Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go running alone at night in the park

136 replies

MamaGhina · 18/09/2023 10:43

YABU - why on earth would anyone think this is ok
YANBU - anyone should be able to run at night alone

Have been running in the evening in my local park. It’s a London borough, fairly safe but the park has no lighting and a number of exits and entrances. Impossible to see who else is in the park. I take a torch mainly so I don’t get tangled in any dog walkers leads but generally the park is quiet at night. The torch means my location is obvious to anyone else in the park and obvious I am alone.

Every single person I have told that I do this is surprised, says I am mad or it’s dangerous. That I shouldn’t run alone, I need to find someone to run with or run during the day. I don’t want to run during the day because the park is busy, I end up bumping into loads of people I know and I just want to get on with my run. It’s not always convenient to go during the day, then shower, do hair etc. I prefer to run at night and then shower, get ready for bed. I don’t want to find someone to run with, have to wait for them, meet them, make chit chat etc I want to run to my own schedule.

FWIW I’m female, fairly small, mid 40s.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thementalloadisreal · 18/09/2023 21:41

On the one hand the immediate reaction is no it’s not safe! But on the other hand, are women ever really safe?
It should be safe to go about our business!
It’s so fucking frustrating that we can’t even leave the house without somehow deserving whatever befalls us.

Download strava and have it send a beacon to a family member or friend, at least then if you go missing they can track you.

Gadgetfreak · 18/09/2023 19:41

I’m fairly laid back and have always run in the evening but once it’s dark never in a park. I just move my runs to roadside. I know it’s not ideal and I’m always happy once we get the long evenings again so I can go back to field/ beach/ park runs but no way would a run in a park badly lit and at dark. And I live in a town with a very low crime rate. I guess you obviously feel safe to do that and I wish it was safe to do that but just too much of a risk in my opinion.

Ilefttownonsaturday · 18/09/2023 19:25

https://m.imdb.com/title/tt10016180/

Watch the Netflix film, the little things, about a jogger who goes missing after running alone at night......

The Little Things (2021) ⭐ 6.3 | Crime, Drama, Mystery

2h 8m | 15

https://m.imdb.com/title/tt10016180

CallieTR · 18/09/2023 19:14

I live in a leafy London borough that has lower crime rates than others (so probably similar area to OP) but sadly I wouldn’t feel safe doing this.

Despite it being a relatively low crime area, there are still violent crimes reported in parks during the day and at night.

Statistically chances of something happening are low but so is being involved in a car accident and I still always wear a seat belt.

Women shouldn’t have to be so afraid of male violence but here we are.

MrBernardCheeseman · 18/09/2023 19:07

I run in the dark, otherwise I wouldn’t be able to run for 8 months of the year. However, I only run in residential areas so I can be heard, I take my phone (I don’t in daylight, I prefer to travel light) and I have an Empowered by Ashley alarm in the palm of my hand, at the ready. I avoid parks and snickets. I tell DH I’m going and where I’m going.

It pisses me off that I have to do this.

Louloulouenna · 18/09/2023 18:57

And also while you may be in danger of being assaulted at work surely it’s wise to do whatever you can to reduce the chances of it happening eg don’t go out drinking on your own with the office pervert for example.

TheHappinessEnigma · 18/09/2023 18:50

Batatahara · 18/09/2023 17:42

There was a long thread very recently about whether women had been sexually assaulted at work - most had - but no one ever says women shouldn't work in case of sexual assault. I think it's almost certainly more common than being assaulted after dark

One thing being considered more dangerous (if it is, I’m not convinced) doesn’t render another thing safe.
That’s not how risk works.

TorqueWrench · 18/09/2023 18:49

Teddleshon · 18/09/2023 18:03

Kathleen Stock wrote a brilliant article in The Times recently arguing that is it not victim blaming to suggest ways that women can reduce their vulnerability to being attacked.

I haven't read the article but what I always find telling is that nobody ever talks about victim blaming when men are concerned, even though they're by far the principle victims of violence.

It's actually the stark opposite on here in many discussions. It's often stated that men suffer more violence because they go to places many women avoid such as pubs and bars where alcohol/rowdy behaviour are commonplace. This is the very definition of victim blaming!

Same when people say 'oh, but it's other men visiting the violence on them'. That's not the victim's fault either!

