Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(Covid) To think these recommendations are bonkers?

659 replies

NoCharnce · 18/09/2023 12:11

So the government commission into how to memorialise the Covid pandemic has recommended the government implement “A UK-wide day of reflection should be established and held annually.”

Other recommendations include national memorials (10 sites already identified!), oral histories and museums plus additional funding for local authorities to set up their own memorials.

I can’t be the only one who thinks this is nuts and hope the government ignores the recommendations? I genuinely cannot believe people get paid to produce this crap.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
Sparklecats · 19/09/2023 13:52

Everanewbie · 19/09/2023 13:29

I was told by the government that restrictions were in place to manage hospital capacity, not because of some doomsday scenario where a pandemic coronavirus suddenly mutates to the same threat level as the great plague.

Respiratory, vascular, whatever. When my great-grandmother in law survived it in 2020 alongside her entire nursing home, I realised it was time we stopped wetting are pants as this was not the Antonine Plague of 165AD.

@Everanewbie just because the residents in your GGMIL’s home survived unscathed does not mean this is was universal - far from it.

Perhaps the home had adequate staffing levels, good infection control and management in general, compliance from visitors etc.

A relative of mine and 4 others in their home died within a month of unvaccinated bank workers bringing covid in. The regular staff were totally traumatised as they had done everything they could to follow guidance to the letter and were massively let down by outside staff.

It is not a matter of just surviving it, there is damage, repeatedly if you get it multiple times, that can compromise your overall health and put you at risk of disease development secondary to the covid infection. Studies have shown that those who were in infected in the first waves would likely be the most adversely affected long term but we won’t see the full disease burden of this until further down the line.

It was really well publicised about the potential danger of new variants. With the rate of cases they had and the threat of the problem getting worse they had to preserve hospital capacity and prevent the nhs from getting overwhelmed.

All of the information regarding this was freely available, but you would likely only go looking for the detail of it if from an academic/scientific background. Joe bloggs is probably not going to be bothered reading several 50pg reports and updates every week.

EasternStandard · 19/09/2023 13:39

Everanewbie · 19/09/2023 13:29

I was told by the government that restrictions were in place to manage hospital capacity, not because of some doomsday scenario where a pandemic coronavirus suddenly mutates to the same threat level as the great plague.

Respiratory, vascular, whatever. When my great-grandmother in law survived it in 2020 alongside her entire nursing home, I realised it was time we stopped wetting are pants as this was not the Antonine Plague of 165AD.

Same here. Not sure why that extra threat got added

Everanewbie · 19/09/2023 13:29

I was told by the government that restrictions were in place to manage hospital capacity, not because of some doomsday scenario where a pandemic coronavirus suddenly mutates to the same threat level as the great plague.

Respiratory, vascular, whatever. When my great-grandmother in law survived it in 2020 alongside her entire nursing home, I realised it was time we stopped wetting are pants as this was not the Antonine Plague of 165AD.

1dayatatime · 19/09/2023 12:57

@Sparklecats

"Had we had a stable virus with limited scope for dangerous mutation in smaller outbreaks, with plenty of healthcare capacity I would probably agree with you.

But we didn’t"

+++

Exactly the same argument could be used for flu each winter but we don't shut down the country every winter because there isn't the same level of mass hysteria.

Sparklecats · 19/09/2023 11:57

1dayatatime · 19/09/2023 11:50

@Sparklecats

"It’s a vascular disease. Not cold or flu. And we are still to see the longterm health outcomes from this - you can expect to see significantly more respiratory and circulatory health problems in future because after repeated covid infections people will have damage sufficient to their lungs and vasculature so as to lower their threshold for disease development"

+++

Actually it's a respiratory disease not a vascular disease. Yes there are vascular complications it equally there are sensory complications (loss of taste and smell), liver, kidney and brain complications. In the same way as cutting your finger can lead to complications such as tetanus or septicaemia.

However for the vast majority of people Covid is a mild respiratory infection.

www.healthline.com/health/covid-respiratory-or-vascular

However I think the key point here is whether the measures taken against preventing Covid deaths in order to predominantly protect the elderly (92% of Covid deaths were aged 60 or over, 58% were aged 80 or over) will result in a higher death rates across a wider age group from missed diagnosis on cardio and cancer as well as a rise in deaths caused by increased poverty.

