Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister has said she never wants to speak to me again

159 replies

MadeleineMummy · 18/09/2023 22:14

I have just left my sister’s house, she lived around 50 miles away and it takes a while to get there.

She spent the whole evening being angry and shouting at her husband and her son about what I do not know. She just seemed very awkward. It was embarrassing as we have not seen each other for a few months and I had been invited over for an informal dinner and a catch up and I took the effort to drive quite a distance to her house, leaving my kids at home.

She just seemed angry all the time with everything. She and her son were having an argument at the dinner table and her husband took the son’s side as she was obviously in the wrong. She asked me why I did not support her in the argument and I said it was a family matter and I did not want to get involved. She then started crying and stormed off. She locked herself in her bedroom and asked us all to F off as she did not want to talk to us. We tried talking to her through the door but it became too much of a drama so I left her and her husband to it.

Her husband said he may think if it the time of life, but I never experienced this irrational anger and I am a few years older. My sister is usually not like this and I would like to think she would talk to me about what is happening in her life.

to cut a long story short, as soon as I got home, my sister sent me a series of long ranting texts saying that I never support her, that I have undermined her with her family and I have taken their side against her and then brought up tonnes of resentments from our childhood. Then she stated that as I never support her or have never backed her up, she is cutting me out of her life and never wants to see me again. I tried texting back but she has blocked me. I don’t know what I have done wrong, apart from being impartial.

what should I have done ?

OP posts:
Loubelle70 · 20/09/2023 10:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I was single parent for 11 years but if my sister was struggling and i was aware of it, id listen. Without judgement. Or superiority

stayathomer · 20/09/2023 10:13

If you hadn’t seen her and didn’t know what the argument was about it would have been difficult to support her but in the same way could you not have asked? Also assuming everyone else was in the right seems strange if you didn’t know what it was all about? Plus you said it’s out of character. Forget about the journey, go visit her and communicate with each other. Your sisters!

whatwasthatgrandma · 20/09/2023 10:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

user1492757084 · 20/09/2023 09:55

I don't think your sister is full of self pity.
She genuinely feels low - disrespected, alone and unsupported. Her husband should always side with his wife over an ambiguous issue of parenting.

He could have sensed her dispair and said,
"Mum heard your question as being disrespectful. Make sure you speak gently to your mother who has made this lovely dinner."

I think there is more going on; you sister doesn't feel confident. Perhaps she wanted you to have dinner because she needed someone who appreciates her nearby.
Write to her.. and be ready to forgive the out of character outburst.
Encourage her to attend a female medical clinic to talk about her emotional changes.
Go to a spa and massage session together.
Connect one to one more often for a year or two - even a regular walk and coffee when you both have no other demands.

Loubelle70 · 20/09/2023 09:55

Trickofthetrade · 20/09/2023 08:29

She needs HRT.

She might just need a kind ear and to be supported

Over40Overdating · 20/09/2023 09:55

Ignore the professional contrarians @MadeleineMummy who are determined to stick the boot in. I imagine many behave more like your sister so of course they are invested in telling you you are a heartless, cold, superior monster who should be a doormat for your angry, rude, racist sister.

You already know there’s nothing you can do to have a better relationship with her & whether you’d taken her side, said nothing or defended your nephew you would have been wrong.

She doesn’t love or respect you, has been horrifically racist about your children & husband - she absolutely will have meant what she said - and just wants you about about so she can feel superior.

She adds nothing to your life.

This is a great opportunity to draw a line with her. She is someone you need to arrange your mums care with for now. When that’s no longer the case you have no obligation to make any more effort. She may be a blood relative but she adds nothing your life.

I know that’s easier said than done but you don’t owe this woman anything.

WolfFoxHare · 20/09/2023 09:41

It feels like you're drip-feeding quite a bit here - first of all you say she's not usually like this, and you thought she'd talk to you about anything going on in her life. Then she's rude, racist and you've never been close, she wouldn't share things in her life and she's dramatic. Feels like you're changing the narrative because you're not getting unqualified approval.

whatwasIgoingtosay · 20/09/2023 09:29

MadeleineMummy · 20/09/2023 00:17

My sister would say that she was making a joke about mixed race children rather than being malicious.

