Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(Covid) To think these recommendations are bonkers?

659 replies

NoCharnce · 18/09/2023 12:11

So the government commission into how to memorialise the Covid pandemic has recommended the government implement “A UK-wide day of reflection should be established and held annually.”

Other recommendations include national memorials (10 sites already identified!), oral histories and museums plus additional funding for local authorities to set up their own memorials.

I can’t be the only one who thinks this is nuts and hope the government ignores the recommendations? I genuinely cannot believe people get paid to produce this crap.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 01:20

WhalePolo · 24/09/2023 00:41

@Sparklecats

I’m not a fan of Unherd/Daily Telegraph - and I’m sorry but the justification given by Unherd to the constituency map results reminded me of the same logic used by the likes of Russell Brand to justify their anti lockdown stance.

Which is political - whether people like it or not, or want to cross off their bingo card - rather than giving an adequate explanation as to why: it’s the likes of reformUK/Trump/Elon Musk/Laurence Fox/Farage/Brand who are vehemently anti-lockdown. Who say they champion free speech until someone says something they don’t like. It stinks of survival of the fittest : that other people are dispensable or should die - so long as I’m not uncomfortable and so long as my well being is protected.
It’s an economic right wing argument whether people like it or not.
I’m very willing to be told I’m wrong. I want to be wrong. But I haven’t heard a decent, balanced, unbiased explanation yet…

@WhalePolo looking at the unherd methodology the first thing I would say is that it is too vague to properly critique. The sample size and their justification of it would be my first port of call if I were looking at it. I haven’t used MRP so I wouldn’t know offhand what would be standard but it strikes me they may not have done this with the explanation there. Also would be looking at how unbiased the online platform used to gather responses is.

Personally if I were looking at it, as somebody with no prior knowledge of Unherd, I wouldn’t rate it without further understanding of their methodology… which obviously I am not going to investigate at this time; I’m going to bed lol

WhalePolo · 24/09/2023 01:16

And @JenniferBooth - your stance is putting the economic welfare of a social housing tenant above the health needs of anyone needing urgent access to hospital treatment or in a life or death situation. Which could also be deemed as ‘snobbish’. Your stance would also result in overall better outcomes for the ‘middle class’ and elites. At the expense of a resulting high death toll and collapsing hospitals that can’t treat vulnerable patients.

WhalePolo · 24/09/2023 01:03

It’s absolutely ridiculous to assume that anyone supporting lockdown was a middle class snob. The overwhelming and vast majority were doing it because they were trying to prevent hospitalisations and deaths.

@JenniferBooth

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 01:03

JenniferBooth · 24/09/2023 00:51

so unless you are a barrister or a doctor or a financier you cant understand restrictions and the reasoning behind them And you have the absolute cheek to label others as far right.

People who live in social housing are the supermarket workers the Amazon drivers who brought you your shit during lockdowns Of course they understood restrictions They had to

@JenniferBooth I am using those examples because those professions will have passed their GCSEs, A Levels and have higher education to post graduate level.

The sort of information imparted via the government would be easily understood and furthermore with an academic background you would have research experience and know where to begin gathering your own evidence independent of that given out by the gov, discriminating between reliable/unreliable sources, and forming sound opinions.

It is of course going to be harder for someone of less educational background and it will put them more at risk.

Also to say that all supermarket workers and Amazon workers are socially housed is biased - I know several, they all have mortgages.

JenniferBooth · 24/09/2023 00:58

Well hopefully next time you will get what you wish for and those in social housing who do those jobs i mentioned will lock down too.

JenniferBooth · 24/09/2023 00:51

so unless you are a barrister or a doctor or a financier you cant understand restrictions and the reasoning behind them And you have the absolute cheek to label others as far right.

People who live in social housing are the supermarket workers the Amazon drivers who brought you your shit during lockdowns Of course they understood restrictions They had to

JenniferBooth · 24/09/2023 00:48

Anyone else enjoying the well left critique of those who live in social housing.

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 00:47

JenniferBooth · 24/09/2023 00:39

Sally’s level of education may be low and therefore understanding and following restrictions and the reasoning behind them may be difficult

And there it is folks!!!!! Just because someone lives in social housing.

@JenniferBooth so you are telling me that the majority of people in social housing are highly qualified, high
earning barristers, doctors, financiers etc?

I did say may, of course you will have highly qualified who have become disabled or had chance hard times but for the most part they buy their own homes and are not in social housing.

WhalePolo · 24/09/2023 00:41

@Sparklecats

I’m not a fan of Unherd/Daily Telegraph - and I’m sorry but the justification given by Unherd to the constituency map results reminded me of the same logic used by the likes of Russell Brand to justify their anti lockdown stance.