It’s actually a vascular and respiratory disease if you read up. You can’t accept the opinion of a single publication.

The key point is that the restrictions were brought in relative to the risk of the virus evolving to become more pathogenic and the healthcare capacity.

Had we had a stable virus with limited scope for dangerous mutation in smaller outbreaks, with plenty of healthcare capacity I would probably agree with you.

But we didn’t.

1dayatatime · 19/09/2023 11:50

@Sparklecats

"It’s a vascular disease. Not cold or flu. And we are still to see the longterm health outcomes from this - you can expect to see significantly more respiratory and circulatory health problems in future because after repeated covid infections people will have damage sufficient to their lungs and vasculature so as to lower their threshold for disease development"

+++

Actually it's a respiratory disease not a vascular disease. Yes there are vascular complications it equally there are sensory complications (loss of taste and smell), liver, kidney and brain complications. In the same way as cutting your finger can lead to complications such as tetanus or septicaemia.

However for the vast majority of people Covid is a mild respiratory infection.

www.healthline.com/health/covid-respiratory-or-vascular

However I think the key point here is whether the measures taken against preventing Covid deaths in order to predominantly protect the elderly (92% of Covid deaths were aged 60 or over, 58% were aged 80 or over) will result in a higher death rates across a wider age group from missed diagnosis on cardio and cancer as well as a rise in deaths caused by increased poverty.

DameWhiskers · 19/09/2023 11:48

@Calistano

Because it is an endemic virus. Duh.

Covid isn't endemic yet.

Sparklecats · 19/09/2023 10:38

Everanewbie · 18/09/2023 20:42

It’s not reasonable for the population to commit ritual suicide economically and in terms of health both mental and physical because a virus kills a small percentage of elderly people. I’m sorry if you’ve suffered personal loss. But decent people don’t ask the world to stop turning based on unproven lockdown efficacy.

I’d put your type of post in the black mirror Covid museum. “You wouldn’t say that if your dad/mum/aunt died” No one suggested abandoning their hopes and dreams to avoid hypothetical elderly deaths in flu season, harsh as it sounds, I ain’t prepared to do it now.

@Everanewbie

Jesus Christ.

a small percentage of elderly people…

Mate, pregnant woman and new mothers died, people in their 20s and 30s, children with respiratory and neurodevelopmental disorders died

This was not just a few old farts who according to you were worthless.

Yes “vulnerable” comprises a lot of elderly people, but there are also those with very common conditions such as asthma or diabetes, pregnancy….

Some died with no prior history of anything and we were a matter of mutations away from having a significantly higher death rate.

In the summer of 2021 there was still significant likelihood of absolutely dire outcomes such as 20% fatality, limited therapeutics to combat.

I know this because I kept up with reading assessment reports/papers from various universities, governments and NGOs. Rather than relying on tabloids and Facebook.

The reason it was not treated like cold/flu season is because the level of threat was substantially higher and the ability to deal with that threat substantially lower.

A combination of determined effort, money and scientific expertise coupled with sheer luck is what got us through.

I’ve known somebody in their thirties die of a blood clot related to covid infection a month ago.

What the hell is wrong with people.

It’s a vascular disease. Not cold or flu. And we are still to see the longterm health outcomes from this - you can expect to see significantly more respiratory and circulatory health problems in future because after repeated covid infections people will have damage sufficient to their lungs and vasculature so as to lower their threshold for disease development.

PickAChew · 19/09/2023 10:12

Maybe there should be memorial benches to replace all the seating that was ripped out of our town centres, leaving ugly great tarmac scars.

Lottapianos · 19/09/2023 06:20

'Not changed my mind. You laughed at something that brought people comfort'

It wasn't my laughing emoji! You've got your wires crossed. Go back and read those posts properly

DameWhiskers · 19/09/2023 05:23

DameWhiskers · 18/09/2023 13:07

So this thread is going to be the perfect exhibit of the incredible lack of of thinking that many people seem to possess? Do carry on! I'll get my popcorn and settle in for some entertainment.

