Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(Covid) To think these recommendations are bonkers?

659 replies

NoCharnce · 18/09/2023 12:11

So the government commission into how to memorialise the Covid pandemic has recommended the government implement “A UK-wide day of reflection should be established and held annually.”

Other recommendations include national memorials (10 sites already identified!), oral histories and museums plus additional funding for local authorities to set up their own memorials.

I can’t be the only one who thinks this is nuts and hope the government ignores the recommendations? I genuinely cannot believe people get paid to produce this crap.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
firef1y · 26/09/2023 17:05

GoryBory · 18/09/2023 15:09

These are from the tin hat wearers who can’t seem to grasp that the measures put in place = fewer deaths.

Ive lost count of how many comments I’ve read saying how covid wasn’t as bad as we were told it was going to be and that we were lied to because not that many people died etc.

But the same people are also commenting on how masks, vaccines and lockdowns didn’t work 🤦‍♀️

They are just very confused and not very bright.
They also like to think they’re part of some special club that knows what’s going on and the rest of us don’t.

Except that when you actually look at the graphs, the peaks didn't actually match with the measures put in place. The first hospital wave peaked in a way that showed the infection rate peaked the week before the first lockdown (at that point we really only had hospital and death numbers) Similar with future peaks, it had naturally peaked before harsher measures had come in to effect.
Or the way that we were somehow being convinced that a certain number of people had died with covid in a 24hr period, when in reality the deaths were reported in that period and at one point they were adding in numbers from a year previous.

JenniferBooth · 26/09/2023 16:34

People sacrificed seeing their families for months on end. If those sacrifices were so minimal why arent people doing them now

And ive already sounded a warning. Minimizing and denigrating peoples sacrifices is what is more likely to have people ignoring any future restrictions next time not fucking Partygate

I said on here and in RL in April 2020 that whatever we do and whatever we sacrifice it will never be enough. And ive been proved right!

And when the "we are all in this together" spiel started i knew that it would only count when it came to Covid lockdowns vaccines and masks. And that it would be back to the default setting as soon as possible Aptly demonstrated by the comments about social housing tenants on here.

So next time it will be obvious to more people that it was all about protecting our "betters"

WhalePolo · 26/09/2023 14:55

@1dayatatime

But I don’t understand that. Do you think hospitals would have been all ticking along nicely and running as normal if no restrictions were in place? Cancer patients seen promptly? With Covid circulating unchecked, no vaccine?

Or would there have been an absolute tsunami of very ill patients needing urgent ICU care, pulling resources away from all departments. In my local hospital, I’m aware of wards being cleared to make way for Covid patients - they were presenting as the immediate emergency. And if that number was say - tenfold - because no restrictions were in place, a cancer patient would be put EVEN FURTHER down the back of the queue.

But this is obvious isn’t it??

WomblingTree86 · 26/09/2023 14:43

1dayatatime · 26/09/2023 10:15

@WhalePolo

"Someone was making a point earlier about missed cancer diagnosis due to lockdown. From my experience, there was no manpower or resources to treat cancer patients because the local hospital was completely overwhelmed with Covid. Therefore measures taken to control infection spread were needed to take the burden off hospitals so they COULD treat cancer patients."

+++

That was me. I don't disagree with you on the above on what happened but it is completely illogical.

For the majority of cases and certainly those below 80 Covid was not a life threatening disease. However for the majority of cases cancer is a life threatening condition.

So the hospitals prioritised the treatment of a less life threatening condition over a more life threatening condition.

Covid was life threatening for many of those with cancer.

WestwardHo1 · 26/09/2023 12:21

1dayatatime · 26/09/2023 12:07

@user1497207191

That's horrific and thats with your OH actually having cancer being diagnosed.

My oncologist friend said that for 18 months his first stage referrals dropped by 60%. So there were a lot of cancer patients who didn't even get diagnosed.

I genuinely think that more lives will be lost from the Covid measures than from Covid itself.

I think that's accepted already.

