Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(Covid) To think these recommendations are bonkers?

659 replies

NoCharnce · 18/09/2023 12:11

So the government commission into how to memorialise the Covid pandemic has recommended the government implement “A UK-wide day of reflection should be established and held annually.”

Other recommendations include national memorials (10 sites already identified!), oral histories and museums plus additional funding for local authorities to set up their own memorials.

I can’t be the only one who thinks this is nuts and hope the government ignores the recommendations? I genuinely cannot believe people get paid to produce this crap.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
Calistano · 18/09/2023 16:07

GoryBory · 18/09/2023 16:04

It’s mind boggling that some people genuinely think they know better than all of the doctors, scientists, vaccine creators and disease specialists.

They’re completely delusional.

I can guarantee that most of these people didn’t pass their GCSEs.

OK gory explain how a vaccine which includes one singular spike protein is more efficient than a clever heuristic immune system which we don't fully understand anyway.?

Sparklecats · 18/09/2023 16:07

DayKay · 18/09/2023 15:49

I'd still like to understand how covid is such a special case that it's the only time that having the virus itself, is less protection than a very limited vaccine.

Sometimes, I thought I was going mad because nobody seemed to question any of the rules. Even those who detested the Tories didn't question their stupid rules (that tories themselves were probably laughing at)

Two things

Firstly, getting the virus itself in an unregulated fashion when it is relatively unknown and there is limited hospital capacity/therapeutics is not a sensible thing to do.

You might get a whopping great dose of it and end up hospitalised.

The vaccine is a measured amount of something that can’t cause you to develop clinical infection.

It seeks to prevent you from becoming seriously ill should you contract infection, not to have sterilising immunity.

Secondly, getting the virus naturally you may get a mild dose not enough to develop any sort of long standing immunity. Again development of clinical infection is dependent on factors relating to the host (sex, health etc), environment (density of people with covid, temperature etc) and virus (which variant)…. So it’s all very unregulated.

The vaccine gives some certainty ie X effective, X certainty the immunity will last for X time.

Which is why it’s safer and more sensible to have the vaccine. Not to mention put a block to further waves and protect others in a coordinated fashion.

JenniferBooth · 18/09/2023 16:05

@JerryLovesMargo i was told to cover my face in hibiscrub to enable me to wear a mask

And the fact you were SPAT AT proves the disgusting people who did that did not care about Covid. They did it because they were pissed that you had an exemption and they didnt Their thinking was "i have to wear a mask so why shouldnt you"

TrashedSofa · 18/09/2023 16:04

Sparklecats · 18/09/2023 15:54

@TrashedSofa most of the people on this thread are covid non-believers, anti-vaxxers and the like that are not representative of the majority of the population.

These recommendations will have been based on public consultation via the inquiry and I really can’t see anything that would cost much if anything, more money generating and the final recommendation is so important to have scientists more closely aligned to policy makers.

For one thing, if Jeremy Hunt hadn’t disregarded pandemic preparedness recommendations when health minister then we would have had PPE!!

I didn't say anything about costings, although I do note that the commission's recommendations aren't for things that people will have to pay to do. And rightly so. As such, it's not immediately obvious how their proposals are going to be money generating.

But ultimately, anyone who supports a day of reflection or similar is going to have to accept that it's a divisive subject. It will cause anger, piss taking, trauma exacerbation and lots of other bad things. If you still want it regardless, that's your call.

GoryBory · 18/09/2023 16:04

DyslexicPoster · 18/09/2023 15:49

Maybe they invest the money into educating children on Biology so the next generation don't get sucked into non scientific Bullshit. Some basic grasps of what a virus is, what kills them off, how they jump species barriers, how they spread etc. The amount of people spouting utter BS on Socail media with things I knew wasn't true from GCSE biology boiled my piss as the MN saying goes.

It’s mind boggling that some people genuinely think they know better than all of the doctors, scientists, vaccine creators and disease specialists.

They’re completely delusional.

I can guarantee that most of these people didn’t pass their GCSEs.

Goodbyetoauntie · 18/09/2023 16:01

It's an episode of recent history I'd rather forget TBH. I'd not want to see a fucking memorial or museum or any kind of commemorative bollocks (personally). Crack on and nove on I say the best memorial you can have is continuing life.

GoryBory · 18/09/2023 15:59

JerryLovesMargo · 18/09/2023 15:13

Being appalled at rules which made people say goodbye to loved ones via Facetime, or where grieving children couldn't comfort their bereaved surviving parent at funerals, or where mask exempt people were physically attacked, or those living with DV were locked in with their abuser, or that vulnerable people living alone could not access support but our government saw fit to party doesn't make you a 'tin hat wearer' or 'not very bright'.

Of course some of the rules were awful but this is a contagious disease.

