Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(Covid) To think these recommendations are bonkers?

659 replies

NoCharnce · 18/09/2023 12:11

So the government commission into how to memorialise the Covid pandemic has recommended the government implement “A UK-wide day of reflection should be established and held annually.”

Other recommendations include national memorials (10 sites already identified!), oral histories and museums plus additional funding for local authorities to set up their own memorials.

I can’t be the only one who thinks this is nuts and hope the government ignores the recommendations? I genuinely cannot believe people get paid to produce this crap.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
JerryLovesMargo · 03/10/2023 07:07

And you know what, you're quite right. Why am I on MN, when it's upsetting?

I've been here since 2010 and it's been a massive support to me in the past. During the pandemic the climate here changed for the worse, with ableist attitudes such as the ones displayed on this thread which still unfortunately persist. Posters cannot comprehend anything that doesn't chime with their own lifestyles or beliefs. The idea that vulnerable people had no choice but to go out to work during a pandemic is anathema to them - they must be lying, because after all, they themselves would never have done that.

Well, you're wrong. DD is a teacher and lost several colleagues. I lost colleagues. DH did. Who do you think was dying? It wasn't just care home residents. Tens of thousands of vulnerable people died, many of whom caught covid because they had no choice but to go to work or use public transport.

I literally could not wear a mask and neither could tens of thousands of others. People who were gagged during sexual assault, for example, who were also told on here they were lying or that they needed to get over it. People with TN were laughed at because they wet themselves when they lose consciousness (yep, that was me). Parents with autistic children were told to keep their DC at home for the sake of others.

Nah, I'm done here. Being called a liar when I've been talking about becoming extremely ill from covid, when talking about my disabilities and how difficult it was being CEV during the pandemic - nah.

I'll leave you to it.

JerryLovesMargo · 03/10/2023 06:53

Sparklecats · 02/10/2023 23:48

@WomblingTree86

I think the only reasonable explanation would be that some CEV prioritised their personal liberty to be able to do xyz over their personal safety.

Seeing my friend as a corpse so young cleared me of any vigilante notions of rising up against restrictions and putting myself at risk for the sake of an hour in tesco, having a pint in the pub or having a few extra quid in my pocket. Literally one of the worst experiences of my life to see their body, I will never get over it.

My point of view was I didn’t want to kill off DC/DH or anyone else or leave my DC without a mother. So I was altogether dull and stayed away from potential harm.

Admittedly my educational background with study of zoonotic disease did play a part too because I’d read so much of other countries previous experience.

But yeah, some people won’t have experience of prior study, or bereavement, or have any of the motivators I had to want to comply with guidance to keep myself safe. Up to them. But not for me.

No, not 'personal liberty'. Being able to pay bills, or have my fortnightly blood tests.

I barely left the house unless it was for work or hospital appointments. I was terrified all the time. I was on antidepressants.

I wasn't an antimasker (I really, really wanted to wear one and tried so hard to do so, or find an alternative).

'A few extra quid in my pocket' indeed. As if going to work was a choice in order to buy pretty things.

JerryLovesMargo · 03/10/2023 06:49

WomblingTree86 · 02/10/2023 23:29

I'm not being nasty. By definition clinically extremely vulnerable means covid could easily hospitalize you and perhaps kill you if you catch it once let alone 10 times and yet this poster is still working, going to crowded places and complaining about people being pressurised to wear a mask. Not plausible.

Covid did make me that ill, prior to vaccination. I have been given antivirals since to avoid becoming that ill again, and I've had eight vaccinations (which don't work so well at preventing infection in immunosuppressed patients but do make illness less severe).

I have never once complained about people being pressured to wear a mask. I've 'complained' that those who couldn't shouldn't have been spat at, threatened or abused, which is a different thing. Do you think they should have been?

And I'll say it again - CEV people still had to go to work. Teachers and retail staff didn't have the luxury of WFH. Nor did they have the option to simply stop working. It's why so bus drivers, for example, died.

Why isn't all that 'plausible'? Why are you calling me a liar?

JerryLovesMargo · 03/10/2023 06:44

Sparklecats · 02/10/2023 23:12

@WestwardHo1

I wouldn’t have said anything like this myself.

But it is a struggle to comprehend why someone CEV would be putting themselves in this position.

Everyone I knew was very cautious, had support from employers, family and friends to stay safe.

Some couldn’t wear a mask, but they avoided going into crowded places like public transport/supermarkets/offices etc.