Teddleshon · 18/09/2023 18:03

Kathleen Stock wrote a brilliant article in The Times recently arguing that is it not victim blaming to suggest ways that women can reduce their vulnerability to being attacked.

Batatahara · 18/09/2023 17:42

There was a long thread very recently about whether women had been sexually assaulted at work - most had - but no one ever says women shouldn't work in case of sexual assault. I think it's almost certainly more common than being assaulted after dark

Dolores87 · 18/09/2023 17:40

There is no way I would do this in a London park. It's not safe unless your like secretly trained in Jujitsu or something 😅

But if you insist you want to definitely make sure you change your route each time and don't run the same route at the same time and definitely take a screech alarm or something

Tonight1 · 18/09/2023 17:36

It's such a shame that we have to think about things like this. You should be free to be able to do this.

Unfortunately there is a very small element of society which is unsafe.

BogRollBOGOF · 18/09/2023 17:27

I'm more selective about where I run at night. I have a chest torch which improves visibility- my main concern is tripping. The big thing is to trust your instincts, but that applies anywhere, day or night. Varying your habits is the best form of self-protection.

I've been assualted by an aquaintence in a friend's house. It likely could have escalated to rape if I hadn't woken up and hit him back in time. His actions were repulsive enough, but I'm not going to let scum like him dominate my life an ounce more than is necessary.
I was close to having an accìdent on my way to my run today. I braked hard in time responding to the vehicle in front of me, and the two vehicles behind were tardy at responding and fortunately were clear to swerve to avoid piling into my rear end. Should I never drive to a run again? Should I always avoid that road? I can't change the driving habits of others, but at least I managed my part of the risk by maintaining a decent stopping distance.

My walk to work as a student involved a significant overlap of the last walk of a girl who'd been about 18m older than me, and was found murdered metres away from one point of it a couple of years earlier. Her murderer was at large for years. It was dark when I walked to/ from work in the winter, but it had to be done. It was by a significant margin, the most effective route to get to work and public transport would have been expensive and horrifically inefficient.

Be aware of risks of doing something, and its benefits. What are the risks and benefits of modifying what you do or avoiding it or cracking on with something that you benefit from.

yinsy · 18/09/2023 16:09

I'm in my 60s, overweight, short hair (I think the hiding long hair isn't to hide being female but that hair in a ponytail could more easily be grabbed)..

Ah yes! That makes sense. I think some of the rest of the post was talking about hiding that you're a woman, so I mixed it up, and to be fair tucking my hair into a hat wouldn't conceal that fact even in poor lighting.

Teddleshon · 18/09/2023 16:06

In terms of analogies I minimise the risk of an accident while driving by sticking to the speed limit, never drinking and driving, not using my phone and keeping a safe distance between me and the vehicle in front. Similarly I minimise personal risk while exercising by sticking to daylight hours and avoiding very isolated locations.

Cola2023 · 18/09/2023 16:04

Cola2023 · 18/09/2023 13:58

I live right next to a park and wouldn't go through it in the dark.

I do go walks alone at night, but the park is pushing it.

Years ago, there was a report of a woman being raped in this park at night, so that's stuck in my head since.

There's no-one around to help and people might assume screaming is foxes.

Bumply · 18/09/2023 15:48

I sometimes run alone in the dark. Mostly on streets with lighting, but occasionally down paths with no lighting when I wear a head torch to give me visibility.

I'm in my 60s, overweight, short hair (I think the hiding long hair isn't to hide being female but that hair in a ponytail could more easily be grabbed).. I've never been attacked by a stranger even when I walk home from a night out after midnight and I could be home before the next night bus turns up (this is in Edinburgh rather than London)

I'm aware I could be attacked. I'm aware I would get some of the blame for being outside after dark. I'm aware if a rapist really wanted to rape me he could also do that while I'm home alone in my flat.

The one area I did stop running in the winter dark (early afternoon) was along the Water of Leith as I nearly got knocked into the river by a cyclist with no lights or high vis and apparently no care for anyone who didn't jump out of his way.

Natsku · 18/09/2023 15:20

We should be able to run(walk, whatever) by ourselves at any time, but whether its safe or not to do so depends on where you are (and perhaps even if it is reasonably safe, is it a risk worth taking?). I'm comfortable walking at night alone where I live, in the forest for instance which has parts that are well lit and parts that aren't, but I wouldn't want to in London. But I don't wear headphones like my bloke does, because I want to be able to hear if someone is coming up behind me.

longwayoff · 18/09/2023 15:18

Oh good news, OP, stay safe. I speak as one who, albeit with a friend, walked home from a Soho club, 16 years old across Hampstead Heath at 2am. It was densely dark. Once was enough.

