Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(Covid) To think these recommendations are bonkers?

659 replies

NoCharnce · 18/09/2023 12:11

So the government commission into how to memorialise the Covid pandemic has recommended the government implement “A UK-wide day of reflection should be established and held annually.”

Other recommendations include national memorials (10 sites already identified!), oral histories and museums plus additional funding for local authorities to set up their own memorials.

I can’t be the only one who thinks this is nuts and hope the government ignores the recommendations? I genuinely cannot believe people get paid to produce this crap.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
TrashedSofa · 28/09/2023 14:46

I agree a lot of people supported and continue to retrospectively support the initial lockdown, because of the unknown aspect. Even some people who oppose/d later restrictions. But surely part of that discussion must be about the length of the first lockdown too? Whether we lifted those emergency measures at the optimum time.

WhalePolo · 28/09/2023 13:27

@WestwardHo1 but maybe the reason it wasn’t that bad was because we had a lockdown. It’s impossible to know how we would have fared without one - and I’m applying that on a global level. Half of humanity were in lockdown. I don’t think you can really pick out Sweden and say “well they were ok” because you’d then need to apply their stance across the globe. And we know it wasn’t ‘ok’ in India or Brazil. I do completely agree that it should have been handled better, and we should look to see how other countries fared in terms of how we could handle a future pandemic better.
But when there is a new virus, causing hospitals to be on the verge of collapse, with no vaccine as a method of a control - I do think emergency measures and restrictions are needed.

Subsequent lockdowns, I can see the debate about their necessity. The first lockdown I think was necessary.

WomblingTree86 · 28/09/2023 13:17

WestwardHo1 · 28/09/2023 11:26

I think it might be quite a safe assumption mightn't it? Given that prior to 2020 you would pretty much never have seen someone out in the fresh air in a strong sea breeze wearing a blue surgical mask.

She may have been wearing it like that so she could pull it up easily before going on a bus or inside somewhere. It can be easier than taking it off completely and then having to store it in a pocket or handbag. They weren't as easily available prior to 2020 and many people hadn't experienced wearing them. Now they have, many people prefer wearing them in certain circumstances.

WestwardHo1 · 28/09/2023 11:27

The true extent of the illness wasn't known at that time, and there was no vaccine. It was, and still is, a key killer of the elderly and vulnerable. Schools need teachers and administrators, and they were sick too in large numbers.

Not in June 2020 they weren't.

WestwardHo1 · 28/09/2023 11:26

user1497207191 · 28/09/2023 10:51

You're making a huge assumption that she was wearing a mask as a measure against covid or similar respiratory disease. That's a big assumption. You don't know why she was wearing a mask, do you? She could have had her own reasons for wearing one for other reasons.

I think it might be quite a safe assumption mightn't it? Given that prior to 2020 you would pretty much never have seen someone out in the fresh air in a strong sea breeze wearing a blue surgical mask.

user1497207191 · 28/09/2023 10:53

SaltyOne · 28/09/2023 10:16

@WestwardHo1

But the point, I think, was that with Covid it wouldn't have been necessary for enormous swathes of elderly people to give their lives so that children could go to school. It wasn't the bubonic plague or the Spanish flu.

The school closures and the way they were handled (with the associated utter lack of safeguarding for children and young people) were appalling. Why did children not return to school during the summer term of 2020?

The true extent of the illness wasn't known at that time, and there was no vaccine. It was, and still is, a key killer of the elderly and vulnerable. Schools need teachers and administrators, and they were sick too in large numbers.

But did they really know a lot more about covid at the end of August when all kids went back to school, than they did in, say, June? I don't think so. In fact, covid infection rates were pretty low in June and were rising pretty steeply in August (after the stupidity of EOTHO). It's that kind of illogic thinking that people are calling out!

user1497207191 · 28/09/2023 10:51

WestwardHo1 · 27/09/2023 14:26

And while I'm here, today in town I saw a woman walking along the prom - outside in a F9 gale - wearing a mask over her mouth (her nose she left free to inhale the fresh sea air).

That is exactly the kind of thing people mean when they talk about a lack of logic and rationality. Yet according to some, this woman's morals are on a higher level that someone who concluded that such a thing would be pointless.

You're making a huge assumption that she was wearing a mask as a measure against covid or similar respiratory disease. That's a big assumption. You don't know why she was wearing a mask, do you? She could have had her own reasons for wearing one for other reasons.

