Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(Covid) To think these recommendations are bonkers?

659 replies

NoCharnce · 18/09/2023 12:11

So the government commission into how to memorialise the Covid pandemic has recommended the government implement “A UK-wide day of reflection should be established and held annually.”

Other recommendations include national memorials (10 sites already identified!), oral histories and museums plus additional funding for local authorities to set up their own memorials.

I can’t be the only one who thinks this is nuts and hope the government ignores the recommendations? I genuinely cannot believe people get paid to produce this crap.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
WhalePolo · 25/09/2023 06:16

@SaltyOne

I think if anyone was unable to wear a mask and was concerned about the safety of others, they’d support other measures for socially distancing.

However, anti mask wearers tend to also be anti lockdown and anti other interventions to control viral spread.

Which means their motivation is more to do with personal freedom, and putting their individualism above the needs of others.

There is also an oppositional defiance to anything suggested by ‘the government’ - but even if you hate our current government : it was easy to see what global scientific consensus was advising.

SaltyOne · 25/09/2023 01:36

@JerryLovesMargo

This is exactly the sort of thing those of us who were exempt had to put up with.
I lost count of the times I was called a killer/murderer/disease vector/thick.
By people who claimed to care about the vulnerable, while completely missing the point that many who were exempt were so due to vulnerability/disability.

What annoyed me, though, was how those who apparently couldn't wear a mask (and plenty printed off sunflower lanyards from the internet) weaponised the word 'vulnerable'. Suddenly, they were vulnerable because they weren't wearing a mask - not particularly to the virus, but to public opinion - and bizarrely, the actual vulnerable felt more pushed into isolation.

Of course, this doesn't apply to everyone unable to wear a mask, but there certainly was (and is) a vocal and aggressive element in a particular segment of those who don't wear masks for some reason.

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 23:34

JerryLovesMargo · 24/09/2023 22:37

Our flat is council, DH works for a HA. 'Reassessments' regarding income don't apply to either and never have.

Nobody claims benefits here. You've always had to inform HB/UC of changes in income, not sure why you mentioned that. I'm not sure why you're making things up.

@JerryLovesMargo I live in a major city, maybe things are different here, I don’t know. You could expect differences across the U.K. regions as well.

I am not making things up, imparting what I know about social housing where I am based both from personal experience and that of friends/family. Pretty much all have some sort of UC coming in if they are socially housed.

JerryLovesMargo · 24/09/2023 22:37

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 17:05

@JerryLovesMargo

Ok so you fit into the disabled category.

Where I am the wait list can be 4years. Some people never get a social house because there are more needy who achieve more points, say a disabled single mother with several kids, trumps single man with no health issues.

I know of the reassessments, brought in via Cameron wasn’t it? Because my friend went from paying £220 a month to £550 a month and she and partner then decided to buy the house as a mortgage was cheaper. Some others have moved elsewhere.

It may depend whether your house is a genuine council house or under a housing association as to what applies.

Never the less if receiving housing benefit (uc now) you have to tell of changes to income.

Our flat is council, DH works for a HA. 'Reassessments' regarding income don't apply to either and never have.

Nobody claims benefits here. You've always had to inform HB/UC of changes in income, not sure why you mentioned that. I'm not sure why you're making things up.

WhalePolo · 24/09/2023 22:11

@Sparklecats

I’m so sorry you’ve lost loved ones.

I also feel that the needs of the vulnerable were disregarded, glossed over or deemed as inconvenient by some. In favour of individualism, personal freedom and wealth. However I do believe it was the minority. The majority took the safety of others seriously.

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 21:36

@WhalePolo thank you for respecting that some would wish for a remembrance.

I can fully understand how others want the whole thing forgotten about.

For me, at the time it felt my loved ones deaths were disregarded by some.

I remember trying to explain to someone that I’d had vulnerable friends die and I didn’t want to take any chances with DC. They actually rolled their eyes and tutted.

Now it seems we’re at risk of forgetting the people who died entirely, the sacrifices to keep us all safe and the enormous effort to find a route to ending restrictions.

