Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(Covid) To think these recommendations are bonkers?

659 replies

NoCharnce · 18/09/2023 12:11

So the government commission into how to memorialise the Covid pandemic has recommended the government implement “A UK-wide day of reflection should be established and held annually.”

Other recommendations include national memorials (10 sites already identified!), oral histories and museums plus additional funding for local authorities to set up their own memorials.

I can’t be the only one who thinks this is nuts and hope the government ignores the recommendations? I genuinely cannot believe people get paid to produce this crap.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
JerryLovesMargo · 02/10/2023 17:02

WhalePolo · 02/10/2023 16:18

@JerryLovesMargo

I hope - never again - that a CEV very close to me will not be viewed as an unworthy, dispensable, inconvenient person - so that others can have their freedom of choice and wealth.

I hope that, too, as a CEV person who felt that way all through the pandemic.

The feelings of being inconvenient and dispensable were compounded by being unable to wear a mask, and the way I was treated because of that.

When people are spitting at, and wishing death upon, a person who is visibly disabled, it's clear that we've come to a pretty awful pass.

JenniferBooth · 02/10/2023 16:28

@WhalePolo which is exactly what the disability benefits cuts do.

WhalePolo · 02/10/2023 16:18

@JerryLovesMargo

I hope - never again - that a CEV very close to me will not be viewed as an unworthy, dispensable, inconvenient person - so that others can have their freedom of choice and wealth.

JenniferBooth · 02/10/2023 16:03

Totally @JerryLovesMargo And the comments coming out of the Conservative Party conference now show (as i and others predicted) that its back to the default setting now that they have finished using disabled people as a tool to emotionally blackmail others to follow restrictions. Now its back to cutting their benefits!!

JerryLovesMargo · 02/10/2023 15:56

Sparklecats · 02/10/2023 14:23

Again - start a thread about masks if you want, all this ranting completely detracts from the thread topic.

On the contrary. This thread is about proposals for commemorating aspects of the pandemic. Some of the comments here are a perfect reminder of how some people lost all empathy, understanding and humanity in 2020/21.

Do an AS in the covid topic, dates between say July 2020 and March 2021, using 'mask exempt' as your keywords. See for yourself some of the awful things people were saying to the parents of autistic children, rape and DV survivors, people with TN... I've just done precisely that on the back of this thread and I'm in tears at some of it. Despicable.

Let's hope we never, ever again tell people they must not go to work, get on a bus, go to A&E, buy food, because they have a health condition or disability. Or call them whiners, selfish, 'vectors', filthy, reckless...

WhalePolo · 02/10/2023 15:15

I agree with that @sparklecats - but no restrictions/collapsing health system I think WOULD segregate society into the healthy/unhealthy - and cause an even bigger divide between the rich and the poor, countries with better resourced hospitals becoming wealthier - and those with poor health care systems becoming poorer.

I think the arguments here about lanyards, or social housing - while important - are not addressing full global scale of the issue for ALL vulnerable people. There were a great many people who were worrying about staying alive as well as the impact of wearing a mask on their welfare, the impact of lockdown on their livelihoods. You can’t just consider the impact on one sector of society - you have consider all sectors around the globe and the amount of harm caused by restrictions or no restrictions.

Everanewbie · 02/10/2023 14:33

@Sparklecats I agree. New suggestion. Something along the lines of bonfire night with a bit of xmas thrown in where we create a bonfire with a 'guy' wearing one of those stupid cloth facemasks like that 'NHS Doctor' on facebook made a killing from, and burn it whilst ritually bashing pots and pans. Then, as is tradition, we dine on a scotch egg and watch reruns of the 5pm doomfest.

Sparklecats · 02/10/2023 14:23

Again - start a thread about masks if you want, all this ranting completely detracts from the thread topic.

Sparklecats · 02/10/2023 14:19

JenniferBooth · 02/10/2023 13:52

And look at the date. That was before they were even mandatory.

Strange how there wasnt such a pressure for parents to prove their childrens age exemption as ive mentioned above. Imagine the AIBU at the time if it had been recommended that parents carry their kids birth certificates around,

Aside from anything else - children clear the virus faster, have mild symptoms and have lower viral load so they are less of a threat, unless it’s someone like a caregiver where they have repeated close contact thus transmitting multiple doses.

An adult, particularly if they are immunocompromised, will be more likely to transmit a dose that would lead to clinical infection in others.

I had a friend who wore a sunflower lanyard, this was accepted, no issues.

