Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My professional salary only just covers my rent. How can this be?

504 replies

Rentmakesmepoor · 19/09/2023 09:20

I am an occupational therapist in the NHS. I am a single parent. After tax, student loan and pension I take home roughly £1900.
I live in the South East of England. My rent is £1750 a month for a 3 bed, SMALL semi detached house with a courtyard garden

How is it that we have got to the point in this country that my salary literally just pays for my rent and nothing else??

I am permanently skint. I am not looking for solutions as I do nd claim everything I can (which is not alot).

But how can this be?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
Oaktree1233 · 25/09/2023 19:35

I dd not realise that the OP had 4 kids as she failed to mention a fairly relevant and pertinent fact in her opening post.

According to official NHS Data OT’s start on salaries of £26500 to £31634. However specialist OT’s can earn £32306 to £39,027. Advanced specialists can earn £40,057 to £45,839 and clinical leads can earn £63,872.

So she has the opportunity to earn more. There are numerous jobs advertised on the NHS and council websites for in the region of £40,000 plus. For instance, a senior occupational paediatric therapist is required in Hampshire pay £42,000 to 46549 plus benefits

Private OT cam earn considerably more. She is allowed to and can combine her NHS work with private work and have huge earnings. She can simply work one day a week privately. As a private OT she could be earning up to £76,000 once 8 years qualified.

There is a colossal shortage of private OTs. I was unable easily to find an occupational therapist for my SEN son. I needed one to work weekly with him and I needed another to prepare reports for Tribunal. When we had to pay for reports they were costing sizeable amounts and also we had to pay for that OT to attend Tribunal.

Like many jobs, there is more money to be made for instance diversifying into private work and doing Tribunal work or just offering regular private OT to SEN kids.

Like many professions you can choose to do more worthy public work or do both public and private work or just private. It’s a choice you make. it has always been that way for many professions and nothing much has changed in decades.

So, in my previous line of work would be the equivalent of working for a really badly paid criminal defence law firm, the CPS or doing legal aid family law as opposed to going something more financially rewarding.

The bottom line is that for professions that work for the state or are funded by the state the financial rewards are and have always been poor. The state has not got much money and taxes are already at an all time high.

So for instance, Criminal lawyers can earn as little as about £26000 per annum maybe rising to £45000 but with( unlike OT in the NHS) no decent pension other than the auto enrolment. To become a lawyer you need 3 years university, 1 year law school and 2 years training minimum. In reality you required probably a couple of years working as a paralegal on about £20,000 to get a training contract. So that’s 8 years training for that pay. So elope tend to not go into that career without a vocation.

Even 30 years ago few people would voluntarily work for the CPS or a high street criminal law practice. Of those that did, some eventually became locum prosecutors on quite sizeable daily chunks as they approached retirement.
It was accepted thar working for the state your pay is lower and unlike the NHS private criminal lawyers did not even get decent public sector pension.

As for the 4 children, it is perfectly fair to say that having 4 children is a luxury in this day and age. Having children before establishing your career is also unusual in this day and age and another luxury. There are few working people who have more than 2 children maybe 3 at a push and most wait until they’re 30’s. To have so many children and to do so younger is a decision that someone has made and it does have financial consequences. It does impact your career and Carrer progression as you have so much time off for maternity leave etc.

The reality is that many of us would have loved more children but lacked the support or money to do so without making huge financial sacrifices. I think it’s fair to all people who have had to chose 2 children only to acknowledge that. Having so many children will impact earning potential and career advancement - again a decision that she made.

An OT who is ambitious and career driven can do both NHS and private work combined and have a pretty good income.

NalafromtheLionKing · 20/09/2023 21:44

EarlofShrewsbury · 20/09/2023 21:25

That doesn't make it OK though.

It doesn't change the fact that the OP can't afford the rent with a fairly decent job.

If 'professionals' are needing to claim so much in top up benefit there is something seriously wrong.

Rents are insanely high in some areas and the government are just handing out the money to cover it. Wages should cover it or rents should be lower. The country/taxpayers are lining the pockets of landlords and nothing is being done about it.

It’s not just a professional trying to support herself though.

