Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Just go for a walk..."

335 replies

LittleMissUnreasonable · 19/09/2023 08:11

Why does this always seem to be one of the big solutions for people who are suffering from poor mental health? Maybe if I lived in Southern Spain having a nice sunny walk would be very pleasant. But the weather being so miserable and grey ends up making me feel worse. The thought of putting on waterproofs to trudge through the grey endless rain, only to end up in a condensation filled cafe that smells of damp coats just doesn't seem very appealing

OP posts:
Giveituphq · 19/09/2023 10:45

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

fettuccini · 19/09/2023 10:45

I think the issue isn't with the 'go for a walk' suggestion in itself. It's the dismissal that your mental health is cured by this. And the dismal of how severe mental health problems can be. Many people still think it's just being a bit sad. Often dismissal from heath care workers who don't want to prescribe medication or therapies. Often spouted by people who has no first hand experience of mental trauma, who don't understand how hard it can be ti find the energy to get out of bed in the morning, let alone get dressed and leave the house. Going for a walk can be therapeutic, but it's not going to cure or provide long term relief for severe mental health problems.

GoryBory · 19/09/2023 10:43

defi · 19/09/2023 10:19

It’s interesting that the posters who do walk say it helps their mental health, and those that don’t walk claim it wouldn’t help them

^ I'm an avid hiker and paddle boarded. There is nothing more patronising then being told to go for a walk or have a bath in mental health crisis.

I don’t think anyone is saying that taking one walk is going to cure your mental illness, just like taking 1 antidepressant pill won’t.

But how do you think antidepressants work?

They literally have a similar effect on the brain of going for a walk outdoors, which is why so many doctors recommend it.

Obviously going out for a walk is hard when you have depression though and the antidepressants can come in different strengths.

So I’d always advise getting antidepressants too but walking outdoors can definitely help.

CClaire · 19/09/2023 10:43

YANBU in the sense that [usually wellmeaning] people make infuriatingly insensitive/ignorant/reductive, unsolicited suggestions to people with complicated, poorly understood conditions and I’m sure depression is a good example of this.

A close friend of mine has suffered horrendously incapacitating mental and physical health issues due to her thyroid in recent years and she has heard it all. Have you tried going for a walk? Cutting out gluten? Getting a SAD lamp? A weighted blanket? Etc etc. Of course she’s bloody tried everything and your ‘advice’ makes her want to smash her head into the wall.

That said, getting out into nature for a walk is scientifically proven to bring many mental and physical health benefits. I find trudging about in the rain when I’m sad highly therapeutic. But I’ve never suffered from depression and I don’t know how you’re feeling. Hope you find some coping mechanisms OP and things improve for you.

millymog11 · 19/09/2023 10:43

Totally understand the weather angle to this. The suggestion is probably more about "getting in the zone" exercise wise rather than forcing yourself out into all kinds of hostile weather and environments.

Giveituphq · 19/09/2023 10:42

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

randobear · 19/09/2023 10:42

I think even being in the rain and wind is good for your mental health even if you can only manage 10 minutes! I set myself a target of 8k steps a day whatever the weather and the days I feel the best after are actually the rainy windy days. Even if you think 8k is too much (for me it's low enough that it motivates me even on bad days) you could start with 5k or less. Make the habit nice and easy to start with but do it every day. Mastering this before thinking about other bigger challenges will give you motivation for the other better ones, step by step.

Cockmigrant · 19/09/2023 10:38

PersonIrresponsible · 19/09/2023 10:22

I can 100% vouch that I took the advice "if you have a lot on your mind, go for a walk" very seriously. It is now my specialist subject.

I walked across America: from Mexico to Canada. Six months later I was back on anti-depressants, but a year later my self-esteem was at its highest levels ever, and I was off the pills. I even wrote a book about it.

So no, a walk fixed nothing in the short term. However, there is some good news is that after approx 1,700 miles, I noticed that I had total peace of mind for a few hours a day.

More sensible research suggests that only those who live in the countryside and have access to large green spaces benefit from the advice. Those who live in busy places have an increase in cortisol after a walk, especially if you are female.

No surprises there.

Could you possibly pm me your book title please?
I also hike long distances but have never done a really long one yet - I love to read books like this as it gives me inspiration and keeps me going when times are tough.

Cola2023 · 19/09/2023 10:38

defi · 19/09/2023 10:19

It’s interesting that the posters who do walk say it helps their mental health, and those that don’t walk claim it wouldn’t help them

^ I'm an avid hiker and paddle boarded. There is nothing more patronising then being told to go for a walk or have a bath in mental health crisis.

No-one is claiming it's going to cure psychosis.

ChocolateCinderToffee · 19/09/2023 10:37

Have you tried playing Pokemon Go, OP? I'm not kidding, during lockdown in particular it was sometimes the only thing that got my out of my house. It also helps you notice all kinds of things that you'd previously overlooked. You get rewarded for walking certain distances.

Gnomegnomegnome · 19/09/2023 10:35

I voted Yanbu because it doesn’t suit everyone in the same way that one style of medication or therapy doesn’t suit everyone.

Find your thing. It could be washing your face, it could be baking, anything that helps you in the moment.

