Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Just go for a walk..."

335 replies

LittleMissUnreasonable · 19/09/2023 08:11

Why does this always seem to be one of the big solutions for people who are suffering from poor mental health? Maybe if I lived in Southern Spain having a nice sunny walk would be very pleasant. But the weather being so miserable and grey ends up making me feel worse. The thought of putting on waterproofs to trudge through the grey endless rain, only to end up in a condensation filled cafe that smells of damp coats just doesn't seem very appealing

OP posts:
Tessisme · 19/09/2023 11:50

DoItAgainPlz · 19/09/2023 11:27

People don't want to help themselves. It's pathetic but you're not alone in that, OP.

I was talking to a doctor once who said every Tuesday morning his clinic is full of people - mostly women - asking for antidepressants. A few questions and it transpires they spend their weekends drinking Prosecco and other sugary alcoholic drinks, then spend Sunday and Monday hungover and coming down from the sugar high.

They're told this and still they don't accept that it's their lifestyle that's contributing to their low mood. Why should they when they can just start popping antidepressants which will solve all their problems?

I wouldn't go out in torrential rain but walking is great for your health and even if you get home cold and wet, having a shower and sitting wrapped up in bed feels much better after a walk than it would after sitting on the couch all day.

If a doctor really did make those comments, then they're a bloody disgrace.

And calling people pathetic because they can't face going for a walk when their mood is low is appallingly lacking in understanding or empathy. But hey, 'you're not alone in that' @DoItAgainPlz.

Bubop · 19/09/2023 11:47

I’m sorry you’re strugglingFlowers I know it sounds like daft advice but walking really helped me when I was recovering from depression (and it’s still part of my ‘self care’ routine).

Getting out is the hardest part, but fresh air and exercise release endorphins. It might not be a miracle cure, but it can help… even in the rain.

Bobbielikespeas · 19/09/2023 11:46

I think it depends on where in the country you live though. I used to live in the inner city where it wouldn't have been safe to walk most of the time, so yeah walking would not have been the answer at all. I'm lucky to live near lots of walking routes now though and there is enough good weather in the year to walk fairly frequently.

shakeitoffsis · 19/09/2023 11:44

I don't suffer with poor mental health but I can say that 6 months ago I started a conscious effort to go for a walk every single day and I have loved it. I try and go first thing in the morning but but it's dark that's going to have to change however I can honestly say it is a fabulous way of setting me up for the day.

hamstersarse · 19/09/2023 11:43

But how do you think antidepressants work?

They don't.
There is no evidence they work at all

Calmdown14 · 19/09/2023 11:43

But even if you don't enjoy the walk, does it make you appreciate home more afterwards?

For me one of the benefits of forcing myself out even in the worst of weather is that it raises my mood at home.

If I just stay in I feel low and like I am wasting time. But if I go out and come back again I feel I've earned the down time and actively enjoy it.

Perhaps looking at it from the opposite perspective might help.

GoryBory · 19/09/2023 11:36

defi · 19/09/2023 10:52

But how do you think antidepressants work?

They literally have a similar effect on the brain of going for a walk outdoors, which is why so many doctors recommend it.

^ there are multiple types of antidepressants that manipulate the uptake of serotonin. You'll have to excuse me but working in the mental health field I'm very jaded at the complete and utter lack of mental health support in this country. Daily patients with complex mental health needs and a combination of social economic issues are advised well try yoga and a walk. It's like slapping a plaster on a war wound.

Which is exactly what a walk does.

If you work in the field then you know that pills can only do so much and self help like waking, which has been proven to help with depression is always advised alongside other treatments.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 19/09/2023 11:34

YANBU. Walking is so fucking boring. Trudging around in the rain round a housing estate - not exactly a great experience. No cafes or anything nearby here either. I do force myself out but I can only tolerate it listening to podcasts

Ghostjail · 19/09/2023 11:33

I get it OP. When I feel shit, have a headache, haven't slept much, have an ingrown toenail, anything really, my husband's suggests I "go for a walk". Each time I feel rage.

Having said that I love walking in the rain. Nae such thing as bad weather, just the wrong clothes. 😁

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 19/09/2023 11:33

I often have to force myself to go out (I’m basically lazy!) but I invariably feel better afterwards. A bit of rain or drizzle won’t stop me - a real downpour is different. I prefer it in the cooler/colder months - it warms me up. If I’ve felt a bit chilly beforehand - albeit with the heating on - I certainly don’t afterwards.

Giveituphq · 19/09/2023 11:30

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

DoItAgainPlz · 19/09/2023 11:27

People don't want to help themselves. It's pathetic but you're not alone in that, OP.

