Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(Covid) To think these recommendations are bonkers?

659 replies

NoCharnce · 18/09/2023 12:11

So the government commission into how to memorialise the Covid pandemic has recommended the government implement “A UK-wide day of reflection should be established and held annually.”

Other recommendations include national memorials (10 sites already identified!), oral histories and museums plus additional funding for local authorities to set up their own memorials.

I can’t be the only one who thinks this is nuts and hope the government ignores the recommendations? I genuinely cannot believe people get paid to produce this crap.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
19
WestwardHo1 · 03/10/2023 22:53

lookingforMolly · 18/09/2023 17:22

The stupid thing is that 'Covid' is ongoing.. elderly & chronically unwell people are being admitted to our local ED with Covid now! It hasn't actually just gone.

Not sure anyone claiming it is "gone".

Did any of you watch "Partygate"?

Sparklecats · 03/10/2023 18:14

WomblingTree86 · 03/10/2023 17:54

The green book is for the purpose of vaccination which was obviously later. Page 23 lists all clinical risk groups not just those considered extremely clinically vulnerable who were originally asked to sheild. e.g. people with diabetes are on there but they weren't in the CEV group who were asked and supported to shield in 2020.

@WomblingTree86 if you have the original list then stick it up. I can’t find it right now. I referred to the green book due to this All patients who were on the original CEV list also fell into group 6, which included a broader range of disease categories that JCVI advised would constitute a higher clinical risk for COVID-19 vaccination (tables 3 and 4)

A few interesting reports on CEV perspectives/experiences if anyone wants to chew over this further.

https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/healthandsocialcare/conditionsanddiseases/bulletins/coronavirusandclinicallyextremelyvulnerablepeopleinengland/4aprilto23april2022

https://www.health.org.uk/news-and-comment/charts-and-infographics/understanding-the-needs-and-experiences-of-those-most-clinic

Coronavirus and clinically extremely vulnerable (CEV) people in England - Office for National Statistics

Analysis of people previously considered to be clinically extremely vulnerable (CEV) in England during the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic, including their behaviours and mental and physical well-being.

https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/healthandsocialcare/conditionsanddiseases/bulletins/coronavirusandclinicallyextremelyvulnerablepeopleinengland/4aprilto23april2022

WomblingTree86 · 03/10/2023 17:54

Sparklecats · 03/10/2023 16:22

@WomblingTree86 please see page 23, table 3, which I believe corresponds to the CEV list as was.

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1186479/Greenbook-chapter-14a-4September2023.pdf

The green book is for the purpose of vaccination which was obviously later. Page 23 lists all clinical risk groups not just those considered extremely clinically vulnerable who were originally asked to sheild. e.g. people with diabetes are on there but they weren't in the CEV group who were asked and supported to shield in 2020.

Sparklecats · 03/10/2023 16:22

WomblingTree86 · 03/10/2023 15:35

Both examples are CV but most people with MS are not CEV. I don't think anyone with MS was in the shielding category to begin with either unless they had just received cladribine or stem cell treatment. I think there is a difference between what category you have been put in officially and whether you actually are extremely vulnerable.

@WomblingTree86 please see page 23, table 3, which I believe corresponds to the CEV list as was.

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1186479/Greenbook-chapter-14a-4September2023.pdf

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1186479/Greenbook-chapter-14a-4September2023.pdf

WomblingTree86 · 03/10/2023 15:35

Sparklecats · 03/10/2023 15:06

I can assure you @WomblingTree86 it is MUCH more complicated than you’re making it out to be.

If you encounter low exposure to a mild variant, have MS and are on a low dose of immunosuppressive drugs, that is different to someone with cancer who has had several rounds of chemo and is exposed on multiple occasions to a variant inducing more severe pathology…

Both examples are clinically vulnerable, but disease, medication, exposure history are all different.

If the poster has had is ten times and hasn’t encountered any severe symptoms they would be extremely lucky. Without further detail of their health, job etc you can’t really say what variables are contributed to this luck.

Both examples are CV but most people with MS are not CEV. I don't think anyone with MS was in the shielding category to begin with either unless they had just received cladribine or stem cell treatment. I think there is a difference between what category you have been put in officially and whether you actually are extremely vulnerable.

pigsDOfly · 03/10/2023 15:22

As a memorial, I propose a 'national pan banging day' during which the country will unite by everyone standing at their front door every hour, on the hour, banging pans for 5 minutes.