1dayatatime · 26/09/2023 12:07

@user1497207191

That's horrific and thats with your OH actually having cancer being diagnosed.

My oncologist friend said that for 18 months his first stage referrals dropped by 60%. So there were a lot of cancer patients who didn't even get diagnosed.

I genuinely think that more lives will be lost from the Covid measures than from Covid itself.

user1497207191 · 26/09/2023 11:16

@1dayatatime

For the majority of cases and certainly those below 80 Covid was not a life threatening disease. However for the majority of cases cancer is a life threatening condition. So the hospitals prioritised the treatment of a less life threatening condition over a more life threatening condition.

Yes, sadly that's what happened. My OH was due to start chemotherapy the week before Boris announced the first lockdown. Hospital phoned on the morning of his treatment to say it was cancelled and they'd get back to him with a re-arranged date. Months passed. Radio silence from the hospital. He phoned several times to try to chase them up, but it was mostly answerphones where he left a message but they never got back to him. A few times he managed to speak to someone but they just said they'd pass the message on, but again, no call backs. He got so worried after a few months that we went in person to the chemo dept to ask in person, but it was all closed and shuttered!

Finally, with persistence, he got to speak to someone who couldn't believe he'd not started his treatment as they claimed they'd been doing the chemo sessions throughout and apparently "he'd fallen through the cracks". Then things started to move, he needed to start again with blood tests, skeletal x-ray, MRI scans, etc as the previous ones were now out of date. He also needed an in person consultant appointment. So we went to various hospitals over a few weeks, and ever single one was like a zombie apocalypse - literally empty except for a few staff crowded around reception desks - entire waiting areas taped off and empty, corridors empty. Chemotherapy dept completely empty, even the treatment rooms when he started his infusions were empty. So, no, they really weren't treating "urgent" patients as normal as cancer treatment is just about the most urgent you can get really. The year later (2021), those same places were heaving with people again, treatment rooms were chock full, as was the chemotherapy waiting rooms. People really can't say that cancer patients were being treated as normal - we saw with our own eyes that numbers were tiny. I suspect, like OH, they were deliberately delaying treatment to keep patients out of the hospital. I shudder to think how many cancer patients needlessly died whilst waiting for their treatment to start if what happened to my OH is typical.

WestwardHo1 · 26/09/2023 10:40

SaltyOne · 26/09/2023 01:30

Which sacrifices are you speaking of? Wearing a mask?

Because hell, we were just being paid to sit at home and watch Netflix, right,?

1dayatatime · 26/09/2023 10:15

@WhalePolo

"Someone was making a point earlier about missed cancer diagnosis due to lockdown. From my experience, there was no manpower or resources to treat cancer patients because the local hospital was completely overwhelmed with Covid. Therefore measures taken to control infection spread were needed to take the burden off hospitals so they COULD treat cancer patients."

+++

That was me. I don't disagree with you on the above on what happened but it is completely illogical.

For the majority of cases and certainly those below 80 Covid was not a life threatening disease. However for the majority of cases cancer is a life threatening condition.

So the hospitals prioritised the treatment of a less life threatening condition over a more life threatening condition.

SaltyOne · 26/09/2023 01:30

JenniferBooth · 25/09/2023 13:41

The person it happened to is on this very thread. Are you accusing them of lying. Bad enough minimizing and belittling the sacrifices people made which will make compliance less likely next time. Accusing people of lying certainly will.

Which sacrifices are you speaking of? Wearing a mask?

JenniferBooth · 25/09/2023 14:46

Whale Well those men were a bunch of arseholes wanting to assert power over a woman.

WhalePolo · 25/09/2023 14:34

Of course spitting on someone is disgusting at any time or for any reason.

Anecdotally, I remember being laughed at as I bought adult nappies - because I was wearing a mask and trying to socially distance in a shop. The group of men were intentionally trying get close to me and breathe on me. I then had to take the nappies to a cancer patient who was CEV.

Someone was making a point earlier about missed cancer diagnosis due to lockdown. From my experience, there was no manpower or resources to treat cancer patients because the local hospital was completely overwhelmed with Covid. Therefore measures taken to control infection spread were needed to take the burden off hospitals so they COULD treat cancer patients.

