Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(Covid) To think these recommendations are bonkers?

659 replies

NoCharnce · 18/09/2023 12:11

So the government commission into how to memorialise the Covid pandemic has recommended the government implement “A UK-wide day of reflection should be established and held annually.”

Other recommendations include national memorials (10 sites already identified!), oral histories and museums plus additional funding for local authorities to set up their own memorials.

I can’t be the only one who thinks this is nuts and hope the government ignores the recommendations? I genuinely cannot believe people get paid to produce this crap.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 20/09/2023 09:06

Good luck with the army support and the like happening in the event of a major outbreak with high pathogenicity!

I saw a lot of posts on here and Twitter when people wanted a harder lockdown and that the army would do this and the army would do that - man barricades to stop people loving around and distribute food were two suggestions. I had to point out that the army is about 75,000 strong, which is one squaddie per town in the UK. It also assumed that the army wouldn't be decimated by sickness.

TrashedSofa · 20/09/2023 08:57

I agree the oral histories idea is really interesting.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 20/09/2023 08:56

*So the government commission into how to memorialise the Covid pandemic has recommended the government implement “A UK-wide day of reflection should be established and held annually.”

Other recommendations include national memorials (10 sites already identified!), oral histories and museums plus additional funding for local authorities to set up their own memorials*

That all sounds a bit....Soviet to me. Are children going to be taken on school trips to the memorials and museums every year and told how the Great Leader Hancock led us to victory? and what exactly does a 'day of reflection' entail? time off work to reflect how batshit some of it all was?

Oral histories are, OTOH, a good idea. My local museum has asked people too donate any diaries they kept during the pandemic.

As to memorialising it...I shouldn't imagine anyone who lived through it needs reminding about it, let alone every year. Some shops STILL have screens up and the local supermarket hasn't removed the 'keep 2 metres apart signs' they laid outside when we all had to queue.

Everanewbie · 20/09/2023 08:53

VeryGoodVeryNice · 20/09/2023 00:43

One of my FB memories popped up where I lamented the bag restrictions at DD’s primary school. No rucksacks allowed, because they were very covid-y. So they could take their things in in carrier bags instead (same one every day), as they seemed to possess covid-repelling properties. However, bizarrely they were allowed to take book bags in, which are made out of the same material of rucksacks 🤷‍♀️

This is bonkers. The school got to tick a box to say they were doing something though! Some of the measures were just so pointless and awkward without any logic or purpose behind it. Don't get me wrong, I will always be furious at the fear campaigns and the house arrest, but what they did to children was beyond forgivable, Hancock masking kids in school because it was easier than having the debate with Sturgeon? Just throw the kids under the bus so Hancock could avoid public debate.

TrashedSofa · 20/09/2023 08:40

In terms of the funnelling more money towards research and development, the commission have tried their best to emphasise that. Understandably so, because pretty much everyone thinks this could've been done better. One of the most striking things we know is how much we don't know, still.

But they've not really linked the two convincingly. The stuff they're proposing appears to be free access, and the benefits they posit wouldn't exist if people were going to be financially excluded. I can't see them going for sponsorship for it, either. These things are going to cost money, not make it. And nobody has really explained why a day of reflection, which we know full well would be divisive, is going to facilitate any of this.

TrashedSofa · 20/09/2023 08:36

Sparklecats · 20/09/2023 00:31

Well no @1dayatatime you can expect the death toll to be higher because we may have a major outbreak of a hemorrhagic fever virus.

And I suspect they will be preparing army support and the like to deal with that scenario and will have lockdown conditions where fatality is >10% sewn up. So good luck with this idea of rule breaking in the event of a major outbreak with high pathogenicity 👍

Good luck with the army support and the like happening in the event of a major outbreak with high pathogenicity!

Honestly, in that situation, all bets are off.

WestwardHo1 · 20/09/2023 08:22

Sparklecats · 20/09/2023 00:41

@WestwardHo1

To my mind the suggestions serve 3 purposes

  1. give some closure to relatives of the deceased - particularly when they often did not get to say goodbye to loved ones etc and blame the gov… this is the gov doing “something” to recognise the loss.

  2. keep the pandemic in the public psyche because the spectre of further disease outbreaks - and more serious disease at that - is looming and the public being lulled into total relaxation isn’t going to help manage them in future/help them survive.

  3. funnel some money towards R&D and increasing cohesion between scientists and gov, which is hugely important to avoid cock ups.

And this will be achieved through enforced silences?

Perhaps more effective governance might be more effective?

VeryGoodVeryNice · 20/09/2023 00:43

One of my FB memories popped up where I lamented the bag restrictions at DD’s primary school. No rucksacks allowed, because they were very covid-y. So they could take their things in in carrier bags instead (same one every day), as they seemed to possess covid-repelling properties. However, bizarrely they were allowed to take book bags in, which are made out of the same material of rucksacks 🤷‍♀️

Sparklecats · 20/09/2023 00:41

WestwardHo1 · 19/09/2023 20:11

So will all this be proved if we are compelled to have an annual silence?

