Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My professional salary only just covers my rent. How can this be?

504 replies

Rentmakesmepoor · 19/09/2023 09:20

I am an occupational therapist in the NHS. I am a single parent. After tax, student loan and pension I take home roughly £1900.
I live in the South East of England. My rent is £1750 a month for a 3 bed, SMALL semi detached house with a courtyard garden

How is it that we have got to the point in this country that my salary literally just pays for my rent and nothing else??

I am permanently skint. I am not looking for solutions as I do nd claim everything I can (which is not alot).

But how can this be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Wakintoblueskies · 19/09/2023 13:32

Oiyouoverthere · 19/09/2023 13:28

The OP earns the same as teachers, social workers, nurses and lots of skilled professional public service workers. Do we just say that those people don't need to be in certain areas of the UK? That only teachers married to wealthy people can work in the SE, London, parts of Cheshire and Manchester?

YANBU OP. It's dreadful.

It isn't JUST (some) public sectors workers who earn low salaries. Its always the same on these threads when so many posters are public sector. What about supermarket assistants, cleaners, bin collectors, bus drivers?? Is it so hard to include other people in similar circumstances or don't they matter???

HideTheCroissants · 19/09/2023 13:30

gogomoto · 19/09/2023 09:28

That's very high rent, we're I used to live it's about £750 for a 3 bed, where I currently live it's around £1000

And where I live a three bedroom (one of them a box room) end of terrace is £2000 per annum! That’s what the house over the road from me costs. It’s only a high rent compared to what you see in your area! The problem is outrageous house prices. If the landlord put that house on the market it would be at over £500k - not a big house, not a fantastic area but he would get that for it! We are lucky we bought our house a very long time ago - DH is highly paid but we wouldn’t be able to buy our own house at its current market value so heaven help the younger generation.

JamSandle · 19/09/2023 13:30

Oiyouoverthere · 19/09/2023 13:28

The OP earns the same as teachers, social workers, nurses and lots of skilled professional public service workers. Do we just say that those people don't need to be in certain areas of the UK? That only teachers married to wealthy people can work in the SE, London, parts of Cheshire and Manchester?

YANBU OP. It's dreadful.

Exactly. It makes no sense. London weighting is supposed to reflect that London is an expensive area.

Wakintoblueskies · 19/09/2023 13:29

Teenangels · 19/09/2023 12:50

Yes,
rent element let's say £1200
4x child element if all born before 2017 £1100
single person element £375
total 2675
wages £1900 minus £373= 1627
£1627x0.55=£873
so you take
£874 off the total UC entitlement
equals £1802 UC per month.
so wages and UC plus child benefit equals around £3800 plus child benefit.

Rent then is approx 46% of disposable income?

£3800 - £1750 (rent) = £2050 per month disposable income per month?

Oiyouoverthere · 19/09/2023 13:28

The OP earns the same as teachers, social workers, nurses and lots of skilled professional public service workers. Do we just say that those people don't need to be in certain areas of the UK? That only teachers married to wealthy people can work in the SE, London, parts of Cheshire and Manchester?

YANBU OP. It's dreadful.

moneyplantnation · 19/09/2023 13:27

Begsthequestion · 19/09/2023 13:00

Funny, is it? Your lack of empathy is at sociopathic levels here.

We can do better than this race to the bottom.

Do you vote Tory?

Oh do bore off another one who cannot handle opposing views. Sadly this is now the new snowflake norm, moan and blame every one else and shout abuse rather than take control get of your arse and do something.

What does who I vote for got to do with anything? you really are coming across as a bit of a sociopath yourself. 😂

MonikerBing · 19/09/2023 13:23

hi @Rentmakesmepoor . I get it.

I don't agree that moving area is the answer. But practically - is there a different part of town you could move to that is a bit cheaper?

Is there a part time (out of hours) job you could do? Are your children old enough to be left on their own if you got an evening job? (And I know that would be exhausting and untenable for a long term solution). There are also ways of earning money by working from home - have you explored these? Is there any possibility of taking your skills to the private sector and earning more?

And also, do double check you are getting all you are entitled to. Gingerbread could help with benefits but also other sources of support. Good luck x

user1497207191 · 19/09/2023 13:22

SueVineer · 19/09/2023 13:00

It’s not really possible to reduce wealth in London without just making us all poorer. people live there because there are good opportunities there - refusing to build houses just makes life harder for people like the op.

London is actually quite a low rise city which is spread out and a lot of land which is currently unable to be built on due to regulations. There is an awful lot of building that could be done.

