Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask my husband NOT to tell his parents every time we argue

107 replies

Chipmunk09 · 18/09/2023 18:00

DH and I had a disagreement yesterday (I wouldn’t even say it was an argument but it got heated and I was upset). Now I can hear him in the other room divulging every detail to his parents over FaceTime. I’ve asked him before not to do this because it makes me uncomfortable with them knowing we’ve had an argument. Also I feel like it doesn’t paint me in a very good light, as obviously he’s going to be bias.

I have never ever told my mum or any other family member when we’ve had an argument. I feel like it is something deeply personal and I’ve always tried to resolve the issue between us.

I’m still upset following yesterday’s disagreement and I have been cold with him all day. I just have no energy to engage with him. I feel like he never truly understands my perspective or takes responsibility for his own actions. Him running to his parents just makes me even more mad!!!

AIBU to ask him not to tell his parents about our arguments?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Carmargo · 16/12/2023 12:16

I realise this thread was started a few months ago but I've similar experience.
I used to get on OK with my MIL.
Until my stupid (soon to ex) husband one day decided to tell all to her during an argument.
Boy did the bitch use this as an excuse to slag me off. And some.

Stupid woman, she missed out for years as no more prompting my useless husband (who in all honesty doesn't give a f*. about her in spite of all his b. s. about '' duty'') about birthdays etc. We, thankfully, have no dc' s so no keeping her away from the grandkids (which I wouldn't do anyway) but I basically ignored her from that point.

I now realise my stbx is just a narcissist enlisting flying monkeys-he did similar with his sister, who surprise, surprise, was equally as much of a cow.

steppemum · 19/09/2023 15:22

I have very rarely if ever vented to my mum about dh.
I am very close to her and there has been the odd winge, but nothing like what the OP is talking about.

This is deliberate. I winge to her about everything else, especially the kids.
But not my marriage.
I think once or twice I have asked her advice, that is not the same as post argument winging.

I do winge to my best friend and she to me about our dhs. But usually it is somewhat censored. And my friend and I worl from the basis that we love our dhs and want our marriage to continue, but that sometimes we need a vent.

I think it is different with parents. And I think it is unhelpful. In fact I am surprised that his mum doesn't gently but firmly tell him he is talking to the wrong person

Goldflap · 19/09/2023 09:05

StrawberryWater · 18/09/2023 21:57

If my oh did that I’d be wondering what else he told them.

It’s just so unsexy, I’m not sure I’d ever get wet again with a tattle tale running to his mommy for bitty every time we disagreed.

🤣

Superwooman · 19/09/2023 06:50

Tell DH you are emailing your ILs - some of his moves when you have sex do not suit you and you feel he needs some advice and suggestions. As they have a long marriage and are so good at supporting him could they come up with some ideas for him.
DIL

ImustLearn2Cook · 19/09/2023 06:18

ChubbyMorticia · 19/09/2023 05:55

No, I’d tell her that she was being immature, that a marriage deserves privacy, and that she’s bringing her mother into her private life, where she has no business being.

I can’t imagine how violated I’d feel if my husband was running off and talking about any and every disagreement we had with his mother. I wouldn’t be able to trust him, honestly, and I’d feel incredibly disrespected that a private discussion had now been aired to his mother. It would make me question if I had any privacy in our marriage at all.

@ChubbyMorticia That is exactly how I would feel too. Also, I have never rung up my parents or family members to discuss disagreements I have had with a partner.

I wouldn’t involve other family members with disagreements I have had with another family member because that would not be fair or respectful to anyone. And could cause family conflict.

Your family are your partner’s in-laws.

In a group of friends it wouldn’t be ok to bitch about another member of the group or get the friendship group to take sides. If a friend did that to me they wouldn’t be my friend anymore.

It’s basic respect. The only sexist posts on this thread are the pp accusing women of answering differently because it is a man discussing his marital disagreements with his parents. Rubbish !