JenniferBooth · 25/09/2023 13:48

Oh i get it Its like PIP. Its the new version of "its the cheats who make it harder for the genuine people to claim disability benefits" Except this was the post 2020 Covid version.

JenniferBooth · 25/09/2023 13:46

I strongly suspect a lot of lanyard wearing mask refusers weren't actually "unable" to wear a mask after all

So how were you able to tell the difference.

JenniferBooth · 25/09/2023 13:44

Obviously the person removed their mask to spit at @JerryLovesMargo Dont be deliberately abusive

JenniferBooth · 25/09/2023 13:41

The person it happened to is on this very thread. Are you accusing them of lying. Bad enough minimizing and belittling the sacrifices people made which will make compliance less likely next time. Accusing people of lying certainly will.

SaltyOne · 25/09/2023 13:25

user1497207191 · 25/09/2023 12:40

@SaltyOne

What annoyed me, though, was how those who apparently couldn't wear a mask (and plenty printed off sunflower lanyards from the internet) weaponised the word 'vulnerable'. Suddenly, they were vulnerable because they weren't wearing a mask - not particularly to the virus, but to public opinion - and bizarrely, theactualvulnerable felt more pushed into isolation.

I agree with this. It was a massive kick in the teeth to the genuinely ECV people to have people apparently unable to wear a mask not showing them any respect, not giving the required social distancing, etc. Common sense would suggest that those not wearing a mask would make some kind of effort to stay away from other people, as they were clearly a threat to the ECV etc. But no, most people wearing sunflower lanyards seemed to think they special and didn't give a toss about potentially vulnerable people they were close to (often unnecessarily close!). So many didn't even respect the 2 metre social distance suggested forcing mask wearing vulnerable people to have to walk away from queues, etc as they wanted to stay away. I strongly suspect a lot of lanyard wearing mask refusers weren't actually "unable" to wear a mask after all, they just didn't want to and probably were covid deniers by the way many of them acted.

Totally agree.

SaltyOne · 25/09/2023 13:25

JenniferBooth · 25/09/2023 12:47

So how do explain a PP being spat at when she couldnt wear a mask Im really surprised NOT that there hasnt been more concern about how much Covid people could spread by this disgusting act. Or are little droplets more likely to spread Covid than actual spitting. Please can the more educated among you enlighten me!!

Or is the reason it is being swept under the carpet is because y"all know the real reason Jerry was spat at was because someone was jealous that she had an exemption. Thats the real motive!

I doubt jealousy was a motive, if the incident happened at all. (Can a person spit through a mask?)

SaltyOne · 25/09/2023 13:19

@JenniferBooth

Oh and its not a good reflection on your higher university education when you say Oh anti lockdowners are all anti vaxxers and Covid deniers. Bullshit. Im anti lockdowns (see what i did there. PLURAL) cos i understand why we had to have the first one. Although it should have been shorter. But i happily had the vaccines.

If you dont understand that one can be against one thing but not against the other then i dont think much of the higher education you had. OR were you just being childish

Who are you talking to? Are you mixing posters up?

JenniferBooth · 25/09/2023 12:47

So how do explain a PP being spat at when she couldnt wear a mask Im really surprised NOT that there hasnt been more concern about how much Covid people could spread by this disgusting act. Or are little droplets more likely to spread Covid than actual spitting. Please can the more educated among you enlighten me!!

Or is the reason it is being swept under the carpet is because y"all know the real reason Jerry was spat at was because someone was jealous that she had an exemption. Thats the real motive!

user1497207191 · 25/09/2023 12:40

@SaltyOne

What annoyed me, though, was how those who apparently couldn't wear a mask (and plenty printed off sunflower lanyards from the internet) weaponised the word 'vulnerable'. Suddenly, they were vulnerable because they weren't wearing a mask - not particularly to the virus, but to public opinion - and bizarrely, theactualvulnerable felt more pushed into isolation.