Which is political - whether people like it or not, or want to cross off their bingo card - rather than giving an adequate explanation as to why: it’s the likes of reformUK/Trump/Elon Musk/Laurence Fox/Farage/Brand who are vehemently anti-lockdown. Who say they champion free speech until someone says something they don’t like. It stinks of survival of the fittest : that other people are dispensable or should die - so long as I’m not uncomfortable and so long as my well being is protected.
It’s an economic right wing argument whether people like it or not.
I’m very willing to be told I’m wrong. I want to be wrong. But I haven’t heard a decent, balanced, unbiased explanation yet…

JenniferBooth · 24/09/2023 00:39

Sally’s level of education may be low and therefore understanding and following restrictions and the reasoning behind them may be difficult

And there it is folks!!!!! Just because someone lives in social housing.

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 00:35

JenniferBooth · 23/09/2023 23:09

SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO how many of you are willing to be part of a campaign to end the bedroom tax for good to enable more room for isolation next time

Sparkle? You up for it!!!!!!!!!!!!

@JenniferBooth

I think bringing the bedroom tax into this isn’t wholly appropriate..

The point being if you have working class Sally let’s say in a 2 bed terrace home and you do away with the bedroom tax which allows her to have a 3 bed terrace home - that isn’t really going to have a massive input to her ability to isolate properly and protect herself.

  1. Sally’s house still has one bathroom and one kitchen. Unless she gets a portable loo, endless food supply, and means of cooking in there it’s going to be hard to isolate without opening the door to others.
  2. She still may be living with a large (for the given space) family in confined conditions.
  3. Her neighbours are in close proximity to her and everyone is coughing so windows are open - it’s airborne so you have amplified risk from adjoining properties.
  4. Adding an additional room 3x3x2.3 room gives you an additional 20.7m3 of potential airspace for the dispersal of covid viral particles which isn’t a wild lot of a difference.
  5. Sally likely has much stronger family and community ties and will rely on them more than say an upper class person and breaking these will be more difficult.
  6. Sally’s level of education may be low and therefore understanding and following restrictions and the reasoning behind them may be difficult.
  7. Sally may have experienced a myriad of negative experiences and this may have led to her being distrusting of the government and therefore less likely to follow guidance for her own protection.

Meanwhile John who lives in a detached property in the country with no close neighbours converted his garage to an annexe a while back so he or his family members can use this or his caravan, or his holiday home to isolate safely….

Do you see? An extra bedroom in a very small council house with the social circumstances surrounding makes sod all difference.

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 00:14

WhalePolo · 23/09/2023 19:46

@TrashedSofa

I’m just surprised! Ok Unherd’s take on the data there is still lockdown = bad. “So why, three years on, do most people not share this conclusion? Partly because most people haven’t seen the evidence. Nor will they. The media and political establishment were so encouraging of lockdowns at the time that their only critique was that they weren’t hard enough. They are hardly going to acknowledge such a grave mistake now. Nor do I expect the inquiry to ask the right questions : obfuscation and distraction will continue and mea culpas will never arrive.”

So pretty much “the general population are sheep and don’t question the narrative unlike me. Me the extra special person who can see through the media. Follow me and come be part of my cult” type line that’s also been the mantra of certain vile comedian in the news.

@WhalePolo Why exactly are you bringing Russell Brand into this?!

Look I am telling you, as a person who is not a Professor, but is well enough trained. That I looked at the stats in Jan of 2020, practically shat myself and got on the phone to relatives abroad telling them get the fuck home this is nuclear.

If you have studied zoonotic disease and virology in any respect you’d realise a coronavirus’s capacity to evolve quickly, particularly given the size of the host population and transmissibility.

There being a realistic chance of the fatality rate increasing to something akin to SARS or MERS was just plain horrifying.

Catastrophic. Especially considering the complete lack of therapeutics.

Lockdowns prevent not only deaths/disease but also slow evolution of the virus. We were incredibly lucky we had a scaffolding of sorts with which to develop vaccines. And we are incredibly lucky that as yet variants have had a low fatality rate.

I hope that our luck holds out and that we are able to establish a structure whereby we would be set to develop vaccines/therapeutics quickly towards whatever diseases emerge in future.

To have not had lockdowns considering the threat/lack of any real way of fighting it would have been imbecilic and utterly irresponsible, not only for the health and well being of our own people, but for those worldwide.

Obviously the trade offs involved need to be properly analysed and a robust plan developed for the future.

What happened was unprecedented and under the circumstances I don’t see what other way it could have been handled. The fine details changed maybe. But the main headline restrictions, not so much.

To be clear, I was not a sheep, I questioned the narrative, I read 100s of papers during nights when I couldn’t sleep because of the negative impact the restrictions were having on my life. I applied everything I had ever learnt to the situation and I read widely. I came to the conclusion that there was FA else we could be doing than what we were doing.