Ultimately we won’t solve the housing crisis unless (usually well housed older people) stop opposing home building.

Why would it make everyone poorer? We just need to spread things out again, how it always used to be. Big organisations/employers would still make the same profits if they moved all or some of their staff to regional offices. After all, their customers are spread all over the country, especially the likes of banks, insurance firms, professional firms, etc. They no longer need to be close to each other, like in the old days of banks and solicitors having "walkers" to hand deliver documents between themselves!

In my home town (Northern run down town now), we used to have regional offices for two huge insurance firms - both were closed down in the 90s upon centralisation to London with the loss of thousands of jobs. Likewise we had small/local offices of national chains of accountants, solicitors, banks, etc., - all now long gone, with the centralisation in London, again, hundreds of jobs lost.

No decent local jobs means graduates never return from Uni as there are no decent jobs for them, and often, no decent jobs in their Uni cities either, so they end up in London/SE because that's where the jobs are!

Basically, London and the SE has sucked the life out of regional economies, aided and abbeted by London Centric governments. It needs a reversal and that needs to start at the top, in Government. We desperately need to get business and enterprise back into the regions, we need "localism" policies to regenerate all the run down towns.

user1477391263 · 19/09/2023 13:22

Fightyouforthatpie · 19/09/2023 12:54

The SE of England is massively overcrowded already - how much more building do you think it could support? Wouldn't it be better to try to reduce the overconcentration of wealth and economic activity in an already overcrowded tiny part of the country?

Actually, there is a lot of scope for building even in the SE: Golf courses, run-down shopping centers, a lot of parking (which would be less necessary if we had denser urban cores in more parts of the SE that are dense enough to support good public transit networks), adding extra floors to buildings, replacing bungalows with mid-rise flats and maisonette blocks....

horseyhorsey17 · 19/09/2023 13:22

JamSandle · 19/09/2023 13:17

Why should people who've grown up in the south east, who have ties and family there, be priced out? It isn't right.

Because the angry right wing Boomers who sit on Mumsnet furiously replying to these sort of posts say so.

horseyhorsey17 · 19/09/2023 13:21

Hufflepods · 19/09/2023 12:39

@horseyhorsey17 *She's not on a below average income. £1900 after tax, student loan etc is around £32K take home. That's more than the average income by some way.

But don't let facts spoil your bitching.*

Average income in the SE is £34.5k. £1900 after tax isn't 'more than average by some way'.

Depends what source you're looking at. The first answer on Google puts it at £28.2K. And that's factoring in the fact that the vasy majority of the highest earners/millionaires live in the South East, pushing up the average/median salary by some way - in reality it'll be closer to £25K.

user1477391263 · 19/09/2023 13:19

For context:

My professional salary only just covers my rent. How can this be?
KimKardashiansKarpetKrab · 19/09/2023 13:17

Southeastdweller · 19/09/2023 09:29

Could it be because you live in the south east of England?

The point of this thread is what, exactly?

So what if the South East of England is nearer London and jobs? If those jobs don't pay decent standard of living wages, then rents really have no business being so bloody high.

JamSandle · 19/09/2023 13:17

Why should people who've grown up in the south east, who have ties and family there, be priced out? It isn't right.

user1497207191 · 19/09/2023 13:15

Fightyouforthatpie · 19/09/2023 12:54

The SE of England is massively overcrowded already - how much more building do you think it could support? Wouldn't it be better to try to reduce the overconcentration of wealth and economic activity in an already overcrowded tiny part of the country?

Yes, but successive governments for past few decades have deliberately pursued "pro London/SE" policies which has caused the concentration and centralisation of things into that tiny part of the country. We need politicians who'll turn things around and develop the regions. That's exactly why Boris was so popular when he announced policies to regenerate the run down Northern towns etc., the policies which Rishi sadly seems to have forgotten, but then again, he's a "City" banker, so probably has no interest in the regions and I doubt Starmer is too bothered either, so whoever wins the next GE, we'll have another five years of the run down areas of the country being ignored whilst London and SE get even more crowded!

TorqueWrench · 19/09/2023 13:14

Southeast and £1750 are the two factors here. You'd easily be paying £1k less on rent in the midlands.

user1477391263 · 19/09/2023 13:12

I guess you could do.... Two-bed flat/terrace, no garden, sofabed for Mum in living room?

I mean... that would be a shit situation with four kids, alright. But I honestly don't know what else I'd do or suggest in these circumstances, if moving is not possible. :( It's a hard one, no doubt about it. The UK has a housing crisis, and posters like the OP suffer as a result.

