Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we should up the age of consent to 18?

404 replies

whatnet · 19/09/2023 00:10

I just have this utterly sick feeling about the constant narrative pushed in the UK about a CHILD being ‘16’ and therefore, “what is your problem?”… “it’s ‘legal’” I am so sick of the exploitation of our girls in this country. Our CHILDREN. Our future. Who do not have a voice, because they are children. They need to be protected. I will pre empt some of your arguments. The UK government has classified the violence against Women and Girls as a “National Threat”

https://lordslibrary.parliament.uk/tackling-violence-against-women-and-girls-in-the-uk/

A 16 year old girl is a child and should be protected as a child, by law.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Ilmecourtsurleharicot · 27/09/2023 20:28

Nobody on this thread has been arguing for sixth form students to be criminalised for having sex with each other

Circe7 · 27/09/2023 19:46

I think a law which is going to be routinely broken by normal teenagers engaging in normal behaviour and where you have to rely on CPS guidelines to prevent the majority of teenagers being criminalised for a sex offence is very bad law. Few people actually see two 17 year olds or an 18 year old and a 17 year old having sex as behaviour which should be criminal. In practice of course we don’t tend to criminalise sex between teenagers but a new law could be treated differently, particularly as 15 year olds would be a long way of the age of consent if it was 18. Plus if you introduce a law which no one takes seriously because the majority of people break it it may not have the desired affect of preventing 17 year olds from sleeping with older men either.

I’d also be worried about the impact on sex education in schools. Can a school really give comprehensive sex education if it’s technically illegal for almost every student in their school to have sex and where they would have to teach that technically sex is illegal until 18? It gives a message to older teenagers that there is something shameful/ wrong about sex. I actually think it’s quite healthy for teenagers to experiment with other teenagers and realistically if children start having sexual feelings at 12/13 they’re not all going to wait 6 years to have sex anyway.

I can see the benefit of a law which would prevent a much older man exploiting a child but don’t think you need to criminalise sex between sixth form students to get there.

Poptones · 27/09/2023 19:41

It's funny how you've got such faith in the law that you'll accept that 18 is adulthood but 16 shouldn't be age of consent which is also law.

Talk about picking and choosing the laws you like.

You come across as really illogical.

Yet again I reiterate my belief that there is not much difference between the ages of 16-18 from a sociological perspective these days.
Most don't leave home until after 18 so are still 'kids'.

And there certainly is not any difference in terms of sexual maturity between a 16-year-old and an 18-year-old.
Not like there is 14 and 18.

So given this you should be campaigning for much higher, say 25.

At least there'd be some logic to your argument then. As of yet, there is none.

whatnet · 27/09/2023 19:24

I don’t need to. It’s self explanatory.

You are correct.

OP posts:
BIossomtoes · 27/09/2023 19:23

whatnet · 27/09/2023 19:20

BIossomtoes · Today 19:18

Yet another way of infantilising our kids.

explain further please?

I don’t need to. It’s self explanatory.

whatnet · 27/09/2023 19:20

BIossomtoes · Today 19:18

Yet another way of infantilising our kids.

explain further please?

OP posts:
BIossomtoes · 27/09/2023 19:18

Yet another way of infantilising our kids.

whatnet · 27/09/2023 19:03

“I understand your arguments for why you would like the age increased. Looking at the petition someone posted, they have written ‘children are anyone under 18, and therefore sex with children is legal’. The issue seems to be largely to do with the inconsistency in the legal definition. I just don’t think 16-17 year olds are ‘children’ in the same way 14-15 year olds are.

And someone over 18 having sex with a 16 or 17 year old does not make them a paedophile.

(Paedophilia is a sexual interest in pre-adolescent children.)”

I have teenagers, I work with teenagers. 16 and 17 year olds are CHILDREN. For what ‘gain’ do you require for them not to be seen as ‘children’? For me, I want them all to be protected by law because I work with them day in and day out and see how vulnerable they are. And to me they are the best, most lovely souls, sometimes in the most difficult circumstances making their way into the world. It breaks my heart every time I know the “16” card has been played, and my support and legal fight ends there. If that was your daughter or son, do you just, ‘give up’, There is no ‘grey area’ 16 and 17 year olds are children, and we as a nation should protect our children. It shouldn’t be this hard. Why is it this hard? 🤔

OP posts:
Poptones · 27/09/2023 18:33

whatnet · 27/09/2023 18:20

“I have no agenda, you do. I think the age of consent is about right. Not perfect but nothing is.
That's that. I don't know why anybody would get so worked up about it.