Frabbits · 18/09/2023 15:15

Obviously we all should be able to go running wherever and whenever we like, and everyone also obviously has their own thresholds for how much risk they are willing to take.

Sadly, the reality of the situation is that going running as a lone female in a poorly lit park is potentially risky, more so than going running in the daytime in busy areas. Whether or not you accept that risk is a personal decision, but there are of course things you can do to mitigate the risk - not wearing headphones, making sure someone knows where you are and what time you will be back etc.

CharlotteBog · 18/09/2023 15:08

DoItAgainPlz · 18/09/2023 14:44

Congratukations, this may be the most Mumsnetty response of the entire thread.

Perhaps we have different definitions of "poorly lit". Parks and country roads without street lighting are poorly lit (or not lit at all). Main streets with street lamps are fine.

Running absolutely poses more of a risk than other activities. You're one wet leaf or piece of litter away from slipping and twisting your ankle when running, which you could avoid if you could actually see where you're going.

Unless you think I live somewhere with enternal sunshine, I am also one of the millions who lives, works and persues leisure activities after 4pm on winter evenings.

My definition of poorly lit is the same as yours. I stand by what I said to the poster who said "Nobody should be running in a poorly lit area." I disagree.

I have a very bright head torch. I don't think I am any more likely to slip or twist my ankle than when I run in day light. I'm not going to let the amount of light stop me doing what I want to do.

TheCurtainQueen · 18/09/2023 15:06

I’d be interested to know which park this is because they are often closed after dark.

The police strongly advise against this. I live in London and know a number of women who have been approached in parks after dark by police patrols and advised not to enter the park after dark. These are either people jogging or taking a short cut home.

Obviously you should be able to do this as an adult in a free and demoncratic country, but the reality is that you are taking a massive risk. I think you’re mad.

RubiRage · 18/09/2023 15:05

Fairly safe, how do you know this? Many crime’s don’t get reported, even if they do they won’t make the news.

Quiet at night? So no one will be around to hear your screams. Even if they do, your attacker will probably have escaped from one of the many exists.

UnaOfStormhold · 18/09/2023 14:55

There are definitely risks which needs to be weighed up for running in a park at night., just as there are with going out on the roads (or indeed being a couch potato). People are often more aware of the risks of things they don't do which can skew their judgement, plus attacks in parks get far more publicity than road accidents which are more common.

There are some easy precautions that can reduce the risks of running in a park at night - vary your route and timing, be careful with any tracking apps you use e.g. strava so you don't broadcast your runs, carry an alarm or have a live tracker just in case. Maybe even borrow a friend's dog? Having done the easy things, it's a question of whether it's worth the remaining risk and what the alternatives are. Running is such a gift to health and wellbeing that I'd definitely do what you need to do to fit it in; if the evenings is the only time you can run and you feel safe, it's probably manageable make runs in the park part of your week (on an unpredictable schedule etc).

That said, I think it's worth considering why you avoid running in the daytime and whether the risks you are concerned about there are really as much of an issue as you think. People generally don't expect runners to stop and any sensible person will think positively about people of any age, sex, appearance etc taking exercise. If you can just get into the habit of smiling and running on by people you meet without feeling awkward or self-conscious, that way you can enjoy the park scenery as well as the fresh air.

DoItAgainPlz · 18/09/2023 14:44

CharlotteBog · 18/09/2023 14:30

Millions of people live, work and pursue leisure activities in poorly lit areas.
Do you think they never go out alone from 4pm during the winter months?
Running doesn't pose any more risk than other activities.

Congratukations, this may be the most Mumsnetty response of the entire thread.

Perhaps we have different definitions of "poorly lit". Parks and country roads without street lighting are poorly lit (or not lit at all). Main streets with street lamps are fine.

Running absolutely poses more of a risk than other activities. You're one wet leaf or piece of litter away from slipping and twisting your ankle when running, which you could avoid if you could actually see where you're going.

Unless you think I live somewhere with enternal sunshine, I am also one of the millions who lives, works and persues leisure activities after 4pm on winter evenings.