Anyone with CEV health issues would have a major argument, if not court case, with an employer who forced them to use public transport/come in when under threat; especially if they were unable to protect themselves by wearing a mask.

I think that is the angle - though badly worded - @WomblingTree86 has taken.

It doesn’t sound a plausible scenario, unless someone has no friends, family, or ability to raise their rights with an employer.

I don't have any family apart from DH and DD, or friends, not that it's relevant. And unfortunately, not all jobs can be done from home. I did of course have the option not to go into work at all, but that would have meant resigning. So, not really an option.

I said it then and I'll say it now - not everyone has a support network, can drive, has the option to WFH. People who did have those options during the pandemic were utterly disbelieving that others did not. It must have been such a relief for the CEV/mask exempt who were able to avoid crowded public places to be able to do so. But tens of thousands of teachers, retail staff, hospitality staff etc could not.

Why is that so hard to believe?

And however politely you try to 'word' it, calling a disabled person a liar when they're telling you their lived experience is pretty crap.

I'd happily supply details of all my positive tests and the AVs I've been given and my various diagnoses which make me CEV. But why should I prove myself to a stranger online - particularly one who no doubt was all about protecting the vulnerable during the pandemic, but is now quite happy to suggest I'm lying about my health.

Yes. This thread and some of the attitudes on it is the perfect memorial to a really shitty, terrifying time for CEV people. Privileged, fit and healthy people able to wear masks and WFH and avoid buses and busy workplaces telling us we're doing vulnerability wrong.

JerryLovesMargo · 03/10/2023 06:31

WomblingTree86 · 02/10/2023 20:51

Given that you also claim to have covid 10 times and still seem to be working and going into crowded spaces without a mask you don't sound too vulnerable to me.

I've had covid 10 times because I'm immunosuppressed.

And of course I need to work. What choice do I have? Millions of vulnerable people have had to work throughout the pandemic. Tens of thousands have died, including people I know.

Why are you being so nasty? And why are you being so disbelieving and deeply unpleasant to someone who is CEV - you know, the very type of person you wanted to 'protect' back in 2020?

WhalePolo · 03/10/2023 06:20

That’s true I think. The CEV I knew just didn’t go out. All shopping was delivered and she was ‘quarantining’ the shopping where she could and then putting it away with gloves.

I do sympathise with @JerryLovesMargo experience, but yes I think that is an argument supporting your personal liberty (where your personal safety was then compromised) - rather than personal safety. And I’m afraid I’d prioritise personal safety - and as stated above there were some extremely vulnerable people who were completely isolated and unable to go out at all.
I think I’ve forgotten how bad it was, but it was a knife edge of life/death. Getting the cancer treatment required on time and then being acutely careful that she didn’t get Covid. I gave the example earlier of having to get nappies, and being intimidated and laughed at for having a mask/trying to be careful about distancing. I did sit and just cry afterwards in the car.

I think there are spitting incidents that I read about for people being asked to wear a mask too (aimed at bus drivers or shop workers).

Sparklecats · 02/10/2023 23:48

@WomblingTree86

I think the only reasonable explanation would be that some CEV prioritised their personal liberty to be able to do xyz over their personal safety.

Seeing my friend as a corpse so young cleared me of any vigilante notions of rising up against restrictions and putting myself at risk for the sake of an hour in tesco, having a pint in the pub or having a few extra quid in my pocket. Literally one of the worst experiences of my life to see their body, I will never get over it.

My point of view was I didn’t want to kill off DC/DH or anyone else or leave my DC without a mother. So I was altogether dull and stayed away from potential harm.

Admittedly my educational background with study of zoonotic disease did play a part too because I’d read so much of other countries previous experience.

But yeah, some people won’t have experience of prior study, or bereavement, or have any of the motivators I had to want to comply with guidance to keep myself safe. Up to them. But not for me.

WomblingTree86 · 02/10/2023 23:29

WestwardHo1 · 02/10/2023 22:37

😱

This has got absolutely fucking nasty. Jesus Christ

I'm not being nasty. By definition clinically extremely vulnerable means covid could easily hospitalize you and perhaps kill you if you catch it once let alone 10 times and yet this poster is still working, going to crowded places and complaining about people being pressurised to wear a mask. Not plausible.

Sparklecats · 02/10/2023 23:23

@JenniferBooth

But seriously, how would someone get themselves into this position??

If you are so ill and immunosuppressed.

