Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(Covid) To think these recommendations are bonkers?

659 replies

NoCharnce · 18/09/2023 12:11

So the government commission into how to memorialise the Covid pandemic has recommended the government implement “A UK-wide day of reflection should be established and held annually.”

Other recommendations include national memorials (10 sites already identified!), oral histories and museums plus additional funding for local authorities to set up their own memorials.

I can’t be the only one who thinks this is nuts and hope the government ignores the recommendations? I genuinely cannot believe people get paid to produce this crap.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
WhalePolo · 27/09/2023 17:33

@1dayatatime

Yes there were different opinions. But there is a consensus opinion which feeds health guidelines everywhere. In any situation, whether you are trying to send a rocket to the moon - or treating cancer, you go with the consensus view as it’s likely to be the safest. I also don’t think the consensus view has changed : masks, or - lockdown in an emergency situation as seen recently with Ebola in Uganda. Of course the debate is good, but until ‘masks don’t work’ for example, becomes the new consensus - it’s not the safest thing to advise on a global scale.

1dayatatime · 27/09/2023 17:11

The loss of learning, freedom and hope to children during the Covid-19 pandemic could have been prevented:

www.savethechildren.org.uk/news/media-centre/press-releases/harm-to-children-in-covid-lockdown-preventable-new-report-conclu

Even worse this was pointed out at the time, but was dismissed as anti vaxx or Covid denier or children will bounce back or children are disease vectors etc etc.

1dayatatime · 27/09/2023 17:05

@WhalePolo

". I trust the science,"

+++

What the pandemic taught me was that there is no one true science in relation to Covid at the time as many believed or "followed the science ".

There were different scientific views at the time and the decisions on restrictions and lockdowns were political decisions not scientific decisions as Chris Whitty said.

WhalePolo · 27/09/2023 16:10

I agree with you there too @WestwardHo1 . About the trust - about how we’d cope with another pandemic. I’d say it’s important to extrapolate the science from the politics. I trust the science, and think the global comparison is important if the politicians here are behaving like idiots.

WestwardHo1 · 27/09/2023 16:05

WhalePolo · 27/09/2023 15:56

I think a lot of that WAS nonsense @WestwardHo1 - and very much down to mismanagement by our government.

But then the global consensus scientific opinion, and the reasoning behind that - wasn’t nonsense.

In every country there would have been atrocious government decisions as to how to implement restrictions - someone being shot in the Philippines as an extreme example.

Well we agree on the colossal unforgiveable mismanagement then

My point all the way through was that the government handled this so unbelievably badly that they totally lost the faith of the population. Covid quite clearly was not "the big one", and by the time the big one does come around (e.g. if birdflu does a bit of cross species jumping), any kind of infections controls will be far far more difficult to implement. Probably impossible.

Bloody idiots the lot of them. They completely failed.

Chuck in the revelations about Partygate, is it any wonder that many people concluded, "well THEY weren't scared. Why were we?"

WhalePolo · 27/09/2023 16:04

@1dayatatime

I think a comparison is so hard (Sweden/Florida) as the majority of their neighbours WERE in lockdown, which might have afforded maverick country the chance to do that. However ALL countries, EVERYWHERE? I think would have been a disaster. If you look at India, Brazil who went for the no restrictions approach - it did not work out there. Also - our healthcare system was not great prior to Covid. I would imagine Sweden’s were better able to cope. Also need to consider population density, and compliance in other ways. Sweden had ‘trust’ in their government/one of highest vaccine uptakes in Europe.

If you are saying ‘lockdown doesn’t work’ then you have to apply that reasoning on a global scale. Saying some countries can, others can’t - would cause massive global division and poverty : in probably the poorest countries as it is already.

WhalePolo · 27/09/2023 15:56

I think a lot of that WAS nonsense @WestwardHo1 - and very much down to mismanagement by our government.

But then the global consensus scientific opinion, and the reasoning behind that - wasn’t nonsense.

In every country there would have been atrocious government decisions as to how to implement restrictions - someone being shot in the Philippines as an extreme example.

1dayatatime · 27/09/2023 15:51

-@WhalePolo

"I think had we not had restrictions, the results would have been more catastrophic in the short term AND the long term. Because hospitals would have collapsed and it would have been difficult for them to recover"

++++

It is impossible to say what the number of Covid cases and Covid deaths would have been without the restrictions simply because there were restrictions.

