Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Just go for a walk..."

335 replies

LittleMissUnreasonable · 19/09/2023 08:11

Why does this always seem to be one of the big solutions for people who are suffering from poor mental health? Maybe if I lived in Southern Spain having a nice sunny walk would be very pleasant. But the weather being so miserable and grey ends up making me feel worse. The thought of putting on waterproofs to trudge through the grey endless rain, only to end up in a condensation filled cafe that smells of damp coats just doesn't seem very appealing

OP posts:
TempyBrennan · 19/09/2023 13:25

I said YABU purely because I drag my arse out whatever the weather, even in my deepest darkest moments my husband got me outside and it has kept me alive to this day.
So yes, it does help. And judging by my local support groups it helps us all, so I’m casting a wide net with my response!

off · 19/09/2023 13:14

It's not even just about whether you can "face it". When my mood is low, my mind and body are slowed so much that the organisation and energy required to get myself dressed and outdoors is immense (washed? don't make me laugh). Once out, my walking speed will be maybe a third of what it usually is, a shuffle at best. My stiffened, unresponsive muscles will ache at every weighted, leaden step. My observations, thoughts and reactions won't happen fast enough to allow me to safely cross the road, let alone have friendly chats with shopkeepers or marvel at rustling trees. I may slow up and stop altogether, and be unable to work out how I'm going to get home again, or care about it. When I do get back, I'll have pain all over my body, and that's all the energy I might have used for speaking/eating/drinking/moving from sofa to bed for sleep/concentrating on understanding and responding when spoken to, used up on "a nice walk".

Kat19899 · 19/09/2023 13:07

I agree that a walk doesn’t help much and when you’re struggling it’s bloody hard to force yourself.

However I’ve been a consistent walker for years and I would say the benefits come down to three things. 1. The achievement of committing to something and doing it regularly can be a small win or first step. 2. Walking fast and hard enough to sweat and be out of breath will make you feel way better than a random stroll. 3. The walk is not really actually about walking anyway, it’s about being present while you look around and letting thoughts drift through your brain so you’re practising mindfulness without really trying

Exercise is great for depression but only if you enjoy it. It’s about finding something you actually want to do, not forcing yourself to do what you think you should do

ShadyPaws · 19/09/2023 13:04

I mean it depends how depressed you are too
Slightly low mood then yeah, it'll help
Lying on the floor wondering how the fuck you stay alive for another hour, you're probably going to need the medication to be able to function enough to even consider a walk
Been there. Still on the medication, exercise helps but I need the medication to be able to exercise... not walking as I hate it

defi · 19/09/2023 13:03

If a doctor really did make those comments, then they're a bloody disgrace.

And calling people pathetic because they can't face going for a walk when their mood is low is appallingly lacking in understanding or empathy. But hey, 'you're not alone in that' @DoItAgainPlz.

^ quite right, that attitude is vile. Let's not forget people can be depressed to the point of inertia. Try a little empathy.

truthhurts23 · 19/09/2023 13:00

Endorphins, fresh air, exercise, nature

Kat19899 · 19/09/2023 13:00

GoryBory · 19/09/2023 12:53

Of course they work!
And there’s loads of evidence for this.

Obviously they’re not a miracle pill and it can take a long time to find the right dosage and get to the root of any underlying issues but they absolutely do work for the majority of people.

I agree they work but I definitely don’t think it’s a majority. I’m sure I’ve seen figures that say about 30% of people respond to them

GoryBory · 19/09/2023 12:53

hamstersarse · 19/09/2023 11:43

But how do you think antidepressants work?

They don't.
There is no evidence they work at all

Of course they work!
And there’s loads of evidence for this.

Obviously they’re not a miracle pill and it can take a long time to find the right dosage and get to the root of any underlying issues but they absolutely do work for the majority of people.

actualpuffins · 19/09/2023 12:53

"Just go for a walk" can be facile but as I say, also a much more sustainable, achievable, cheap and accessible aim for many people than "join a gym" for health, general lifestyle or mild to moderate MH issues.

Serious (mental) health issues also need medication and other therapy.

For a lot of people, chipping away at things daily is better than big and unsustainable aims and goals.

whatwasthatgrandma · 19/09/2023 12:52

EverythingYouDoIsaBalloon · 19/09/2023 12:47

OMG I know. Why do so many people trot this out? I suffer from depression and getting out for a walk in decent weather does help me a lot, but it's a long way from being the cure-all panacea a lot of people make it out to be. It really minimises what depression is imo, and inevitably some of the people who parrot this line will either have never experienced depression and be confusing it with just feeling a bit miz, or will have found it helpful because they were only mildly depressed in the first place.

