Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if an expensive travel system is worth it?

68 replies

overprepper · 18/09/2023 12:17

I can’t believe the cost of some, nearly £2000…!

My friend who had a baby 6 months ago has already ditched her travel system and bought another.

Is it really necessary to get a bulky & pricy all in one when they use it for such little time? Surely a better investment if you’re going to spend a lot is on a compact one that they will be in for longer, ie the yoyo or another cabin friendly one that can be used for travelling and every day, in and out the shops etc

We dont exactly need to make this choice immediately but just saving and budgeting for expensive items as we are about to start ttc. We both drive, live somewhere suburby and about a 10-15 min drive from the nearest town. Public transport isn’t great. We like going for a couple of big walks a week but if there’s no path/even surface then I’d imagine it would be easier to use a carrier for those situations

Did you get much use from yours?

OP posts:
Curseofthenation · 18/09/2023 15:07

Nah, you don't need a whole travel system. We got an ex-display Uppababy Vista, which was worth it to us as I walk miles and miles with it. I've just got my almost 3yo out of it as I'm due to have my second any day now.

We got a Joie 360 car seat, which goes from newborn to four. It's great. I'd highly recommend both.

These two items combined still set us back 1k. If you aren't a big walker then you could probably get away with a cheaper or second hand buggy.

overprepper · 18/09/2023 14:57

WillowCraft · 18/09/2023 12:47

Most car seats go on most prams, so get a new car seat and second hand pram. If you are walking everywhere a big pram is ok but if in and out of the car then something easy to fold is better.

I recommend baby jogger city mini gt, it's fine for rougher terrain, can fit a car seat, is light, folds one handed, lies flat enough for a newborn, and costs about £350 new.

Definitely do not spend £2000! You don't need anything new for a baby except possibly a car seat. Most of the stuff is barely used and in excellent condition and you can get rid of it after 6 months or so for the same youpaid for it. Facebook marketplace is your friend

Yes we’d definitely get a new car seat and research which make is safest.

OP posts:
overprepper · 18/09/2023 14:54

Really interesting & helpful mix of answers so far!

OP posts:
ColleenDonaghy · 18/09/2023 14:42

Uppababy Vista still being used, DC are 5 and 3. Bought for the first, never put away (but it was shit as a double, we had a separate double). Can take the 3yo, changing bag, towel for swings, two helmets, two scooters and god knows what else.

An absolute workhorse, definitely our best baby buy and possibly the best product I've had.

However, it's still in great nick (if filthy!) so second hand would be absolutely fine.

mycoffeecup · 18/09/2023 14:22

TheOutlaws · 18/09/2023 13:44

Travel systems are a con. I only used slings and a cheap buggy (and a car seat), but mostly my babies were in slings. I cannot believe it when I see what parents parade their kids around in.

I think there's a big status element for some parents.

YouHoooo · 18/09/2023 14:02

Depends what you do with it. I walk everywhere including to the shops, and my Vista is perfect (I can get a weekly shop underneath it). I’ve never had a problem on London busses with it.

It wouldn’t be so great if I needed to put it in a car, or regularly use tube stations with stairs.

Triplixate · 18/09/2023 13:49

We have a cosatto woosh 2 (ex display too) and a car seat separately and never regretted it for a second. I never had issues with folding or lifting the pushchair/pram or fitting it in boots like other mums I know. I’m disabled so travel systems weren’t an option due to the weight but even some fit and healthy mums had retired theirs before the first birthday as it was just impractical. Also, I personally find the set ups where the car seats clip onto the pram wheels silly. We just got baby out of her car seat and put her in her buggy. Even with my mobility issues I can still do that in a regular width bay. Having said that I’m sure some people swear by them! It does depend on lifestyle as some people will need something to go more off-road or load up with bags etc but for what we needed our set up was and still is perfect.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 18/09/2023 13:44

I have the bugaboo fox and the butterfly. The butterfly is great for certain situations and the fox great for others. I wouldn’t have wanted just one of the two as there are situations when one is better than the other (the butterfly for travel and the fox for muddy walks). We could have gone for something half way in between the two big then we would have been always compromising and anything bigger than the butterfly wouldn’t have been good for travel.