I have one friend who was able to establish wfh.

Another who changed jobs to be able to wfh. Unfortunately they later died, despite it all.

We were all CV, even then I never would have considered going into a supermarket. We cut off contact from people not following guidance for over a year to protect DC.

I can’t understand why a CEV person would feel forced into putting themselves at enhanced risk… and then wouldn’t raise it with an employer/seek legal recourse.

JenniferBooth · 02/10/2023 23:16

Siri show me someone who says they wouldnt make the same derogatory comment and then goes on to say the same thing

Sparklecats · 02/10/2023 23:12

WestwardHo1 · 02/10/2023 22:37

😱

This has got absolutely fucking nasty. Jesus Christ

@WestwardHo1

I wouldn’t have said anything like this myself.

But it is a struggle to comprehend why someone CEV would be putting themselves in this position.

Everyone I knew was very cautious, had support from employers, family and friends to stay safe.

Some couldn’t wear a mask, but they avoided going into crowded places like public transport/supermarkets/offices etc.

Anyone with CEV health issues would have a major argument, if not court case, with an employer who forced them to use public transport/come in when under threat; especially if they were unable to protect themselves by wearing a mask.

I think that is the angle - though badly worded - @WomblingTree86 has taken.

It doesn’t sound a plausible scenario, unless someone has no friends, family, or ability to raise their rights with an employer.

JenniferBooth · 02/10/2023 22:57

@WestwardHo1 Just proves my point really They are not really bothered about people who are CEV until and unless they can use them as tools to emotionally blackmail others. Now its blatant

WestwardHo1 · 02/10/2023 22:37

WomblingTree86 · 02/10/2023 20:51

Given that you also claim to have covid 10 times and still seem to be working and going into crowded spaces without a mask you don't sound too vulnerable to me.

😱

This has got absolutely fucking nasty. Jesus Christ

Sparklecats · 02/10/2023 22:22

Oh I give up, we’ll done all for derailing the thread repeatedly with your mask ranting.

If @JenniferBooth is the voice of reason God help us all. The posts I’ve read are overly emotive, off topic and parroting unsubstantiated facts.

As for whoever was crying over past mask posts on MN. Why were you putting yourself through that on MN? It is full of predominantly - so it appears to me - parents of SEN kids, disabled, neurodiverse, mentally disturbed and abused women.

It is hardly a healthy cross-section of society where you are going to get a balanced outlook. Just look at this thread!

For god’s sake if something is distressing you avoid it.

As for CEV behaviour during the pandemic. We were all CV; kids stayed at home, I changed to wfh, DH was furloughed. We got tesco delivery and didn’t go near crowded shops or public transport because we didn’t have a death wish. Anyone we knew CV/CEV either got an adaptation to wfh, changed job or took time out from work.

As for the masks, I respect there are a myriad of reasons from not wearing, but anyone CEV not wearing one is putting themselves at enormous risk.

Well done for ruining the thread 😷

WomblingTree86 · 02/10/2023 20:51

JerryLovesMargo · 02/10/2023 20:33

Well, yes, I was. I've had 8 vaccinations (my first in January 2021) and been eligible for antivirals when I've had covid. I inject a chemo drug weekly for an autoimmune disease.

Good of you to tell me that I wasn't CEV though - if only you'd told me at the start of the pandemic, it would have saved me so much worry (and getting extremely ill with covid in March 2020). Also really impressive that you know more about my health than the HCPs who look after me, particularly given you don't even know me. Well done!

Given that you also claim to have covid 10 times and still seem to be working and going into crowded spaces without a mask you don't sound too vulnerable to me.

JerryLovesMargo · 02/10/2023 20:33

WomblingTree86 · 02/10/2023 19:51

I didn't say that you weren't immunosuppressed but that doesn't mean that you were in the CEV category. Not everyone who was immunosuppressed was.

Well, yes, I was. I've had 8 vaccinations (my first in January 2021) and been eligible for antivirals when I've had covid. I inject a chemo drug weekly for an autoimmune disease.

Good of you to tell me that I wasn't CEV though - if only you'd told me at the start of the pandemic, it would have saved me so much worry (and getting extremely ill with covid in March 2020). Also really impressive that you know more about my health than the HCPs who look after me, particularly given you don't even know me. Well done!

WomblingTree86 · 02/10/2023 19:51

JerryLovesMargo · 02/10/2023 18:58

Well, you don't believe that I needed to enter busy public spaces despite being immunosuppressed, or that I was spat at or told I deserved to catch covid and die, do you?