I was talking to a doctor once who said every Tuesday morning his clinic is full of people - mostly women - asking for antidepressants. A few questions and it transpires they spend their weekends drinking Prosecco and other sugary alcoholic drinks, then spend Sunday and Monday hungover and coming down from the sugar high.

They're told this and still they don't accept that it's their lifestyle that's contributing to their low mood. Why should they when they can just start popping antidepressants which will solve all their problems?

I wouldn't go out in torrential rain but walking is great for your health and even if you get home cold and wet, having a shower and sitting wrapped up in bed feels much better after a walk than it would after sitting on the couch all day.

TussleBack · 19/09/2023 11:26

defi · 19/09/2023 10:52

But how do you think antidepressants work?

They literally have a similar effect on the brain of going for a walk outdoors, which is why so many doctors recommend it.

^ there are multiple types of antidepressants that manipulate the uptake of serotonin. You'll have to excuse me but working in the mental health field I'm very jaded at the complete and utter lack of mental health support in this country. Daily patients with complex mental health needs and a combination of social economic issues are advised well try yoga and a walk. It's like slapping a plaster on a war wound.

And if you work in MH you'll be aware of the extensive research around exercise, fresh air and being outside in nature having significant impacts on mild-moderate depression.

And the fact that we have a mental crisis in this country not just because of underfunded MH services, but because for decades GPs doled out benzodiazapines and anti-depressants to millions of people who weren't helped at all by those medications and often became worse off because they suffered side effects or addiction.

And none of those medications actually solved the issue for many people who weren't suffering from endogenous depression but were struggling single Mums, bereaved people, traumatised people or just people for whom life was stressful or shit.

So researched helped us to realise that exercise, walks, routines, productive activity and talking therapies were for most people, much better than medications.

Medication absolutely plays a part in treatment of some depressive and anxiety disorders and can be life saving.

But it isn't always the case that there's a magic pill which will make everything brighter. And even if those pills lift mood, like mirtazapine did for me when i was seriously depressed, there's the side effects of increased appetite and weight gain for which walking helped.

depressionpitofdoom · 19/09/2023 11:24

So a walk is not going to be a super effective treatment for depression and its never as simple as 'just going for a walk' - trying to find the actual motivation to get up and get ready to go on that walk in the first place is a huge hurdle and one I find too big to get over some days, let alone the actual walk itself. However - if you are on a severely low place, for instance experiencing suicidal thoughts or self harm urges, going for a walk can distract you enough to get past that initial really strong urge. It might ground you enough to be able to reach out to someone.

Going for a walk isn't a treatment for mental illness, its not a magic cure, it's not as simplistic as you can fix your mental health if you just think positively enough, if you just try harder (which is what it can come across as a lot of the time, I know when I'm in the depths of my worst days I hate people telling me to just go for a walk, or have I tried excericising). But sometimes things like walks can be a really useful distraction technique (if you can get up and get ready in the first place of course).

I know how frustrating it is though, I've lost count of the comments I get from people such as 'how can you be so depressed you don't wash - that's gross' and 'how can you allow your house to get that messy, that's so lazy'.......I get do depressed I want to kill myself, I think that's a little more concerning than skipping a shower some days. We may have come a long way from the 50's but there's still a loooonnnngggg way to go in terms of understanding and help available for mental illness. It doesn't help that there genuinely is very, very little available support, I find it extremely hard to make friends which means I don't have a support group around me, I rang samaritans and text shout recently and didn't get a response from either one. It's terrifying at the moment.

Lovemusic82 · 19/09/2023 11:21

I walk every day (well almost), I walked today in the rain and although it was windy and wet it still made me feel good. I totally get it’s not a magic cure for everyone but moving/exercising is known to help improve mental health. If the weathers too awful then I go for a swim instead, I hate being stuck indoors and hate going a day without exercise (it makes me feel worse).

Flossflower · 19/09/2023 11:19

YABU. I have had some lovely walks in full waterproofs. It does make you feel good.

colourwheelofortune · 19/09/2023 11:19

And walking is BORING

I accept fully it is good for mental health but it makes my teeth itch.

Its slightly bearable if you listen to an audio book OP?

Eartoday · 19/09/2023 11:17

It does help, so much, and it doesn’t rain every day. Even in the greyest months.

actualpuffins · 19/09/2023 11:17

@blobby10

I'd actually advise going gently (not a health professional, just speaking from personal experience). If you are stressed and not sleeping then getting up even earlier to go to the gym, or any high impact exercise like HIIT or running will actually stress out your body and just make you get every bug under the sun.