In hindsight there should have been much more support in place for vulnerable people but this would have meant other people having to put themselves and their families at risk.

You’re acting like the government was wrong to put sanctions in place but are completely ignoring all of the other people involved.
In care homes for example, yes people died and it was awful but if they allowed visitors then that would be an extra 100 odd people visiting a week which wouldn’t have been fair on the workers who if they got sick they wouldn’t have been able to work (affecting the patients) and they could have passed it to their own families.

You are angry at a government (who I agree are twats and should have received a punishment for some of their behaviour) but we’re not the only country who put these rules in place.
In fact we are very fortunate in this country as some countries had way stricter rules than we did.

Calistano · 18/09/2023 15:57

DyslexicPoster · 18/09/2023 15:49

Maybe they invest the money into educating children on Biology so the next generation don't get sucked into non scientific Bullshit. Some basic grasps of what a virus is, what kills them off, how they jump species barriers, how they spread etc. The amount of people spouting utter BS on Socail media with things I knew wasn't true from GCSE biology boiled my piss as the MN saying goes.

Educate us all, what are we missing oh great bearer of truth.

Lizzypet · 18/09/2023 15:57

DayKay · 18/09/2023 15:49

I'd still like to understand how covid is such a special case that it's the only time that having the virus itself, is less protection than a very limited vaccine.

Sometimes, I thought I was going mad because nobody seemed to question any of the rules. Even those who detested the Tories didn't question their stupid rules (that tories themselves were probably laughing at)

Yes! Govt were absolutely falling over themselves to stress that the immunity from the vaccine was way superior to that from being infected. This was surely before there had been time to gather evidence either way.

Sparklecats · 18/09/2023 15:57

Ginmonkeyagain · 18/09/2023 15:54

Well that article is bollocks - it is estimated that 100,000 people died in the Great Plague alone (of course it is hard to know as they weren't really keeping meticulous records). Of course it is also a matter of scale in 1665 that was 1/5 of London's population.

Edited

Ok so what should we do disregard all the people that died and the trauma?? If they’re so insignificant then would you like to offer up some of your family members for the next wave? No? Thought not.

Honestly people are so dim.

These recommendations won’t cost much if anything and it remembers the dead, funnels money towards preventing similar. End of.

Calistano · 18/09/2023 15:55

DayKay · 18/09/2023 15:49

I'd still like to understand how covid is such a special case that it's the only time that having the virus itself, is less protection than a very limited vaccine.

Sometimes, I thought I was going mad because nobody seemed to question any of the rules. Even those who detested the Tories didn't question their stupid rules (that tories themselves were probably laughing at)

Hard agree, apparently natural immunity is not a thing anymore. It's just pure coincidence I didn't get chicken pox for the second time when my kids came down with it. Surely the common cold can't be vaccinated against because there are many viruses that cause it? But you can get the same strain of covid again and again, makes sense. I just don't believe all these people who say they had it 7 times.

That president who tested a papaya which came back positive mysteriously died. Hmm.

Sparklecats · 18/09/2023 15:54

TrashedSofa · 18/09/2023 15:45

The fact that it continues to be such a traumatic issue is one of the reasons why the OP is right about the proposals not being a great idea.

For one thing, a memorial day potentially functions as a giant, gaping wound for many of those who lost people for other reasons, in conditions which were made worse or sometimes even caused by restrictions. It simply wouldn't be felt as a special day or something positive by everyone, and even the few pages of this thread makes it clear that it would be the trigger for lots and lots of arguments.

I think keeping the existing memorial wall would be a good thing though.

@TrashedSofa most of the people on this thread are covid non-believers, anti-vaxxers and the like that are not representative of the majority of the population.

These recommendations will have been based on public consultation via the inquiry and I really can’t see anything that would cost much if anything, more money generating and the final recommendation is so important to have scientists more closely aligned to policy makers.

For one thing, if Jeremy Hunt hadn’t disregarded pandemic preparedness recommendations when health minister then we would have had PPE!!

Ginmonkeyagain · 18/09/2023 15:54

Well that article is bollocks - it is estimated that 100,000 people died in the Great Plague alone (of course it is hard to know as they weren't really keeping meticulous records). Of course it is also a matter of scale in 1665 that was 1/5 of London's population.

Sparklecats · 18/09/2023 15:49

JerryLovesMargo · 18/09/2023 15:44

it was a warlike experience

I believe that some restrictions prior to vaccines being introduced were necessary and I agree that the whole thing was incredibly traumatic (I was on antidepressants for the first time in years around Christmas 2020, and am still trying to overcome a sort of agoraphobia which kicked in then). However I find comments like this incredibly offensive and ignorant.