I’m not ready to forget loved ones, it all still feels acutely painful - and recent actually - a close family friend died a year ago, a work colleague a month ago…

I mean people are still dying from this it’s horrible.

WhalePolo · 24/09/2023 21:26

@1dayatatime

Whereas those of us who needed to be careful because we were CEV or had a CEV in our household were referred to as ‘sheep’ - or snobs - or belittled - because we were choosing to follow global scientific consensus opinion in order to protect ourselves/others. In my case desperately waiting for a hospital bed to become available to treat cancer before it became untreatable.

I would personally rather forget that time, but fully understand that those who lost their loved ones to Covid may need a time for reflection.

1dayatatime · 24/09/2023 20:14

@WestwardHo1

"I thoroughly agree it was all hugely traumatic. It was made more traumatic than it needed to be because of the insanity we got caught up in.

I look back at it in horror.

I don't think state mandated remembrance will do a thing to help ease that."

+++

I think a state mandated remembrance would simply make many of us squirm with embarrassment and awkwardness at how easily we all got caught up in the hysteria and blindly followed the guidance even when it was contradictory or made no sense at all.

How many people were very happy to inform on those not following the rules or how any questioning of the guidance was shut down by accusation of being an anti vaxxer or COVID denier.

Nah I think we are better off trying to forget the whole thing and pretend it never happened.

WestwardHo1 · 24/09/2023 18:54

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 15:09

@WestwardHo1

I know people get sick and die.

But when we lost people to covid we very often hadn’t been able to see them for months. Some died very suddenly, others had prolonged spells isolated in care homes or hospitals.

I remember hearing my relative who was partially deaf crying and semi hysterical because they couldn’t understand what was going on or why we couldn’t come to the hospital. Several traumatic events followed. Then the abnormal funeral etc.

We lost more than a dozen family, friends, colleagues.

It was hugely traumatic and I think that’s why I like the idea of a space to acknowledge that. To sit by myself or with others to remember, chat, reflect.

And to have some sort of communal reflection, standing together. It does sound comforting to me.

But I appreciate that won’t be everyone’s experience.

I thoroughly agree it was all hugely traumatic. It was made more traumatic than it needed to be because of the insanity we got caught up in.

I look back at it in horror.

I don't think state mandated remembrance will do a thing to help ease that.

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 17:05

JerryLovesMargo · 24/09/2023 15:16

there are reassessments done relative to wage and SH rent upped to open market value if professional wages are involved

No there aren't. Absolute tosh. Source: I live in social housing, DH works in SH.

Please don't make things up.

Our rent is market rent anyway, which around here is under £500pcm for a 2 bed flat.

DD is a NQT so on a fairly low wage and I'm disabled so can't work, not that it makes any difference.

The wonderful thing about social housing is that it was conceived for working people of all backgrounds to live side by side. Where I am there isn't a shortage - several flats and houses near me have been empty for months because there isn't the demand. And we've lived here for over 20 years, paying back into the 'pot' (and no, we'd never buy our flat, even though we could for under £20k as we've been here for so long). So everyone benefits.

Maybe stop derailing the thread by making up lies and sharing your assumptions on people who live in SH, eh.

@JerryLovesMargo

Ok so you fit into the disabled category.

Where I am the wait list can be 4years. Some people never get a social house because there are more needy who achieve more points, say a disabled single mother with several kids, trumps single man with no health issues.

I know of the reassessments, brought in via Cameron wasn’t it? Because my friend went from paying £220 a month to £550 a month and she and partner then decided to buy the house as a mortgage was cheaper. Some others have moved elsewhere.

It may depend whether your house is a genuine council house or under a housing association as to what applies.

Never the less if receiving housing benefit (uc now) you have to tell of changes to income.

countrygirl99 · 24/09/2023 15:24

Dontcallmescarface · 24/09/2023 09:38

My (then), 82 year old dad was. When mum died in late March 2020 dad refused to have anyone in the house for 14 days after her death as he was so scared we would get into trouble ("bubbles" weren't a thing then). He was past caring if he caught it and died...he'd just lost the woman he had spent nearly 60 years with. Imagine an elderly man spending 2 weeks grieving alone because the media and state had terrified him into thinking that his daughter could get into trouble just by crossing the threshold of his home. As for the funeral rules back then, well the less said about that the better. We all heard the "thoughts are with the bereaved" line trotted out day after day by Johnson et al but in reality they didn't give a shit about any of us.