Fightyouforthatpie · 19/09/2023 13:12

SueVineer · 19/09/2023 13:00

It’s not really possible to reduce wealth in London without just making us all poorer. people live there because there are good opportunities there - refusing to build houses just makes life harder for people like the op.

London is actually quite a low rise city which is spread out and a lot of land which is currently unable to be built on due to regulations. There is an awful lot of building that could be done.

Ultimately we won’t solve the housing crisis unless (usually well housed older people) stop opposing home building.

There's no actual reason for a lot of concentration in London - and much of it is self-fufilling. Thinking you can high-rise build your way to provision of affordable housing doesn't sound like a long term sustainable plan to me.
There is no reason why spreading the London wealth and massive subsidies would make us all poorer.

Fightyouforthatpie · 19/09/2023 13:09

DisquietintheRanks · 19/09/2023 13:01

If we are going to have regional public payscales, then we'd better have regional taxation also. Otherwise we'd just have a system where the rest of the UK just subsidises London house prices. That's not on.

Well we already subsidise London Health Education and Transport spending so it's not new.

Anewnamea · 19/09/2023 13:08

And can we do something about all the foreign property investors buying up all the new build flats in London that often just sit empty! I suspect it’s money laundering in a lot of cases but whatever it is, it doesn’t help the locals.

RenovationNightmare · 19/09/2023 13:08

It is relevant that you are a single parent with four children, hence the need for a three bed house - not a two bed flat. Sadly it is difficult for any parent (single or otherwise) if they have children prior to owning a property in London and large parts of the south. Living in private rental properties is always going to be problematic in thes areas, council or housing association properties are much easier on the wallet and provide security. It is a horrible fact of life in this part of UK. I say that as someone who bought a 2 bed flat in London in 2011. If I didn't buy it then, somehow managed to save £1000 a month and added that to my 2011 deposit, I still couldn't afford the flat in 2023. And rent on that property is now over 2.5 what it was in 2011. If I had an NHS job I'd consider moving to a different/cheaper location, but I can imagine it's a more difficult decision if your children are happy, settled in school, and have had to deal with the trauma of a parent dying.

Anewnamea · 19/09/2023 13:06

Oliotya · 19/09/2023 12:52

Wouldn't work. More disposable income will just drive rent and house prices up further, just as increasing housing benefit does. Would we also have a regional minimum wage to ensure private workers don't get forced out now that public sector workers earn more?
House prices need to come down, not be continually propped up. Only solution is build more housing and put an end to housing as investments.
And as individuals, we have to make realistic choices about where we can afford to live.

Exactly, even if incomes go up the landlords are just waiting for the opportunity to hike rents up accordingly.

As someone who used to work in a role supporting low income families I was shocked even back in 2010, at just how much housing benefit went on huge private rent bills and often the accommodation was substandard. Damp, cramped and repairs not carried out.

The governments NEED to get a grip on house prices and rent and social housing.

DisquietintheRanks · 19/09/2023 13:01

If we are going to have regional public payscales, then we'd better have regional taxation also. Otherwise we'd just have a system where the rest of the UK just subsidises London house prices. That's not on.

Begsthequestion · 19/09/2023 13:00

moneyplantnation · 19/09/2023 12:16

Funny how people like you and others on MN call people nasty, smug and spiteful, Just because they have opposing opinions.

Sorry for your past and you ex but that does not give you the right to talk to others like that. One thing that is missing these days is self responsibility and cutting your own cloth.

Since when have practical and honest options been smug?

Just seems some nowadays every one want to blame everyone else and the government for their own life decisions.

Fact is we live in a rich country and the fact you have a safe home and a roof over your head, food and water is far more than a majority of the population of the planet.

Funny, is it? Your lack of empathy is at sociopathic levels here.

We can do better than this race to the bottom.

Do you vote Tory?

SueVineer · 19/09/2023 13:00

Fightyouforthatpie · 19/09/2023 12:54

The SE of England is massively overcrowded already - how much more building do you think it could support? Wouldn't it be better to try to reduce the overconcentration of wealth and economic activity in an already overcrowded tiny part of the country?

It’s not really possible to reduce wealth in London without just making us all poorer. people live there because there are good opportunities there - refusing to build houses just makes life harder for people like the op.

London is actually quite a low rise city which is spread out and a lot of land which is currently unable to be built on due to regulations. There is an awful lot of building that could be done.

Ultimately we won’t solve the housing crisis unless (usually well housed older people) stop opposing home building.