I'm sure those currently living in war torn countries like Ukraine would agree that while traumatic for many, lockdown was not equal to bombs falling on you as you sleep, facing an occupying force, your country's infrastructure being wiped out and so on.

@JerryLovesMargo

Covid led to massive restrictions in our freedoms and killed an enormous amount of people. Huge. If that isn’t warlike I don’t know what is.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/covid-deaths-uk-latest-plague-aids-war-b1790890.html

UK Covid deaths now greater than Great Plague, Aids pandemic and every terror attack and war since 1945

Latest milestone is also more than double the death toll from the Blitz during Second World War

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/covid-deaths-uk-latest-plague-aids-war-b1790890.html

DyslexicPoster · 18/09/2023 15:49

Maybe they invest the money into educating children on Biology so the next generation don't get sucked into non scientific Bullshit. Some basic grasps of what a virus is, what kills them off, how they jump species barriers, how they spread etc. The amount of people spouting utter BS on Socail media with things I knew wasn't true from GCSE biology boiled my piss as the MN saying goes.

DayKay · 18/09/2023 15:49

Calistano · 18/09/2023 14:46

Blimey jerry, much love, sounds like an awful time. Oh don't forget changing the very definition of vaccines in dictionaries.

I'd still like to understand how covid is such a special case that it's the only time that having the virus itself, is less protection than a very limited vaccine.

Sometimes, I thought I was going mad because nobody seemed to question any of the rules. Even those who detested the Tories didn't question their stupid rules (that tories themselves were probably laughing at)

Calistano · 18/09/2023 15:48

JerryLovesMargo · 18/09/2023 15:45

@Calistano u ok hun?

Fine thanks, still covid free, cope and seethe.

JerryLovesMargo · 18/09/2023 15:45

@Calistano u ok hun?

TrashedSofa · 18/09/2023 15:45

Sparklecats · 18/09/2023 15:32

Finding it a bit disturbing that everyone is making fun of this…

Lot my best friend (30s), several relatives, friends lost their parents. Many people still very disabled by it (and many more are going to die or become disabled). People lost their livelihoods and homes.

It was all really traumatic.

Personally I like the idea of having a memorial garden to go to to remember loved ones and a special day for them. Least we could do really, it was a warlike experience.

The fact that it continues to be such a traumatic issue is one of the reasons why the OP is right about the proposals not being a great idea.

For one thing, a memorial day potentially functions as a giant, gaping wound for many of those who lost people for other reasons, in conditions which were made worse or sometimes even caused by restrictions. It simply wouldn't be felt as a special day or something positive by everyone, and even the few pages of this thread makes it clear that it would be the trigger for lots and lots of arguments.

I think keeping the existing memorial wall would be a good thing though.

JerryLovesMargo · 18/09/2023 15:44

it was a warlike experience

I believe that some restrictions prior to vaccines being introduced were necessary and I agree that the whole thing was incredibly traumatic (I was on antidepressants for the first time in years around Christmas 2020, and am still trying to overcome a sort of agoraphobia which kicked in then). However I find comments like this incredibly offensive and ignorant.

I'm sure those currently living in war torn countries like Ukraine would agree that while traumatic for many, lockdown was not equal to bombs falling on you as you sleep, facing an occupying force, your country's infrastructure being wiped out and so on.

Sparklecats · 18/09/2023 15:42

@Everanewbie I agree… except it isn’t going to cost much to repurpose existing green spaces and a chargeable museum would have good return within a short space of time, which would then fund R&D and pandemic preparedness which is extremely vital to all of our health and well-being.

Everanewbie · 18/09/2023 15:39

If there is any money going spare it should go to services for children that have stunted mental development due to not being able to go to school, nursery, and sensory classes. Maybe also to various small business owners with their businesses killed off by these ridiculous restrictions. After that, deal with alcoholism and obesity. Then spend as much money on informing people that crappy bits of cloth over your mouth does naff all as they spent on those "tell this person looking miserable on a respiratory that you never bend the rules" posters.

Sparklecats · 18/09/2023 15:39

Also, you do realise a big role for all of this aside from providing memorial for the dead.

Is to channel funds to research and development and forward pandemic preparedness… ie fund research into it and educate the public on covid/make sure they don’t forget so that they are easier to manage when the next pandemic comes (matter of years really).

Calistano · 18/09/2023 15:35

Nobody seems to care about anything anymore, everyone accepts being spied on constantly by phones and alexa, that was a conspiracy theory at one point. People were overjoyed to be confined to 4 walls because of a coronavirus as long as they were paid. There might be a bit of consternation when they ban flights for proles, people who lap it up deserve it. The earth is heating up so let's kill ourselves, yay.

So much malthusian programming and discontent. Ever noticed how many kids the "elite" have, musk has about 10 according to Google.