Edited

Yep @Dontcallmescarface My parents were terrified that I would get arrested for going round to care for my 93 yo dad when he came out of hospital after a late diagnosis of an infection thay was actually more likely to kill him than covos as his GP refused to see him face to face and misdiagnosed him.
My MIL got too terrified to even go into the garden and panicked when the carers who needed to hoist her out of bed came near her.

ReliantRobyn · 24/09/2023 15:21

There should be a tasteful tribute to the nutters of the pandemic: the covid deniers the conspiracy theorists.

JerryLovesMargo · 24/09/2023 15:16

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 14:43

@JerryLovesMargo

Because I don’t understand why several people on professional wages would be still in a social house.

Particularly when there are reassessments done relative to wage and SH rent upped to open market value if professional wages are involved. SE rent is astronomical so it might make sense that those on professional wages wouldn’t be able to afford it and would need SH. Not so much the NE.

Unless there is someone degree qualified and later disabled or say a nurse who is a single parent, something like that.

You don’t generally get families on 60-80k a year staying in a social house as their rent would be reassessed in light of higher income than when they first moved in…. And if paying market rate they usually would want to move elsewhere.

To get on a social housing list where I am there have to be problems - single parents, job loss, homelessness, disability etc etc and if financial circumstances improve you are reassessed. Very often people move on anyway, after buying the house at massive discount of course.

there are reassessments done relative to wage and SH rent upped to open market value if professional wages are involved

No there aren't. Absolute tosh. Source: I live in social housing, DH works in SH.

Please don't make things up.

Our rent is market rent anyway, which around here is under £500pcm for a 2 bed flat.

DD is a NQT so on a fairly low wage and I'm disabled so can't work, not that it makes any difference.

The wonderful thing about social housing is that it was conceived for working people of all backgrounds to live side by side. Where I am there isn't a shortage - several flats and houses near me have been empty for months because there isn't the demand. And we've lived here for over 20 years, paying back into the 'pot' (and no, we'd never buy our flat, even though we could for under £20k as we've been here for so long). So everyone benefits.

Maybe stop derailing the thread by making up lies and sharing your assumptions on people who live in SH, eh.

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 15:09

@WestwardHo1

I know people get sick and die.

But when we lost people to covid we very often hadn’t been able to see them for months. Some died very suddenly, others had prolonged spells isolated in care homes or hospitals.

I remember hearing my relative who was partially deaf crying and semi hysterical because they couldn’t understand what was going on or why we couldn’t come to the hospital. Several traumatic events followed. Then the abnormal funeral etc.

We lost more than a dozen family, friends, colleagues.

It was hugely traumatic and I think that’s why I like the idea of a space to acknowledge that. To sit by myself or with others to remember, chat, reflect.

And to have some sort of communal reflection, standing together. It does sound comforting to me.

But I appreciate that won’t be everyone’s experience.

WomblingTree86 · 24/09/2023 15:03

WestwardHo1 · 24/09/2023 14:58

You not knowing them doesn't mean it didn't happen 🙄

I'm not suggesting it didn't happen but if there were huge numbers of people who were petrified despite being young and healthy I would have known some of them.

WestwardHo1 · 24/09/2023 15:01

How are families losses to be commemorated?

How do people normally remember their family and friends?

I demand an Alzheimer's memorial. My dad died of Alzheimer's just before the pandemic. Actually what "killed" him was someone coming into the care home with a cold, which he caught and it developed into pneumonia, and he died with his lungs gargling fluid.

It was pretty awful. However people go through this every day.

WestwardHo1 · 24/09/2023 14:58

WomblingTree86 · 24/09/2023 10:15

I don't know anyone who was young and physically healthy and "petrified" of catching it themselves to the extent they barely went out for months/years. Most young healthy people understood that they were not personally at high risk after the first couple of months.