If you can I'd suggest trying to build in a bit of walking during your work day and a bit more at the weekend. And there are lot of free yoga videos online- doesn't have to be long, just 20 minutes would have an effect.

Also if a job/my lifestyle is stopping me from exercising then I've always aimed to change that when possible - as a long term aim if not possible straight away.

Tessisme · 19/09/2023 11:16

I love walking. I grew up in a family with no car, so we walked everywhere. I have always felt that my day is not complete and my brain not quite calibrated without a walk, whatever the crappy NI weather!

BUT

My mum just died last month. I am depressed. Am I going for walks? Nope. I know it would help me overall but I can't be arsed. Walking, moving my body, frees up my mind to think. It FORCES me to think. I don't want to think. Normally I would listen to an audiobook, but right now I can't block out the clamouring thoughts. What IS helping me right now is knitting or crocheting while simultaneously watching a series on Netflix or the iPlayer.

So, while I would say that walking is generally excellent for your mental health, it depends. I will probably get to the point of wanting/needing to walk again, but for now it's knitting and Netflix and Magnums!!!

NosnowontheScottishhills · 19/09/2023 11:15

Ive just got back from a walk I looked out of the window and it was (as usual for here) pissing with rain. By the time Id got ready to go put on the wet weather clothing etc and met my friend it had stopped raining. We've just had a lovely walk and I swear I can see some blue sky and the mist is starting to lift off the hills that surround us.
Im lucky I live in a very rural location over the year I watch the season change, we're coming into a time of year I hate short days lots of darkness rain and wind but just after Xmas when Ive really had enough I start to see the snowdrops in our hedges coming through for me it signifies the beginning of the end of the the winter and hope, then daffodils come and there are lambs in our fields, then the leaves start coming out on the trees and the days start to get longer. The migratory geese that fill our fields in the winter start getting ready to fly back to the artic, blossoms comes out in the trees, calves are born and then I see the first swallow, its nearly summer and the very long days are really here again. I see willow herb growing in our hedges honeysuckle meadow sweet cow parsley and thrift all over our beaches bats are flying at night. Now of course its autumn the swallows are gone or getting ready to go sitting on the electric wires, the geese are coming back, the curlews have been back for a quite a while and its raining as always. In a minute the trees are going to change colour and briefly look beautiful. But I know whats to come dark days and wind and rain but I also know that just after Xmas the snowdrops will be back in our hedges the that means the end of the winter and hope for whats going to come.
All this just by walking every day and it's completely free!

HobbiddoH · 19/09/2023 11:13

I have a friend who has suffered with mental health issues and addiction issues for many years. They have now moved away from everyone they know to a beautiful area with stunning views, walks. Each day they drag themselves out of bed and force themselves to go for long walks in the countryside. They say that it really helps keep them going ok the right path, and even though they struggle to get up some mornings, they always feel so much better after these glorious walks, whatever the weather.

Sarvanga38 · 19/09/2023 11:13

I also thoroughly agree with those who say make your winter outdoor clothing bright colours - far better a bright red, yellow, blue than more grey.

Sarvanga38 · 19/09/2023 11:12

PersonIrresponsible · 19/09/2023 10:22

I can 100% vouch that I took the advice "if you have a lot on your mind, go for a walk" very seriously. It is now my specialist subject.

I walked across America: from Mexico to Canada. Six months later I was back on anti-depressants, but a year later my self-esteem was at its highest levels ever, and I was off the pills. I even wrote a book about it.

So no, a walk fixed nothing in the short term. However, there is some good news is that after approx 1,700 miles, I noticed that I had total peace of mind for a few hours a day.

More sensible research suggests that only those who live in the countryside and have access to large green spaces benefit from the advice. Those who live in busy places have an increase in cortisol after a walk, especially if you are female.

No surprises there.

Could you PM me the title too please?

fellowworrier · 19/09/2023 11:11

defi · 19/09/2023 10:52

But how do you think antidepressants work?

They literally have a similar effect on the brain of going for a walk outdoors, which is why so many doctors recommend it.

^ there are multiple types of antidepressants that manipulate the uptake of serotonin. You'll have to excuse me but working in the mental health field I'm very jaded at the complete and utter lack of mental health support in this country. Daily patients with complex mental health needs and a combination of social economic issues are advised well try yoga and a walk. It's like slapping a plaster on a war wound.

I think this thread is mostly people advising the Op not to dismiss the idea of going for a walk, as it may help, rather than people telling her that it's all anyone needs to do to fix mental illness by itself.