This, of course will be obligatory on pain of £100 fine for non compliance, unless of course, you're an MP, in which case you will be allowed to quaff wine, and attend garden parties all day.

Makes as much sense to me as creating a memorial to the whole ghastly episode.

Sparklecats · 03/10/2023 15:18

WomblingTree86 · 03/10/2023 14:56

I didn't say she didn't have the right to go to shops/restaurants/pubs. Very unusual to do so if CEV though particularly if you couldn't wear a mask.

I would 100% agree with this @WomblingTree86 I didn’t know any CEV or CV people that did this.

But that isn’t to say they didn’t exist; some just didn’t buy that covid was that dangerous or didn’t want to have their freedoms curtailed.

To be fair to @JerryLovesMargo she did say that the situation had her on antidepressants and she was very frightened so I think best to leave it there.

At the end of the day, some people over exaggerate their position to prove a point on MN, others are pure as the driven snow.

I think we can all see clearly the individual had a terrible time during the pandemic and has some strong beliefs.

If the account is to be believed then what can be said is that the employer failed in their duty of care. Accommodations should have been made to have her wfh or on leave during lockdown periods. No way any employer would have forced someone CEV to come in - they’d be liable legally. And you’re right if in a council house they wouldn’t evict CEV and lot of flexibility built in around that time for people CEV/CV/furloughed etc with financial/needs issues.

Sparklecats · 03/10/2023 15:06

WomblingTree86 · 03/10/2023 10:32

CEV stands for clinically ^extremely" vulnerable to Covid. By definition if someone has had COVID ten times, has only had fairly mild symptoms on most of those occasions (I assume that's the case if someone is still working), then they weren't actually extremely vulnerable to Covid.

I can assure you @WomblingTree86 it is MUCH more complicated than you’re making it out to be.

If you encounter low exposure to a mild variant, have MS and are on a low dose of immunosuppressive drugs, that is different to someone with cancer who has had several rounds of chemo and is exposed on multiple occasions to a variant inducing more severe pathology…

Both examples are clinically vulnerable, but disease, medication, exposure history are all different.

If the poster has had is ten times and hasn’t encountered any severe symptoms they would be extremely lucky. Without further detail of their health, job etc you can’t really say what variables are contributed to this luck.

WomblingTree86 · 03/10/2023 14:56

JenniferBooth · 03/10/2023 14:37

Perhaps she wanted to go to the shops She had the right to do so That right wasnt negated by the fact that she couldnt wear a mask

I didn't say she didn't have the right to go to shops/restaurants/pubs. Very unusual to do so if CEV though particularly if you couldn't wear a mask.

WomblingTree86 · 03/10/2023 14:54

JenniferBooth · 03/10/2023 14:35

If its housing association believe me they would have no qualms about evicting her. There is very very little true council housing now Most stock has been transferred over.

She said it was a council house. They didn't evict people who were CEV and officially shielding.

JenniferBooth · 03/10/2023 14:37

Perhaps she wanted to go to the shops She had the right to do so That right wasnt negated by the fact that she couldnt wear a mask

JenniferBooth · 03/10/2023 14:35

If its housing association believe me they would have no qualms about evicting her. There is very very little true council housing now Most stock has been transferred over.

WomblingTree86 · 03/10/2023 14:16

JenniferBooth · 03/10/2023 13:45

On another thread you say that you don't work and live in social housing

Its been THREE YEARS Maybe her circumstances have changed. Maybe her employer got the hump at her catching Covid and having time off
Lets not forget that people have been happily voting for the erosion of workers rights for the last 13 years.

She said " I had to go to work and use public transport to get there. The CEV people you know were extremely fortunate to not need to go out to work or use buses and trains to get there. Unfortunately, that was a privilege many millions didn't have during the pandemic, CEV or otherwise."

I was surprised at that given she also states that she says she has lived council house for 20 years and rent is under 500. The council wouldn't have evicted her. She also lives with her DH who works and mentioned her DD who is a teacher so would be quite a high earner. Doesn't sound like she needed to risk her life to earn money and also probably didn't need to visit shops/restaurants/pubs (where she claims to have been spat on).

MoonShinesBright · 03/10/2023 13:52

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

JenniferBooth · 03/10/2023 13:45

On another thread you say that you don't work and live in social housing

Its been THREE YEARS Maybe her circumstances have changed. Maybe her employer got the hump at her catching Covid and having time off
Lets not forget that people have been happily voting for the erosion of workers rights for the last 13 years.