I agree with this. It was a massive kick in the teeth to the genuinely ECV people to have people apparently unable to wear a mask not showing them any respect, not giving the required social distancing, etc. Common sense would suggest that those not wearing a mask would make some kind of effort to stay away from other people, as they were clearly a threat to the ECV etc. But no, most people wearing sunflower lanyards seemed to think they special and didn't give a toss about potentially vulnerable people they were close to (often unnecessarily close!). So many didn't even respect the 2 metre social distance suggested forcing mask wearing vulnerable people to have to walk away from queues, etc as they wanted to stay away. I strongly suspect a lot of lanyard wearing mask refusers weren't actually "unable" to wear a mask after all, they just didn't want to and probably were covid deniers by the way many of them acted.

JenniferBooth · 25/09/2023 12:22

What annoyed me, though, was how those who apparently couldn't wear a mask (and plenty printed off sunflower lanyards from the internet) weaponised the word 'vulnerable

Many people couldnt wear a mask so you can shove your "apparently"

And here is a way the word vulnerable was weaponised. People who couldnt give a shit about disabled people and/or the elderly pre Covid were suddenly concerned about them but only in the way that they could use them as a tool or a stick to bully and emotionally blackmail others into following Covid restrictions. And when those some of those same disabled people couldnt wear a mask they were treated appallingly. So happy to use them as a tool when wanting others to follow rulz but back to the default setting of treating them like shit when they couldnt wear a mask.

Oh and its not a good reflection on your higher university education when you say Oh anti lockdowners are all anti vaxxers and Covid deniers. Bullshit. Im anti lockdowns (see what i did there. PLURAL) cos i understand why we had to have the first one. Although it should have been shorter. But i happily had the vaccines.

If you dont understand that one can be against one thing but not against the other then i dont think much of the higher education you had. OR were you just being childish.

1dayatatime · 25/09/2023 11:32

@SaltyOne
@WhalePolo

"Agreed. There seems to be such a narrow focus: how if effects me; it is my choice; my bodily autonomy; the government is doing this to me; can't the government appreciate how this decision affect me/the group I identify with.

Governments across the world made broadly similar decisions. Nothing was personal or aimed with malicious purpose at any particular group. I'm not certain why some persist with these kinds of ideas, as it's divisive and harmful."

+++

So firstly on the point of masks you have to weigh up what is cost to individuals in complying with the requirement to wear a mask (some discomfort but otherwise minimal) versus the benefit (which is a reduction in the spread of a predominantly airborne disease). Indeed pre covid, mask wearing was quite common in Asian countries.

On other restrictions it becomes more complicated such as the loss of education to young people that will impact their life chances (and therefore health in later years), the economic damage that will increase relative poverty and therefore health of the country, the missed cancer and cardio diagnosis and resultant deaths.

So you have to weigh up from the societal view as many did at the time point out- do these restrictions whilst reducing deaths in the short term predominantly amongst the elderly result in the longer term a greater number of deaths amongst all ages of society but especially amongst the poor and significant economic damage.

But anyone making this point at the time was shot down as either "covid denier " or "anti vaxx".

SaltyOne · 25/09/2023 07:01

WhalePolo · 25/09/2023 06:16

@SaltyOne

I think if anyone was unable to wear a mask and was concerned about the safety of others, they’d support other measures for socially distancing.

However, anti mask wearers tend to also be anti lockdown and anti other interventions to control viral spread.

Which means their motivation is more to do with personal freedom, and putting their individualism above the needs of others.

There is also an oppositional defiance to anything suggested by ‘the government’ - but even if you hate our current government : it was easy to see what global scientific consensus was advising.

Agreed. There seems to be such a narrow focus: how if effects me; it is my choice; my bodily autonomy; the government is doing this to me; can't the government appreciate how this decision affect me/the group I identify with.

Governments across the world made broadly similar decisions. Nothing was personal or aimed with malicious purpose at any particular group. I'm not certain why some persist with these kinds of ideas, as it's divisive and harmful.