Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(Covid) To think these recommendations are bonkers?

659 replies

NoCharnce · 18/09/2023 12:11

So the government commission into how to memorialise the Covid pandemic has recommended the government implement “A UK-wide day of reflection should be established and held annually.”

Other recommendations include national memorials (10 sites already identified!), oral histories and museums plus additional funding for local authorities to set up their own memorials.

I can’t be the only one who thinks this is nuts and hope the government ignores the recommendations? I genuinely cannot believe people get paid to produce this crap.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
JerryLovesMargo · 24/09/2023 14:20

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 13:19

@JerryLovesMargo

SE England?

No, north east. Why do you ask?

Dontcallmescarface · 24/09/2023 13:50

How are families losses to be commemorated?

Privately and not being used to score points by either side of the debate would do me....not going to happen though.

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 13:25

The thread’s gone off on a tangent.

What do people think of the recommendations?

If you aren’t impressed, how would you improve upon them?

Do you think covid should be remembered and learnt from to prepare us better in future?

How are families losses to be commemorated?

What would you want to see happening in future pandemic preparedness? What would you be happy with or consider acceptable when another novel virus emerges?

EasternStandard · 24/09/2023 13:19

WomblingTree86 · 24/09/2023 13:08

How do you know they weren't taking their actual risk into account?

I‘m not sure what you are asking here but if you had family members that were high risk yes you could have taken that into account when deciding on your behaviour

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 13:19

JerryLovesMargo · 24/09/2023 12:58

We're a family of three with six degrees between us and we live in a council flat. Our neighbours include a nurse, a teacher and a lecturer.

Shut up with your classist assumptions.

@JerryLovesMargo

SE England?

WomblingTree86 · 24/09/2023 13:08

EasternStandard · 24/09/2023 10:06

That may be true. And you could have taken that into account when deciding on what to do

If the messaging had not been fear based but just accurately showing risk

How do you know they weren't taking their actual risk into account?

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/09/2023 13:03

Also plenty of people live in private blocks of flats where isolating was hard. We had to pass through communal areas to go in and out of our block. There was no choice.

JerryLovesMargo · 24/09/2023 12:58

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 00:47

@JenniferBooth so you are telling me that the majority of people in social housing are highly qualified, high
earning barristers, doctors, financiers etc?

I did say may, of course you will have highly qualified who have become disabled or had chance hard times but for the most part they buy their own homes and are not in social housing.

We're a family of three with six degrees between us and we live in a council flat. Our neighbours include a nurse, a teacher and a lecturer.

Shut up with your classist assumptions.

JerryLovesMargo · 24/09/2023 12:54

CwmYoy · 23/09/2023 16:07

I would like memorial gardens to remember the family members we lost.

I will never forgive the mask dodgers who passed Covid around through their ignorance. Too many people taken before their time.

This is exactly the sort of thing those of us who were exempt had to put up with.

I lost count of the times I was called a killer/murderer/disease vector/thick.

By people who claimed to care about the vulnerable, while completely missing the point that many who were exempt were so due to vulnerability/disability.

EasternStandard · 24/09/2023 12:51

SaltyOne · 24/09/2023 12:10

@EasternStandard

Yes it was only after the miscalculation on numbers that the approach was changed

Really? Do you have a source for this?

It was evidence on a committee hearing. I listened at the time but here is transcript (a few said the same but this is MH)

I remember very, very clearly when the new projections from SPI-M came in towards the end of the week beginning 9 March; I cannot remember exactly what day it was, but towards the end of that week SPI-M came in with some new projections. I remember going into No. 10 and one of the most senior advisers saying to me, ashen-faced, "Have you seen these new projections? Isn't this awful?"

They then launched into lockdown planning

Also on scientific advice this came up, related but different point

Scientists would not have proposed lockdowns without ministers suggesting them, the country’s most senior doctor has said.

Sir Chris Whitty, the Chief Medical Officer for England, told the Covid Inquiry he would have been surprised if scientists had included national shutdowns as part of the planning for a pandemic.

Giving evidence on the eighth day of the Inquiry, Sir Chris said planning for such an “extraordinarily major social intervention” would not have occurred unless a minister had requested it.

WomblingTree86 · 24/09/2023 12:22

EasternStandard · 24/09/2023 11:08

People were concerned over their own risk. That is all here in the threads on mn

So many threads on that, looking at it by profession even

If you think everyone was not reacting to fear campaign how different do you think behaviour and compliance would have been without daily death and case count?