I think it depends what you are using them for in terms of what you need. I liked having the carrycot that could also be used for daytime sleeps and the ability to attach the car seat and used that a lot.

TheOutlaws · 18/09/2023 13:44

Travel systems are a con. I only used slings and a cheap buggy (and a car seat), but mostly my babies were in slings. I cannot believe it when I see what parents parade their kids around in.

301963Laurie · 18/09/2023 13:42

Had the all singing all dancing pram for 1st child but soon resorted to umbrella buggy . Number 2and 3 straight into lie flat buggy with cosytoes for number 3 because born in January.
. I would save the money for very decent car seat instead.

TakeMe2Insanity · 18/09/2023 13:40

We used a bugaboo bee, separate car seat, or sling when out. Always took our bee on holiday until he was 1 and luggage got left behind, then when it arrived it was jammed shut. After that we bought a light holiday buggy gb pockit which was fantastic. Both had really amazing wheels. Now 7 years later we’re having number 2, dragonfly doesn’t look as robust as the bee but looking at the fox as it’s sturdy and know we’ll buy a travel pram at 6 months. Probably won’t buy the yoyo as the wheels look rickety and don’t seem to cope well.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 18/09/2023 13:40

My youngest DS3 is now 22, but my experience is still the same
For my first I bought a top of the range silver cross wayfarer travel system with carrycot car seat and pushchair, which was really heavy and actually put me off going out with him, so at 4 months I moved on to a Maclaren lie back buggy which was brilliant
DS3 I had a really cheap but brilliant lie flat Graco for £70 with a huge basket then the Maclaren
Separate car seat as I didn't use the one on the silver cross
Don't spend 2k, do buy second hand( new car seat)
You can then buy a second stroller

TropicalTrama · 18/09/2023 13:37

We had an icandy peach. It was bulky, took up the whole boot of the car, DD hated being loose in the bassinet, the wheels were massive but weren’t proper tires so it was crap off road, the seat was weirdly small so at 18 months she was really cramped. Monumental waste of money.

Also had a YoYo which was fantastic. So compact, great for public transport, narrow shops, plane travel. As tiny babies they were so much more snug securely strapped into the newborn pack rather than loose in a bassinet getting bumped around. We’ve had it in continuous use for 6 years now and it’s still going strong. Yes the basket is small but we buy 99% of stuff online so who cares.

mycoffeecup · 18/09/2023 13:34

Definitely not. I only ever had a maclaren techno

RichTeee · 18/09/2023 13:33

I had an uppababy vista.
Used it as a carrycot as the base has airholes so safe to sleeping overnight. As we caravan it was a bonus for us. The bassinet is also bigger than most so DC we're in it until around 5/6 months.

I did use a sling if popping to the shops or would put the baby seat in a trolley more than using the base as a travel system. I think I was paranoid about the length of time they were in the car seat.

Loved that it front and rear faced and was so easy to "drive". My friend had her DC at the same time and bought a Chicco system and hated it as it was so clunky and like a 3 wheeled shopping cart to push. We used to swap when we went for walks to stop her taking her DC out and throwing it in the road. By her next pregnancy that was binned and replaced by my uppababy.

It's now 10 years old and has had 8DC in it, with new car seats for each and new mattresses.

So I'd go for a great 2nd hand system rather than a cheaper new one.

HamstersAreMyLife · 18/09/2023 13:27

For me it wasn't worth it. I got a brilliant buggy from mother care that could be a pram or buggy and both forward and rear facing for £200. It folded easy and fit in the back of my car. Got a separate car seat suitable up to stage 3 for £80 which I used for my second. I then swapped it for a secondhand bugaboo bee once my youngest was past the pram. There's a lot to be said for the pram but the ease of getting around people and obstacles and in and out of the house plus the space it took up inside was negligible so if I had another I would get something cheap and easy to maneuver. Even my first buggy was significantly easier than some of the expensive travel systems I looked at so really do try and play with some before you buy. Think about ease of use for you whatever that may look like.

