Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Just go for a walk..."

335 replies

LittleMissUnreasonable · 19/09/2023 08:11

Why does this always seem to be one of the big solutions for people who are suffering from poor mental health? Maybe if I lived in Southern Spain having a nice sunny walk would be very pleasant. But the weather being so miserable and grey ends up making me feel worse. The thought of putting on waterproofs to trudge through the grey endless rain, only to end up in a condensation filled cafe that smells of damp coats just doesn't seem very appealing

OP posts:
5128gap · 19/09/2023 22:10

I love to walk. But even if I didn't, the way i see it, if I'm going to be depressed whatever I do, then I might as well be depressed while doing something good for me.

Frambuesa · 19/09/2023 22:05

To be honest I spent over a decade living in southern Spain with severe anxiety. I lost count of the amount of walks and runs I had, and I still had a breakdown.
I understand what you're saying OP. Some people with mental health issues are beyond being helped by going for a walk.

I refused meds for many years because everyone around me steered me away from them and told me I needed to walk and do breathing exercises instead.
Thank god I gave in in the end and tried the GPs way otherwise I might not be here now.

Member869894 · 19/09/2023 21:49

All I know is that I have never ever been for a walk I any weather/circumstances and not felt better for it. I don't know why but there must be a scientific explanation for it. As you say the thought might not appeal but the action of walking ends with positive results

EverythingYouDoIsaBalloon · 19/09/2023 18:58

DoItAgainPlz · 19/09/2023 11:27

People don't want to help themselves. It's pathetic but you're not alone in that, OP.

I was talking to a doctor once who said every Tuesday morning his clinic is full of people - mostly women - asking for antidepressants. A few questions and it transpires they spend their weekends drinking Prosecco and other sugary alcoholic drinks, then spend Sunday and Monday hungover and coming down from the sugar high.

They're told this and still they don't accept that it's their lifestyle that's contributing to their low mood. Why should they when they can just start popping antidepressants which will solve all their problems?

I wouldn't go out in torrential rain but walking is great for your health and even if you get home cold and wet, having a shower and sitting wrapped up in bed feels much better after a walk than it would after sitting on the couch all day.

FFS.

Of course some people fall into the category you describe, but it's insulting to tar OP (and by implication other people on this thread) with the same brush just because this is how some people deal with depression. I can't tell from your post whether you suffer from it yourself, but I suspect not or you wouldn't be making such reductive overgeneralisations.

EverythingYouDoIsaBalloon · 19/09/2023 18:53

whatwasthatgrandma · 19/09/2023 12:52

Nobody said it was a cure all panacea. But it IS scientifically proven to help depression. that's a fact, no matter what you think of it.

you don't need an area thats pleasant to walk in to just walk.

I agree it can help (definitely helps me), but some people do seem to think its a 'fix' for depression in itself. I agree that claim isn't being made on here, but IRL I've heard multiple claims that so-and-so's friend/sibling/neighbour's postman used to be depressed but then took up walking or another sport and 'now they're fine', so there are definitely people who view this in such simplistic terms.

I think my point about whether an area is at least moderately pleasant to walk in is valid, though. I'm not saying it has to be fields and woodlands, but if someone's living in an area they find depressing, I can easily see how walking through it could cancel out a lot of the benefit of the walk, and at least one pp (I haven't RTFT) has attested to that.

Handcreamqueen · 19/09/2023 17:25

It all depends on where you are walking.

I have suffered with poor mental health most of my life, it will never leave me, I accept that but walking around the fields and woodlands where I live (with my dog) has kept me sane. Being in nature is one of the most pleasurable experiences for me, I love all of the seasons and I am a strange one in the fact that I love, love walking in the rain (probably because I’m an introvert and most people don’t come out in the rain).
I defy anyone not to feel uplifted being in nature.

On the other hand, once a week, I walk my friend’s dog round the town she lives in and boy is that boring - houses upon houses, buildings upon buildings and smelly traffic, no thanks.

Oh and btw I never ended up in a cafe after my walks.

gannett · 19/09/2023 17:15

No one's ever said a walk is a magic fix for depression and certainly not a walk in the miserable rain. It's just literally a step in the right direction. You could sub in for "a walk" anything that gets you moving, gets your heart rate up, gets you engaging with the wider world and gets you present in the moment. You don't have to trudge around and get wet.