@WestwardHo1

To my mind the suggestions serve 3 purposes

  1. give some closure to relatives of the deceased - particularly when they often did not get to say goodbye to loved ones etc and blame the gov… this is the gov doing “something” to recognise the loss.

  2. keep the pandemic in the public psyche because the spectre of further disease outbreaks - and more serious disease at that - is looming and the public being lulled into total relaxation isn’t going to help manage them in future/help them survive.

  3. funnel some money towards R&D and increasing cohesion between scientists and gov, which is hugely important to avoid cock ups.

Sparklecats · 20/09/2023 00:34

1dayatatime · 19/09/2023 15:29

@Sparklecats

"I would hope and suspect that following the inquiry and enormous expense that they will be in future."

++++

The Covid enquiry has so far spent £40 million after hearing just 23 days of evidence. The legal fees so far for the 62 assisting lawyers has cost almost £14 million.

@1dayatatime

The cost to us if we fuck up pandemic preparedness in future is potentially billions and complete economic collapse.

I consider the above quotation to be a pretty cheap quote to avert future disaster.

Sparklecats · 20/09/2023 00:31

1dayatatime · 19/09/2023 15:26

@Sparklecats

"It was an extraordinary situation, bud sadly one that we will be getting more used to emergence of diseases from wildlife is escalating. So it is important to remember and learn lessons from the experience. So that we might prepare for future outbreaks of novel diseases, potentially pandemics."

++++

One point I think we can agree on is that future new viruses / diseases will have a more serious impact in terms of death tolls as the population next time will be much less likely to follow the rules or take it seriously - that is until it is too late.

Well no @1dayatatime you can expect the death toll to be higher because we may have a major outbreak of a hemorrhagic fever virus.

And I suspect they will be preparing army support and the like to deal with that scenario and will have lockdown conditions where fatality is >10% sewn up. So good luck with this idea of rule breaking in the event of a major outbreak with high pathogenicity 👍

Yestostructure · 19/09/2023 21:29

One of my strongest memories of Lockdown 1 is having no knowledge of this (working my arse off in a stressful job from home while trying to look after a 5 year old so barely on SM, didn't have freeview etc so not watching news etc) and going for a short walk then everyone started coming out clapping (also setting of fireworks- it was still fucking light FFS) etc and it felt like I was being applauded for going for walk. Only when I was home and my husband said, ah right OK then. Surreal!!

Perhaps we should just pay them more and have made sure they had the correct PPE, that might have made them feel more appreciated...God this country sometimes!

WestwardHo1 · 19/09/2023 20:11

Sparklecats · 19/09/2023 13:52

@Everanewbie just because the residents in your GGMIL’s home survived unscathed does not mean this is was universal - far from it.

Perhaps the home had adequate staffing levels, good infection control and management in general, compliance from visitors etc.

A relative of mine and 4 others in their home died within a month of unvaccinated bank workers bringing covid in. The regular staff were totally traumatised as they had done everything they could to follow guidance to the letter and were massively let down by outside staff.

It is not a matter of just surviving it, there is damage, repeatedly if you get it multiple times, that can compromise your overall health and put you at risk of disease development secondary to the covid infection. Studies have shown that those who were in infected in the first waves would likely be the most adversely affected long term but we won’t see the full disease burden of this until further down the line.

It was really well publicised about the potential danger of new variants. With the rate of cases they had and the threat of the problem getting worse they had to preserve hospital capacity and prevent the nhs from getting overwhelmed.

All of the information regarding this was freely available, but you would likely only go looking for the detail of it if from an academic/scientific background. Joe bloggs is probably not going to be bothered reading several 50pg reports and updates every week.

So will all this be proved if we are compelled to have an annual silence?

1dayatatime · 19/09/2023 19:20

@Slothmoth
@ALongHardWinter

Yes the taxpayer is paying for the inquiry. Given the first 23 days of the inquiry has cost £40 million and it is not due to finish until 2026 I think the Covid inquiry will easily end up being the most expensive Government inquiry ever.

Slothmoth · 19/09/2023 17:55

I think it's fine, there's lots of lessons to be learnt from covid and lockdown I don't think we should forget about it otherwise it was all for nothing.

ALongHardWinter · 19/09/2023 16:58

Totally bonkers. And it's the great British public who will be paying for it,I presume?

TrashedSofa · 19/09/2023 16:30

1dayatatime · 19/09/2023 15:26

@Sparklecats

"It was an extraordinary situation, bud sadly one that we will be getting more used to emergence of diseases from wildlife is escalating. So it is important to remember and learn lessons from the experience. So that we might prepare for future outbreaks of novel diseases, potentially pandemics."

++++

One point I think we can agree on is that future new viruses / diseases will have a more serious impact in terms of death tolls as the population next time will be much less likely to follow the rules or take it seriously - that is until it is too late.

That is a possibility we have to give very serious consideration to.

1dayatatime · 19/09/2023 15:29

@Sparklecats

"I would hope and suspect that following the inquiry and enormous expense that they will be in future."

++++

The Covid enquiry has so far spent £40 million after hearing just 23 days of evidence. The legal fees so far for the 62 assisting lawyers has cost almost £14 million.