... and I'm pleased to say it didn't disappoint. So many absolutely seething, vicious, bonkers posters in one place.

sleepwouldbenice · 19/09/2023 00:14

Lottapianos · 18/09/2023 20:41

'Your laughing emoji implied otherwise'

Oh well, now you know

Not changed my mind. You laughed at something that brought people comfort

TrashedSofa · 18/09/2023 22:28

CruCru · 18/09/2023 20:08

A UK-wide day of reflection should be established and held annually.

Does this mean that we will have a mandatory 3 minutes' silence every year? I remember the ones we used to have for 9/11. A friend's father was killed in it and he utterly hated the 3 minutes' silence. Having someone patrol the office to make sure that everyone was properly observing the silence didn't feel respectful or helpful.

I didn't see any mention of one in the consultation proposals. It doesn't seem like the best idea to me. Not sure it'd be observed.

1dayatatime · 18/09/2023 20:58

@InterFactual

"Well aren't you a special sort of person.

I wonder if you'd be so dismissive if half your family dies in the next pandemic eh? Apparently premature death is fine when it happens to other people."

+++

Whilst not dismissive of any death my concern is that the measures taken against Covid will cause far more deaths from other diseases where diagnosis was missed such as heart conditions, cancer, suicide etc than those who died from Covid. And this is before we get on to the topic of economic and educational damage.

www.bhf.org.uk/what-we-do/news-from-the-bhf/news-archive/2023/june/100000-excess-deaths-cardiovascular-disease

Everanewbie · 18/09/2023 20:42

InterFactual · 18/09/2023 20:32

Well aren't you a special sort of person.

I wonder if you'd be so dismissive if half your family dies in the next pandemic eh? Apparently premature death is fine when it happens to other people.

It’s not reasonable for the population to commit ritual suicide economically and in terms of health both mental and physical because a virus kills a small percentage of elderly people. I’m sorry if you’ve suffered personal loss. But decent people don’t ask the world to stop turning based on unproven lockdown efficacy.

I’d put your type of post in the black mirror Covid museum. “You wouldn’t say that if your dad/mum/aunt died” No one suggested abandoning their hopes and dreams to avoid hypothetical elderly deaths in flu season, harsh as it sounds, I ain’t prepared to do it now.

Lottapianos · 18/09/2023 20:41

'Your laughing emoji implied otherwise'

Oh well, now you know

sleepwouldbenice · 18/09/2023 20:35

Lottapianos · 18/09/2023 18:09

'Friend of mine who worked on covid wards and was exhausted and not seeing her family said it really kept her going
You do NOT speak for everyone'

Never said I did! And I know that plenty of individual people were very sincere about expressing genuine thanks to the NHS. I was working on a COVID ward myself at the time. I still think it was behaviour that was more appropriate for a primary school class than for grown adults, but it was an exceptionally weird time

Your laughing emoji implied otherwise

Anyway this thread is where all those who think they were so clever and challenged the rrroooolz now hang out
Yiu woukd have thought they had moved on to minimising climate change by now

InterFactual · 18/09/2023 20:32

Calistano · 18/09/2023 12:56

Blah blah so tedious, seriously after that cruise ship, which was handily a perfect model of how covid spread/killed it was blatantly obvious it was just another virus, not doomsday. Most propagandised event in history.

Well aren't you a special sort of person.

I wonder if you'd be so dismissive if half your family dies in the next pandemic eh? Apparently premature death is fine when it happens to other people.

Lovesacake · 18/09/2023 20:30

I’m going to admit it here….I clapped on my doorstep for the first couple of Thursdays and I don’t regret it. It was such a weird, scary, isolating time and those two or three minutes were, to my mind, a way of communities feeling heard and connected in a world that had gone silent (at least where I live it had, it was like Christmas Day on the roads every day). We felt powerless and taking part in the clapping and seeing my neighbours do the same actually moved me.
I didn’t for one minute think that it was a replacement for a properly funded nhs. I didn’t for one minute think that anyone should be berated for not doing it. But I don’t look back on those couple of weeks with embarrassment because at the time it felt like a moving thing to be part of.

RunningUpThatBuilding · 18/09/2023 20:19

1dayatatime · 18/09/2023 19:53

Whilst a truly believe that only a very very small number of conspiracy theorists denied the actual existence of Covid, what I found very disturbing was that any criticism at the time of the Covid measures was met with accusations of being "a Covid denier" or "anti vaxx". It was very akin to shouting "witch" when anyone raised a counter prevailing viewpoint.

