Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(Covid) To think these recommendations are bonkers?

659 replies

NoCharnce · 18/09/2023 12:11

So the government commission into how to memorialise the Covid pandemic has recommended the government implement “A UK-wide day of reflection should be established and held annually.”

Other recommendations include national memorials (10 sites already identified!), oral histories and museums plus additional funding for local authorities to set up their own memorials.

I can’t be the only one who thinks this is nuts and hope the government ignores the recommendations? I genuinely cannot believe people get paid to produce this crap.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
WestwardHo1 · 23/09/2023 17:59

@JenniferBooth speaks for a hell of a lot of people.

No amount of patronising insults, belittling language and yawning emojis changes that.

WhalePolo · 23/09/2023 16:42

“Chris Dye, professor of epidemiology at the University of Oxford, who led the review on masks for the Royal Society, said if they had only looked at randomized controlled trials they would have come to the same conclusion as the Cochrane review. But the researchers behind the paper released Thursday chose to analyze a larger body of studies and found strong evidence that masks work. “

WhalePolo · 23/09/2023 16:41

“The most effective measure, according to the review, was one of the most controversial — restrictions on movement and social interactions through lockdowns, distancing and rules around the size of gatherings. These were repeatedly found to be associated with a “significant reduction” in transmission of the virus, with the more stringent the measure, the greater the effect.“

CwmYoy · 23/09/2023 16:07

I would like memorial gardens to remember the family members we lost.

I will never forgive the mask dodgers who passed Covid around through their ignorance. Too many people taken before their time.

WhalePolo · 23/09/2023 15:55

“Measures taken during the Covid pandemic such as social distancing and wearing face masks “unequivocally” reduced the spread of infections, a report has found.
Experts looked at the effectiveness of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) – not drugs or vaccines – when applied in packages that combine a number of measures that complement one another.
The Royal Society report, called Covid-19: examining the effectiveness of non-pharmaceutical interventions, reviewed the evidence gathered during the pandemic for six groups of NPIs and their effectiveness in reducing transmission.”

JenniferBooth · 23/09/2023 14:46

The "dont be put off by DM" Will remember that!

WhalePolo · 23/09/2023 03:32

@Sparklecats

That’s a good article. Not sure about the Daily Mail Covid coverage in general though. They tend to feature ‘studies’ by the likes of Steve Hanke with strong economic bias.

I’ve not seen an anti-lockdowner yet who doesn’t just ‘gloss over’ the collapsing hospitals/virus with no method of control - or have an alternative solution to that issue. They tend to have an individualistic rant and then only side with any hardship caused by lockdown, whist conveniently ignoring any adverse effects that no lockdown would have caused.
Or think that it was something cooked up purely by our government - and not looking at the global scale of the issue.

Sparklecats · 23/09/2023 00:43

Article just out by Kate Bingham underlining the urgency for pandemic preparedness, puts things in layman’s terms.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-12551251/amp/pandemic-disease-x-covid.html

Don’t be put off by DM, whoever their science editor is is very good and they are quicker at putting out info and in more details than other well known outlets.

Next pandemic is coming and it could kill millions more than Covid

To combat Disease X - as the WHO calls it - we will once again need vaccines to be engineered and delivered in record time. But, as things stand, there is no guarantee that will happen.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-12551251/amp/pandemic-disease-x-covid.html

1dayatatime · 21/09/2023 09:51

@EasternStandard
@TrashedSofa

At the time I remember any concerns being raised about the impact of the measures on children (school closures, club closures etc) being dismissed as:

"Children are resilient, they'll bounce back"

"Any impacts are not as severe their parents dying and being orphaned "

There will be additional catch up funding for education

www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-57335558.amp

user1497207191 · 21/09/2023 09:48

EasternStandard · 21/09/2023 09:14

I did submit and mentioned dc but hadn’t thought about under 18 doing their own

There was no allocated voice for children, every sector had their own, unions and everyone demanding their needs were listened to

One big gap was no set up for young people. Whatever the enquiry unearths I hope it addresses this and we learn from it

I hope that it also examines the appalling way in which Uni students were treated. They were conned and lied to by the Unis to get them to sign up for expensive Uni accommodation and once the contracts/payments were made, some Unis changed their websites which previously promised blended learning, i.e. a mix of in-person and online, and removed the "in person" promises. That left students paying for expensive Uni accommodation but no actual need or use to be at the Uni because literally everything was online and the Unis knew that a couple of months before, because they'd told lecturers etc that they'd be working online and not on campus. Money grabbing bastards!