She would indeed say that, wouldn't she? That's the hallmark of those making bullying, misogynistic or racist remarks: 'Oh, I was only joking!' implying that you're the one at fault for no seeing the joke. But what do YOU think? You seem to be making excuses for her, but surely you can see that by any standards she IS racist. I'm guessing at least 90% of posters on this thread would find it extremely offensive and racist to hear a remark about 'mongrel' children. 😕

Gsd3 · 20/09/2023 09:19

Sounds like some sort of mental health problem if it's not hormones... You could always send her a message/email just apologising to her if she thought you were taking sides and saying you'd like to help if you can. If she's still prickly then maybe just leave the offer on the table until she decides herself what she needs. Hopefully her partner will support her through whatever is going on but it must have been so awkward having been a witness to all of it so I really feel for you. It wasnt fair of your sister to drag you in to be in the middle of a row with her husband..x

Ramalangadingdong · 20/09/2023 09:13

Is she having counselling or something. Bringing up the past etc makes it sound as though she has been going through some sort of process.

Your post sounds sincere but I am afraid I don’t have any advice. It is unfair that she treated you like that - quite abusive, really. You’re the one who should be going NC.

Spellbounder · 20/09/2023 09:09

Lifecanbebeautiful12 · 20/09/2023 09:03

This is quite a mean thing for you to say. Your sister is obviously struggling mentally and it sounds like you have no sympathy because you think your life has been harder and you managed ok (do you have some kind of resentment towards her for that?). And you mentioned in your OP that you hadn’t experienced menopause symptoms so her behaviour can’t be due to that? It doesn’t sound like your sister is indulging in drama or self-pity but that she is maybe not doing so well mentally. If you don’t care then it’s better for her that she did cut you off, tbh. If it was my sister I’d be very concerned and trying to find out what’s going on with her and how I could help.

I don’t agree with this. It’s clear that the OPs sister feels she can always ‘speak her mind’ and cause drama. Personally I find that behaviour really draining and I just can’t indulge it on an ongoing basis. It’s the sister who need to get some help to work out her issues. There is simply not enough time and attention in the world for her - the OP just won’t be able to meet her unquenchable need for attention

Violinist64 · 20/09/2023 09:07

To be honest, this sounds like far more than the menopause. It sounds as if she is having a nervous breakdown. Something that you are completely unaware of may well be triggering this. I agree with you not interfering between husband and wife but you sound very unsympathetic to me. I think you should get in touch with her, saying that you are very concerned about her (if you are) and that you want to be supportive and how would she like you to do this. I would also explain that you didn't want to make matters worse when you were at her house, which is why you stayed quiet at the time.

Spellbounder · 20/09/2023 09:07

She sounds like my Mum. I would just leave it. If she wants to see you she will
make contact. These type of personalities will never see anything wrong with their behaviour, they are always the victim. Just take a step back

Lifecanbebeautiful12 · 20/09/2023 09:03

MadeleineMummy · 18/09/2023 22:51

Unfortunately there is just the two of us and no one to intervene.

I am a single mother who has brought up all my children by myself and did not have the time or space for drama and self-pity.

This is quite a mean thing for you to say. Your sister is obviously struggling mentally and it sounds like you have no sympathy because you think your life has been harder and you managed ok (do you have some kind of resentment towards her for that?). And you mentioned in your OP that you hadn’t experienced menopause symptoms so her behaviour can’t be due to that? It doesn’t sound like your sister is indulging in drama or self-pity but that she is maybe not doing so well mentally. If you don’t care then it’s better for her that she did cut you off, tbh. If it was my sister I’d be very concerned and trying to find out what’s going on with her and how I could help.

mixedpeel · 20/09/2023 09:02

To those posters who reckon OP should’ve laid out everything that she has later said in her first post, can’t you appreciate that she initially posted about the recent event, but as the conversation here has developed and she has thought further about things, other memories resurface?