Plus, as pps have pointed out, not everyone lives in an area that's pleasant to walk in.

Nobody said it was a cure all panacea. But it IS scientifically proven to help depression. that's a fact, no matter what you think of it.

you don't need an area thats pleasant to walk in to just walk.

inamarina · 19/09/2023 12:50

madeinmanc · 19/09/2023 09:15

People also don't want to feel that there's an insurmountable challenge for some people when it comes to mental health. They want to maintain that there is a solution, there must be. Anything else is a challenge to their beliefs about life.

This is actually in evidence in the replies here to your post, @LittleMissUnreasonable . "Walking must help", "There is no mental ill in life that cannot be cured by a brisk walk. There isn't.".

Edited

"There is no mental ill in life that cannot be cured by a brisk walk. There isn't.".

I didn’t see anyone phrasing it in those absolute terms.

"Walking must help"

Walking does help. As stated by several posters on this thread who struggled with mental health issues themselves.
Walking won’t solve all issues or cure clinical depression, but many people do find it very helpful.

EverythingYouDoIsaBalloon · 19/09/2023 12:47

OMG I know. Why do so many people trot this out? I suffer from depression and getting out for a walk in decent weather does help me a lot, but it's a long way from being the cure-all panacea a lot of people make it out to be. It really minimises what depression is imo, and inevitably some of the people who parrot this line will either have never experienced depression and be confusing it with just feeling a bit miz, or will have found it helpful because they were only mildly depressed in the first place.

Plus, as pps have pointed out, not everyone lives in an area that's pleasant to walk in.

theemmadilemma · 19/09/2023 12:38

When I got sober was when I fell in love with being outside in the open air. Just the feel of the wind, sun, rain, snow on your face makes you feel alive. The feel of grass on bare feet, or the crunch of snow under boots is grounding. It's where I find my sanity, calmness.

It sounded so stupid when people said it to me. It's so very true.

Idontpostmuch · 19/09/2023 12:34

Do you like reading? If so, try walking while listening to audiobooks. It's my favourite cure for the blues. Or get a book of walks for your area. I don't mean hill walks, but urban walks. Some books detail walks around interesting areas alive with history. It's surprising how many interesting corners there are in the most mundane parts of town. A step counting app also makes walking more interesting. Treasure Trails are fun too. Walks of only about 2 miles, but you usually walk farther because you sometimes have to double back to find clues, and perhaps walk to the start, and home from the end. Check out www.treasuretrails.co.uk The UK actually has a good climate for walking. We can even walk through much of summer, apart from during heatwaves, which only account for around 3 or 4 weeks, and that's in the warmest part of the country. Walking in Spain in summer would be hard work. OK so we get rain, but plenty dry days too. Build up to walking 4 or 5 miles and let endorphines work on your mood. It will be worth it.

Treasure Trails - Treasure Hunts, Detective & Spy Missions

Explore outdoors like never before with Treasure Trails. Solve the clues, see the sights and have fun with over 1,200 exciting adventures all over the UK.

http://www.treasuretrails.co.uk

Lifeomars · 19/09/2023 12:31

Bobbielikespeas · 19/09/2023 11:46

I think it depends on where in the country you live though. I used to live in the inner city where it wouldn't have been safe to walk most of the time, so yeah walking would not have been the answer at all. I'm lucky to live near lots of walking routes now though and there is enough good weather in the year to walk fairly frequently.

I've just posted saying something similar. I am in an inner city and tbh going out can often make my mood dip significantly. Walking past fly tips and drug deals just makes me miserable. There is rubbish everywhere, I have seen fights, drunks passed out on the local park, the roads are very busy so the escooters and cyclists ride on the pavement and give you verbal abuse if you don't leap out of their way. I'm ashamed of where I live, so going for a walk often makes me feel worse about myself

Lifeomars · 19/09/2023 12:22

I agree with you that it has a lot to do with where you live. I live in a run down inner city area and while there are a couple of pleasant green spaces close to my home, reaching them means walking down my crappy street where nobody puts their bins in, there is always fly tipping, lots of street drinkers. It just makes me more depressed knowing that this is where I am stuck as I cannot afford to move. In fact it makes me feel like a worthless failure at times, no matter how clean and pleasant my actual home it, the area I live is ugly and depressing. I can literally go the park and be pestered by beggars on my way there. Sometimes I imagine how much better I would feel if I live in a less unpleasant environment. A walk does help, I am not disputing that, it can shift your mood, make you feel connected with nature and make you naturally tired so you sleep better. However in my case, going out often makes me feel worse

BarborousBarbra · 19/09/2023 12:16

I hate this too. I live in the Lake District and walking the dog and hiking are two of my favorite things, but when I'm mentally unwell, no amount of walking helps and the 'just go for a walk' attitude does not help. if it was that easy nobody would be depressed.

