Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Its like downtown Kabul round here"

344 replies

PyongyangKipperbang · 19/09/2023 02:34

This has been bugging me all day.

Took my father (72) to a hospital appointment today as my mother was suffering with a migraine.

As we drove from our village through town he made this comment. It was school run time and we had just driven past two women who were wearing traditional muslim attire , wearing full matching outfits, one in black and one in the most stunning purple. Forgive me for not using the correct names but I would rather not try than get them wrong. There were a fair few families dressed similarly, but more that were in jeans and trainers!

Our small town is very very multicultural. My ex husband is Jamaican by heritage, British by birth as ex MIL and late FIL were both part of the Windrush generation. There is a large Asian community and now a lot of Eastern Europeans too.

Me - What?! They follow a different religion and dress that way, so what? And at least their dd's get to go to school.

Him - Oh well if youa re going to be like that about it

Me - Yes I am. In Kabul W X Y Z (my dd's, his GD's) wouldnt be allowed to go to school and would be forced to wear certain clothes, unlike here where we just let people be.

Then he said "well thats what I think and I can say it if I think it" and I said "Not in my car you cant. and if you think that they should all go back to where they came from, that includes Z (youngest DD, mixed race)"

Silence for a second and then "Thank you for the lift, I will get out at the lights and walk the rest of the way" I said to stop being childish. Then a dickhead cut me up and I called him as such and father said "Oh I bet all the bad drivers are only white british....." in a mumble. I said "Well as it happens, that one was" dropped him off at the hospital and all was done.

He has been cobby with me since. He needed a couple of favours later today as he can no longer drive and Ma couldnt because of her head and it was couched very much as "Your mother needs this and I cant go" rather than, as it would normally me "would you do me a favour?"

I wasnt wrong to pull him up on this was I? He isnt "elderly", just fucking "ist" when it suits him and inclusive when it doesnt. For example, DD1's partner is autistic which is thinks is made up and attention seeking...."apart from [him]". He has always been like this but I strongly suspect I am going to get the silent treatment for a while (unless he needs something). And yes, he does read THAT paper.......

We are very close and I love him very much and he me. But when Mr Daily Hate comes out......not so much..,,,

OP posts:
GarlicGrace · 19/09/2023 16:17

BurnToastAgain · 19/09/2023 16:13

Erm, survive what “nonsense”? I’m not sure what you’re talking about. You are being massively disrespectful of my heritage though by calling it restrictive and oppressive. Would you talk about other people’s heritage in the same way? If not, why not? Is it because you know just how offensive that would be?

It's the UK's heritage, you numpty. Shared by all of Europe, some of the Near East & North Africa, and exported across the Americas & to Australia.

If you want to take personal ownership of it, though, you're welcome to it. Keep it!

BurnToastAgain · 19/09/2023 16:13

GarlicGrace · 19/09/2023 16:09

That's a ridiculous non-argument. I'm saying past beliefs leave residues, and that this isn't the same as forming the entire basis of society. Current UK society doesn't give a shit if I sleep around, wear shorts, have my own job & control of my finances, live with a man I'm not married to, have children while unmarried, use contraception, laugh loudly, get drunk, answer back to a man, read my horoscope and never go to church. While Judæo-Christianity held sway, all the above (and a lot more restrictions) were illegal.

This oppressive past doesn't explain my existence in the way that having ancestors does - except insofar as my ancestors managed to survive this nonsense long enough to have children.

Erm, survive what “nonsense”? I’m not sure what you’re talking about. You are being massively disrespectful of my heritage though by calling it restrictive and oppressive. Would you talk about other people’s heritage in the same way? If not, why not? Is it because you know just how offensive that would be?

BlooDeBloop · 19/09/2023 16:12

MarkWithaC · 19/09/2023 15:07

BlooDeBloop, I think someone would have to be pretty dim not to see a difference between a woman in the supermarket with her face covered with a veil and someone in a crash helmet in a bank.

The notion of the UK having one particular and monolithic clothing norm or culture is just meaningless. For good reasons and for less edifying ones, for much of the UK's history it's been home to people from all kinds of countries and cultures, dressing and looking all kinds of different ways.

It is ironic that you wax lyrical about the UK being a place where 'There is great latitude where people generally feel able to wear what they want', and yet do not feel that this applies to people who want to wear a veil or 'black drapes'.

It's interesting that you throw around the phrase 'culturally Christian values' until challenged, and then – of course! – all you meant was 'secular values', and you could just as easily have used that phrase instead, you just didn't...