You not knowing them doesn't mean it didn't happen 🙄

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 14:57

JenniferBooth · 24/09/2023 14:50

Yes Sparkle im deffo the right wing one 🙄

@JenniferBooth I was homeless at 18 and I had to go on the housing list, it was incredibly hard to get on it despite my situation at the time and plenty of points.

I was offered a few flats - all in an apartment block the floor above had alcoholic men, the floor below sex offenders.

Then a house finally but it needed massive renovation that was not forthcoming and I couldn’t afford, and somebody had vomited over the window so I decided It wasn’t for me and stayed in private rentals.

The demand for housing is so strong and has been for decades, it’s not like anyone can walk in and be handed a house.

BlackeyedSusan · 24/09/2023 14:54

LoobyDop · 18/09/2023 12:52

Memorial Day agenda

09:00 one hour of exercise (max)
10:00 queuing in a car park
11:00 coffee and cheese
12:00 break for lunch. Plans will depend on tier status.
13:00 shout at people on Mumsnet
14:00 PPE knitting circle
15:00 government briefing (subject to timely conclusion of lunchtime party essential team meeting
16:00 pan banging

I remember the coffee and cheese madness.

Sadly I had a similar incident this morning...half frozen milk led to cereal and cream which isn't very nice at all.

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 14:50

JenniferBooth · 24/09/2023 14:26

If the next pandemic is 10%+ fatality you will have more than trying to stop and control families seeing each other at Christmas Sparkle. Essential workers will be too scared to go to work. So no water, electric, internet etc, They hit the sweet spot with Covid in that people were scared but not scared enough not to go to work. Do you really think essential workers will want to go to work and put their kids and other relatives at risk .............for you?

@JenniferBooth I think you need to go to a library and pick up a number of books on zoonotic disease.

It is well documented that disruption occurs and anyone at the planning level would be anticipating this and managing it. Things like PPE, back up workers if some fall ill/die/refuse to work.

For instance with Ebola “At the community level, a cyclical pattern of fear occurs, with a loss of trust in health services and stigma, resulting in disruptions of community interactions and community break down“.

Ultimately you will still have people going out to work despite grave health risk because they need money to feed their family.

JenniferBooth · 24/09/2023 14:50

Yes Sparkle im deffo the right wing one 🙄

JenniferBooth · 24/09/2023 14:48

"In the 1980s, residualisation may have been a partly unintended consequence of housing policies pursued with varying ideological intent"

Since 2010, and more so since the return of single-party Conservative government in 2015, we’ve seen something further: welfarisation – ‘a conception of social housing as a very small, highly residualised sector catering only for the very poorest, and those with additional social “vulnerabilities”, on a short-term “ambulance” basis

From Municipal Dreams The Rise and Fall of Council Housing by John Boughton.

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 14:43

JerryLovesMargo · 24/09/2023 14:20

No, north east. Why do you ask?

@JerryLovesMargo

Because I don’t understand why several people on professional wages would be still in a social house.

Particularly when there are reassessments done relative to wage and SH rent upped to open market value if professional wages are involved. SE rent is astronomical so it might make sense that those on professional wages wouldn’t be able to afford it and would need SH. Not so much the NE.

Unless there is someone degree qualified and later disabled or say a nurse who is a single parent, something like that.

You don’t generally get families on 60-80k a year staying in a social house as their rent would be reassessed in light of higher income than when they first moved in…. And if paying market rate they usually would want to move elsewhere.

To get on a social housing list where I am there have to be problems - single parents, job loss, homelessness, disability etc etc and if financial circumstances improve you are reassessed. Very often people move on anyway, after buying the house at massive discount of course.

JenniferBooth · 24/09/2023 14:28

Its chilling isnt it @JerryLovesMargo The attitude to masks here and towards people who cant wear them clearly shows it would happen again.

JenniferBooth · 24/09/2023 14:26

If the next pandemic is 10%+ fatality you will have more than trying to stop and control families seeing each other at Christmas Sparkle. Essential workers will be too scared to go to work. So no water, electric, internet etc, They hit the sweet spot with Covid in that people were scared but not scared enough not to go to work. Do you really think essential workers will want to go to work and put their kids and other relatives at risk .............for you?