EasternStandard · 23/09/2023 23:58

Sparklecats · 23/09/2023 23:53

@TrashedSofa I am again agreeing!!

One of the biggest frustrations in science is getting anything to go forward into policy, and even when it does it might not remotely resemble the initial output from research.

Very often the science is sound, but to put that into policy would not forward political objectives and so it goes by the wayside. I’m talking everything from conservation policy to disease control. Really frustrating.

By political it’s more that decisions cannot be based on science alone because there are a raft of societal considerations which need to be taken into account for a pandemic

I used it initially in the broadest sense. Eg science feeds in to but isn’t the only factor in decisions.

I felt Whitty and co spoke well on that

Sparklecats · 23/09/2023 23:53

TrashedSofa · 23/09/2023 19:18

Very true. It's extremely naive to think the way we manage pandemics could somehow not be political. That was true of covid and it will be true with the next one that comes along.

@TrashedSofa I am again agreeing!!

One of the biggest frustrations in science is getting anything to go forward into policy, and even when it does it might not remotely resemble the initial output from research.

Very often the science is sound, but to put that into policy would not forward political objectives and so it goes by the wayside. I’m talking everything from conservation policy to disease control. Really frustrating.

WhalePolo · 23/09/2023 23:44

So what’s the solution then? An out of control virus, no method of control and hospitals that are collapsing under the strain.

People aren’t supporting lockdown or mask wearing to be lofty or sneery : they are doing it because they want don’t want others to die, get seriously ill and so that hospitals could provide care to their patients.
According to that constituency map, people DON’T think lockdown was a mistake. So I’m not sure who this ‘entire population’ refers to…

Sparklecats · 23/09/2023 23:43

TrashedSofa · 23/09/2023 18:29

Some of the Royal Society report conclusions are more tenuous than others, but they were obviously right about how lockdowns worked to get cases down. Because anything that reduces contacts will do that. Especially for the less contagious strains- I accept the picture becomes a bit more complex with something as contagious as Omicron, although most places had stopped locking down by then anyway. But broadly, it holds.

Just as important is what they said about how what we will need to do is decide whether the negatives are worth the positives. Which probably is going to involve some value judgements about what to prioritise, even way into the future when we have a fuller picture of the downsides of both covid and restrictions.

@TrashedSofa

I completely agree with this. Feel like they need some sort of algorithm to follow according to parameters of potential diseases.

i.e. novel disease has X fatality rate, Y transmissibility and hospital capacity is Z therefore we implement plan 2.3.7.

Once they have the inquiry and a sound cost benefit analysis this sort of thing could be easily done.

WomblingTree86 · 23/09/2023 23:22

Calistano · 18/09/2023 12:56

Blah blah so tedious, seriously after that cruise ship, which was handily a perfect model of how covid spread/killed it was blatantly obvious it was just another virus, not doomsday. Most propagandised event in history.

Given 9 people out of the 700 who caught died, the death rate was a lot higher than flu.

JenniferBooth · 23/09/2023 23:17

Oh and in future you pay people their whole wage plus a bit extra to self isolate.

JenniferBooth · 23/09/2023 23:14

Hi @WestwardHo1 Hope you are keeping ok Flowers

JenniferBooth · 23/09/2023 23:13

15 pages in and this didnt even occur to people who claim to care so much.

JenniferBooth · 23/09/2023 23:10

You heard it here first folks its people on the right who want to end the bedroom tax Apparently!

JenniferBooth · 23/09/2023 23:09

SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO how many of you are willing to be part of a campaign to end the bedroom tax for good to enable more room for isolation next time

Sparkle? You up for it!!!!!!!!!!!!

WestwardHo1 · 23/09/2023 23:07

And I don't doubt that there's another pandemic coming that will be more serious.

Governments, especially the UK one, have ruined any kind of pandemic preparedness by their nonsensical illogical rules during the last one, and their insistence that it was the big one, despite it being clear pretty early in that it was not. They have alienated and made sceptical entire populations. THAT'S the worrying thing

JenniferBooth · 23/09/2023 23:06

People using vulnerable people as a tool to emotionally blackmail others while not giving a fuck about them the rest of the time.

AND i cant help noticing that the concern about some of us living in smaller places so couldnt self isolate have not yet developed into a campaign about people being allowed to live in bigger homes where they can self isolate more easily. e,g the bedroom tax still stands. Its funny how certain people didnt/dont want to follow up their faux concern with more room for social housing tenants to self isolate. We could start with a new campaign to end bedroom tax for good. I wonder how many of the middle class who loved lockdown but denigrate SH tenants would put their money where their mouths are for this!!!