EasternStandard · 21/09/2023 09:14

TrashedSofa · 21/09/2023 08:13

If you wanted to talk about people’s roles and how they responded who would you talk to to understand the impact on children? That was the issue, no group or senior person existed as the voice of children.

Well however they reckon they're going to achieve this, it doesn't currently include accepting personal submissions from anyone under 18 in the listening exercise.

https://www.savethechildren.org.uk/blogs/2023/include-children-in-covid19-inquiry

Supposedly they're in the process of designing something to 'engage with children and young people'.

https://covid19.public-inquiry.uk/every-story-matters/

Taking a while over it, though.

I did submit and mentioned dc but hadn’t thought about under 18 doing their own

There was no allocated voice for children, every sector had their own, unions and everyone demanding their needs were listened to

One big gap was no set up for young people. Whatever the enquiry unearths I hope it addresses this and we learn from it

TrashedSofa · 21/09/2023 08:13

If you wanted to talk about people’s roles and how they responded who would you talk to to understand the impact on children? That was the issue, no group or senior person existed as the voice of children.

Well however they reckon they're going to achieve this, it doesn't currently include accepting personal submissions from anyone under 18 in the listening exercise.

https://www.savethechildren.org.uk/blogs/2023/include-children-in-covid19-inquiry

Supposedly they're in the process of designing something to 'engage with children and young people'.

https://covid19.public-inquiry.uk/every-story-matters/

Taking a while over it, though.

Children's Rights Organisations Urge Covid-19 Inquiry To Hear From Children

Leading children’s rights organisations warn Covid-19 Inquiry risks failing to understand the pandemic’s impact if it doesn’t urgently hear from children.

https://www.savethechildren.org.uk/blogs/2023/include-children-in-covid19-inquiry

EasternStandard · 21/09/2023 06:38

From the little I heard of the enquiry at the beginning politicians on all sides sounded like they were playing politics

There was a film at the beginning setting the scene reminding people of ‘loved ones’ (bad term but it was soppy)

If you wanted to talk about people’s roles and how they responded who would you talk to to understand the impact on children? That was the issue, no group or senior person existed as the voice of children.

Those things concern me, if we are weighing up damage from all this there needs to not be a tip towards one side, although it’s not been reported on for a while so maybe it’s improved

DameWhiskers · 21/09/2023 03:01

@JenniferBooth

a. im entitled to my opinion But you have demonstrated my point beautifully that it wasnt enough to follow the restrictions We had to like them as well. And yes i damn well will say something about what I had to follow.

Pardon? I've not heard this one before.

Sparklecats · 20/09/2023 23:21

1dayatatime · 20/09/2023 23:13

@Sparklecats

"We generated 786bn in tax in 22/23 alone…. The inquiry runs for what 4yrs… and you’re worried about 1bn. When the insights garnered from this will contribute to us being properly prepared for pandemics, potentially save trillions and prevent economic collapse. "

+++

Alternatively the insights garnered from this inquiry are ignored because "well it happened so long ago", put to one side because another crisis is more important in 2026, dismissed as hindsight or lastly great ideas but unfortunately the Government doesn't have the money to implement them.

Meaning the inquiry was a waste of time and taxpayers money for everyone.

Plausible scenario.

But I’m trying to be optimistic.

Perhaps the Tories will be out by then.

1dayatatime · 20/09/2023 23:13

@Sparklecats

"We generated 786bn in tax in 22/23 alone…. The inquiry runs for what 4yrs… and you’re worried about 1bn. When the insights garnered from this will contribute to us being properly prepared for pandemics, potentially save trillions and prevent economic collapse. "

+++

Alternatively the insights garnered from this inquiry are ignored because "well it happened so long ago", put to one side because another crisis is more important in 2026, dismissed as hindsight or lastly great ideas but unfortunately the Government doesn't have the money to implement them.

Meaning the inquiry was a waste of time and taxpayers money for everyone.

Sparklecats · 20/09/2023 22:59

1dayatatime · 20/09/2023 21:56

@Sparklecats

The Covid enquiry has so far spent £40 million after hearing just 23 days of evidence. The legal fees so far for the 62 assisting lawyers has cost almost £14 million.

@1dayatatime

The cost to us if we fuck up pandemic preparedness in future is potentially billions and complete economic collapse.

I consider the above quotation to be a pretty cheap quote to avert future disaster.

+++

I don't think you understand that the Covid inquiry has SO FAR spent £40 million hearing 23 days of evidence.

Given that the inquiry is not due to finish until 2026 then I am sure you can do the maths that the final cost of the inquiry will be staggering- my guess is somewhere around £1 billion.