Ilikeicecream · 19/09/2023 12:12

megletthesecond · 19/09/2023 08:28

Litter picking walks are good. Gives you something to do when you get home too as you'll probably have to fire off an email to the council about fly tipping.

This is very good advice. Plus you feel better by doing something good.

Cyllie33 · 19/09/2023 12:09

Hi OP, I find getting outside massively helps me - it’s not always easy but I find a couple of things that help me are:

having somewhere to go, so a purpose (def not a smelly cafe tho) - I wrote a lot of postcards so I had to get out to go to the postbox, or go and get a nice takeaway coffee

listening to podcasts - I enjoy no such thing as a fish and You’re Dead to Me so I only listen to them when either going for a walk or doing the ironing to motivate me to do those things

MrsVeryTired · 19/09/2023 12:08

I don't mind walking in the rain at all, as long as I have a good jacket and waterproof boots. Its the exercise and the fresh air that helps with the mood imo rather than sunshine, although sunshine is nice too. Having dogs I have to walk anyway and it definitely helps my mental health.

off · 19/09/2023 12:05

When I'm depressed, going for a walk invariably makes me feel worse. 🤷

depressionpitofdoom · 19/09/2023 12:04

DoItAgainPlz · 19/09/2023 11:27

People don't want to help themselves. It's pathetic but you're not alone in that, OP.

I was talking to a doctor once who said every Tuesday morning his clinic is full of people - mostly women - asking for antidepressants. A few questions and it transpires they spend their weekends drinking Prosecco and other sugary alcoholic drinks, then spend Sunday and Monday hungover and coming down from the sugar high.

They're told this and still they don't accept that it's their lifestyle that's contributing to their low mood. Why should they when they can just start popping antidepressants which will solve all their problems?

I wouldn't go out in torrential rain but walking is great for your health and even if you get home cold and wet, having a shower and sitting wrapped up in bed feels much better after a walk than it would after sitting on the couch all day.

I don't know what sort of doctor you were talking to but it sounds like they could do with some education on mental health. It's not pathetic to be unwell. It is incredibly difficult to find the motivation to do what needs to be done in order to help yourself when you are that low. It's not just going out for a walk for example; first of all I need to think about getting ready, which entails thinking about getting dressed which means trying to work out what clothes I need to wear to suit the weather and I need to find those clothes, and I should probably shower first (although admittedly this gets skipped on the worst days because showering is a whole other list of tasks that are too overwhelming to think about sometimes) and I need to think about where I'm walking to and am I going to need yo take anything with me, where are those things and do I have a bag for those things and frankly just thinking about getting ready to go out exhausts me and overwhelms me so much that I can't muster up the energy. That's not because I am pathetic - it's because I'm not well.

Those women who are drinking that much, are potentially self medicating because they feel low, if that drink at the end of the week is the only thing getting them through the week then why on earth would they want to give that up (much like most things people self-medicate with).

Poudretteite · 19/09/2023 12:01

I have anxiety and panic attacks, and going for a walk really helps me. It might not work for you, but it can help a lot of people.

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 19/09/2023 12:00

LittleMissUnreasonable · 19/09/2023 09:36

@Bettyboobaloo
I seem defensive after thanking about 8 posters individually for their motivating and good advice. Okay then 😂

Thank you everyone else for the advise. You've inspired me to get a good pair of waterproof shoes and actually get out there! 😊

Good resolution!

I think that you don't have to enjoy the walk for it to do good.

There is something about moving about outside that lifts you and untangles your head - even when nothing has changed and you didn't like doing it.

Perhaps it is that you also face head-on the struggle to get out and do something... and can see your success in overcoming the horrible inertia of depression and anxiety.

blobby10 · 19/09/2023 11:50

@Giveituphq and @actualpuffins Thank you both of you for taking the time to read my posts and tag me with suggestions. I cycle a lot at the weekends (30-40 miles per day) and do spend lots of time outdoors but that's only 2 days out of 7 - need to find something to get me out of the house during the week. I hate exercise classes whether its yoga or spin and tbh don't really have the spare cash right now. Doing yoga or pilates in front of the tv seems to defeat the objective of getting away from the house and screens! Grin
Giving up or changing work also not an option as I'm running the company and have 15 other people to think about and look after all of whom have mortgages and families like me. Hoping that work will pick up soon and life will be a lot less stressful...............................!

Swipe left for the next trending thread