1dayatatime · 19/09/2023 15:26

@Sparklecats

"It was an extraordinary situation, bud sadly one that we will be getting more used to emergence of diseases from wildlife is escalating. So it is important to remember and learn lessons from the experience. So that we might prepare for future outbreaks of novel diseases, potentially pandemics."

++++

One point I think we can agree on is that future new viruses / diseases will have a more serious impact in terms of death tolls as the population next time will be much less likely to follow the rules or take it seriously - that is until it is too late.

Sparklecats · 19/09/2023 14:23

1dayatatime · 19/09/2023 14:00

@Sparklecats

"A relative of mine and 4 others in their home died within a month of unvaccinated bank workers bringing covid in"

+++

Look the Covid vaccine doesn't prevent you catching or transmitting the Covid virus, it simply means that if you do get Covid then the symptoms are less severe and your chances of dying are therefore lower. So whether the bank workers were vaccinated or not it wouldn't have made much difference, if they had tested themselves before hand then that would have made more sense.

@Sparklecats - I honestly think it would be better if you did what everyone is doing namely quietly admit to yourself that we panicked, blindly followed rules and embarrassingly all got a bit swept up in the mass hysteria and that the best thing to do now is to try and forget about it and pretend it never happened.

The vaccine doesn’t just prevent you from having more severe symptoms. Unvaccinated are 20x more likely to pass on infection. For a vaccinated person you can expect to see peak viral load shedding fall within a day, whereas unvaccinated it’s much longer so the viral load transmitted to those in close proximity is much greater and more likely to cause others serious harm.

Apparently the girls were at an all night rave (obviously against restrictions), then they came into the home. Hard to know if they would have faked their tests but they should never have been there in the first place.

I’m sorry to tell you but my background as a biologist won’t allow me to think that, because I didn’t follow rules blindly… I read around the data as much as I could to communicate what was going on to my family, some of whom like you were doubtful. From what I read at the time there really wasn’t anyway around implementing restrictions.

It was an extraordinary situation, bud sadly one that we will be getting more used to emergence of diseases from wildlife is escalating. So it is important to remember and learn lessons from the experience. So that we might prepare for future outbreaks of novel diseases, potentially pandemics.

If you look at Asia they are experiencing things like this pretty frequently, that is coming our way.

snowlady4 · 19/09/2023 14:13

Hillarious thread!
Agree, ridiculous suggestion from our government. Not surprising. Money to burn.
An annual comedy show would be more appropriate.

Sparklecats · 19/09/2023 14:11

1dayatatime · 19/09/2023 12:57

@Sparklecats

"Had we had a stable virus with limited scope for dangerous mutation in smaller outbreaks, with plenty of healthcare capacity I would probably agree with you.

But we didn’t"

+++

Exactly the same argument could be used for flu each winter but we don't shut down the country every winter because there isn't the same level of mass hysteria.

That is because flu has been circulating for years and there would be some level of immunity both via vaccination and natural immunity to protect the population to some extent even if you had a variant emerge that caused more severe or widespread illness it would unlikely be so genetically distinct so as to overcome all immune defence.

Covid-19 by contrast was a novel virus with high transmissibility, released upon a naive population of 8 billion, giving it a free for all to evolve quickly… considering fatality rates of 10-35% in SARS and MERS which are closely related, the transmissibility and complete lack of immunity in the global population caution was required.

Failings, so far as I am concerned, were a lack of pandemic preparedness, lack of investment in research and development, and lack of cohesion across government departments which made the formulation and implementation of control measures difficult and somewhat shambolic.

There was plenty of notice something like this was going to happen, the plans should have been ready made and good to go to protect us and give as little disruption as possible.

I would hope and suspect that following the inquiry and enormous expense that they will be in future.

1dayatatime · 19/09/2023 14:00

@Sparklecats

"A relative of mine and 4 others in their home died within a month of unvaccinated bank workers bringing covid in"

+++

Look the Covid vaccine doesn't prevent you catching or transmitting the Covid virus, it simply means that if you do get Covid then the symptoms are less severe and your chances of dying are therefore lower. So whether the bank workers were vaccinated or not it wouldn't have made much difference, if they had tested themselves before hand then that would have made more sense.

@Sparklecats - I honestly think it would be better if you did what everyone is doing namely quietly admit to yourself that we panicked, blindly followed rules and embarrassingly all got a bit swept up in the mass hysteria and that the best thing to do now is to try and forget about it and pretend it never happened.

Sparklecats · 19/09/2023 14:00

This paper for example from 2021 was written about in most newspapers and obviously published on gov website as is by sage and discusses the possible evolutionary trajectories, their likelihood and control measures.

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1007566/S1335_Long_term_evolution_of_SARS-CoV-2.pdf

I studied SARS and MERS so maybe would have been more aware of the underlying reasons for restrictions and control measures… but do remember there being clear information regarding current threat, potential threat and healthcare capacity in relation to these.

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1007566/S1335_Long_term_evolution_of_SARS-CoV-2.pdf