We generated 786bn in tax in 22/23 alone…. The inquiry runs for what 4yrs… and you’re worried about 1bn. When the insights garnered from this will contribute to us being properly prepared for pandemics, potentially save trillions and prevent economic collapse.

I think it’s really important and I think it’s money well spent. But I respect that you feel differently.

JenniferBooth · 20/09/2023 22:38

Ingognito im sorry for your loss Flowers

ingognito82 · 20/09/2023 22:36

My husband was admitted to hospital where he caught Covid and died during the pandemic.
I think an annual day of reflection where people can either get upset or argue is a horrible idea.
It's terrible that people who were doing their jobs were given inadequate PPI and some died but I still think an annual remembrance day is not a good idea.
Perhaps the government could reflect on how they treat public servants?
Personally, I can reflect at my leisure and in private.

Wakintoblueskies · 20/09/2023 22:19

LoobyDop · 18/09/2023 12:52

Memorial Day agenda

09:00 one hour of exercise (max)
10:00 queuing in a car park
11:00 coffee and cheese
12:00 break for lunch. Plans will depend on tier status.
13:00 shout at people on Mumsnet
14:00 PPE knitting circle
15:00 government briefing (subject to timely conclusion of lunchtime party essential team meeting
16:00 pan banging

Don't forget the obligation to make banana bread!!!

Sparklecats · 20/09/2023 22:17

Agree with you @TrashedSofa that we did not have all the expertise needed, nor the infrastructure, funding etc to be able to deal with a pandemic well. Austerity, compartmentalisation across government and a lack of prioritisation led to us being ill equipped.

I am glad of the inquiry and the opportunity to have my say, I did find the situation on very many levels destructive and I wasn’t happy with what happened on a personal level.

Sitting reading the stats every week, every day sometimes, realistically I knew they were backed into a corner.

So it was very conflicting - professionally thinking ok they have no choice something must be done, but personally thinking this is unbearable in every regard.

I really hope that the inquiry is worthwhile. Would be good to have an executive summary for the public to read at the end of the inquiry. I would like to see the outcome of it all.

Does anyone know if there is an opportunity for the public to feedback on these recommendations for the legacy of covid?

Sparklecats · 20/09/2023 22:03

1dayatatime · 20/09/2023 21:50

"But I still think that people who are qualified trying to make the best of a terrible situation is better than a bunch of people with no education experience, or even a biology gcse in some cases trying to shout the odds"

++++

This reminds me of "we need to follow the science" mantra at the time, as if "science" is the one truth and forgetting that in science there are different views. During COVID any scientific view that differed from the orthodoxy of the "one prevailing true science " was dismissed as anti vaxx, COVID deniers or peddling false information.

In particular I remember the criticism levelled at the NHS doctor saying that he wouldn't be having the vaccine as there wasn't much point given he had already had Covid:

amp.theguardian.com/politics/2022/jan/08/nhs-doctor-challenges-sajid-javid-over-covid-vaccination-rules

Lastly with regards to your comment about "people with no education experience, or even a biology gcse in some cases trying to shout the odds" , you don't really need a biology gcse to realise that using an anti bacterial hand gel to counter an airborne virus is going to have bugger all benefit, in fact you just need to read the sodding label. But again when pointed out at the time it was shouted down as anti vaxx / covid denier.

Just to give feedback on the transmission pathway.

In the beginning covid was a novel virus and transmission pathways were not elucidated.

While airborne transmission as the main route is now well established, in the beginning this was not the case.

Therefore guidance given was typical for infection control, which includes sanitiser.

Most recent discussion around transmission via fomites suggests the risk is low but can’t be totally dismissed.

You can find the papers yourself there are plenty.

TrashedSofa · 20/09/2023 22:03

I think we pretty much have to have an enquiry though. It was inevitable.

1dayatatime · 20/09/2023 21:56

@Sparklecats

The Covid enquiry has so far spent £40 million after hearing just 23 days of evidence. The legal fees so far for the 62 assisting lawyers has cost almost £14 million.

@1dayatatime

The cost to us if we fuck up pandemic preparedness in future is potentially billions and complete economic collapse.

I consider the above quotation to be a pretty cheap quote to avert future disaster.

+++

I don't think you understand that the Covid inquiry has SO FAR spent £40 million hearing 23 days of evidence.

Given that the inquiry is not due to finish until 2026 then I am sure you can do the maths that the final cost of the inquiry will be staggering- my guess is somewhere around £1 billion.