I don't recall feeling much more grown up between 16 and 18 anyway so I think you've no real scientific basis for raising it by a couple of years anyway.

It's as if you've just thought two years and that's it. Like you've pulled the figure out of thin air. No reason for it on terms of sociological or biological differences.

Most people don't start employment until after 18 so you're argument really should be it is raised higher than that.
Because 16-18 is not much different really yet you are happy for people to be classed as adults at 18.

Doesnt make sense to me.

Most 16 year olds aren't having sex with people a decade or decades older than them anyway.

And the problem is with that not just 5 years or so. Or getting together with a man in his very early twenties.

Big fuss over nothing.”

I do have an agenda, clearly. Raise the age of consent to 18. You clearly have an agenda too, do not raise the age of consent to 18.

“It's as if you've just thought two years and that's it. Like you've pulled the figure out of thin air. No reason for it on terms of sociological or biological differences.”

18 is a universally agreed age of ‘adulthood’ in many countries, even 21. As more and more scientific studies come out, it is even more widely accepted that ‘adulthood’ in a brain development/scientific sense, does not happen until much later than previously thought.

“Most people don't start employment until after 18 so you're argument really should be it is raised higher than that.
Because 16-18 is not much different really yet you are happy for people to be classed as adults at 18.”

With the current UK approach to justify their political worth, they are committed to keeping every under 18 in full time education, be that school, college or university, with a tiny percentage going into full time/part time employment or apprenticeship. So, most 18 and under will still very much view the world as ‘children’.

“Most 16 year olds aren't having sex with people a decade or decades older than them anyway.”

You are missing the point, again.

“And the problem is with that not just 5 years or so. Or getting together with a man in his very early twenties.”

Look up the profile of a Pedophile. Again, I am guessing you have no interest in protecting children.

“Big fuss over nothing.”

hmmm

How dare you accuse me of not wanting to protect children.
Let me tell you this: there is little biological maturity between 16-18 so if a guy is a paedophile for being attracted to 16 year olds he is also logically a paedophile for being attracted to 18 year olds.
Your suggestion is nuts.

It would make more sense if you said 25 because at least then there's a discernible difference.

Loopy just loopy.

whatnet · 27/09/2023 18:30

Tumbleweed101 · Today 18:24

I've experienced a very stressed parent of a 16yo boy worried I might get him in trouble for having a sexual relationship with my 15.5yr old daughter. They were both in the exact same year group at school. I'm not even sure they were exploring that at that point but his parents were really worried.

but of course you wouldn’t @Tumbleweed101 because that would be “batshit crazy” as other posters have mentioned and CPS wouldn’t be interested anyway. So, nothing to worry about. If it was a 21/30/40 year old on the other hand. Yes, yes, you all should have something to worry about. Hope that helps.

OP posts:
Tumbleweed101 · 27/09/2023 18:24

I've experienced a very stressed parent of a 16yo boy worried I might get him in trouble for having a sexual relationship with my 15.5yr old daughter. They were both in the exact same year group at school. I'm not even sure they were exploring that at that point but his parents were really worried.

whatnet · 27/09/2023 18:23

*paedophile 🙃 I always get the spelling wrong 😑

OP posts:
whatnet · 27/09/2023 18:20

“I have no agenda, you do. I think the age of consent is about right. Not perfect but nothing is.
That's that. I don't know why anybody would get so worked up about it.

I don't recall feeling much more grown up between 16 and 18 anyway so I think you've no real scientific basis for raising it by a couple of years anyway.

It's as if you've just thought two years and that's it. Like you've pulled the figure out of thin air. No reason for it on terms of sociological or biological differences.