People are being critical because anyone who is a relatively low earner and renting who has four(!) children in their twenties with a boyfriend is automatically putting themselves in an extremely precarious position. I earn several times the OP’s salary (PT) and am a married homeowner but we still stuck at two DC largely for financial reasons.

Of course it is very sad that OP’s ex died but surely unrealistic to say that she should be able to single-handedly support a family of five in an expensive location without benefit top ups. Not a moral judgement on OP’s job or other life choices as morality is irrelevant to this situation.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 20/09/2023 21:31

Whatapickle23 · 20/09/2023 20:55

All occupational therapists, nurses, teachers, care assistants, shop assistants, cleaners, anyone in a job that doesn't pay big bucks should be removed from the south and resettled up north where everyone knows you can buy a 3 bed semi for a fiver and a KitKat. Previous posters are right, anyone who isn't wealthy is the scourge of society and doesn't deserve to live in the prestigious south.

Children can be taught online by private tutors, anyone needing care or medical treatment can obviously move up north or travel up north for treatment. People will have to grow their own food and clean their own houses and offices on their lunch breaks from their big important jobs.

OP is a terrible human being for choosing a career in a helping profession instead of the mumsnet ideal of financial services. Ditto for having 4 children with her partner, how dare she have children in her TWENTIES!!! The audacity of it! And then her relationship ended and her partner died. This was obviously on purpose so that OP could claim benefits and be villified for it on mumsnet. Also, what an idiot for not buying her own home years ago! Everyone should have bought their own home and anyone who didn't and is now struggling with extortionate rent increases has no right to complain because it's all their own fault for being poor!

I moved up north and lived in a tent for 6 years with my 3 children as I retrained in (insert acceptable job) and now I earn £500,000 per day and live in a mansion, why can't OP do the same?

NOT MY ACTUAL VIEWS, JUST A SUMMARY OF SOME OF THE ABSOLUTE SHITE THAT HAS BEEN POSTED ON THIS THREAD SO FAR. YES, THE CAPITALS ARE NECESSARY.

That's a fair summary of a lot of the shite being spouted on this thread. Some of the comments are batshit, and would be funny if they didn't display such horrifying ignorance and spite.

EarlofShrewsbury · 20/09/2023 21:25

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 19/09/2023 20:34

I've put the info the OP has shared into Entitled.to and its estimated that she can claim £310.70 pcm in Child Benefit. Plus she can claim £1815.36 in Universal Credit.

This brings the OPs income to a (sensible) estimate of £4k pcm.

Interesting.

Oh! And this was assuming zero childcare costs and doesn't include the discounted council tax. So she would receive more if she has childcare bills to pay too.

That doesn't make it OK though.

It doesn't change the fact that the OP can't afford the rent with a fairly decent job.

If 'professionals' are needing to claim so much in top up benefit there is something seriously wrong.

Rents are insanely high in some areas and the government are just handing out the money to cover it. Wages should cover it or rents should be lower. The country/taxpayers are lining the pockets of landlords and nothing is being done about it.

Whatapickle23 · 20/09/2023 20:55

All occupational therapists, nurses, teachers, care assistants, shop assistants, cleaners, anyone in a job that doesn't pay big bucks should be removed from the south and resettled up north where everyone knows you can buy a 3 bed semi for a fiver and a KitKat. Previous posters are right, anyone who isn't wealthy is the scourge of society and doesn't deserve to live in the prestigious south.

Children can be taught online by private tutors, anyone needing care or medical treatment can obviously move up north or travel up north for treatment. People will have to grow their own food and clean their own houses and offices on their lunch breaks from their big important jobs.

OP is a terrible human being for choosing a career in a helping profession instead of the mumsnet ideal of financial services. Ditto for having 4 children with her partner, how dare she have children in her TWENTIES!!! The audacity of it! And then her relationship ended and her partner died. This was obviously on purpose so that OP could claim benefits and be villified for it on mumsnet. Also, what an idiot for not buying her own home years ago! Everyone should have bought their own home and anyone who didn't and is now struggling with extortionate rent increases has no right to complain because it's all their own fault for being poor!

I moved up north and lived in a tent for 6 years with my 3 children as I retrained in (insert acceptable job) and now I earn £500,000 per day and live in a mansion, why can't OP do the same?