I also note the appearance on the thread of that old favourite trope that if we can't see someone's eyes we struggle to connect with them and our 'instincts' (which of course we all act on, all the time) tell us we cannot trust them. And we simply cannot get past that Hmm

Why is it someone in any debate has to go all black and white? Who on earth is advocating monolithic clothing or cultural norms? Rather like the free speech advocates (I include myself) there is always the point at which it is challenged i.e. inciting hate, or whatever. In a free living society that is especially free in expression there is a challenge when it comes up against a culture of intolerance or inequality marked by highly restrictive or prescriptive clothing. I wouldn't want to legislate against the freedom of Muslim women to veil, but I don't condone it and I wish they would rip it off like the brave Iranian women.

Further, the veil is a visible marker of that division. I'm even less clued up about orthodox Jews - does their culture and values come into such stark conflict with Western values? If they do we don't hear about it or crucially SEE it in quite the same way as the veil.

I don't think we should all dress the same or look the same. God forbid, I'm a non conformer 😅. When it comes to the level of integration (how to define that is another topic), then clothing within the norms would be one factor to consider. The norms of this country are thankfully wide but not limitless. Is that Islamophobic ?

Zarah123 · 19/09/2023 16:12

Thanks for being one of the good guys and being actively anti-racist, OP.

I'm British Pakistani, fair skinned and light haired and don't wear hijab so most people assume I'm European. I do experience racism but probably only 2-3 times a year.

When I'm out with my family who do wear hijab, the number of racist/Islamophobic incidents really go up. My heart hurts for my nieces, they're such lovely girls and they don't deserve the treatment they get.

I'd say every other time we experience some sort of incident. And we're in the London suburbs!

I'm sad to see people telling you not to make a big deal out of it. We need people to speak up and tell their family members (no matter how old) and friends that these comments are not ok.

BurnToastAgain · 19/09/2023 16:09

Aw, poor thing. I’d not realised she couldn’t use the quote function and had used it accidentally to address me directly. Maybe someone could explain how it works?

GarlicGrace · 19/09/2023 16:09

BurnToastAgain · 19/09/2023 15:48

That’s like saying your ancestors had absolutely nothing to do with your existence though. You can’t opt out of facts because they don’t accord with your feelings.

That's a ridiculous non-argument. I'm saying past beliefs leave residues, and that this isn't the same as forming the entire basis of society. Current UK society doesn't give a shit if I sleep around, wear shorts, have my own job & control of my finances, live with a man I'm not married to, have children while unmarried, use contraception, laugh loudly, get drunk, answer back to a man, read my horoscope and never go to church. While Judæo-Christianity held sway, all the above (and a lot more restrictions) were illegal.

This oppressive past doesn't explain my existence in the way that having ancestors does - except insofar as my ancestors managed to survive this nonsense long enough to have children.

MarkWithaC · 19/09/2023 16:04

BurnToastAgain · 19/09/2023 15:50

I’m sorry. Where have I engaged in lectures? Or judging women by their clothes or any form of phobia or bigotry? Please point it out, otherwise I shall assume you’re talking about a fictional poster rather than me?

Hate to disappoint, but I don't think MotherofGorgons was talking about you personally.

BurnToastAgain · 19/09/2023 15:51

AlexandriasWindmill · 19/09/2023 15:47

You are not heartened. You are deliberately misunderstanding the thread. Christians might pray for you but none of them will entertain or engage with your goady, divisive nonsense. You are showing your complete lack of respect for all heritages and faiths.

I am religious. Please explain in what fashion I am showing a lack of respect for all heritages and faiths? Your post makes absolutely no sense.

BurnToastAgain · 19/09/2023 15:50

MotherofGorgons · 19/09/2023 15:46

I'd like to replace all religions with secularism. I am not keen on any of them. Including my own. What I am also not keen on is judging women by their clothes. Usually descends into Islamophobia and bigotry. Then into a phobia of anyone who looks different or dresses differently. And eventually a lecture about Christian values.

I’m sorry. Where have I engaged in lectures? Or judging women by their clothes or any form of phobia or bigotry? Please point it out, otherwise I shall assume you’re talking about a fictional poster rather than me?

BurnToastAgain · 19/09/2023 15:48

GarlicGrace · 19/09/2023 15:46

forms the basis of Western society is overreach. It's pervasive in our cultures, yes. Still, we can choose to ignore most or all of it. Things like the justice hierarchy are holdovers from religious structures, no longer expressions of it.

That’s like saying your ancestors had absolutely nothing to do with your existence though. You can’t opt out of facts because they don’t accord with your feelings.

AlexandriasWindmill · 19/09/2023 15:47

BurnToastAgain · 19/09/2023 15:40

I’m heartened by the almost unanimous support for the religion of Islam, but baffled as to why that acceptance, or even celebration, doesn’t extend to Christian religions?