The only time I would respond differently is if someone was being abused by their partner/spouse. In that situation they need to get help and support and a safe place to escape the abuse and protection from being assaulted or murdered.

ChubbyMorticia · 19/09/2023 05:56

That response was to the member who commented it would be different if a woman was talking to her mother

ChubbyMorticia · 19/09/2023 05:55

No, I’d tell her that she was being immature, that a marriage deserves privacy, and that she’s bringing her mother into her private life, where she has no business being.

I can’t imagine how violated I’d feel if my husband was running off and talking about any and every disagreement we had with his mother. I wouldn’t be able to trust him, honestly, and I’d feel incredibly disrespected that a private discussion had now been aired to his mother. It would make me question if I had any privacy in our marriage at all.

Goldbar · 19/09/2023 05:42

Why not just ring them up and turn on speaker-phone when you start arguing, OP?

That will save your OH having to repeat the argument to them afterwards and they can get the full picture.

PuddlesPityParty · 19/09/2023 05:39

Goldbar · 18/09/2023 20:29

But in this case, he's not so much venting to his parents as telling on her to his mummy and daddy. Like small children do.

That’s what the OP says. Probs is just venting though isn’t it considering she gives the cold shoulder whenever they fight.

electriclight · 19/09/2023 05:28

I ring my mum every time I have an argument with dp because she gives good advice. I wouldn't let him tell me what I can and can't talk to my mum about, we talk every day.

saffronsoup · 19/09/2023 05:24

These threads always bring out people who have never spoke a word about their husband or marriage to any family or friend.

Then in other threads no one has any issue with talking to family or friends. And you get a thread of responses of people who share about their spouse and marriage with friends and family.

Everyone always only tells their side, on here and in real life.

I agree to that since it is a man the response is very different from a woman who calls her family daily and vents to others about her husband. We never see her called names or told she is never to speak of him in a bad light.

ImustLearn2Cook · 19/09/2023 05:14

@Chipmunk09 There is a similar discussion on reddit but it is the wife posting about her discussing her marital problems with friends and family.

The general consensus was not to. Some people said ok to discuss with friends but not with your family. One poster said that she had discussed marital arguments with her parents and her parents ended up hating her husband. And for the last 10 years of her marriage there has been issues with them hating her husband.

YANBU. Anything negative he says could change their opinion of you and seriously affect family dynamics. Also, they are not getting the full picture, he is their son so they will be biased in favour of him.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Marriage/comments/125bc75/do_you_talk_to_friendsfamily_about_your_marriage/

Reddit - Dive into anything

https://www.reddit.com/r/Marriage/comments/125bc75/do_you_talk_to_friendsfamily_about_your_marriage/

Newestname002 · 19/09/2023 03:30

@aloris

A considered and very balanced post from you. 🌹

mushti · 19/09/2023 03:03

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 19/09/2023 01:34

Not all women, believe me.

But nobody calls them a silly mummy’s girl if they do.

the level of sexism on this thread is through the roof.

mathanxiety · 19/09/2023 02:51

YANBU

Your H is a silly mummy's boy. I bet your MIL is lapping it all up. This sort of unhealthy thing takes two.

My exH used to do this. ExMIL sent him photocopies of magazine articles about OCD because he whinged to her that I kept pictures the DCs had drawn in a folder. I still have the pictures. I don't know where exH is at this point.

Tell him he needs to choose between you and his mummy. He can't have it both ways. What is going on here is seriously messed up and unhealthy.

GodspeedJune · 19/09/2023 01:51

Does he have friends? I’m not saying that unkindly, but it’s not unusual (to me) for friends to discuss arguments they’ve had with their partners. I don’t think that’s unhealthy, sometimes it’s good to hear a third party perspective or just to have some reassurance that your gut feeling on something is right.

Just wondering if he doesn’t have friends so is using his parents in place of this.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 19/09/2023 01:34

WandaWonder · 18/09/2023 23:54

Women seem to tell all to their mums, seem like you both have issues though

Not all women, believe me.