NOT MY ACTUAL VIEWS, JUST A SUMMARY OF SOME OF THE ABSOLUTE SHITE THAT HAS BEEN POSTED ON THIS THREAD SO FAR. YES, THE CAPITALS ARE NECESSARY.

Noa23 · 20/09/2023 19:18

@TripleDaisySummer I’m sure the OP is perfectly capable of considering the option, she just wanted to vent not be piled on.

I can’t speak for her but unless she has family/a support system in a cheap part of the country where there is a suitable job for her then it’s probably not actually a viable option.

Nobody should have to move to a completely different part of the country from where they’ve built their life unless they want to. I don’t think a bog standard 3 bed is a luxury.

OT’s are needed all over the country, rich southerners aren’t exempt from things like strokes, spinal cord or brain injuries. The answer is to sort out wages and affordable housing and the shit show currently going on in the nhs.

Tonight I was hours late getting home due to a last minute issue which was only doable because I have a support system where I moved to. My best guess would be that if she had a support system somewhere cheaper she’d be there and not on here.

TripleDaisySummer · 20/09/2023 16:34

Noa23 · 20/09/2023 16:00

@TripleDaisySummer I have also done it and mentioned this in an earlier comment.

Than what was the issue with moving area to a cheap one then no one was claiming it's an ideal solution but it's a possible one.

Incidentally I can see the OP posts - but while I've read all the pages and posts I don't know how to work out among so many posters who else posted what.

OP has 4 kids on a NHS wage in an expensive part of the country - that's going to be hard - and that's not looking like it will change any time soon.

In meantime she can cover the rent and it sounds like every month she'll be going through savings or accumulating debt which if far from ideal and moaning about the situation - which affects many others - changes nothing.

SusiePevensie · 20/09/2023 16:07

We haven't built enough homes for decades.

Belleweather · 20/09/2023 16:05

I've been paying 785 for a very rundown 2 bed semi in Newcastle. Single parent, good, professional work like you, I regret getting divorced sometimes (which is crackers because i had no option) because its almost impossible to see any lights in long dark tunnels. Just wanted to say, it's almost as bad jn the North as well. Landlords ick!

Noa23 · 20/09/2023 16:00

@TripleDaisySummer I have also done it and mentioned this in an earlier comment.

Fuckingfuming1 · 20/09/2023 15:38

Milktrauma · 20/09/2023 14:55

is That a joke? Where I am there are new homes going up all the time on any available open space.

They are locally to me as well, if you have 450,000 of our great British pounds, you can buy yourself a new build, semi detached three bedroom house on what we used to call Ashlawn pools …. I actually feel genuinely nothing, but sorry for those poor souls that have purchased houses in effectively a bog.

user1497207191 · 20/09/2023 15:25

Milktrauma · 20/09/2023 14:55

is That a joke? Where I am there are new homes going up all the time on any available open space.

Yes, and it's still not enough. We are millions of homes short. I don't think people realise the scale of the problem.

Tinklyheadtilt · 20/09/2023 15:11

lavender2023 · 20/09/2023 11:45

I would think what you said to a widow of 4 kids is sadly indicative of the current state of UK society. Lots of people on unimpressive salaries who wouldn't be able to survive without free at the point of access healthcare, state education and the many services provided by the state but who decide to look down their noses on otherz

At least while I own my flat in London and have a combined income of £120k I know that while it is better than others, I am still poor like the majority of people and only marginally less reliant on the government than OP. You should try some humility. Unless you are literally in the clouds with minimum £250k combined income, mortgage free home and asset wealth, there is no point in being smug because you are still at the mercy of capitalism. It is a very unequal world you live in.

Edited

She chose to have that many children. She choose not to marry her partner. She chose not to buy a house. Those decisions are now biting her.

There is nothing smug about it. People need to be responsible for their own actions.

midgemadgemodge · 20/09/2023 14:59

because the population is rising faster
And because there may be more single person households
And because lots of people own second homes and lots of homes have been converted to holiday mega

And because it's not every available space , it just seems that way

Milktrauma · 20/09/2023 14:55

NotDavidTennant · 19/09/2023 09:36

The reason is that we don't build enough new houses in this country.

is That a joke? Where I am there are new homes going up all the time on any available open space.