Why do you assume that those who were concerned about their own risk on mn were being irrational? Not everyone on here is young and healthy and there seem to be quite a few with children who may have been at high risk too.

SaltyOne · 24/09/2023 12:10

@EasternStandard

Yes it was only after the miscalculation on numbers that the approach was changed

Really? Do you have a source for this?

SaltyOne · 24/09/2023 12:08

@TooOldForThisNonsense

I definitely think there was an element of this. Look at how the government behaved. Would they really have been having parties and all sorts if there was a significant risk to them

Were you on MN at that time? According to a good amount of posters on the Covid boards, they were ignoring the rulez and partying too, so ...

TooOldForThisNonsense · 24/09/2023 11:54

WestwardHo1 · 24/09/2023 08:39

Because they had been deliberately terrified by the state and the media.

I definitely think there was an element of this. Look at how the government behaved. Would they really have been having parties and all sorts if there was a significant risk to them.

the real problem with Covid was always the numbers

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 11:47

TrashedSofa · 24/09/2023 11:19

I agree with a lot of this, the Christmas example is a good one. Except there isn't a mechanism for public opinion not to hold sway, however dangerous the illness might be. It's not a nice to have, it's an inherent part of any pandemic management strategy. It would be the all bets are off situation we agreed on upthread. So really the issue is to what extent could public views be influenced/managed. Which is thornier.

@TrashedSofa

I think there are avenues to distribute propaganda such as social media, post, shops, schools, workplaces.

They may put out guidance set in law on infection control/what to do and what will potentially happen in the event of an outbreak to workplaces, schools etc. Which would allow planning across the public and private sectors. And facilitate even things like pandemic insurance possibly. I’m sure the gov would want something like that so they don’t have to foot a furlough bill next time.

Public education, communication of science overall will be upscaled.

I see the recommendations re covid legacy more as reinforcing the above, a piece of the puzzle in influencing public opinion rather than instrumental.

They’d be mad if they didn’t use it as it’s the pandemic closest to people’s minds.

EasternStandard · 24/09/2023 11:46

SaltyOne · 24/09/2023 11:43

@EasternStandard

If we had enough places it’s feasible that it could have been passed through population without barriers

In other words, "let it rip"? Pre-vaccine, I think that would only have succeeded in a great many more deaths.

Yes it was only after the miscalculation on numbers that the approach was changed

DinnaeFashYersel · 24/09/2023 11:44

Kids could get a scavenger hunt/bingo card to collect all the covid classics (granny killer, new normal, social distancing, selfishk super spreader etc) and be rewarded with a rainbow coloured facemask at the end

SaltyOne · 24/09/2023 11:43

@EasternStandard

If we had enough places it’s feasible that it could have been passed through population without barriers

In other words, "let it rip"? Pre-vaccine, I think that would only have succeeded in a great many more deaths.

EasternStandard · 24/09/2023 11:43

In fact thinking back that was the initial plan. Except the numbers were out

They realised and about a week later we had lockdown

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 11:32

WomblingTree86 · 24/09/2023 10:04

You're assuming everyone is only interested in their personal risk though. Most people would have had close family members of friends who were at much higher risk and they were very concerned about them.

@WomblingTree86

This is true. I saw a good friend as a corpse because they were let down by others who refused to follow guidance.

Whenever we then had some family not follow guidance I cut off contact for a year - because myself and DC are vulnerable.

It caused a lot of issues. But we are alive and weren’t put at risk so I felt it was worth it.

It wouldn’t have mattered to me who it was, at the time my personal assessment was that the guidance needed to be followed (vaccination/some social restriction) and I didn’t want to mix with anyone who didn’t play their part. Not only for myself and DC, we mixed with others who were vulnerable or had elderly relatives. It wouldn’t have been fair to expose myself to escalated risk and thus put others in danger.

EasternStandard · 24/09/2023 11:30

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 11:19

@EasternStandard

I don’t think you’re getting that this was a novel virus and an RNA virus at that with enormously high mutation rates!!

Calculating personal risk in the beginning was impossible.

We knew in the beginning that it was killing people, predominantly older, with certain health conditions, but some younger too.

We didn’t know the transmission routes, we didn’t know the full scope of the disease (we still don’t), we didn’t have any therapeutics, the risk of higher fatality developing was very real due to what we knew about other coronavirus outbreaks.