Most people don't start employment until after 18 so you're argument really should be it is raised higher than that.
Because 16-18 is not much different really yet you are happy for people to be classed as adults at 18.

Doesnt make sense to me.

Most 16 year olds aren't having sex with people a decade or decades older than them anyway.

And the problem is with that not just 5 years or so. Or getting together with a man in his very early twenties.

Big fuss over nothing.”

I do have an agenda, clearly. Raise the age of consent to 18. You clearly have an agenda too, do not raise the age of consent to 18.

“It's as if you've just thought two years and that's it. Like you've pulled the figure out of thin air. No reason for it on terms of sociological or biological differences.”

18 is a universally agreed age of ‘adulthood’ in many countries, even 21. As more and more scientific studies come out, it is even more widely accepted that ‘adulthood’ in a brain development/scientific sense, does not happen until much later than previously thought.

“Most people don't start employment until after 18 so you're argument really should be it is raised higher than that.
Because 16-18 is not much different really yet you are happy for people to be classed as adults at 18.”

With the current UK approach to justify their political worth, they are committed to keeping every under 18 in full time education, be that school, college or university, with a tiny percentage going into full time/part time employment or apprenticeship. So, most 18 and under will still very much view the world as ‘children’.

“Most 16 year olds aren't having sex with people a decade or decades older than them anyway.”

You are missing the point, again.

“And the problem is with that not just 5 years or so. Or getting together with a man in his very early twenties.”

Look up the profile of a Pedophile. Again, I am guessing you have no interest in protecting children.

“Big fuss over nothing.”

hmmm

OP posts:
Tumbleweed101 · 27/09/2023 18:18

As a parent to teen daughters - I would like something that says a teens between 16-18 can't have a sexual relationship with anyone over the age of 20. That would mean the boys they are most likely to be experimenting with wouldn't be getting in trouble since they are pretty much as innocent as the girls at that point but they are all protected by older adults.

A teen fumble is very different to older adults deliberately seeking out teens. Boys and girls should be protected without making illegal those early relationships.

Poptones · 27/09/2023 18:00

whatnet · 27/09/2023 16:59

Poptones · Yesterday 18:39

“I have no idea why you're so worked up about this, OP.
Really I mean it.
16 is about right for the majority.
You cannot make laws to suit everyone. The age of consent is what it is because it seems about right for most of us and that's good enough.
No law is perfect.

You come across like a pearl clutcher.
I mean what is your agenda?

16/18 makes no real difference if someone is victim to a predator.

I see no real changes between 16-18 anyway really. I mean what major psychological changes happen during those two years? Unless in employment, not much really. Most at still at school or further education.

So why not go the whole hog and raise it to 30 and only for people born in the same year?
Put a 30-year-old man who has sex with a 29-year-old in jail.

I'm truly sorry if you've suffered some grooming experience but I mean this in a kind way but really the world does not revolve around you.

I mean it. You're idea is nuts.

(This is from someone who lost their virginity at 19 BTW.)

I hope your idea goes nowhere as frankly this sort of illogical emotional response gets on my nerves.
Wasting government time when there's real issues of abuse to tackle. Effing annoying.”

You have no idea why I am so worked up about this? I assume you have no parental responsibility for teenage girls or interest in the health or well-being of teenage girls from that statement? The “pearl clutcher” dialogue has been used a few times on this thread. It is depressing. My argument is, 16 and 17 year olds are children, and should be protected by law as children. To safeguard them from predators. Again, no one is talking about prosecuting teen to teen consensual sex. I have already included CPS info on how they would view that anyway and would not be looking to prosecute. You come across as someone who is unable to see the bigger picture of protecting children against predators. I mean, what is your agenda? This is a “real” issue. Have you read the news recently?

I have no agenda, you do. I think the age of consent is about right. Not perfect but nothing is.
That's that. I don't know why anybody would get so worked up about it.

I don't recall feeling much more grown up between 16 and 18 anyway so I think you've no real scientific basis for raising it by a couple of years anyway.

It's as if you've just thought two years and that's it. Like you've pulled the figure out of thin air. No reason for it on terms of sociological or biological differences.