TrashedSofa · 28/09/2023 10:22

In summer 2020? I thought the best info we had about sickness rates then is they were pretty low, especially as we'd been in lockdown so contacts had been significantly reduced. Is there data about school staff being too ill for schools to open at that time?

Intuitively I'd have thought that would've been more of an issue in September 2020 when they actually did fully open, rather than June and July. All the EOTHO stuff.

SaltyOne · 28/09/2023 10:16

@WestwardHo1

But the point, I think, was that with Covid it wouldn't have been necessary for enormous swathes of elderly people to give their lives so that children could go to school. It wasn't the bubonic plague or the Spanish flu.

The school closures and the way they were handled (with the associated utter lack of safeguarding for children and young people) were appalling. Why did children not return to school during the summer term of 2020?

The true extent of the illness wasn't known at that time, and there was no vaccine. It was, and still is, a key killer of the elderly and vulnerable. Schools need teachers and administrators, and they were sick too in large numbers.

SaltyOne · 28/09/2023 10:08

@WestwardHo1

Can you perhaps lose the scornful tone? Now that posters are debating civilly?

Oh, now you want to be civil? Ironic.

WestwardHo1 · 28/09/2023 09:42

WhalePolo · 28/09/2023 03:15

My Mum also said a similar thing. “I’d give my life so others could go to school etc”. I pointed out this was very noble. However if she got seriously ill, I’d expect her to have access to ambulance, hospital etc to ease her suffering. And if you’ve got a huge, huge, huge number of elderly “giving their life” for others - do you think they’d just pass away peacefully from Covid at home? Or would they be in pain, struggling to breath, and taking up space in a hospital which impacts all departments, availability of ambulances etc. So what’s the other option? Euthanise them? Can you see what dodgy territory this is? @WestwardHo1

But the point, I think, was that with Covid it wouldn't have been necessary for enormous swathes of elderly people to give their lives so that children could go to school. It wasn't the bubonic plague or the Spanish flu.

The school closures and the way they were handled (with the associated utter lack of safeguarding for children and young people) were appalling. Why did children not return to school during the summer term of 2020?

WestwardHo1 · 28/09/2023 09:34

SaltyOne · 28/09/2023 01:25

If this occurred, no, that's a bit silly.

Yes it did occur

But thanks for the cunning little hint that I'm lying 👍

EasternStandard · 28/09/2023 09:34

SaltyOne · 28/09/2023 09:22

@EasternStandard

Even worse because this is a parenting site and those posters managed to attack people enough to try to overrun all threads

Strange - I was about then, and I felt the exact opposite to be true. Those against any mitigation measures dominated the threads until board became unusable.

Probably depends which threads posters were on

I know for sure talking about exactly what is in that report meant utter abuse.

WestwardHo1 · 28/09/2023 09:33

SaltyOne · 28/09/2023 01:29

Ah yes, we heard these types of anecdotes frequently. "My mother is only 60 but would give her life so the childrenz could go to school again!"

Can you perhaps lose the scornful tone? Now that posters are debating civilly?

WestwardHo1 · 28/09/2023 09:31

WhalePolo · 27/09/2023 16:10

I agree with you there too @WestwardHo1 . About the trust - about how we’d cope with another pandemic. I’d say it’s important to extrapolate the science from the politics. I trust the science, and think the global comparison is important if the politicians here are behaving like idiots.

But, with respect, there was no consensus on "the science". Science isn't a finite answer or an ultimate truth - it's a series of questions. And they politicised this notion of "the science" and used it to control people. It was very very dubious

SaltyOne · 28/09/2023 09:22

@EasternStandard

Even worse because this is a parenting site and those posters managed to attack people enough to try to overrun all threads

Strange - I was about then, and I felt the exact opposite to be true. Those against any mitigation measures dominated the threads until board became unusable.

Ginmonkeyagain · 28/09/2023 07:30

It can both be true that lockdown was needed and it was applied an insane and damaging way that privileged certain sections of society over others.

EasternStandard · 28/09/2023 06:57

1dayatatime · 27/09/2023 17:11

The loss of learning, freedom and hope to children during the Covid-19 pandemic could have been prevented:

www.savethechildren.org.uk/news/media-centre/press-releases/harm-to-children-in-covid-lockdown-preventable-new-report-conclu

Even worse this was pointed out at the time, but was dismissed as anti vaxx or Covid denier or children will bounce back or children are disease vectors etc etc.

Well that’s thorough and damning and exactly what some of us were saying at the time.

