Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(Covid) To think these recommendations are bonkers?

659 replies

NoCharnce · 18/09/2023 12:11

So the government commission into how to memorialise the Covid pandemic has recommended the government implement “A UK-wide day of reflection should be established and held annually.”

Other recommendations include national memorials (10 sites already identified!), oral histories and museums plus additional funding for local authorities to set up their own memorials.

I can’t be the only one who thinks this is nuts and hope the government ignores the recommendations? I genuinely cannot believe people get paid to produce this crap.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
Sparklecats · 18/09/2023 16:40

Everanewbie · 18/09/2023 16:17

@Sparklecats This is the problem. I actually received an award for my voluntary work in delivering the COVID vaccine, and having had COVID 3 times, I do not deny its existence. I don't think Johnson et al were capable of some big conspiracy. What I do disagree with is the response, the manipulation, the panic, the restrictions based on public opinion after being scared half to death, the reliance on one set of scientists and ignoring incredibly respected virologists that disagreed with measures.

It was a novel nasty virus that unfortunately killed some, and hastened the death of many more that were already seriously ill. But we burnt down the house in an attempt to kill the wasp. The wasp stung us anyway but now we haven't got a house and have third degree burns to go with our wasp sting. My museum will have the theme of how group think and panic can cause governments and populations to follow illogical rules, and provide a warning to future generations to keep calm and act proportionately.

@Everanewbie WHO has a list of priority diseases based on their potential to cause a public health emergency and the absence of efficacious medical countermeasures. Accordingly there is an urgent need for accelerated research and development so they have the R&D blueprint. The potential for disease X was known about… and of course there is still potential for another disease X or several….

There are a huge number of government depts across the world, NGOs, Universities but there is a lack of coordinated action and firm pandemic preparedness/planning.

Politics is too far removed from the scientific community and there needs to be more cohesion and as you rightly pointed out diversification/less bias of expertise.

Covid exposed these weaknesses and I hope examining what happened that response to future disease outbreaks is more robust.

What I will venture to say is that peoples noncompliance and behaviour in response to a disease that could have evolved to kill 20% was terrifying… we were in such a precarious situation and the virus had free reign and an enormous amount of hosts to evolve in… we were incredibly lucky that it didn’t get worse. The reprobate behaviour of people failing to comply with rules made me wish for mandatory vaccination and tough punishments. We had friends abroad and their rules were much tougher, but they complied and had hardly any outbreaks. By contrast a lot of the U.K. behaved like delinquent teens and didn’t want to work as a team to defeat the virus.

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 18/09/2023 16:39

A what about a memorial of elderly parents in care homes calling their kids telling them they were desperate to see their only grandchild and not understanding why they couldn't only to die a few days later 😢

Calistano · 18/09/2023 16:38

Certainly not over the trauma. I'm angry with a capital fucking A. Twat bags.

TrashedSofa · 18/09/2023 16:36

DoorStopper · 18/09/2023 16:34

Don't forget to warn visitors on entry that they can't come into the museum unless jabbed.
Just like they told healthcare workers that they would be sacked if they didn't have the jab.
Same with those who had booked holidays prior to the pandemic. The have a jab and you can go on your holiday lie.
I think the memorial should be set in a hotel where you have to stay for ten days trapped in a room with shit food.
All for the admission price of around £1800. However, a free pan will be provided for you to bang at 20.00 on a Thursday.

With the possibility of sexual harassment from security for female guests too, of course. Essential part of the experience!

I honestly don't know what they were thinking with that. It was so obvious that if you have women stuck on their own and men in positions of power over them, the outcome is going to be some of those men trying to take advantage of it.

JerryLovesMargo · 18/09/2023 16:35

Well isn't it nice to see that the nasty dementors v anti dementors/anti vax preposterousness/name-calling bollocks so prevalent on here during the pandemic hasn't gone away. One mention of the C word and you're all off.

Meanwhile in the real world most people understood that there was a need for some restrictions, but that those restrictions had awful knock-on effects for millions. That vaccines weren't perfect (no vaccine is) but once they had been rolled out the death rate dropped from thousands a day to a few hundred a week.

But on MN you are, and always were, either a bedwetting sheep terrified of their own shadow (if you thought maybe parties weren't a great idea at Christmas 2020 or have had all your jabs) or a tin foil hat wearing conspiracy theorist (if your daily walk lasted longer than an hour or you bought hairdye with your weekly shop).

What this shows more than anything, I guess, is that many people are absolutely not over the trauma of it all.

DoorStopper · 18/09/2023 16:34

Don't forget to warn visitors on entry that they can't come into the museum unless jabbed.
Just like they told healthcare workers that they would be sacked if they didn't have the jab.
Same with those who had booked holidays prior to the pandemic. The have a jab and you can go on your holiday lie.
I think the memorial should be set in a hotel where you have to stay for ten days trapped in a room with shit food.
All for the admission price of around £1800. However, a free pan will be provided for you to bang at 20.00 on a Thursday.