It doesn’t at all read to me as though OP has purposely kept information back to ‘drip feed’ in later.

StBernie · 20/09/2023 09:02

Calling a mixed race person (which I happen to be myself) a ‘mongrel’ is absolutely racist. What part of it is a joke? Who’s laughing?

I don’t know why you’d want any sort of relationship with her whatsoever.

Idonthavetoberight · 20/09/2023 08:55

GrinAndVomit · 20/09/2023 07:26

God the flip flopping on here makes it impossible to offer any advice or even empathy.

What did I do wrong? How can I fix it?
to
I can’t be bothered with her self pity!
to
I have always made such an effort with our relationship
to
She’s made horrifying, racist comments about my children
to
She’s not racist, she just unthinking.

OP, perhaps you might take some time to really gather your thoughts on whether you want to help her or you are glad to be out of her life. We can’t give advice until you have made that decision.

Agree with@GrinAndVomit - OP you have given so many conflicting descriptions about yourself and your sister, it's difficult to know which version is reality and which version you've curated for your post. There are lots of different versions of you in your comments. If you just want justification for any of your actions from random people on the internet, then there are lots of replies on here giving you that in response to some of your comments. Doesn't mean you or they are 'right', they just see things the way you've put them in that post and you've got the response you were hoping for. If you actually want to help your sister or have a better relationship with her, then take on board the more critical comments without coming up with more reasons why you're right and your sister is wrong. I hope you find a way through this.

Mikimoto · 20/09/2023 08:48

Let her stew, but don't stop seeing your nephew or BIL.

Trickofthetrade · 20/09/2023 08:29

She needs HRT.

Alwaysdieting · 20/09/2023 08:17

Id just leave it to be honest. You sound more like acquaintances than family. She has her husband and her blond son so its not like shes alone. You can choose your friends but not your family.

SoTiredNeedHoliday · 20/09/2023 08:14

Perhaps you ned to get BIL to get your sister some help from the GP? I don't think you could have 'done anything' in the moment if that behaviour is not normal for her (as you say).

You can't just leave it and let her struggle like this though

Queenofscones · 20/09/2023 08:13

I don't think there's anything else you could have done. This is obviously nothing to do with you. My sister seems to be going through a similar crisis and has recently sent me emails calling me names and clearly designed to hurt me. She too is always angry and defensive. Nothing I say or do is right. She also seems to be fixating on our childhood, many years ago now, and about things that I have no memory of.

I'd give it time. It's distressing and you have my sympathy. I hope there's come a time when you can both laugh about this blip.

GemmaH1982 · 20/09/2023 08:12

I went through this with my sister , except I was the other sister . I can only say she is probably going through something right now . She is probably under alot of stress and is probably sat at home upset with herself . The one thing I would suggest is to keep reaching out for as long as it takes , I understand you were treated badly and that's not fair on you but these relationships once you call it a day you will find it harder to reconnect as you will build walls to protect yourself and she will do the same. If you can not find legitimate reasons to call it a day I.E she always behaves like this , then I can assume something is happening within her life that she is struggling with . Email , write a letter and keep calling , go to her house and attempt to put this right if you can , this is by no means your fault but she may not be as strong as you and her outburst may actually be a cry for some help .I hope you manage to come together and be ok .

Loubelle70 · 20/09/2023 07:43

I disowned my sister because she always pulled me down, when kids she would threaten and beat me up etc. When older she humiliated me in front of others. We are in touch now, she ended up being sectioned so that could have been why she constantly attacked me. A bit different to your situation. You should reach out just incase she is struggling with things you do not know, also you dont know if her husband and DS are on at her all the time, closing ranks.

Viviennemary · 20/09/2023 07:42

Just do nothing. She is obviously in a very unhappy place and you have got caught in the crossfire.

Swipe left for the next trending thread