If I point out that Judæo-Christianity forms the basis of Western society would people disagree? If so, upon what do you consider it’s based? Or, if you agree with me, can you explain why this is considered a bad thing and with what, if anything, you’d like to replace it?

You are not heartened. You are deliberately misunderstanding the thread. Christians might pray for you but none of them will entertain or engage with your goady, divisive nonsense. You are showing your complete lack of respect for all heritages and faiths.

MotherofGorgons · 19/09/2023 15:46

BurnToastAgain · 19/09/2023 15:40

I’m heartened by the almost unanimous support for the religion of Islam, but baffled as to why that acceptance, or even celebration, doesn’t extend to Christian religions?

If I point out that Judæo-Christianity forms the basis of Western society would people disagree? If so, upon what do you consider it’s based? Or, if you agree with me, can you explain why this is considered a bad thing and with what, if anything, you’d like to replace it?

I'd like to replace all religions with secularism. I am not keen on any of them. Including my own. What I am also not keen on is judging women by their clothes. Usually descends into Islamophobia and bigotry. Then into a phobia of anyone who looks different or dresses differently. And eventually a lecture about Christian values.

GarlicGrace · 19/09/2023 15:46

forms the basis of Western society is overreach. It's pervasive in our cultures, yes. Still, we can choose to ignore most or all of it. Things like the justice hierarchy are holdovers from religious structures, no longer expressions of it.

ShadyPaws · 19/09/2023 15:43

What gets me is people who are being racist and have no idea of their background. There was a YouTube video on DNA which was really interesting, I'm sure there was one that said he hated a certain country and it turns out his ancestry was that country!

Like I would say I'm white british, so would my parents and their parents and that's our ancestry. I did the family tree and it's not white british

BurnToastAgain · 19/09/2023 15:40

I’m heartened by the almost unanimous support for the religion of Islam, but baffled as to why that acceptance, or even celebration, doesn’t extend to Christian religions?

If I point out that Judæo-Christianity forms the basis of Western society would people disagree? If so, upon what do you consider it’s based? Or, if you agree with me, can you explain why this is considered a bad thing and with what, if anything, you’d like to replace it?

thetrainatplatform4 · 19/09/2023 15:38

and I said "Not in my car you cant. and if you think that they should all go back to where they came from, that includes Z

You were the one that jumped to conclusion here though OP and put words in his mouth. So on this basis YABU and took an I'll judged comment too far by assuming that he was thinking this

BlooDeBloop · 19/09/2023 15:24

therealcookiemonster · 19/09/2023 15:10

@BlooDeBloop have you looked into the availability of english language classes? the last time I looked, the waiting lists were around a year long where I live. my last housekeeper (from Eastern Europe) was desperate for the course, but just couldn't get a place and the kind of work she could do was severely restricted as a result.

Oh bless her. There are tons of independent esl teachers online but I'm sure price will put a lot of people off. Back in the day I self taught but I came at it as an independent learner and few people do it well that way. However, classes only get you so far. It's catch 22: you need a job to learn the language, but you need the language to get a job. It isn't easy for anyone which is why you need a long term commitment and where the 'value' part comes from. If you value the language highly enough you climb the barriers to learning it.

BlooDeBloop · 19/09/2023 15:17

Bonkersworknonsense · 19/09/2023 15:02

@therealcookiemonster I’m wondering what your point is about Orthodox Jewish women? Some wear wigs or scarves wrapped around their hair. They cover their upper arms, collarbones, and legs are in tights. They do not cover their faces, and their dress is modern, just what they consider “modest”. Orthodox men stand out a lot more as they wear a variety of distinctive hats (with kippah under the hat), black suits in all weather (except sects like Satmar where most men will wear an 18th century frock coat, knee pants, and white stockings), and tallit.

You're right. Orthodox Jews stand out but perhaps no more than many other people. People wear all sorts nowadays. I have a lovely friend who wears gone with the wind peasant dresses with no irony 😁. I think I would be far more likely to clock a trans woman than an orthodox Jew. But that's what's so interesting about the reaction to veiled women. There is a part of me that is shocked to see it. I'm sorry but it's true. And I can only think it's the way in which it challenges my conceptions of the society we all live in.

therealcookiemonster · 19/09/2023 15:10

@BlooDeBloop have you looked into the availability of english language classes? the last time I looked, the waiting lists were around a year long where I live. my last housekeeper (from Eastern Europe) was desperate for the course, but just couldn't get a place and the kind of work she could do was severely restricted as a result.

BlooDeBloop · 19/09/2023 15:08

therealcookiemonster · 19/09/2023 14:44

@BlooDeBloop in the incidence that you mentioned. I would also judge. but the judgement is how that man is a twat and not fulfilling his islamic obligations of helping his wife. what you observed is cultural/man being a twat not to do with Islam.