Absolutely this!

There was no rational discussion to be had with many people. You were either fully on board with the government’s (often contradictory) messages or you were a tin foil hat wearing raving lunatic that couldn’t understand science.

CruCru · 18/09/2023 20:08

A UK-wide day of reflection should be established and held annually.

Does this mean that we will have a mandatory 3 minutes' silence every year? I remember the ones we used to have for 9/11. A friend's father was killed in it and he utterly hated the 3 minutes' silence. Having someone patrol the office to make sure that everyone was properly observing the silence didn't feel respectful or helpful.

Wherly · 18/09/2023 19:59

1dayatatime · 18/09/2023 19:53

Whilst a truly believe that only a very very small number of conspiracy theorists denied the actual existence of Covid, what I found very disturbing was that any criticism at the time of the Covid measures was met with accusations of being "a Covid denier" or "anti vaxx". It was very akin to shouting "witch" when anyone raised a counter prevailing viewpoint.

It was awful. I lost friends over this. They were friends I made through activism, I still can't follow their logic but I think it was "the right wing don't want to take vaccines/have lockdown ergo we should force people to do it"

Fuck what the right wing think. What do you think and why?

Wherly · 18/09/2023 19:55

1dayatatime · 18/09/2023 18:56

@LoobyDop

"I actually think it’s really important that we don’t forget about the mass hysteria and the world going collectively nuts, for the reasons you’ve outlined here. I’m not prepared to write that off as “oh yes, but we were scared so we get a free pass”. Bad decisions were made, that weren’t needed, that hurt people. People were treated really badly. It wasn’t ok, and not everyone was too caught up in terror to realise that at the time."

+++

Whilst I don't disagree with you from a factual perspective you have to recognise that for many people from a psychological perspective given a choice between a) openly admitting that they were lied to, got caught up with and were willing participants in the mass hysteria or b) let's just forget about it and pretend it never happened. Then most people will go for Option B.

It's a bit like after WW2 in Germany the Allied soldiers couldn't find hardly anyone who openly admitted to supporting or accepting the Nazi regime. Most preferred to try and forget about the whole thing.

The comparison is very silly. The world denounced the Nazis, there is no consensus on the lockdowns.

Also I have found most people are quite happy to acknowledge that things were a bit much even if they supported it at the time.

I was furious about the measures for a number of reasons but they were never very popular ones. My issue could be summed up best with a succient tweet I saw at the time "There is no lockdown, just poor people bringing things to wealthy people". And, yep, that was how it was. The whole lockdown narrative was hijacked by the middle class who were working from home. All the jokes and discourse were about Teams and WFH culture shock etc.

We acted like the only people not working were the key workers and front line health and social care (of which I was one) ignoring factory workers and order pickers (in none food settings) who were packed to the rafters.

My primary issue was principle. I remember being so grateful for those absolute cranks who were protesting and deliberately goading thr police into arresting them. They were nutters for sure but they were the only ones who were challenging the insane loss of civil liberties. I was genuinely horrified that so few people were willing to challenge the measures on principle.

I don't need to believe covid was a lie or a pys op or whatever (to be clear I don't think it was either) to be against the government restricting our personal life and effectively handing powers to private bodies to allow them to restrict our movements.

1dayatatime · 18/09/2023 19:53

Calistano · 18/09/2023 17:51

People who deny covid have a big overlap with people who deny viruses as a whole. Its pretty idiotic to my mind, pretty much everyone has anecdotal evidence of giving or receiving a virus. Noro, chicken pox the flu. It's akin to flat earth in its idiocy.

Whilst a truly believe that only a very very small number of conspiracy theorists denied the actual existence of Covid, what I found very disturbing was that any criticism at the time of the Covid measures was met with accusations of being "a Covid denier" or "anti vaxx". It was very akin to shouting "witch" when anyone raised a counter prevailing viewpoint.

LlynTegid · 18/09/2023 19:49

The best memorial for me would be justice for the families of those who died of Covid who were effectively sent to their death in old people's homes without testing, or because of inaction in early March.

Though my lifelong opposition to the death penalty prevents my supporting the hanging of Boris Johnson.

Swipe left for the next trending thread