Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(Covid) To think these recommendations are bonkers?

659 replies

NoCharnce · 18/09/2023 12:11

So the government commission into how to memorialise the Covid pandemic has recommended the government implement “A UK-wide day of reflection should be established and held annually.”

Other recommendations include national memorials (10 sites already identified!), oral histories and museums plus additional funding for local authorities to set up their own memorials.

I can’t be the only one who thinks this is nuts and hope the government ignores the recommendations? I genuinely cannot believe people get paid to produce this crap.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
WomblingTree86 · 24/09/2023 11:02

EasternStandard · 24/09/2023 10:55

I don’t think that tallies with reactions, particularly around schools and demands for closures across various places

Without daily deaths we’d have seen different behaviour

The fact that some people wanted schools to close to reduce overall deaths doesn't mean they weren't aware that the young and healthy weren't personally at high risk.

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 10:55

Dontcallmescarface · 24/09/2023 05:51

Not forgetting care workers, hospital porter/cleaners etc....the ones who actually had to deal with the impact of covid on a daily basis and whose risk of catching it was a lot higher than a fucking barrister or financier.

@Dontcallmescarface

There was a strong correlation between social deprivation and development of covid infection/hospitalisation/vaccine hesitancy.

Essentially you had people from certain areas in cramped housing, limited money for sanitiser/masks, limited comprehension of the biology behind restrictions/vaccine development, distrustful of the government, and working in jobs where they would be more exposed.

I think education needs be be a major factor in trying to protect people from socially deprived backgrounds in future. Be that via public outreach or school. It needs to be hammered home.

I was at an extended family funeral (DH’s) during the covid period.

Myself and DH stood outside the tiny terrace house. All the rest went in were sitting in a room 3x3 room with the coffin, touching the body. The person died after being in intensive care for several weeks with covid (restrictions had lifted to a certain extent but still advised do not go into homes where over X people present etc, and the number in a church limited). At the church people did comply but at the house before the church it was complete bedlam and they all ignored the advice because they thought covid was a cold and didn’t trust the government. Then they wondered why many of them got sick a week or so later 🤷‍♀️

EasternStandard · 24/09/2023 10:55

WomblingTree86 · 24/09/2023 10:48

I think most posters on mn knew that the young and healthy weren't at high risk.

I don’t think that tallies with reactions, particularly around schools and demands for closures across various places

Without daily deaths we’d have seen different behaviour

Theunamedcat · 24/09/2023 10:55

BusyBees1234 · 18/09/2023 12:31

Why not post in the Covid section?

Because its about money not covid as such? Because as a tax payer you will be expected to pay for this and it should be put out publicly not shunted off to one side under all things covid

WomblingTree86 · 24/09/2023 10:48

I think most posters on mn knew that the young and healthy weren't at high risk.

EasternStandard · 24/09/2023 10:40

WomblingTree86 · 24/09/2023 10:17

I think the messages were clear although I'm sure it depends on what you read.

What do you mean, what was clear?

The overriding daily message was the death and case count as a good way to get high compliance

It worked. Incredibly well.

It was a huge part of the pandemic response and filtered on to mn daily. Which message was stronger than that for you?

(personally I did listen to risk messaging as I could see why they were using the campaign but that doesn’t mean I couldn’t see the huge impact of of the above)

WomblingTree86 · 24/09/2023 10:17

EasternStandard · 24/09/2023 10:06

That may be true. And you could have taken that into account when deciding on what to do

If the messaging had not been fear based but just accurately showing risk

I think the messages were clear although I'm sure it depends on what you read.

WomblingTree86 · 24/09/2023 10:15

WestwardHo1 · 24/09/2023 09:43

And yet you had physically healthy people who barely went out for months/years other than for vaccinations, who were still petrified of catching it. That sounds proportionate to you?

I don't know anyone who was young and physically healthy and "petrified" of catching it themselves to the extent they barely went out for months/years. Most young healthy people understood that they were not personally at high risk after the first couple of months.

EasternStandard · 24/09/2023 10:06

WomblingTree86 · 24/09/2023 10:04

You're assuming everyone is only interested in their personal risk though. Most people would have had close family members of friends who were at much higher risk and they were very concerned about them.