Most people don't start employment until after 18 so you're argument really should be it is raised higher than that.
Because 16-18 is not much different really yet you are happy for people to be classed as adults at 18.

Doesnt make sense to me.

Most 16 year olds aren't having sex with people a decade or decades older than them anyway.

And the problem is with that not just 5 years or so. Or getting together with a man in his very early twenties.

Big fuss over nothing.

ehupo7 · 27/09/2023 17:32

whatnet · 27/09/2023 17:17

ehupo7 · Today 13:56

“Personally I think it would make more sense to make a distinction between 16-17 year olds and actual children. They’re not the same thing are they.

If there were to be any change, it wouldn’t have to include R&J provisions of some kind. Although as someone pointed out above, 16 is about right for most people.”

Yip, 16 and 17 year olds are still children in my honest opinion, and they can experiment between themselves, which has always happened and will always happen. If anyone, as a fully functioning adult does not see them as children, and groom or knowingly pursue them sexually, then they are a Pedo. I think it’s pretty straightforward. Protect 16 and 17 year olds in law, as children. It actually extends much further to vulnerable children in care who are so easily exploited and manipulated and constantly let down because, “you are 16” or you look 16 🤢 😡. JS/HE/PS/RB, cases such as Rotherham also back up the point of needing to protect vulnerable CHILDREN. A whole other thread. 16 and 17 year olds are children, and should be protected by law. That is my point.

I understand your arguments for why you would like the age increased. Looking at the petition someone posted, they have written ‘children are anyone under 18, and therefore sex with children is legal’. The issue seems to be largely to do with the inconsistency in the legal definition. I just don’t think 16-17 year olds are ‘children’ in the same way 14-15 year olds are.

And someone over 18 having sex with a 16 or 17 year old does not make them a paedophile.

(Paedophilia is a sexual interest in pre-adolescent children.)

whatnet · 27/09/2023 17:17

ehupo7 · Today 13:56

“Personally I think it would make more sense to make a distinction between 16-17 year olds and actual children. They’re not the same thing are they.

If there were to be any change, it wouldn’t have to include R&J provisions of some kind. Although as someone pointed out above, 16 is about right for most people.”

Yip, 16 and 17 year olds are still children in my honest opinion, and they can experiment between themselves, which has always happened and will always happen. If anyone, as a fully functioning adult does not see them as children, and groom or knowingly pursue them sexually, then they are a Pedo. I think it’s pretty straightforward. Protect 16 and 17 year olds in law, as children. It actually extends much further to vulnerable children in care who are so easily exploited and manipulated and constantly let down because, “you are 16” or you look 16 🤢 😡. JS/HE/PS/RB, cases such as Rotherham also back up the point of needing to protect vulnerable CHILDREN. A whole other thread. 16 and 17 year olds are children, and should be protected by law. That is my point.

OP posts:
whatnet · 27/09/2023 16:59

Poptones · Yesterday 18:39

“I have no idea why you're so worked up about this, OP.
Really I mean it.
16 is about right for the majority.
You cannot make laws to suit everyone. The age of consent is what it is because it seems about right for most of us and that's good enough.
No law is perfect.

You come across like a pearl clutcher.
I mean what is your agenda?

16/18 makes no real difference if someone is victim to a predator.

I see no real changes between 16-18 anyway really. I mean what major psychological changes happen during those two years? Unless in employment, not much really. Most at still at school or further education.

So why not go the whole hog and raise it to 30 and only for people born in the same year?
Put a 30-year-old man who has sex with a 29-year-old in jail.

I'm truly sorry if you've suffered some grooming experience but I mean this in a kind way but really the world does not revolve around you.

I mean it. You're idea is nuts.

(This is from someone who lost their virginity at 19 BTW.)

I hope your idea goes nowhere as frankly this sort of illogical emotional response gets on my nerves.
Wasting government time when there's real issues of abuse to tackle. Effing annoying.”

You have no idea why I am so worked up about this? I assume you have no parental responsibility for teenage girls or interest in the health or well-being of teenage girls from that statement? The “pearl clutcher” dialogue has been used a few times on this thread. It is depressing. My argument is, 16 and 17 year olds are children, and should be protected by law as children. To safeguard them from predators. Again, no one is talking about prosecuting teen to teen consensual sex. I have already included CPS info on how they would view that anyway and would not be looking to prosecute. You come across as someone who is unable to see the bigger picture of protecting children against predators. I mean, what is your agenda? This is a “real” issue. Have you read the news recently?