StrongandNorthern · 19/09/2023 17:10

Hi OP..
I'm sorry - I've not read all the responses.
I hope they were useful. Well, some would have been ... and some wouldn't ... and the odd (prob best word on many levels) one would be unhelpful and/or inflammatory.
Anyway - just to say
a walk/frequent walks can help.
Lying on sofa trying not to die of fright doesn't help ... but sometimes it's the best (only) option.
Once - when at totally 'end of tether' I was told to 'try swimming' ... that after a 9 month wait for 'counselling'.
Really I just wanted to say - feeling bad for whatever MH reason is 'The Worst Thing'.
So -I hope stuff improves for you asap.
There are no quick fixes but eventually (hopefully) you'll find something/things which help.
I'm not going to suggest any (esp not walking or swimming 😂) but I hope you'll find something (it can take time ...oh, and vodka's not optimal tbh).
Good Luck my lovely.
It's crap feeling crap.
My 'best thing what's was a card from a mate. It said 'This too shall pass'.
It will.
(It comes back. But it passes again).
Hug.

off · 19/09/2023 17:09

Research has also shown that antidepressants can help with depression, but that doesn't mean they help everybody, or that there aren't some people who get awful side effects, or that people should pressure and push and nag people who don't want to take them, or refuse to believe them if they say it doesn't help them.

Suggestions are fine, and encouragement can be helpful, but there's a hard core of walk-for-wellness absolutists who flat-out refuse to believe someone if they say that going for a walk won't help their mood, even a little bit, or even if they say that they can't do it when depressed. Sometimes it even extends to the point of implicitly or explicitly blaming someone for their depression, because even if they say they've tried it before but it didn't help or made things worse, that can't be true, and if they simply got off their arse and trudged round their local suburb for half an hour a day, they would definitely 100% for certain become less mentally ill. This also includes some mental health crisis team staff members Hmm

Mumof3children · 19/09/2023 16:58

Research has shown that walking IS good for mental health (especially to combat depression).
Skies often look greyer from inside than they are in reality.

AInightingale · 19/09/2023 15:40

I used to live in the middle of a city and my favourite times and places to walk were at 6am on a Sunday morning in the brighter months, and at night through the posh suburbs, in the rain, often. When your mood is low you don't want to see lots of people. But also appreciate that some cities nowadays are not safe places at any time.

Saverage · 19/09/2023 15:00

Walking has helped me 99% of the time - to stay level, and with mild depression.

On the occasional very depressed days though, it doesn't work at all. My limbs feel like lead, I feel paranoid and I want to cry. On those days I might start a walk, get a little way and realise it would be better to be at home.

AlienatedChildGrown · 19/09/2023 14:27

I felt the same.

Annoyingly it turned out to be great advice and bang on the money. But I had to get my baseline to a higher place via medication before I was able to go for a walk, let alone benefit from it. I now go for a walk twice a day. And they are my favourite parts of the day. If there’s a storm I end up doing my best sad dog impression, staring out the door with a hopeful expression, until I can go out. If I can’t I end up with an evening of deep sighs. Bloody lightning is a buzz killer.

MaryMcCarthy · 19/09/2023 14:26

I find walking to be fantastic. Really helps my clear my mind and think things through, to the benefit of my mental and physical health.

And you don't have to end up in a damp café if you don't want to.

The joy is that you can go anywhere you want.

It's not necessarily about the destination.

nopuppiesallowed · 19/09/2023 14:23

@RaraRachael
My Tai Chi class has people ranging from early 30s to 80 and includes a man who's recovering from hip surgery, a woman with balance problems and a man who has obviously had a stroke. I've got osteoporosis (but no fractures). The others look 'normal'. The movements are slow and careful. I honestly didn't feel I'd go more than once as, until my osteoporosis diagnosis and then Long Covid, I preferred to do everything fast, but it's amazing. (And I'm not related to anyone teaching it)

ManchesterLu · 19/09/2023 14:15

Walking (or exercise in general) is really, really good for your mental health, and I say that as someone who has previously struggled to get out and about, but always felt better once I'd done it.

However, I'm with you 100%. Not when the weather is crap. It's not enjoyable, and getting home wet and cold is not helpful to how I feel in the slightest.

This time of year is so tough, but one thing that helps me is searching for an exercise video on YouTube and following that. Any exercise is better than nothing - and make the most of the dryer, brighter days when and if you can.