I feel sometimes ppl confuse integrate with assimilate. someone can be a fully paid up member of british society but eat different foods/wear different clothes/believe the moon is made of cheese. some individuals who immigrate and dont even learn the language for example - that i agree is a problem. but many muslims who wear hijab were born here and are not even immigrants and shouldnt feel the need to take it off to 'fit in'

I don't think many people would demand assimilation over integration. I think as a basic requirement to be 'integrated' to a minimal degree good language is key. From my own experience, the three main reasons acquisition fails is 1/ cognitive ability (previous education level, age, or disability) and 2/ value of the adopted culture, 3/ fear (affects men more than women, to speak in the second language and make a hash of it can feel humiliating). When learning a language with perceived low value, acquisition is much harder and the final mastery level is lower. Whether fair or not when a person presents with a rudimentary or non existent spoken English the receiver is likely to judge that person poorly i.e. they don't value English ways of life. It's a leap but I think that's the conclusion reached, rightly or wrongly.

MarkWithaC · 19/09/2023 15:07

BlooDeBloop, I think someone would have to be pretty dim not to see a difference between a woman in the supermarket with her face covered with a veil and someone in a crash helmet in a bank.

The notion of the UK having one particular and monolithic clothing norm or culture is just meaningless. For good reasons and for less edifying ones, for much of the UK's history it's been home to people from all kinds of countries and cultures, dressing and looking all kinds of different ways.

It is ironic that you wax lyrical about the UK being a place where 'There is great latitude where people generally feel able to wear what they want', and yet do not feel that this applies to people who want to wear a veil or 'black drapes'.

It's interesting that you throw around the phrase 'culturally Christian values' until challenged, and then – of course! – all you meant was 'secular values', and you could just as easily have used that phrase instead, you just didn't...

I also note the appearance on the thread of that old favourite trope that if we can't see someone's eyes we struggle to connect with them and our 'instincts' (which of course we all act on, all the time) tell us we cannot trust them. And we simply cannot get past that Hmm

therealcookiemonster · 19/09/2023 15:06

Bonkersworknonsense · 19/09/2023 15:02

@therealcookiemonster I’m wondering what your point is about Orthodox Jewish women? Some wear wigs or scarves wrapped around their hair. They cover their upper arms, collarbones, and legs are in tights. They do not cover their faces, and their dress is modern, just what they consider “modest”. Orthodox men stand out a lot more as they wear a variety of distinctive hats (with kippah under the hat), black suits in all weather (except sects like Satmar where most men will wear an 18th century frock coat, knee pants, and white stockings), and tallit.

my point is that this is a community which dresses differently (it was not specific to Orthodox Jewish women per se) to the general British population and that no one is attacking them because the problem isn't dressing differently, it's islamophobia.

just in case it wasn't clear, it wasn't a dig at orthodox Jewish practice. all religions should be able to dress however they deem appropriate. that is my point.

Iwasafool · 19/09/2023 15:05

therealcookiemonster · 19/09/2023 14:52

@Iwasafool well what the husband said says it all. for him his wife covering was about him, nothing to do with Islam. in the Qur'an it literally says "there is no compulsion in religion".

I understand people worry about women not "choosing it", but that worry often becomes thinly veiled racism where Muslim women are perceived as not having agency compared to other women.

Believe me the Muslim women I know, just a handful so a small sample, are strong characters, the woman I referenced being a great example, but it must be hard to do what she did if you feel that not only your husband but your family and your community will all view what you are doing as shameful. Not to mention finding your first job and being responsible for feeding and housing your children. I know not all Muslims share the same cultural beliefs but I suppose it is likely that if you are in a marriage like hers then you are likely to be part of a family/community with similar views.

The happy ending is her children have grown up to be lovely people, all been to university and all incredibly close to their mother. She had it tough but she must be proud of what she has achieved.

Bonkersworknonsense · 19/09/2023 15:02

@therealcookiemonster I’m wondering what your point is about Orthodox Jewish women? Some wear wigs or scarves wrapped around their hair. They cover their upper arms, collarbones, and legs are in tights. They do not cover their faces, and their dress is modern, just what they consider “modest”. Orthodox men stand out a lot more as they wear a variety of distinctive hats (with kippah under the hat), black suits in all weather (except sects like Satmar where most men will wear an 18th century frock coat, knee pants, and white stockings), and tallit.

therealcookiemonster · 19/09/2023 14:58

@BlooDeBloop I mean that is a fair enough observation. just be wary of making assumptions though.

because the other end of that as Muslim women is that we get patronised and discriminated against.

Swipe left for the next trending thread