That may be true. And you could have taken that into account when deciding on what to do

If the messaging had not been fear based but just accurately showing risk

WomblingTree86 · 24/09/2023 10:04

EasternStandard · 24/09/2023 09:27

They are I agree

But the Covid response leaned heavily on messaging to provoke fear over risk

Everyone’s risk was not high but use of daily death and case counts was the most effective behaviour change programme I’ve ever seen

That was a decision made by governments which fed into public demands. You could see it on mn throughout, daily threads on numbers etc

To put it another way if we’d reacted by personal risk and messages had been based on that we’d demand different things

You're assuming everyone is only interested in their personal risk though. Most people would have had close family members of friends who were at much higher risk and they were very concerned about them.

WestwardHo1 · 24/09/2023 09:44

Please don't try and re write history.

This happened. The daily death figures show (littered with half truths) was shown to frighten us.

WestwardHo1 · 24/09/2023 09:43

WomblingTree86 · 24/09/2023 09:26

People I know weren't "terrified" by the state or media. They just didn't want to get or vulnerable members of their family to get covid. One of my relatives caught it and died in March 2020 and a middle aged colleague was in ICU.

And yet you had physically healthy people who barely went out for months/years other than for vaccinations, who were still petrified of catching it. That sounds proportionate to you?

Dontcallmescarface · 24/09/2023 09:38

WomblingTree86 · 24/09/2023 09:26

People I know weren't "terrified" by the state or media. They just didn't want to get or vulnerable members of their family to get covid. One of my relatives caught it and died in March 2020 and a middle aged colleague was in ICU.

My (then), 82 year old dad was. When mum died in late March 2020 dad refused to have anyone in the house for 14 days after her death as he was so scared we would get into trouble ("bubbles" weren't a thing then). He was past caring if he caught it and died...he'd just lost the woman he had spent nearly 60 years with. Imagine an elderly man spending 2 weeks grieving alone because the media and state had terrified him into thinking that his daughter could get into trouble just by crossing the threshold of his home. As for the funeral rules back then, well the less said about that the better. We all heard the "thoughts are with the bereaved" line trotted out day after day by Johnson et al but in reality they didn't give a shit about any of us.

TrashedSofa · 24/09/2023 09:37

EasternStandard · 24/09/2023 09:27

They are I agree

But the Covid response leaned heavily on messaging to provoke fear over risk

Everyone’s risk was not high but use of daily death and case counts was the most effective behaviour change programme I’ve ever seen

That was a decision made by governments which fed into public demands. You could see it on mn throughout, daily threads on numbers etc

To put it another way if we’d reacted by personal risk and messages had been based on that we’d demand different things

Yes I'd definitely expect more attempts to influence public behaviour by messaging, as we saw with covid 19. That's a given. What's less clear is how it would work, particularly after multiple goes.

EasternStandard · 24/09/2023 09:27

TrashedSofa · 24/09/2023 09:15

Harms to society could at least theoretically be factored into that equation. I think the bigger issue is that however well evidenced it might be, governments sooner or later are slaves to public responses. Especially in a democracy. So I think you're right about it only being half of the equation, but a different missing half.

They are I agree

But the Covid response leaned heavily on messaging to provoke fear over risk

Everyone’s risk was not high but use of daily death and case counts was the most effective behaviour change programme I’ve ever seen

That was a decision made by governments which fed into public demands. You could see it on mn throughout, daily threads on numbers etc

To put it another way if we’d reacted by personal risk and messages had been based on that we’d demand different things

WomblingTree86 · 24/09/2023 09:26

WestwardHo1 · 24/09/2023 08:39

Because they had been deliberately terrified by the state and the media.

People I know weren't "terrified" by the state or media. They just didn't want to get or vulnerable members of their family to get covid. One of my relatives caught it and died in March 2020 and a middle aged colleague was in ICU.

TrashedSofa · 24/09/2023 09:15

EasternStandard · 24/09/2023 09:09

I think the X Y equation isn’t a bad way to look at it, better than handing over decisions to the WHO

But I’d say it is missing half the equation

You’d have to factor in harms to society as part of it. Which is why it’s not just science but societal impact, ie political arena

Harms to society could at least theoretically be factored into that equation. I think the bigger issue is that however well evidenced it might be, governments sooner or later are slaves to public responses. Especially in a democracy. So I think you're right about it only being half of the equation, but a different missing half.

EasternStandard · 24/09/2023 09:09

I think the X Y equation isn’t a bad way to look at it, better than handing over decisions to the WHO

But I’d say it is missing half the equation

You’d have to factor in harms to society as part of it. Which is why it’s not just science but societal impact, ie political arena

TrashedSofa · 24/09/2023 09:04

Sparklecats · 23/09/2023 23:43

@TrashedSofa

I completely agree with this. Feel like they need some sort of algorithm to follow according to parameters of potential diseases.

i.e. novel disease has X fatality rate, Y transmissibility and hospital capacity is Z therefore we implement plan 2.3.7.