RaraRachael · 19/09/2023 14:06

Thanks @Snippysocks I had wondered about pilates, yoga etc but Tai Chi never entered my head. I'll have a look online to see if I can find anything as I'm in quite a rural location with no classes anywhere near.

nopuppiesallowed · 19/09/2023 13:56

@RaraRachael
Ouch! Painful knees would definitely get in the way of a good walk. Me? I'd look into doing Pilates or Tai Chi. A good teacher will tailor exercises for you. And for people with depression? Tai Chi keeps your mind totally focused on the slow movements, so will give you at least an hour free from thinking negative thoughts. I honestly thought I'd die of boredom during the first lessons but now I'm hooked on it. There are some brilliant YouTube videos if you want to try it at home but like most activities, it's more beneficial to do it in a group. If there are no groups in your area, contact a teacher and ask him / her to set one up near you.

littlelionroars · 19/09/2023 13:53

A few years back I went for a dental check up, I was told that I clearly clench my teeth and asked why I do that. I shrugged and said, I didn't realise that I was doing it but it was probably stress related.

Dentist looked at me and asked, what are you stressed about? Which I thought was a very personal question coming from someone I had just met moments earlier.

Then before I could answer he helpfully stated: Next time you feel stressed go for a walk instead of clenching your teeth. 🙄

I do think walking is beneficial but don't think it was helpful advice in this particular circumstance...

PersonIrresponsible · 19/09/2023 13:44

Happy to

It's called Everything You Ever Taught Me. On Amazon.

PoshPineapple · 19/09/2023 13:42

I wish I could go for a lovely, long walk - a spinal injury and many surgeries later, walking more than about 50 yards is something I can no longer do. I do however have a trusty little mobility scooter that I like to whizz around on, but it's not quite the same as a good ole walk and definitely not as calorie-burning!

Your whiffy, muggy cafe reference made me laugh. I often wonder how fictional novels make these places sound sooooo cosy and inviting when filled with rain-sodden characters in the book. It conjures up images of all sorts of convivial atmospheres, with children giggling and the comforting chitter chatter of weary, but happy adults, all enjoying a steaming hot chocolate with whipped cream and marshmallows on top.

We all know the stark reality is the smell of wet dog, tuna and rain-sodden padded coats. The hot chocolate is economy powdered shite from Bestway and the whipped cream is a squirt of watery air out of a can courtesy of Anchor. Oh and the marshmallows have usually fallen off by the time it's made it to the table. The giggling children are more often screeching and wailing and the chitter chatter of the adults is usually them yelling the kids to behave.

Ah yes, I love a cafe in rainy weather!

Highdaysandholidays1 · 19/09/2023 13:42

I spent my entire childhood walking to school in the rain, going on lovely walking holidays trudging along the coastal path with a cagoule on with rain dripping down my neck, and going out on Sundays for a walk as the exciting activity of the day.

Safe to say I'm not mad on walks as an adult! But, I do find that exercise helps, so I substitute walks for dancing like a crazy thing around the living room for 15 min or exercising on my bike or whatever, although I agree in a very depressed state, simply moving may be beyond you.

Other people stepping in can help, one of my children had depression and I used to find something to do outside every day, not necessarily a walk, but going to the shop, the drive through for a coffee, just anything to be outside with other people.

It's fine not to like walking, and it's impossible to be a chirpy walker when really down, but exercise, even a tiny bit in your own home or doing a small step goal or anything like that helps mood and sleep.

GoryBory · 19/09/2023 13:28

Kat19899 · 19/09/2023 13:00

I agree they work but I definitely don’t think it’s a majority. I’m sure I’ve seen figures that say about 30% of people respond to them

That’s usually if people don’t take them correctly or don’t make changes in their lifestyles to help themselves after they come off them.

I think the rate of effectiveness is over 80% if taken correctly.

kitsuneghost · 19/09/2023 13:26

The thought is worse than the doing and people with poor mental health are already in a negative state of mind so of course think that it won't solve anything.
They don't think anything will solve anything.

Positive people see fresh air, gorgeous smell of rain, rainbows and cosy cafes

Negative people see trudging through the grey endless rain, only to end up in a condensation filled cafe that smells of damp coats.

off · 19/09/2023 13:25

Even when I'm only mildly depressed and can think/walk at a more or less normal speed, the whole thing about it is that nothing much gets through the depression perception/emotion filter. There are birds singing. So? My face tingles coming in from the cold. A mere observation of a meaningless sensation. And lo, I did leave the house, traverse a wiggly circle, and return. A series of images passed before me, a series of bodily sensations happened. Nothing was achieved, nothing is changed, energy was exerted, time passed, and here I am, still contemplating the maw of internal despair, etc. etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread