Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go running alone at night in the park

136 replies

MamaGhina · 18/09/2023 10:43

YABU - why on earth would anyone think this is ok
YANBU - anyone should be able to run at night alone

Have been running in the evening in my local park. It’s a London borough, fairly safe but the park has no lighting and a number of exits and entrances. Impossible to see who else is in the park. I take a torch mainly so I don’t get tangled in any dog walkers leads but generally the park is quiet at night. The torch means my location is obvious to anyone else in the park and obvious I am alone.

Every single person I have told that I do this is surprised, says I am mad or it’s dangerous. That I shouldn’t run alone, I need to find someone to run with or run during the day. I don’t want to run during the day because the park is busy, I end up bumping into loads of people I know and I just want to get on with my run. It’s not always convenient to go during the day, then shower, do hair etc. I prefer to run at night and then shower, get ready for bed. I don’t want to find someone to run with, have to wait for them, meet them, make chit chat etc I want to run to my own schedule.

FWIW I’m female, fairly small, mid 40s.

OP posts:
wheresmymojo · 18/09/2023 11:39

I agree with PP also. Attractiveness and age have much less correlation with attacks than people think.

Growlybear83 · 18/09/2023 11:38

Of course anyone should be able to go anywhere alone at any time of day, but unfortunately the world we live in isn't like that and I think it's very very foolish and unsafe to be alone in a park after dark.

wheresmymojo · 18/09/2023 11:38

Okay, I think this makes sense.

I've been attacked multiple times by strangers in all sorts of circumstances (not just in the dark, or alone).

So obviously my sense of the 'risk' will be different to someone with a different experience.

I don't like to alter how I live to take account of this - hence I'd still walk/run in the dark in most circumstances but an unlit park or forest would be one I wouldn't do.

That's as much because it wouldn't be an enjoyable experience for me as anything as I'd be constantly 'on alert' which is quite stressful.

Bogbrushhair · 18/09/2023 11:38

OP very obviously this is unsafe. Yes you ‘should’ be able to do this but sadly it’s dangerous for a woman to be alone anywhere isolated at night. You know that. If you still want to do it however, of course you go for it.

NowWhattt · 18/09/2023 11:37

TheHappinessEnigma · 18/09/2023 10:59

Well, you’re insistent that it’s safe and you’re going to continue doing it, so what can anyone tell you?
🤷🏻‍♀️
Don’t know why you bothered posting.

Agree with this.
Whats the point of posting

Fizbosshoes · 18/09/2023 11:37

Having said that I'm over 50, wear glasses and I certainly don't look attractive running! I don't have any fancy gear on display either (phone concealed etc).

I'm not sure what you look like has any bearing on whether you're likely to be raped or attacked. I know I don't look attractive or glamorous when running, but I don't feel that's any protection.
(I never even take a phone when I run)

Teddleshon · 18/09/2023 11:36

I’ve been attacked by a stranger in the street (in London) and have come across multiple flashers.

TerryOrange1w2 · 18/09/2023 11:34

wheresmymojo · 18/09/2023 11:26

Also to the PP's who feel the risks are overstated, have you ever been attacked by a stranger or felt an attack could be imminent?

This isn't leading to a criticism (none of my business), I'm just genuinely intrigued why you would feel that the risk is overstated...

No I haven't. I've been attacked by a partner in my own home but never a stranger. Stranger attacks are rare. I've never been frightened walking in the dark alone. I've been scared several times in pubs though so I avoid those.

MamaGhina · 18/09/2023 11:34

@wheresmymojo sorry, I just saw your second post.

I’ve never been attacked by a stranger, no. I was in a bad relationship for a long time and was used to being told I couldn’t do x or y. I have friends who are too scared to walk home from the pub alone or who won’t go into central London because they are too afraid. I don’t want to live like that …. but also appreciate the need for balance.

OP posts:
InTheFutilityRoomEatingBiscuits · 18/09/2023 11:33

I would be fine with this, I don’t do exactly the same as I don’t live in a london borough but I regularly walk and run before dawn or after dark in the fields, moor and footpaths and towpaths around where I live.

I’m not saying I don’t sometimes feel nervous because sometimes I do, mainly worry about ankle breakers and unexpected bogs but occasionally it’s an awkward encounter with someone and it can put you on edge. But I do it anyway because the alternative to me is way worse. (Being trapped at home, which has risks of its own)

I do feel that the risks are overstated yes. That is, I feel that the risks of being out in daylight or as a duo/group are under-stated, the risks of being at home, alone or with friends and family, are under-stated. Rather than the risks of being out alone at night are overstated.

Yes, I have been attacked by strangers before. On a footpath in the daytime, on a busy main road in the daytime, on a bus at nighttime, in a taxi AND in and around my own home.

Hardbackwriter · 18/09/2023 11:33

wheresmymojo · 18/09/2023 11:26

Also to the PP's who feel the risks are overstated, have you ever been attacked by a stranger or felt an attack could be imminent?

This isn't leading to a criticism (none of my business), I'm just genuinely intrigued why you would feel that the risk is overstated...

I have been sexually harassed more times than I can recall, groped twice, been in situations where I felt unsafe but nothing came of it - all the standard stuff for a woman, sadly. That doesn't change my decision that the risk of being attacked while running at night is very low and outweighed by the benefits.

I have had periods in my life of severe, clinical anxiety which included suicidal ideation and as a result have had extensive therapy including CBT. Because of this I feel very passionately that my priority is making logic-based decisions and not allowing anxiety alone to determine them. I particularly want to model that to my children as, sadly, statistically my odds of passing on clinical anxiety are high and I want to do all that is in my power to avoid that. I do find that this makes me less risk-averse than most women I know, and significantly less so than most posters on MN. I feel comfortable with that!

redavocado · 18/09/2023 11:32

nevynevster · 18/09/2023 11:26

Kind of depends on the exact park. I run in all the parks near me and there's a few I'd never run in the evenings. Finsbury Park for example, if I walk past of an evening the vibe is very different to 7am and personally I wouldn't feel safe. Highbury Fields on the other hand is fine, technically not a park I guess, but lots of people walking to and from tube so I don't feel unsafe. Although there's reports of lots of mobile phone snatchers around.

Having said that I'm over 50, wear glasses and I certainly don't look attractive running! I don't have any fancy gear on display either (phone concealed etc).
I agree that bad stuff can happen to anyone and not just in the dark, I don't know that I'd take unnecessary risks although it sucks not to be able to do what you want whenever you want.

Fwiw I think a poorly lit quiet park is a bad idea so if you want to run alone in the evening find somewhere busier or better lit. I also don't get your comment about day time, I see people I know when I run during the day and I wave at them as I run past. I certainly don't feel obliged to stop and chat!

I completely agree. I live/have lived very close to both of these parks and while I'd probably walk or cycle home via Highbury Fields there's absolutely no way I'd go into Finsbury Park or any other proper park after dark. It's fine for running during the day (though not my favourite in the area) but in the time I've lived nearby numerous women have been attacked there plus a woman's been murdered there.

Batatahara · 18/09/2023 11:31

Fizbosshoes · 18/09/2023 11:29

I walk and run in the dark - I'm not sure how anyone gets anywhere/does anything between 4pm and 8.30am in the winter if they'd never walk in the dark?
However I also wouldn't walk or run (for any distance) in a fenced in Park

I think some people just drive everywhere.

MamaGhina · 18/09/2023 11:30

@southlondoner02 this is the thing, it’s not late. I put the DC to bed and go. I’m often out of the house before it’s dark but it’s dark before 8pm here.

@wheresmymojo thank you for taking the time to give that advice, rather then just tell me I’m stupid. I think I will stick to the roads which are well lit going forwards. It was the smoggy feeling running alongside the cars that was putting me off, whereas the air in the park feels much fresher. I feel freer there and can run without having the stop at every junction, traffic lights etc but I think the number of people saying it’s not worth the risk are right.

OP posts:
Fizbosshoes · 18/09/2023 11:29

Batatahara · 18/09/2023 11:26

I walk in the dark all the time and genuinely didn't realise how many women didn't until I came on mumsnet.

But I wouldn't in an unlit park.

I walk and run in the dark - I'm not sure how anyone gets anywhere/does anything between 4pm and 8.30am in the winter if they'd never walk in the dark?
However I also wouldn't walk or run (for any distance) in a fenced in Park

wheresmymojo · 18/09/2023 11:28

And I would, and have, run in the dark on lit city or suburban streets.

I would also run on unlit streets in the sleepy village I live in.

I wouldn't run in an unlit park in a city.

wheresmymojo · 18/09/2023 11:26

Also to the PP's who feel the risks are overstated, have you ever been attacked by a stranger or felt an attack could be imminent?

This isn't leading to a criticism (none of my business), I'm just genuinely intrigued why you would feel that the risk is overstated...

Batatahara · 18/09/2023 11:26

I walk in the dark all the time and genuinely didn't realise how many women didn't until I came on mumsnet.

