critically injured is going to be put on a waiting list ffs.

Are you suggesting that everyone who is taken to hospital following such injury should be vetted before they treat them? Would that not put them on a waiting list...?

jswnp · 20/09/2023 01:03

What a ridiculous, idiotic take.

TorqueWrench · 20/09/2023 00:54

Most of the country broke the law over lockdown....

Somewhereovertherainbowweighapie · 20/09/2023 00:51

How would a paramedic know who to treat? Imagine someone stepping in to help someone being attacked, gets stabbed then left to die because it was assumed they were part of a gang.

Dotcheck · 20/09/2023 00:50

This is a fabulous idea op.

And while we’re at it, let’s not treat victims of domestic abuse- after all they’ve chosen their life.
People who were in car accidents? If there is any hint of it being their fault, they shouldn’t be prioritised.

Swipe left for the next trending thread