The best estimate we can get is looking at places like Sweden and Florida which has no lockdowns and fewer restrictions and did not suffer disproportionately higher covid cases and covid deaths than those places with much more stringent restrictions.

1dayatatime · 27/09/2023 15:47

@WomblingTree86

Have you provided the evidence or data either way showing other countries are in the same boat or is it just your perception that they are?

++++

Without knowing which country you are referring to it is difficult to provide the relevant data.

However here is a Lancet article referring to the increase in cancer deaths in Australia as a result of missed diagnosis:

www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpub/article/PIIS2468-2667(22)00111-6/fulltext

A similar article in relation to the US:

www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-covid-cancer-effect/

WestwardHo1 · 27/09/2023 15:30

I don't think though that people are saying that there should have been no restrictions.

Personally what I am angry about is the nonsensical illogical aspects of it, and the total over reach of the "authorities" and the state. Remember those children playing in their garden on a sunny day and being ordered inside by a police officer who told them (inaccurately) "1000 people died yesterday", as though that was the children's responsibility and them playing outdoors contributed to it. Golf clubs opening before schools. Swings being tied up. Single people living alone not being "allowed" to get a hug when they needed it. The politicking of Nicola Sturgeon and that idiot Drakeford. Not being "allowed" to buy felt tips and paper in Wales, though being "allowed" to buy copious amounts of booze. Elderly people being isolated in their rooms sometimes for months. Schools remaining shut during the summer of 2020 long after the peak had passed. Why?

Those "look them in the eye" adverts. The adverts which told kids "Don't kill granny". WTF?

I cannot believe there are people who defend this shit.

WhalePolo · 27/09/2023 14:59

I would imagine that you are seeing - in terms of global population growth - a large dip around Covid times, and now a rise again. If restrictions were THAT detrimental, if we were all now dying as a result of restrictions - that Covid dip would be still steadily declining.

WhalePolo · 27/09/2023 14:56

@1dayatatime

I think had we not had restrictions, the results would have been more catastrophic in the short term AND the long term. Because hospitals would have collapsed and it would have been difficult for them to recover. All hospital services would have been impacted (maternity, waiting lists, emergency care, paediatrics) You would have had a nation that was unhealthy, and unable to access basic NHS services. This would have had an even more detrimental impact on education. Schools exist because of the infrastructure that supports that school. An unhealthy infrastructure (adults, parents, staff, catering, facilities) would impact the operation of that school. Children also need access to adequate hospital services - and children could have died as a result of not being able access basic care.

JenniferBooth · 27/09/2023 14:42

@WestwardHo1 I know lockdown as such couldnt have happened in the 80s when i was at school cos no internet but if something similar had happened then and they had closed the schools i likely wouldnt have gone back I was badly bullied at school and would have jumped at the chance to get away from that. I wonder how many of those kids have experienced the same

WomblingTree86 · 27/09/2023 14:37

1dayatatime · 27/09/2023 14:17

@WomblingTree86

I'm currently living in another country. I disagree that they are all suffering similar problems to the UK.

+++

Perhaps you are right, perhaps you are wrong or perhaps the data has not been released
/ publicised as it has in the UK.

Happy to see the evidence and data either way or is this just based on your perception?

Have you provided the evidence or data either way showing other countries are in the same boat or is it just your perception that they are?

WestwardHo1 · 27/09/2023 14:36

I just read that the number of children persistently missing school is double what it was before the pandemic.

Children and young people (and their parents) were given the impression by the government that education is unimportant.

Or is that just a coincidence?

JenniferBooth · 27/09/2023 14:31

DH is now 73 (so 70 when we first locked down) Has COPD ischemic heart disease and was fucking pissed at being used as a tool to emotionally blackmail others into following Covid rules when no one gives a fuck the rest of the time, while also being treated as part of a homogenous mass.

e,g back when he drove (he gave up driving in Jan 2020 and only used car for short distances) he had a blue badge it ran out and our local council INSISTED on him travelling to another area for a medical They would not have it THEN that he could not drive that far for HEALTH reasons so he went without the badge, yet come March 2020 all this sudden caring about health was all over their fb. This is the kind of hypocrisy many are absolutely sick of

1dayatatime · 27/09/2023 14:30

@WhalePolo

"All these arguments are putting the healthy and their rights far above the unhealthy. "

+++

Not at all, it is more a question of do you save a smaller number of lives in the short term at the cost of a greater number of lives lost in the long run or do you accept the loss of lives de in the short run in order to prevent a greater loss of life in the long run.