WandaWonder · 18/09/2023 23:54

Women seem to tell all to their mums, seem like you both have issues though

ALongHardWinter · 18/09/2023 23:52

My ex-husband used to do this. Not on Facetime,it wasn't around then (early 90s) but would phone his mum or his sister. Just one of many reasons why he's my ex.

Sweedey · 18/09/2023 23:17

@Sometimeswinning how can you compare posting vaguely on an anon forum about not living your partner overhearing...

...to sharing intimate details of your relationship with family members...? People op has to see and is supposed to have a positive relationship with...?

Would it be ironic if op was talking to a therapist in confidence? No, of course not. Not the same.

Sweedey · 18/09/2023 23:15

tiggergoesbounce · 18/09/2023 22:50

Its in earshot. No amount of 'emotional support' can make that ok

Do you mean because hes openly discussing it with his family its wrong. Why??? Is it better he sneaks off to do it.

Add in the fact that it's almost certainly a distorted version of reality when a highly agitated person is whinging to a close family member

Which again should not be a problem. Hes allowed to vent to his family, hes allowed to express his opinion and feelings and discuss his troubles

Add in that it's not just a one off and you're worried about upsetting your partner because now they're going to go and tell everyone your private business

They are not telling everyone, telling the people who love him. Why would you care about upsetting the person you love because his parents will find out, surely you care about upsetting him because you love him or you are right and he needs telling so you tell him.and he had to suck up being upset. I wouldn't give 2 hoots what my inlaws thought.

It's not acceptable for many people to misrepresent arguments with your partner with other people within earshot. We don't need the 10-step argument

You can do what you like in your relationship, if you want to share that with other people. Im explaining why other people do not like it

Having had this from a parent and a partner, there are times when it's not just support and it's crossing boundaries

tiggergoesbounce · 18/09/2023 22:50

Its in earshot. No amount of 'emotional support' can make that ok

Do you mean because hes openly discussing it with his family its wrong. Why??? Is it better he sneaks off to do it.

Add in the fact that it's almost certainly a distorted version of reality when a highly agitated person is whinging to a close family member

Which again should not be a problem. Hes allowed to vent to his family, hes allowed to express his opinion and feelings and discuss his troubles

Add in that it's not just a one off and you're worried about upsetting your partner because now they're going to go and tell everyone your private business

They are not telling everyone, telling the people who love him. Why would you care about upsetting the person you love because his parents will find out, surely you care about upsetting him because you love him or you are right and he needs telling so you tell him.and he had to suck up being upset. I wouldn't give 2 hoots what my inlaws thought.

Sometimeswinning · 18/09/2023 22:49

Sweedey · 18/09/2023 22:35

If you've never been on the racing end, you might not understand.

Its in earshot. No amount of 'emotional support' can make that ok.

Add in the fact that it's almost certainly a distorted version of reality when a highly agitated person is whinging to a close family member.

Add in that it's not just a one off and you're worried about upsetting your partner because now they're going to go and tell everyone your private business.

The irony of this post is that the op is cross that her dh has discussed their issues with his family and she’s posted it online to receive the same support he gets from his family.

Id prefer dh spoke to his family than posting online and read loads of comments telling him your wife is awful. You should leave her!

Sweedey · 18/09/2023 22:35

Sometimeswinning · 18/09/2023 22:31

God the amount of times I’ve told my best friends about an argument with dh! They do the same. Struggling with why this is an issue but according to some it’s a deal breaker! Some strange relationships out there.

If you've never been on the racing end, you might not understand.

Its in earshot. No amount of 'emotional support' can make that ok.

Add in the fact that it's almost certainly a distorted version of reality when a highly agitated person is whinging to a close family member.

Add in that it's not just a one off and you're worried about upsetting your partner because now they're going to go and tell everyone your private business.

Sometimeswinning · 18/09/2023 22:31

God the amount of times I’ve told my best friends about an argument with dh! They do the same. Struggling with why this is an issue but according to some it’s a deal breaker! Some strange relationships out there.