Ginmonkeyagain · 18/09/2023 16:31

Both of those things were true - the massive rate of infant mortality skewed the average age of death AND fewer people reached old age. However it is wrong to say loads of people were failing to make it to middle age.

We can see that from the Roman Republic where they had age qualifications for various political offices and you were not allowed to stand to be Consul (the highest office) until you were 43, whch shows that 43 was seen as age not only that many people would reach but seen as an age when the average man was physically and intellectually up to running for highest political office.

Calistano · 18/09/2023 16:30

GoryBory · 18/09/2023 16:27

You’re either a child or just fucking delusional.

So you’re saying people didn’t have lower life expectancies in the past (even though this is fact) but that childhood diseases also skewed the average, even though you’ve just said that there is no need for vaccines 🤦‍♀️

So not only do you think you know more than all of the doctors and scientists, you now think you know better than all of the historians, archeologists and anthropologists.

You are delusional if you think you know better than everyone else.
You are not special.

Whatever mate, believe most people died at 20 in the past if you want. I mean it's only contradicted by most of recorded history.

TrashedSofa · 18/09/2023 16:29

Sparklecats · 18/09/2023 16:23

@TrashedSofa

I attended commemorative church services for relatives - I found that traumatic as it reminded me of not being able to have proper funerals/what state they were in at death (skeletal/emotionally traumatised etc)…. And there were so so many families there, somebody had to March up to the front from each and say a few words. I thought it would never end. So overwhelming.

So I wouldn’t want a whole big palaver. Something like a 5 min silence at 11am and a garden to walk around in where I could meet other friends/family have a picnic and remember. That seems nice and appropriate to be honest.

The commission are proposing quite a bit more than that. A day of reflection, with what sounds like rather a lot of palaver.

I think also, there's at least a realistic possibility that a minute's silence would not be observed, which obviously has the potential to be very upsetting and cause further division too. To that end I'm not sure it would do more good than harm. I think it probably is quite telling that the recommendations talk about people being able to take a moment to reflect but not anything about a silence.

Calistano · 18/09/2023 16:28

JerryLovesMargo · 18/09/2023 16:22

Cope and seethe? What does that even mean?

Congrats on never having had covid, though I'm guessing you've never tested, so how would you know?

I have tested. Believe me ds1 tested all he could to get a week off. If this new variant is different and virulent I doubt "the very specific" tests would pick it up, because they are so so accurate.

GoryBory · 18/09/2023 16:27

Calistano · 18/09/2023 16:18

No they didn't you massive liar. Childhood diseases skewed the average. Liar liar pants on fucking fire. Tbh polio is also disputed, environmental toxins are attributed by some people.

You’re either a child or just fucking delusional.

So you’re saying people didn’t have lower life expectancies in the past (even though this is fact) but that childhood diseases also skewed the average, even though you’ve just said that there is no need for vaccines 🤦‍♀️

So not only do you think you know more than all of the doctors and scientists, you now think you know better than all of the historians, archeologists and anthropologists.

You are delusional if you think you know better than everyone else.
You are not special.

Sparklecats · 18/09/2023 16:23

TrashedSofa · 18/09/2023 16:04

I didn't say anything about costings, although I do note that the commission's recommendations aren't for things that people will have to pay to do. And rightly so. As such, it's not immediately obvious how their proposals are going to be money generating.

But ultimately, anyone who supports a day of reflection or similar is going to have to accept that it's a divisive subject. It will cause anger, piss taking, trauma exacerbation and lots of other bad things. If you still want it regardless, that's your call.

@TrashedSofa

I attended commemorative church services for relatives - I found that traumatic as it reminded me of not being able to have proper funerals/what state they were in at death (skeletal/emotionally traumatised etc)…. And there were so so many families there, somebody had to March up to the front from each and say a few words. I thought it would never end. So overwhelming.

So I wouldn’t want a whole big palaver. Something like a 5 min silence at 11am and a garden to walk around in where I could meet other friends/family have a picnic and remember. That seems nice and appropriate to be honest.

Mirandathepandaisontheverandah · 18/09/2023 16:23

You'd have to have a heart of stone not to build the Museum of Covid in Barnard Castle.

A hunt the lone hiker in the Peak District with a police drone simulation. Interactive No.10 party exhibit. An identify what is and is not a "substantial meal" challenge. The Eat Out to Help Out Museum cafe.

So many possibilities.

JerryLovesMargo · 18/09/2023 16:22

Calistano · 18/09/2023 15:48

Fine thanks, still covid free, cope and seethe.

Cope and seethe? What does that even mean?