WomblingTree86 · 03/10/2023 10:51

JerryLovesMargo · 03/10/2023 06:49

Covid did make me that ill, prior to vaccination. I have been given antivirals since to avoid becoming that ill again, and I've had eight vaccinations (which don't work so well at preventing infection in immunosuppressed patients but do make illness less severe).

I have never once complained about people being pressured to wear a mask. I've 'complained' that those who couldn't shouldn't have been spat at, threatened or abused, which is a different thing. Do you think they should have been?

And I'll say it again - CEV people still had to go to work. Teachers and retail staff didn't have the luxury of WFH. Nor did they have the option to simply stop working. It's why so bus drivers, for example, died.

Why isn't all that 'plausible'? Why are you calling me a liar?

On another thread you say that you don't work and live in social housing.

NotReadyForAutumnYet · 03/10/2023 10:37

@JerryLovesMargo I'm sorry, that's really tough.

WomblingTree86 · 03/10/2023 10:32

Sparklecats · 03/10/2023 10:26

@WomblingTree86 would depend on the variant caught, number of exposures, viral dose, person’s genetics/prior exposure history/specific health condition, and other factors related to the virus/environment/host as to the severity of infection.

Personally I appear to have been walloped by it, but I still have to get on with caring responsibilities for multiple disabled people in the family and work.

My CEV friend who got it and died only had very mild symptoms, no more than a cold; it was the aneurysm months later that killed them.

So to say all CEV people will always be very adversely affected in terms of the symptom profile is erroneous (aneurysms aside).

CEV stands for clinically ^extremely" vulnerable to Covid. By definition if someone has had COVID ten times, has only had fairly mild symptoms on most of those occasions (I assume that's the case if someone is still working), then they weren't actually extremely vulnerable to Covid.

Sparklecats · 03/10/2023 10:26

WomblingTree86 · 03/10/2023 09:40

That's my point. You have had it 5x and you health has severely effected and you are only CV. It doesn't stack up that someone who is severely immunosuppressed would catch it 10 times and still be working and complaining about masks as they would just be too ill by now. Life doesn't necessarily always go on. I am severely immunosuppressed btw.

@WomblingTree86 would depend on the variant caught, number of exposures, viral dose, person’s genetics/prior exposure history/specific health condition, and other factors related to the virus/environment/host as to the severity of infection.

Personally I appear to have been walloped by it, but I still have to get on with caring responsibilities for multiple disabled people in the family and work.

My CEV friend who got it and died only had very mild symptoms, no more than a cold; it was the aneurysm months later that killed them.

So to say all CEV people will always be very adversely affected in terms of the symptom profile is erroneous (aneurysms aside).

WomblingTree86 · 03/10/2023 09:40

Sparklecats · 03/10/2023 09:02

@WomblingTree86

People who are immunocompromised are more likely to develop clinical infection on two counts.

  1. Their threshold to develop infection is lower, they’re not able to fight off much, so wouldn’t need as many exposures/as high a dose of covid to get sick.

  2. They can’t mount a sufficient response to the vaccines so only have limited protection. Essentially they rely on herd immunity via either vaccination or natural spread of infection in others in their community.

I’ve caught it 5x and I’m only CV. And I can attest that my health has been severely affected by it via the covid and worsening of other conditions. For someone who has had it 10x this would be the case too. But life goes on and we still have to get up and get on.

That's my point. You have had it 5x and you health has severely effected and you are only CV. It doesn't stack up that someone who is severely immunosuppressed would catch it 10 times and still be working and complaining about masks as they would just be too ill by now. Life doesn't necessarily always go on. I am severely immunosuppressed btw.

Sparklecats · 03/10/2023 09:02

WomblingTree86 · 03/10/2023 07:54

Peopke who are severely immunosuppressed don't catch it much more often if at all. They just get much more ill if they do so if someone caught it several times their health would be severely effected by now not only from covid itself which would be bad enough but maybe also if would have made their disease much worse.

@WomblingTree86

People who are immunocompromised are more likely to develop clinical infection on two counts.

  1. Their threshold to develop infection is lower, they’re not able to fight off much, so wouldn’t need as many exposures/as high a dose of covid to get sick.

  2. They can’t mount a sufficient response to the vaccines so only have limited protection. Essentially they rely on herd immunity via either vaccination or natural spread of infection in others in their community.