But I wouldn't in an unlit park.

nevynevster · 18/09/2023 11:26

Kind of depends on the exact park. I run in all the parks near me and there's a few I'd never run in the evenings. Finsbury Park for example, if I walk past of an evening the vibe is very different to 7am and personally I wouldn't feel safe. Highbury Fields on the other hand is fine, technically not a park I guess, but lots of people walking to and from tube so I don't feel unsafe. Although there's reports of lots of mobile phone snatchers around.

Having said that I'm over 50, wear glasses and I certainly don't look attractive running! I don't have any fancy gear on display either (phone concealed etc).
I agree that bad stuff can happen to anyone and not just in the dark, I don't know that I'd take unnecessary risks although it sucks not to be able to do what you want whenever you want.

Fwiw I think a poorly lit quiet park is a bad idea so if you want to run alone in the evening find somewhere busier or better lit. I also don't get your comment about day time, I see people I know when I run during the day and I wave at them as I run past. I certainly don't feel obliged to stop and chat!

Thelnebriati · 18/09/2023 11:25

You should be able to go anywhere in safety but the reality is this is not safe, and its not any safer if you are with a friend. I'm not trying to stop you running. But you should be aware that even if you take precautions like having a mobile phone in your hand and an alarm, that won't guarantee your safety.

Fizbosshoes · 18/09/2023 11:23

I fit the same demographic - runner, female, mid 40s and very small.
I mostly run alone and, as winter approaches running in the dark becomes inevitable, if I want yo run several times a week. However, boring as it is, I do tend to stay on streets with lights. Occassionally I might do a short stretch (by a main road) on an unlit path ....to get to another lit path or down a short alley where I can clearly see there is no one else there. I wouldn't run in the park though.
I know I should be able to but I'm not willing to risk it

Hardbackwriter · 18/09/2023 11:23

I also run after dark sometimes, get the same responses and ignore them. People are massively overstating the risk. The risk from not exercising is much, much higher but no one lectures people about that in the same way. But you won't convince people - there was another recent thread about this and people kept giving examples of women being attacked in the day or otherwise in entirely different circumstances as proof that the OP mustn't dog walk at night and apparently most of them couldn't see how completely illogical this was.

wheresmymojo · 18/09/2023 11:23

Have you ever been attacked or been in a situation that's been threatening with a stranger before OP?

I'm interested as to why you don't have 'the fear'?

bengalcat · 18/09/2023 11:22

I run before or after work - it’s beginning to get darker at either time now - I run in my local West London park and don’t feel unsafe - as others have said you do you . My big black dog is 14 now so not as good a running partner although my ‘run ‘ is her fast trot .

wheresmymojo · 18/09/2023 11:21

You're not unreasonable for thinking women should be able to do this without fear of being raped and killed.

I'm not going to tell you that you're unreasonable for going ahead and actually doing it despite the risk of being raped and/or killed because it's your life.

However, it would be far too much of a risk for me to take. TBH the whole thing would be spoilt for me because I'd spend the entire time on edge of my nerves and jumping at shadows.

Don't you feel any nerves or fear while you're out?

All I would say is - I wouldn't do it and I wouldn't advise it.

BUT...if you want to, it's your decision to make but perhaps consider these things...

  • The worst thing you can do is make your routine predictable as this opens you up to a pre-meditated attack on top of opportunistic attacks
  • Vary the time, route and park that you go to so there is no 'routine' that someone can plan on
  • Is there someone, or a group you can use as a 'safety buddy' to let them know when you leave for your run, where you're going, and when they should get worried if you haven't told them you're back?
  • Ideally give multiple people access to your 'Find my IPhone' or whatever
  • Prepare what you would do if you were attacked. You need a plan in advance because you'll be so caught up in the freeze/flight/fight/fawn shock response that your brain will struggle if you don't
  • Research what is best to do in the event of an attack to form your plan (for example screaming 'fire' is more useful than 'help')
  • Make sure you understand the quickest and easiest way to call 999 on your phone. Most models have ways you can do this without all the shit of getting past the lock screen because when you're in shock / being attacked it isn't easy to put your passcode in
  • Don't run with headphones on, they block out all noise that would give you a warning sign that something might be wrong
  • ALWAYS trust your instincts. If you get to the park and suddenly feel a bit wary about entering even though it doesn't usually bother you...DO NOT PUSH PAST THIS FEELING. We pick up on many small signs that something might not be quite right that we may not be conscious of
  • Consider some self-defence classes. You need to punch in a certain way to actually have any power behind it, and most women wouldn't automatically punch properly. Also they will teach you about the areas on an attacker that women can use to their advantage without brute strength
Swipe left for the next trending thread