Are we talking prevention or cure?

user1471519902 · 19/09/2023 10:35

Buy 52 Ways to Walk by Annabel Streets. I promise she is no relation. No vested interest.

Read it when tucked up in bed and you will want to jump out and walk.

caramac04 · 19/09/2023 10:34

Whilst I much prefer a brisk walk in the Spring and Autumn, I can honestly say a wet and windy walk invigorates me in a way that a walk on a very hot day doesn’t.
Part of the walk isn’t the environment, it is the physical activity. If you find the environment uncomfortable then try 15-30 mins indoor exercise- lots of free stuff on the internet or put on your favourite music and dance.
There isn’t a one cure for all for poor mental health but walking is good for lots of people.

ShadyPaws · 19/09/2023 10:33

Spin classes are the thing that helps me most
I can't think about anything other than the fact everything is burning, and when the next interval is
That and wild swimming

Doesn't make any difference to my weight and frustrates me when the doctor says have I tried some gentle walking? No, but I did a 90 min spin class yesterday...

BlueMongoose · 19/09/2023 10:33

If you have good waterproofs, it can be very pleasant walking in the rain (unless it's torrential, of course). I find it quite soothing, though it definitely takes more willpower to get out there.
When it's wet, it's dark and a bit gloomy inside most houses even with the lights on- but it is brighter outside, which helps my mood.

Mistressanne · 19/09/2023 10:31

I love a damp café.
Sorry that's not much help.

BatshitCrazyWoman · 19/09/2023 10:31

TomatoSandwiches · 19/09/2023 08:29

When you walk you naturally fall into a pattern of scanning your view looking left to right and back again, this action can calm anxiety, walking at a pace also helps increase your breathing calming your vagus nerve, it gives you a reset and is beneficial so YABU.

This.

And it doesn't rain all the time - I'm outside every day, and can't remember the last time I used my umbrella. I've walked to town today, and it's breezy, intermittent sun, no rain.

BlastedPimples · 19/09/2023 10:31

Movement is a good thing.

GoryBory · 19/09/2023 10:29

AInightingale · 19/09/2023 10:25

I have depression and walk a lot, incl hill walking. It helps briefly , fresh air is good, and certainly I feel physically better for a short while afterwards, but it really has bugger all meaningful impact on my condition. With depression your ability to appreciate nature is severely limited, I can't take any pleasure in birds, flowers, trees. They're just things to me. They mean nothing anymore.

It’s great that you go out and walk a lot as this is often the last thing you want to do with depression.

But if you didn’t do this then your depression would be a lot worse.

You may not feel the effects but it will be helping.

The antidepressants pills work in a similar way to a walk but just in chemical form.

The best chance at overcoming depression is by taking antidepressants alongside walking outdoors.

WellPlaced · 19/09/2023 10:29

AInightingale · 19/09/2023 10:25

I have depression and walk a lot, incl hill walking. It helps briefly , fresh air is good, and certainly I feel physically better for a short while afterwards, but it really has bugger all meaningful impact on my condition. With depression your ability to appreciate nature is severely limited, I can't take any pleasure in birds, flowers, trees. They're just things to me. They mean nothing anymore.

I’m sorry you feel like that. It must be awful.
It’s good the walking helps a little though in various small ways, albeit temporarily.

Dentistlakes · 19/09/2023 10:29

I know what you mean about the weather! Walking does help even when the weather isn’t great. Just moving your body is beneficial as is getting some fresh air. It does help
if you have somewhere picturesque to walk though. I’m lucky to have a beach nearby which is lovely even in the pouring rain.

Stroopwaffels · 19/09/2023 10:27

I don;t think anyone is saying that going out for a walk is a magic bullet which will "fix" anyone. But it's FREE and doesn't require any specialist equipment like other sports like swimming or cycling, so it's got to be worth a go, right?

AInightingale · 19/09/2023 10:25

WellPlaced · 19/09/2023 10:17

It’s interesting that the posters who do walk say it helps their mental health, and those that don’t walk claim it wouldn’t help them

I have depression and walk a lot, incl hill walking. It helps briefly , fresh air is good, and certainly I feel physically better for a short while afterwards, but it really has bugger all meaningful impact on my condition. With depression your ability to appreciate nature is severely limited, I can't take any pleasure in birds, flowers, trees. They're just things to me. They mean nothing anymore.

Cropcycle · 19/09/2023 10:25

I don’t find walking does anything whatsoever for my MH. I’m the same deeply sad person outside putting one foot in front of the other in the park surrounded by squirrels, birds, kids playing etc, as I am at home doing bugger all. For my friend it’s a huge joy and tonic. So I’d say it’s not a one size fits all thing.

PersonIrresponsible · 19/09/2023 10:22

I can 100% vouch that I took the advice "if you have a lot on your mind, go for a walk" very seriously. It is now my specialist subject.

I walked across America: from Mexico to Canada. Six months later I was back on anti-depressants, but a year later my self-esteem was at its highest levels ever, and I was off the pills. I even wrote a book about it.

So no, a walk fixed nothing in the short term. However, there is some good news is that after approx 1,700 miles, I noticed that I had total peace of mind for a few hours a day.

More sensible research suggests that only those who live in the countryside and have access to large green spaces benefit from the advice. Those who live in busy places have an increase in cortisol after a walk, especially if you are female.

No surprises there.