I’ve caught it 5x and I’m only CV. And I can attest that my health has been severely affected by it via the covid and worsening of other conditions. For someone who has had it 10x this would be the case too. But life goes on and we still have to get up and get on.

Sparklecats · 03/10/2023 08:47

WhalePolo · 03/10/2023 07:13

@JerryLovesMargo Apologies. I can see it was really hard for you, and I hope my posts didn’t come across as a personal attack. Your experience is important.

You state that you’re ‘not anti-mask’ - but I think your situation might be used by others here to advocate an anti mask argument. And I think it’s that which is causing people’s heckles to rise.

I’d like to echo the apology of @WhalePolo, @JerryLovesMargo if you felt offended in any way.

Genuinely, I do really empathise with your position; amongst my family and friends there are a lot of people with conditions such as MS, cancer, neurological issues, crohns etc etc

What I was trying to say was how atypical your experience was, from that of many CEV who were either supported by their employer or chose to seek more suitable employment.

We were only CV and we accepted we had to take a mortgage holiday, and 20-30k lost earnings (still in debt!!). It was really awful.

But not as awful as your position of feeling you had no choice but to put yourself out there. So sorry this happened to you.

WomblingTree86 · 03/10/2023 07:54

JerryLovesMargo · 03/10/2023 06:31

I've had covid 10 times because I'm immunosuppressed.

And of course I need to work. What choice do I have? Millions of vulnerable people have had to work throughout the pandemic. Tens of thousands have died, including people I know.

Why are you being so nasty? And why are you being so disbelieving and deeply unpleasant to someone who is CEV - you know, the very type of person you wanted to 'protect' back in 2020?

Peopke who are severely immunosuppressed don't catch it much more often if at all. They just get much more ill if they do so if someone caught it several times their health would be severely effected by now not only from covid itself which would be bad enough but maybe also if would have made their disease much worse.

Sparklecats · 03/10/2023 07:30

JerryLovesMargo · 03/10/2023 06:44

I don't have any family apart from DH and DD, or friends, not that it's relevant. And unfortunately, not all jobs can be done from home. I did of course have the option not to go into work at all, but that would have meant resigning. So, not really an option.

I said it then and I'll say it now - not everyone has a support network, can drive, has the option to WFH. People who did have those options during the pandemic were utterly disbelieving that others did not. It must have been such a relief for the CEV/mask exempt who were able to avoid crowded public places to be able to do so. But tens of thousands of teachers, retail staff, hospitality staff etc could not.

Why is that so hard to believe?

And however politely you try to 'word' it, calling a disabled person a liar when they're telling you their lived experience is pretty crap.

I'd happily supply details of all my positive tests and the AVs I've been given and my various diagnoses which make me CEV. But why should I prove myself to a stranger online - particularly one who no doubt was all about protecting the vulnerable during the pandemic, but is now quite happy to suggest I'm lying about my health.

Yes. This thread and some of the attitudes on it is the perfect memorial to a really shitty, terrifying time for CEV people. Privileged, fit and healthy people able to wear masks and WFH and avoid buses and busy workplaces telling us we're doing vulnerability wrong.

@JerryLovesMargo

Not calling you a liar at all, absolutely no way.

But I am appalled at what happened with your employer/that you felt you had no other option but to put yourself in harms way.

I think I’ve already stated my whole family is CV so not fit, healthy or privileged.

My CEV friends some of whom were civil service, teachers, essential retail were all accommodated either by wfh or they were facilitated to go on the sick/furlough, yes this meant lesser wages but again they prioritised safety over liberty.

One decided to leave her position and applied for a wfh civil service job. As for us I had to move to wfh because both myself and the DC are CV and this was accommodated, DH was furloughed from retail and didn’t take up any other work because it was all face to face in some capacity. We are still dealing with the financial consequences of this, but we are alive.

That’s why I find it shocking that you weren’t supported by your employer in any way, nor did you feel there were other options open to you to adapt. Honestly I would have sought legal advice.

WhalePolo · 03/10/2023 07:13

@JerryLovesMargo Apologies. I can see it was really hard for you, and I hope my posts didn’t come across as a personal attack. Your experience is important.

You state that you’re ‘not anti-mask’ - but I think your situation might be used by others here to advocate an anti mask argument. And I think it’s that which is causing people’s heckles to rise.

Swipe left for the next trending thread