Caspianberg · 18/09/2023 13:21

Depends.
ours weren’t £2000, but we do have 2 prams. We have a yo-yo for travel, we love it. But it’s useless we’re we live as off road so have a larger three wheel for day to day. It’s been used daily over 3 years

Oysterbabe · 18/09/2023 13:16

It's really not. We had one. When DD started nursery we bought a cheap umbrella fold we could throw in the storage box at nursery. From that day on we didn't use the expensive one again. The cheap folding one was so much lighter and more convenient.

LookingForPurpose · 18/09/2023 13:15

Nope. With my first 3 kids I invested the money in the car seat and just got a umbrella fold buggy that was suitable from birth. With the 4th I had more disposable income so I might a loooovely last season brand new travel system for £180 (2008) but hated it and went back to a proper car seat and folding buggy.

Big fancy prams/travel systems are known as council chariots around here. They are a status symbol and the more hideously fancy and OTT they are, the younger and worse off financially the parents are.

LeafHunter · 18/09/2023 13:13

Second hand here also. Silver cross wave. Used most days still and he’s 9 months.

Calmdown14 · 18/09/2023 13:13

Depends (though I wouldn't go as high as 2k) how you live.

Do you get public transport?

Do you most of your short journeys to local shop etc or tend to go in the car?

Do you have any steps up to your house and a space in your hall to park it?

People tend to ditch them because they are heavy to get in and out of a car or are a pain on public transport. But if you walk a lot then they are much nicer to push.

The unknown quantity is what kind of baby you have. I loved the carrycot on mine with new born's but both kids wanted up by about four months so use was short (though great protection with a winter baby when you live by the North sea!)

First child loved patent facing, was content in the buggy and it was great for him.
Second learned to escape quickly, wanted to walk and wanted to face where she was going so less decent value had it been bought for her.

I would really look into the weight and folding mechanism and definitely consider second hand.

Madcats · 18/09/2023 13:06

I think it all depends on how you plan to live with your baby. [I had a Stokke that I was able to sell for about 2/3rds if what we'd paid 4 years later]. We used ours a lot more than a family travelling everywhere by car.

For example, I have a tall, thin house so used the "pram/bassinet" as a downstairs cot for a good 5 or 6 months. It kept the baby away from our pets.

We hardly used our car, so a sturdy travel system was great for carting shopping home (it came as a bit of a shock when I had to carry bags again!).
Later we could have the pushchair seat forward or backwards facing at table height so eating out was straight forward too.

DappledThings · 18/09/2023 12:56

The whole compatible car seat that fits on the pram chassis was a waste of money for us. Did it once ever over 2 children. Didn't get the point of it at all.

meganorks · 18/09/2023 12:54

We got given one that was a bit rubbish to be fair, but meant we could figure out what we wanted. And we were able to get the pushchair part of the same make to use the car seat with. I think it was less than 300 for that part. I wouldn't have spent thousands! I found mine invaluable and didn't switch to something smaller as they don't have a decent basket underneath and I would walk everywhere and put my shopping there.
I did buy a double when I had my second and I would say that was a waste of money! The baby didn't really like the basket bit so I would often end up with her in a sling anyway. Then once the oldest was a bit bigger they liked the buggy board. Several times I found myself pushing the bloody thing along empty with a toddler insisting on walking and baby in a sling!

welshweasel · 18/09/2023 12:53

Decide what you want and buy second hand (plus new car seat). I had an icandy peach for my first and bugaboo cameleon for my second - both bought second hand and then sold for the same or more after less than a year's use (when we moved on to an out and about nipper, as we live rurally).

Buying new is a waste of money in my opinion. I don't know anyone who was still using their massive pram after a year.

Do buy a decent car seat though - avionaut, maxicosi and besafe all do decent infant seats. The ones that come with travel systems are frequently poor seats, that do not give a newborn a safe position.