Developing serious clinical infection is dependent on the interaction between factors relative to the virus (variant etc), environment (temperature, indoor/outdoor etc) and host (age,sex, pre-existing condition etc).

We did not know what factors were most important or contributing most. As such you stop everything and then try and suss it out by releasing certain restrictions to see what impact it has.

Had we been dealing with a known enemy the response would have been firmer, but with a novel virus there is more risk and it requires more caution. For all.

The idea behind the approach was to ‘flatten the curve’ for hospital numbers

If we had enough places it’s feasible that it could have been passed through population without barriers

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 11:19

EasternStandard · 24/09/2023 09:27

They are I agree

But the Covid response leaned heavily on messaging to provoke fear over risk

Everyone’s risk was not high but use of daily death and case counts was the most effective behaviour change programme I’ve ever seen

That was a decision made by governments which fed into public demands. You could see it on mn throughout, daily threads on numbers etc

To put it another way if we’d reacted by personal risk and messages had been based on that we’d demand different things

@EasternStandard

I don’t think you’re getting that this was a novel virus and an RNA virus at that with enormously high mutation rates!!

Calculating personal risk in the beginning was impossible.

We knew in the beginning that it was killing people, predominantly older, with certain health conditions, but some younger too.

We didn’t know the transmission routes, we didn’t know the full scope of the disease (we still don’t), we didn’t have any therapeutics, the risk of higher fatality developing was very real due to what we knew about other coronavirus outbreaks.

Developing serious clinical infection is dependent on the interaction between factors relative to the virus (variant etc), environment (temperature, indoor/outdoor etc) and host (age,sex, pre-existing condition etc).

We did not know what factors were most important or contributing most. As such you stop everything and then try and suss it out by releasing certain restrictions to see what impact it has.

Had we been dealing with a known enemy the response would have been firmer, but with a novel virus there is more risk and it requires more caution. For all.

TrashedSofa · 24/09/2023 11:19

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 11:04

@TrashedSofa

Yes you’re completely right that public opinion would form part of future planning.

This is where I can see the inquiry feeding in to future planning.

For example if a disease has 1% fatality people would probably not accept lockdown over Christmas Day… 10%+ and you would have to overrule public opinion due to potential anarchy on the streets.

For a pathogen unlikely to kill many (with limited scope to evolve a worse variant), naturally public opinion would hold more sway than say if a pathogen with 10, 20, 40% fatality were to take hold.

I agree with a lot of this, the Christmas example is a good one. Except there isn't a mechanism for public opinion not to hold sway, however dangerous the illness might be. It's not a nice to have, it's an inherent part of any pandemic management strategy. It would be the all bets are off situation we agreed on upthread. So really the issue is to what extent could public views be influenced/managed. Which is thornier.

EasternStandard · 24/09/2023 11:08

WomblingTree86 · 24/09/2023 11:02

The fact that some people wanted schools to close to reduce overall deaths doesn't mean they weren't aware that the young and healthy weren't personally at high risk.

People were concerned over their own risk. That is all here in the threads on mn

So many threads on that, looking at it by profession even

If you think everyone was not reacting to fear campaign how different do you think behaviour and compliance would have been without daily death and case count?

Sparklecats · 24/09/2023 11:04

TrashedSofa · 24/09/2023 09:04

I could see something like that eventually forming part of our pandemic planning yep. Afaik there's broad consensus that we're likely to see them happening more often in the future, so this is a good way to factor in how much of the kitchen sink we can get away with throwing bearing in mind there'll probably be another one in X years.

But I say 'part of' because there is again the question of how the public feel. If the population do not buy into plan 2.3.7, then it isn't going to be achievable.

Which could work for or against restrictions, in fact. The discussion in this thread has more focused on people not observing them, which is understandable as that's where we are now, but it may not be in decades to come. If plan 2.3.7 stops short of lockdown, even if it's for extremely sound reasons, if enough of the public want one regardless then it may still happen. And this goes to both of our points about the inevitability of pandemic management being political.

@TrashedSofa

Yes you’re completely right that public opinion would form part of future planning.

This is where I can see the inquiry feeding in to future planning.

For example if a disease has 1% fatality people would probably not accept lockdown over Christmas Day… 10%+ and you would have to overrule public opinion due to potential anarchy on the streets.

For a pathogen unlikely to kill many (with limited scope to evolve a worse variant), naturally public opinion would hold more sway than say if a pathogen with 10, 20, 40% fatality were to take hold.

Swipe left for the next trending thread