Congrats on never having had covid, though I'm guessing you've never tested, so how would you know?

BellaTheDarkOverlord · 18/09/2023 16:20

Tiers!

(Covid) To think these recommendations are bonkers?
DayKay · 18/09/2023 16:18

@Sparklecats Im not an anti vaxxer (despite peoples best attempts to categorise everyone into Us or Them)
and I get why those who hadn't had the virus would want a vaccine, but I'm questioning more why those who had already had a dose of the virus (and had probably had a good dose as they'd been quite ill with it) were being pressured to take a vaccine and a booster.
They were told that having had the virus was not as good as getting the vaccine (which seems quite limited in its effects) so they should still have it and in some countries, were mandated to have it.

Calistano · 18/09/2023 16:18

GoryBory · 18/09/2023 16:15

Humans used to have a life expectancy of 20 years old.

Even in Victorian times you were lucky to reach 40.

Do you know how many people died from polio or the measles?

Surely it’s not difficult to understand that as we’ve developed more medicine and vaccinations, our life expectancy has increased.

No they didn't you massive liar. Childhood diseases skewed the average. Liar liar pants on fucking fire. Tbh polio is also disputed, environmental toxins are attributed by some people.

GoryBory · 18/09/2023 16:17

Calistano · 18/09/2023 16:14

Well he died, really coincidental.

Yes he died after contracting covid.

People dying is not some great conspiracy, especially someone who refused medical treatment and thought just praying would be enough to save him.

Everanewbie · 18/09/2023 16:17

@Sparklecats This is the problem. I actually received an award for my voluntary work in delivering the COVID vaccine, and having had COVID 3 times, I do not deny its existence. I don't think Johnson et al were capable of some big conspiracy. What I do disagree with is the response, the manipulation, the panic, the restrictions based on public opinion after being scared half to death, the reliance on one set of scientists and ignoring incredibly respected virologists that disagreed with measures.

It was a novel nasty virus that unfortunately killed some, and hastened the death of many more that were already seriously ill. But we burnt down the house in an attempt to kill the wasp. The wasp stung us anyway but now we haven't got a house and have third degree burns to go with our wasp sting. My museum will have the theme of how group think and panic can cause governments and populations to follow illogical rules, and provide a warning to future generations to keep calm and act proportionately.

Sparklecats · 18/09/2023 16:17

Calistano · 18/09/2023 15:57

Educate us all, what are we missing oh great bearer of truth.

Yes @Calistano the absolute nonsense infuriated me too. I am third level educated…. But the lack of GCSE biology even in basic understanding was shocking.

One thing I will say is that it is only relatively recently that zoonoses would have been incorporated in the syllabus at GCSE/A level. God knows why as zoonotic disease accounts for 70% of known human infections and has been increasing exponentially, particularly with factors such as climate change and habitat loss precipitating spillover to humans.

The recommendation to ensure covid/zoonoses/pandemics are incorporated into education is essential.

There was a link to social deprivation in terms of deaths and vaccine hesitancy.. if there had been better education prior it would have saved a lot of lives!!

GoryBory · 18/09/2023 16:15

Calistano · 18/09/2023 16:10

Do you understand that humans existed for eons before vaccines.

Humans used to have a life expectancy of 20 years old.

Even in Victorian times you were lucky to reach 40.

Do you know how many people died from polio or the measles?

Surely it’s not difficult to understand that as we’ve developed more medicine and vaccinations, our life expectancy has increased.

Calistano · 18/09/2023 16:14

Well he died, really coincidental.

GoryBory · 18/09/2023 16:12

That president who tested a papaya which came back positive mysteriously died. Hmm.

@Calistano

You mean the president that didn’t believe in western medicine and told his people to ‘pray’ the disease away.

The same president that caught covid and died.

Calistano · 18/09/2023 16:10

Do you understand that humans existed for eons before vaccines.

DyslexicPoster · 18/09/2023 16:10

Following the rules seems insane in hindsight. But hindsight is a amazing thing isn't it? If I'd know what the future held I'd probably do 50% of my life differently.

Although covid didn't kill anyone I knew personally. I know it killed plenty. So even with hindsight, I'd not trample over others boundaries.

The next outbreak will be interesting as you can bet your life the Tony's antics has eroded the vast majorities faith in lockdown.

Fear is also a great control measure. How anyone could watch the news in Mexico and not feel fear I can't grasp. Even if known the torys was having mass raves at the time, I'd be worried looking at the mass graves.

Another thing is I got covid pre vaccine. It was extremely mild for me. So again its hard to feel personal fear when I knew for a fact covid didn't touch me.

I can respect covid was different for everyone.

I still think knowledge is power and we need to do better educating our kids in real scientific facts. To many flat earthers who don't belive the most basic of biology concepts. We are all to thick.