Sparklecats · 02/10/2023 14:13

WhalePolo · 02/10/2023 05:40

Hmmm. @1dayatatime I don’t like “needs of the old trumped the needs of the young.” I would say the needs of those requiring hospital care (and that applies not only to Covid patients) - ‘trumped’ the needs of those who were healthy. I would say a functioning hospital for any person who needed it was the priority. If you reverse your sentiment, you’re advocating a situation where the needs of the ‘fit’ outweigh the needs of the ‘unfit’. Survival of the fittest. This is what riles me the most. I do not want an emergency situation to push a society to think that the ‘unfit’ are dispensable.

Actually @WhalePolo @1dayatatime

The priority was not the sick or the vulnerable but protecting NHS capacity to function, and preventing complete collapse of the healthcare system.

You’re talking everything from vaccinations for babies, maternity care, flu shots for kids, the whole heap gone or severely compromised.

And they wanted to prevent an escalation of cases that would lead to economic collapse.

Whenever you have a healthcare caseload incredibly high and it’s spreading fast you’re likely dealing with a more dangerous variant so there’s that too.

Honestly, as far as I see it the whole exercise was preservation of infrastructure for societal functioning.

So all this tit for tat, some people over others theory is bollocks. The decisions were made for the benefit of all long term.

JenniferBooth · 02/10/2023 13:52

And look at the date. That was before they were even mandatory.

Strange how there wasnt such a pressure for parents to prove their childrens age exemption as ive mentioned above. Imagine the AIBU at the time if it had been recommended that parents carry their kids birth certificates around,

JenniferBooth · 02/10/2023 13:49

HeIenaDove · 22/07/2020 02:06

46 attacks on disabled people already for not wearing masks

From Twitter................video and thread.

twitter.com/transportforall/status/1285615607744995329?s=20
Add messageThanks
Save
Share

https://twitter.com/transportforall/status/1285615607744995329?s=20

WhalePolo · 02/10/2023 13:44

There would have been a proportion of people who were caused considerable distress by wearing a face mask, but I think there would have been a far greater proportion of people who were saved from death or from becoming seriously ill by having a mask mandate. So overall I think - in terms of overall harm - more harm would have been caused by not having a mask mandate than by having one.

JenniferBooth · 02/10/2023 13:05

Ooh i remember this point being made.

I may have missed it but has there been a demand for children to carry their birth certificates when they are in shops? Exemption applies to children under 11 - some children look young for their age, some look older. Presumably those who favour a rigorous burden of proof being placed on those with medical exemption feel just as strongly about age exemption and would want to apply the same conditions. If not, I wonder why

JenniferBooth · 02/10/2023 12:48

But wasn't it the Government that asked you to show your exemption status, not "people" in general

It was as @JerryLovesMargo has said. I find the rewriting of history and gaslighting pretty fucking sinister.

JerryLovesMargo · 02/10/2023 10:38

SaltyOne · 02/10/2023 09:10

@JerryLovesMargo

We had no choice but to print off exemption badges or buy them from eBay, because people demanded we wore something to 'prove' out exemption (when as you point out, anyone could do so).

Jerry, I'm sorry you had a bad time. But wasn't it the Government that asked you to show your exemption status, not "people" in general? And if you had a genuine reason for exemption, as it sounds like you did, why was there no choice but to print out your badge or buy from eBay? You shouldn't have needed to do that.

I'm not sure who you are talking about here - yourself, or the body of non-maskers in general?

The badges/lanyards weren't mandatory. The government advice was that you could choose to wear one if you wished, but it was up to you. The government advice was also that nobody could ask you for proof of exemption, or deny you admittance to shops etc for being exempt.

There was no 'proof' available - GPs/HCPs were not providing letters of exemption and there was no official lanyard or badge. It did have to be taken on trust. I carried the letter with my diagnosis from years ago but on the couple of occasions I tried to show it to 'prove' my exemption, the staff at the venue and supermarket I was trying to access wouldn't accept it. One said he didn't know what trigeminal neuralgia was, it could be anything - and he had no reason to know about a fairly rare neurological condition, or its symptoms.

To be clear: there was no official exemption certificate/lanyard and many venues, shops etc made up their own rules, which didn't tally with the government rules/advice whatsoever. And because lanyards and badges were freely available to all, they were effectively pointless and proved nothing, and consequently many people didn't believe those who were genuinely exempt were exempt at all.

SaltyOne · 02/10/2023 09:10

@JerryLovesMargo

We had no choice but to print off exemption badges or buy them from eBay, because people demanded we wore something to 'prove' out exemption (when as you point out, anyone could do so).