Once they have the inquiry and a sound cost benefit analysis this sort of thing could be easily done.

I could see something like that eventually forming part of our pandemic planning yep. Afaik there's broad consensus that we're likely to see them happening more often in the future, so this is a good way to factor in how much of the kitchen sink we can get away with throwing bearing in mind there'll probably be another one in X years.

But I say 'part of' because there is again the question of how the public feel. If the population do not buy into plan 2.3.7, then it isn't going to be achievable.

Which could work for or against restrictions, in fact. The discussion in this thread has more focused on people not observing them, which is understandable as that's where we are now, but it may not be in decades to come. If plan 2.3.7 stops short of lockdown, even if it's for extremely sound reasons, if enough of the public want one regardless then it may still happen. And this goes to both of our points about the inevitability of pandemic management being political.

WestwardHo1 · 24/09/2023 08:39

WhalePolo · 24/09/2023 01:03

It’s absolutely ridiculous to assume that anyone supporting lockdown was a middle class snob. The overwhelming and vast majority were doing it because they were trying to prevent hospitalisations and deaths.

@JenniferBooth

Because they had been deliberately terrified by the state and the media.

WestwardHo1 · 24/09/2023 08:36

WhalePolo · 23/09/2023 23:44

So what’s the solution then? An out of control virus, no method of control and hospitals that are collapsing under the strain.

People aren’t supporting lockdown or mask wearing to be lofty or sneery : they are doing it because they want don’t want others to die, get seriously ill and so that hospitals could provide care to their patients.
According to that constituency map, people DON’T think lockdown was a mistake. So I’m not sure who this ‘entire population’ refers to…

Do you think the UK government handled lockdowns well? Overall? Not just "got cases down" but overall.

I know no one who does.

Dontcallmescarface · 24/09/2023 05:51

JenniferBooth · 24/09/2023 00:51

so unless you are a barrister or a doctor or a financier you cant understand restrictions and the reasoning behind them And you have the absolute cheek to label others as far right.

People who live in social housing are the supermarket workers the Amazon drivers who brought you your shit during lockdowns Of course they understood restrictions They had to

Not forgetting care workers, hospital porter/cleaners etc....the ones who actually had to deal with the impact of covid on a daily basis and whose risk of catching it was a lot higher than a fucking barrister or financier.

SaltyOne · 24/09/2023 01:53

JenniferBooth · 24/09/2023 00:51

so unless you are a barrister or a doctor or a financier you cant understand restrictions and the reasoning behind them And you have the absolute cheek to label others as far right.

People who live in social housing are the supermarket workers the Amazon drivers who brought you your shit during lockdowns Of course they understood restrictions They had to

What Sparklecats is saying is if you have a lower level of education, you may not understand the reasons behind restrictions - not the restrictions themselves. Of course, this is a generalisation.

There is no need to be professionally offended on behalf of all social housing tenants.

DameWhiskers · 24/09/2023 01:46

WhalePolo · 24/09/2023 00:41

@Sparklecats

I’m not a fan of Unherd/Daily Telegraph - and I’m sorry but the justification given by Unherd to the constituency map results reminded me of the same logic used by the likes of Russell Brand to justify their anti lockdown stance.

Which is political - whether people like it or not, or want to cross off their bingo card - rather than giving an adequate explanation as to why: it’s the likes of reformUK/Trump/Elon Musk/Laurence Fox/Farage/Brand who are vehemently anti-lockdown. Who say they champion free speech until someone says something they don’t like. It stinks of survival of the fittest : that other people are dispensable or should die - so long as I’m not uncomfortable and so long as my well being is protected.
It’s an economic right wing argument whether people like it or not.
I’m very willing to be told I’m wrong. I want to be wrong. But I haven’t heard a decent, balanced, unbiased explanation yet…

I agree with this.

DameWhiskers · 24/09/2023 01:45

JenniferBooth · 23/09/2023 14:43

I wasn't going to read through the entire thread you copied, but are you talking about posts like this?

"Yes I know it's being discussed but anyone who expresses any dislike of them or discomfort seems to told to STFU. It isn't enough that people wear them. They have to submit too. Why? Why aren't they allowed to question it or at least express their dislike of wearing them."

This is one person's opinion in mid-2020. As far as I recall, no-one enjoyed wearing masks, but to get on with the things we needed to do we wore them (if we could). No-one was struck down for expressing dislike of wearing masks that I'm aware of. This is all in your head.