These two are to be held as true in image from report

And this put in place

  • For the UK government to appoint a Cabinet Minister for Children and Young People, and make sure in times of crisis that they are involved in key decisions, so children’s interests are considered
  • Pass a new law to make schools essential infrastructure so MPs have more oversight before schools can be closed

All things I argued for and got insane amounts of harassment and abuse over

Even worse because this is a parenting site and those posters managed to attack people enough to try to overrun all threads

(Covid) To think these recommendations are bonkers?
WhalePolo · 28/09/2023 03:15

My Mum also said a similar thing. “I’d give my life so others could go to school etc”. I pointed out this was very noble. However if she got seriously ill, I’d expect her to have access to ambulance, hospital etc to ease her suffering. And if you’ve got a huge, huge, huge number of elderly “giving their life” for others - do you think they’d just pass away peacefully from Covid at home? Or would they be in pain, struggling to breath, and taking up space in a hospital which impacts all departments, availability of ambulances etc. So what’s the other option? Euthanise them? Can you see what dodgy territory this is? @WestwardHo1

SaltyOne · 28/09/2023 01:29

WestwardHo1 · 27/09/2023 14:30

It's also by no means certain that these frail elderly people would all have died in huge numbers. My mum was mid 70s and has a chronic lung condition. She caught Covid and though felt grotty for a while (as did I when I got it the first time), she was back to normal fairly quickly. She was horrified at lockdowns and what they were doing to society, to her children's livelihoods and her grandchildren's wellbeing. She was scornful of the idea that it was to "protect" her.

But that's just a personal anecdote.

Ah yes, we heard these types of anecdotes frequently. "My mother is only 60 but would give her life so the childrenz could go to school again!"

SaltyOne · 28/09/2023 01:25

WestwardHo1 · 27/09/2023 14:26

And while I'm here, today in town I saw a woman walking along the prom - outside in a F9 gale - wearing a mask over her mouth (her nose she left free to inhale the fresh sea air).

That is exactly the kind of thing people mean when they talk about a lack of logic and rationality. Yet according to some, this woman's morals are on a higher level that someone who concluded that such a thing would be pointless.

If this occurred, no, that's a bit silly.

SaltyOne · 28/09/2023 01:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Again, this is a confusing post. You're confusing me in part with another poster. I never "wanged on about how SH tenants are less likely to follow restrictions". I said "not relevant" about SH as at that point in the thread, it wasn't. If you are going to be sweary and abusive, at least get the right person.

SaltyOne · 28/09/2023 01:15

JenniferBooth · 27/09/2023 14:42

@WestwardHo1 I know lockdown as such couldnt have happened in the 80s when i was at school cos no internet but if something similar had happened then and they had closed the schools i likely wouldnt have gone back I was badly bullied at school and would have jumped at the chance to get away from that. I wonder how many of those kids have experienced the same

Actually, it could have. Teachers mail lesson plans and assignments; kids mail completed assignments back. I did my entire final year of school in the 1980s this way. I also was a bullied child through many years of school, and though this wasn't ideal, it worked out well. I even did exams this way.

WomblingTree86 · 27/09/2023 17:55

1dayatatime · 27/09/2023 15:47

@WomblingTree86

Have you provided the evidence or data either way showing other countries are in the same boat or is it just your perception that they are?

++++

Without knowing which country you are referring to it is difficult to provide the relevant data.

However here is a Lancet article referring to the increase in cancer deaths in Australia as a result of missed diagnosis:

www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpub/article/PIIS2468-2667(22)00111-6/fulltext

A similar article in relation to the US:

www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-covid-cancer-effect/

The Australian article is not an actual study looking at the incidence. It is referring to a exploratory analysis (a statistical modelling study) of the potential effect of treatment delays during the COVID-19 pandemic. It’s not looking retrospectively at actually what happened or talking about the effects of lockdown.. The US paper is mainly talking about the fact that people were scared to go in for screening. Perhaps they would have been even more scared if there wasn't a lockdown and COVID rates were deaths even higher. Neither state that there has been a long term impact on screening/healthcare and neither suggest this healthcare would have been fine without lockdown.

WhalePolo · 27/09/2023 17:37

That report you’ve linked is not saying ‘no lockdown at all in a pandemic” it’s saying it could have been done better. I agree.

”
· The prioritisation of venues like pubs reopening before schools.
· The 1:1 rule, where adults were allowed to meet a friend outside. Younger children that would have needed supervising were not able to do the same.
· Grassroots sports clubs and other places for children’s activity remained closed while pubs and restaurants re-opened.”

Swipe left for the next trending thread