Middlelanehogger · 20/09/2023 14:53

Gettingbysomehow · 20/09/2023 12:38

If you are in this situation and can't do anything about it you HAVE to move like I did. I never regret moving to the west country, it's brilliant here. I'm not prepared to scrimp and save my whole life just for the priviledge of living in the south east which isn't that great anyway.
Once enough staff have deserted there will have to be a south east weighting of some sort.

Yes. This. I don't understand why there isn't regional weighting as it is, or individual trusts able to set their own wages to manage demand/supply.

People in the south-east don't "deserve" OT treatment, we can get it if we pay for it same as anything else.

Emz6103 · 20/09/2023 14:52

Statice · 20/09/2023 13:53

She has four children.

And there lays the problem..... people having too many children they simply cannot afford. People need to take personal responsibility for their lives, unless you can provide for them In adverse conditions it's wise not to have so many. I could not imagine having five mouths to feed on top of the rent and bills. I read this on MN all the time people having lots of children they cannot afford and have made no provisions for the future should the SHTF such as savings or life insurance.sadly that's today's generation their attention span is as long as a tik tok video, they're extremely frivolous with what they do have such as constant"treats" for themselves and the children (play dates, days out, fast food, false nails, nights out, latest phones....growing up in the 70s we were lucky to get a bag of chips on a Saturday afternoon, no such thing as play dates and days out, our parents saved and we played board games). I see no end of young mums on FB posting pictures of nights out, days out with their kids, fancy food and fast food with the children a very much look at me generation yet are completely screwed when and if tshtf....then they come crying onto MN Iin the AIBU section because they cannot afford their kids and no one will help them out. Sadly most are living the champagne lifestyle whilst earning beer money.

Statice · 20/09/2023 13:53

PickleDig · 20/09/2023 12:27

Can you rent a two bed house? A three bed is more suitable for two working adults, which would then be very affordable.

I say that as a single parent.

She has four children.

Gettingbysomehow · 20/09/2023 12:38

If you are in this situation and can't do anything about it you HAVE to move like I did. I never regret moving to the west country, it's brilliant here. I'm not prepared to scrimp and save my whole life just for the priviledge of living in the south east which isn't that great anyway.
Once enough staff have deserted there will have to be a south east weighting of some sort.

Murpe · 20/09/2023 12:30

These arguments that people couldn't buy on single salaries 30-40 years ago make no sense, loads of us now in our 40s were brought up in these homes: one parent working, house easily affordable. My father had a local authority job at the time my parents bought our 2 bed Victorian terrace with a mortgage, current vacancies for his role are £36-£43k. The houses in our section of the street have recently sold for £650k and higher.

PickleDig · 20/09/2023 12:27

Can you rent a two bed house? A three bed is more suitable for two working adults, which would then be very affordable.

I say that as a single parent.

littlemousebigcheese · 20/09/2023 12:13

on rightmove theres not a single 3 bed house to rent in Somerset for £350 🤔🤔

lavender2023 · 20/09/2023 11:45

Tinklyheadtilt · 20/09/2023 11:19

If you can't add anything of note, don't abuse people. I have reported your post.

I would think what you said to a widow of 4 kids is sadly indicative of the current state of UK society. Lots of people on unimpressive salaries who wouldn't be able to survive without free at the point of access healthcare, state education and the many services provided by the state but who decide to look down their noses on otherz

At least while I own my flat in London and have a combined income of £120k I know that while it is better than others, I am still poor like the majority of people and only marginally less reliant on the government than OP. You should try some humility. Unless you are literally in the clouds with minimum £250k combined income, mortgage free home and asset wealth, there is no point in being smug because you are still at the mercy of capitalism. It is a very unequal world you live in.

Hufflemuff · 20/09/2023 11:28

No point moaning about the NHS salaries etc... its not going to change anything for your situation.

You need to move town, the NHS salary for your job is presumably paying the same wage wherever you might live, so change the variable of your location.

Tinklyheadtilt · 20/09/2023 11:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

If you can't add anything of note, don't abuse people. I have reported your post.

Swipe left for the next trending thread