OP posts:
ehupo7 · 27/09/2023 14:39

ehupo7 · 27/09/2023 13:56

Personally I think it would make more sense to make a distinction between 16-17 year olds and actual children. They’re not the same thing are they.

If there were to be any change, it wouldn’t have to include R&J provisions of some kind. Although as someone pointed out above, 16 is about right for most people.

This should have said ‘would’ have to… (or ought to)

pinkhairdontmare · 27/09/2023 14:26

16 seems a good sensible age there's no need to change it imo. Upping it to 18 would just add an unnecessary layer of puritanical shame to sex. There is nothing wrong with 16 and 17 year olds having consensual sex with their peers. At 16 they are either finishing or have finished school and are moving onto a levels/college etc and becoming more independent. It seems ridiculous that a 17 year old would be able to legally drive a car but not have sex. What happened with Russel Brand is grim but this would be better handled through good sex education that teaches teenagers about consent in relationships and power dynamics. Imo needs to be a more open and honest conversation about sex and relationships and raising the age of consent sends out the opposite message.

ehupo7 · 27/09/2023 13:56

Personally I think it would make more sense to make a distinction between 16-17 year olds and actual children. They’re not the same thing are they.

If there were to be any change, it wouldn’t have to include R&J provisions of some kind. Although as someone pointed out above, 16 is about right for most people.

Ilmecourtsurleharicot · 27/09/2023 13:03

There isn’t yet a current Parliamentary petition I could see about the Romeo and Juliet laws and safeguarding issues. Parliament is the only way to change the law so there needs to be a way to highlight this issue to MPs

There’s one current petition calling for 18 to be the UK age of consent
https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/644226

Petition: Raise the age of consent for sex from 16 to 18

I believe that people under the age of 18 are children and should not be able to give consent to sex or sexual activity. Raise the age of consent from 16 to 18 - I believe this would stop children from being abused legally by adults.

https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/644226

Disturbia81 · 27/09/2023 12:15

takeasadsongandmakeitbetter · 26/09/2023 00:56

As someone who was groomed and abused aged 14-15 by a man who was 29-30 I would absolutely recommend the legal age rise.

Those of you arguing teenagers are just hormonal and horny- yeah no problem, if it's consensual and they are similar in age.

The problem is ADULT men taking advantage of children.

The police are barely interested in actual sexual abuse cases, let alone arresting two horny consensual teenagers.

What RB is accused of doing with 'Alice' SHOULD be illegal

Sorry that happened to you Flowers There's something seriously wrong with these men.

curaçao · 27/09/2023 06:40

whatnet · 25/09/2023 23:55

curaçao · Today 23:49

“I think 16 is probably too high , i would say 15 is more appropeiate like much of Europe.i do think there should be a maximum age gap for under 18s though”

Concerning

What do you find 'concerning'?

Poptones · 26/09/2023 18:39

I have no idea why you're so worked up about this, OP.
Really I mean it.
16 is about right for the majority.
You cannot make laws to suit everyone. The age of consent is what it is because it seems about right for most of us and that's good enough.
No law is perfect.

You come across like a pearl clutcher.
I mean what is your agenda?

16/18 makes no real difference if someone is victim to a predator.

I see no real changes between 16-18 anyway really. I mean what major psychological changes happen during those two years? Unless in employment, not much really. Most at still at school or further education.

So why not go the whole hog and raise it to 30 and only for people born in the same year?
Put a 30-year-old man who has sex with a 29-year-old in jail.

I'm truly sorry if you've suffered some grooming experience but I mean this in a kind way but really the world does not revolve around you.

I mean it. You're idea is nuts.

(This is from someone who lost their virginity at 19 BTW.)

I hope your idea goes nowhere as frankly this sort of illogical emotional response gets on my nerves.
Wasting government time when there's real issues of abuse to tackle. Effing annoying.