Jerry, I'm sorry you had a bad time. But wasn't it the Government that asked you to show your exemption status, not "people" in general? And if you had a genuine reason for exemption, as it sounds like you did, why was there no choice but to print out your badge or buy from eBay? You shouldn't have needed to do that.

I'm not sure who you are talking about here - yourself, or the body of non-maskers in general?

WhalePolo · 02/10/2023 07:49

The other issue is @1dayatatime is that a pandemic needs a global response. Would your ‘no lockdown’ scenario apply to every country worldwide? Or just certain countries that have perhaps better healthcare systems and can cope with a crisis? In which case, the countries that can’t cope would be forced to lockdown causing huge global inequality. The poor would get poorer and the rich would get richer.

WhalePolo · 02/10/2023 05:40

Hmmm. @1dayatatime I don’t like “needs of the old trumped the needs of the young.” I would say the needs of those requiring hospital care (and that applies not only to Covid patients) - ‘trumped’ the needs of those who were healthy. I would say a functioning hospital for any person who needed it was the priority. If you reverse your sentiment, you’re advocating a situation where the needs of the ‘fit’ outweigh the needs of the ‘unfit’. Survival of the fittest. This is what riles me the most. I do not want an emergency situation to push a society to think that the ‘unfit’ are dispensable.

SaltyOne · 02/10/2023 01:17

@1dayatatime

Sadly it was a horrible divisive time, a time of top trumps of vulnerability where my vulnerability outranks yours, where neighbours informed on each other stasi style, where the needs of the old trumped the needs of the young.

The second part of your statement was unnecessary and only adds to the division you suggest you're sad about.

1dayatatime · 01/10/2023 17:27

@JerryLovesMargo
@SaltyOne

Sadly it was a horrible divisive time, a time of top trumps of vulnerability where my vulnerability outranks yours, where neighbours informed on each other stasi style, where the needs of the old trumped the needs of the young.

In answer to the OP original post I would rather not have a commemorative event and instead prefer to try and forget about the whole thing and pretend it never happened.

JerryLovesMargo · 01/10/2023 14:25

SaltyOne · 25/09/2023 13:25

I doubt jealousy was a motive, if the incident happened at all. (Can a person spit through a mask?)

Yes, it happened. He pulled his mask down to spit at me. Obviously.

And no, the irony was not lost on me - just as it wasn't lost on me when people pulled their masks down to theatrically cough next to me or shout at me.

For the record, I was always scrupulous wrt SD, went to shops at the quietest times and as infrequently as possible, used public transport as rarely as I could get away with, and so on. I hated every second of not being able to wear a mask primarily because of the risk I perceived myself to be to others. But also because I'm immunosuppressed and my risk was also increased, and also because I received abuse of some sort almost every time I went anywhere.

It was an awful, awful time and I ended up on antidepressants and self harming. I promise you, I wanted to wear a mask so much. But when I tried to, it resulted in a TN attack during which I lost consciousness the pain was so terrible. I wet myself. I couldn't go through that again, I had absolutely no choice.

JerryLovesMargo · 01/10/2023 14:17

SaltyOne · 25/09/2023 01:36

@JerryLovesMargo

This is exactly the sort of thing those of us who were exempt had to put up with.
I lost count of the times I was called a killer/murderer/disease vector/thick.
By people who claimed to care about the vulnerable, while completely missing the point that many who were exempt were so due to vulnerability/disability.

What annoyed me, though, was how those who apparently couldn't wear a mask (and plenty printed off sunflower lanyards from the internet) weaponised the word 'vulnerable'. Suddenly, they were vulnerable because they weren't wearing a mask - not particularly to the virus, but to public opinion - and bizarrely, the actual vulnerable felt more pushed into isolation.

Of course, this doesn't apply to everyone unable to wear a mask, but there certainly was (and is) a vocal and aggressive element in a particular segment of those who don't wear masks for some reason.

There was no 'apparently' about it for those of us who couldn't wear masks, I assure you.

We had no choice but to print off exemption badges or buy them from eBay, because people demanded we wore something to 'prove' out exemption (when as you point out, anyone could do so).

Many of us live with health conditions which make us vulnerable to covid - for example, in addition to my neurological condition which made me unable to wear a mask, I'm immunosuppressed thanks to the medication I take for an autoimmune disease. Lots of people who couldn't wear masks were in a similar position. Being unable to wear a mask made everything even more fraught and worrying for people like me.

I never, ever saw an exempt person being aggressive. I was the victim of aggression however, as were many, many others who were unable to wear masks.

Thank goodness it's all in the past now.