I agree it's not a pleasant choice, but that is the harsh reality.

WestwardHo1 · 27/09/2023 14:30

It's also by no means certain that these frail elderly people would all have died in huge numbers. My mum was mid 70s and has a chronic lung condition. She caught Covid and though felt grotty for a while (as did I when I got it the first time), she was back to normal fairly quickly. She was horrified at lockdowns and what they were doing to society, to her children's livelihoods and her grandchildren's wellbeing. She was scornful of the idea that it was to "protect" her.

But that's just a personal anecdote.

WestwardHo1 · 27/09/2023 14:26

And while I'm here, today in town I saw a woman walking along the prom - outside in a F9 gale - wearing a mask over her mouth (her nose she left free to inhale the fresh sea air).

That is exactly the kind of thing people mean when they talk about a lack of logic and rationality. Yet according to some, this woman's morals are on a higher level that someone who concluded that such a thing would be pointless.

1dayatatime · 27/09/2023 14:26

@WhalePolo

So in a no lockdown situation - you’ve got a huge, huge number of elderly patients/other vulnerable people who are being ‘sacrificed’ so that the healthy can be educated/have economic wealth.

They STILL need a hospital bed. They cannot die in inhumane circumstances or without support. That requires manpower. Where do they go? - hospital, ICU, ambulance

+++
So to clarify not being sacrificed so that the healthy can be educated / have wealth. But being sacrificed to prevent a greater number of excess deaths across all age groups in the coming years.

Secondly this would have resulted in the situation that we are now facing but seemingly are now accepting:

metro.co.uk/2023/09/25/new-data-shows-that-24-hours-in-ae-isnt-just-a-tv-show-with-huge-wait-times-in-hospitals-19549107/amp/

WestwardHo1 · 27/09/2023 14:23

SaltyOne · 27/09/2023 13:59

A quote from your post above:

"You're saying that, for example, shutting down and constraining the lives and education of small children - months seem like years to little kids on account of them not having been alive very long - is preferable to extending the lives for a short while of people who have already lived a very long time? Globally, 75-80 years is a very long time, and the elderly were by far the largest group of "the vulnerable".

Yes?

You seem to be inferring that I wanted all old people sacrificed or something?

I was asking you a question.

WhalePolo · 27/09/2023 14:20

It’s a very survival of the healthy and ‘fittest’ argument. All these arguments are putting the healthy and their rights far above the unhealthy. That’s very wrong in my opinion. And that’s not what medical science seeks to do - thank god.

1dayatatime · 27/09/2023 14:19

@SaltyOne

In the country where I live, these things have not occurred to any great degree. We had so many deaths from Covid. That has been such a such terrible loss.

++++

Perhaps you are right, perhaps you are wrong or perhaps the excess death data has not been released
/ publicised as it has in the UK.

Happy to see the evidence and data either way or is this just based on your perception?

1dayatatime · 27/09/2023 14:17

@WomblingTree86

I'm currently living in another country. I disagree that they are all suffering similar problems to the UK.

+++

Perhaps you are right, perhaps you are wrong or perhaps the data has not been released
/ publicised as it has in the UK.

Happy to see the evidence and data either way or is this just based on your perception?

WhalePolo · 27/09/2023 14:16

I’ll say again (can’t remember who to!).

So in a no lockdown situation - you’ve got a huge, huge number of elderly patients/other vulnerable people who are being ‘sacrificed’ so that the healthy can be educated/have economic wealth.

They STILL need a hospital bed. They cannot die in inhumane circumstances or without support. That requires manpower. Where do they go? - hospital, ICU, ambulance. The hospital cannot just leave an elderly person struggling to breathe/in pain alone at home. Therefore they need hospital staff/resources. This pulls away from ALL services. Hospitals can’t provide an adequate level of support for maternity, cancer, emergency care etc etc if they are absolutely overwhelmed with Covid cases.

Swipe left for the next trending thread