I didn't say that you weren't immunosuppressed but that doesn't mean that you were in the CEV category. Not everyone who was immunosuppressed was.

JerryLovesMargo · 02/10/2023 18:58

WomblingTree86 · 02/10/2023 18:25

Not sure why you think nobody would believe that an elderly lady collapsed at a bus stop.🤔

Well, you don't believe that I needed to enter busy public spaces despite being immunosuppressed, or that I was spat at or told I deserved to catch covid and die, do you?

JerryLovesMargo · 02/10/2023 18:56

WomblingTree86 · 02/10/2023 17:14

The people I know who were CEV barely went indoors in public spaces during the pandemic even with masks on. I'm a bit skeptical that you were indoors in crowded spaces without a mask on especially if you say you were getting spat on and death threats because of it.

I barely did, too. But unfortunately I had to go to work and use public transport to get there. The CEV people you know were extremely fortunate to not need to go out to work or use buses and trains to get there. Unfortunately, that was a privilege many millions didn't have during the pandemic, CEV or otherwise.

There are many, many documented cases of people being abused and even physically attacked for being unable to wear a mask (please do Google). Are you sceptical of all of us? Why would we lie?

JenniferBooth · 02/10/2023 18:40

Oh come on You know full well what i meant Its always "cool story bro" when ever it was something involving a face mask Unless people could prove it by filming it. Thats why the young woman in the underground filmed the man who was harassing her. The man who walked ALL the way from the other end of the platform to berate her for not wearing a mask Yet they were the only two there. She likely knew she wouldnt have been believed otherwise.

My mum is in her 80s and struggled to wear one She couldnt breathe properly in it. She was told by a Tesco supervisor that she could take it off and i managed to get her a lanyard.

WomblingTree86 · 02/10/2023 18:25

JenniferBooth · 02/10/2023 17:28

@WomblingTree86

Ah yes Something else i remember from the pandemic.

I remember an elderly lady who had collapsed in a bus stop stand. She had a face mask on and had trouble breathing. It was filmed and put on Twitter. People were outraged at the breach of privacy.

BUT as we can see by the doubts levelled at @JerryLovesMargo on here what choice was there

a. Film it and get rounded on for breach of privacy
b. tell people about the experience afterwards but dont film it and get the "cool story bro" "it never happened" replies.

Not sure why you think nobody would believe that an elderly lady collapsed at a bus stop.🤔

JenniferBooth · 02/10/2023 17:28

@WomblingTree86

Ah yes Something else i remember from the pandemic.

I remember an elderly lady who had collapsed in a bus stop stand. She had a face mask on and had trouble breathing. It was filmed and put on Twitter. People were outraged at the breach of privacy.

BUT as we can see by the doubts levelled at @JerryLovesMargo on here what choice was there

a. Film it and get rounded on for breach of privacy
b. tell people about the experience afterwards but dont film it and get the "cool story bro" "it never happened" replies.

JenniferBooth · 02/10/2023 17:22

@JerryLovesMargo Thank you to you too. Flowers

WomblingTree86 · 02/10/2023 17:14

JerryLovesMargo · 02/10/2023 17:02

I hope that, too, as a CEV person who felt that way all through the pandemic.

The feelings of being inconvenient and dispensable were compounded by being unable to wear a mask, and the way I was treated because of that.

When people are spitting at, and wishing death upon, a person who is visibly disabled, it's clear that we've come to a pretty awful pass.

The people I know who were CEV barely went indoors in public spaces during the pandemic even with masks on. I'm a bit skeptical that you were indoors in crowded spaces without a mask on especially if you say you were getting spat on and death threats because of it.

JerryLovesMargo · 02/10/2023 17:07

JenniferBooth · 02/10/2023 16:03

Totally @JerryLovesMargo And the comments coming out of the Conservative Party conference now show (as i and others predicted) that its back to the default setting now that they have finished using disabled people as a tool to emotionally blackmail others to follow restrictions. Now its back to cutting their benefits!!

Ah yes. How often I was told that I was risking the lives of vulnerable people - when I'm one myself.

All the 'if you go out, vulnerable people will die' stuff in 2020. But it's okay for vulnerable people to die of cold or hunger because their benefits have been cut in 2023.

By the way @JenniferBooth you were consistently one of the few voices of reason on here during the pandemic, and still are (I remember your old UN). Thank you.