Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Trigger warning: newspaper story involving sex abuse and baby murder. To be furious that this girl has been treated as a suspect and not a victim

68 replies

Oioicaptain · 18/09/2023 09:58

I am utterly perplexed by the decision to charge and label the daughter as being in a consensual incestuous relationship with her father. She had 2 babies with him before she was 20. He had another with another of his daughters, which was forced. Who on earth in their right mind believes that any daughter would willingly have a consensual sexual relationship with their own father and choose to father his children and give birth at home without any medical assistance and then kill her own babies?!!! This poor young lady lost her mother at a young age and has doubtless endured years of abuse and trauma. Yet here she is, paraded around by the tabloids and charged rather than being treated as a victim.

Remains of three newborns discovered in 'house of horror' in Poland https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12530345/Remains-three-newborns-discovered-basement-father-54-daughter-20-consensual-relationship-raped-girls.html?ito=native_share_article-nativemenubutton

Remains of three newborns discovered in 'house of horror' in Poland

Depraved Piotr Gierasik, 54, and Paulina Gierasik, 20 (pictured), were arrested after the babies' remains were discovered in shallow graves at the property in Czerniki northern Poland

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12530345/Remains-three-newborns-discovered-basement-father-54-daughter-20-consensual-relationship-raped-girls.html?ito=native_share_article-nativemenubutton

OP posts:
diddumsp · 19/09/2023 00:50

This is dreadful and sad but don't be naive enough to think that this doesn't happen ever by choice.
There have been cases of young women who have chosen to engage in sexual relationships with their fathers.
I am not saying that this is what she did.
But to all those saying a young 16 would never do this is simply untrue.
Unfortunately, in my job I have dealt with cases like this.

mike4442 · 19/09/2023 00:41

I am well aware that the girl needs long-term treatment, and being under the influence of her sick father for many years, she may not even be fully aware of what is really going on here, but in Poland such matters are perceived differently, and with such a sick case the authorities probably haven't even dealt yet. It turns out that already 10 years ago someone reported that in this house there may have been sexual contact between the father and the children, but this was ignored. I'm afraid there's a lot we don't know yet.

mike4442 · 19/09/2023 00:33

These are the statements of people who know this girl and her last employer, who noticed that she was recently pregnant and then suddenly there was neither pregnancy nor baby, that is why she notified the authorities. The most shocking thing about this case is that everyone knew about it and no one did anything, everyone saw that they "lived like husband and wife" and considered it normal, because they saw them constantly together in loving embraces and, as they stated, "got used to it." Even her brother knew and, despite being in the military, did nothing about it. I don't know how it will go on, but the Polish law will never forgive her killing this 2 newborns.

Insommmmnia · 18/09/2023 22:24

I am the last person who would judge anyone, but this story is a bit more complicated. The girl was "in a relationship" with her father for a minimum of 4 years

Of course, I agree that the girl is a victim, but according to the testimony of people who knew her, it was a voluntary relationship

4 years ago she was 16. I personally don't believe a 16 year old can be in a voluntary relationship with her father. Especially not a father who shaves her hair off so other boys won't look at her.

And the minimum of 4 years makes it sound like her father was raping her as an underage child. There's nothing voluntary about that even if the child thinks it's voluntary

Blueeyedmale · 18/09/2023 22:00

I have no words poor girl

arabellaL · 18/09/2023 21:58

I was horrified by this story too on multiple levels. And the picture was hugely upsetting too if it is what I assumed it was... why was there no trigger warning and why at all? She very much sounds a child abuse victim.

mike4442 · 18/09/2023 21:26

I am the last person who would judge anyone, but this story is a bit more complicated. The girl was "in a relationship" with her father for a minimum of 4 years, they made no secret of it, the whole village (more than 200 people) knew (including their family, her brother admitted on FB that he also knew), they walked hand in hand, embraced each other in public, the girl's friends said that she never said a bad word about her father, they exchanged affection and heart-to-heart between them on FB for several years. Of course, I agree that the girl is a victim, but according to the testimony of people who knew her, it was a voluntary relationship - she was not imprisoned by her father, she worked, had normal contact with people, a completely different situation than with Fritzl. And as she is suspected of involvement in the murder of 2 newborns, according to the letter of Polish law, the police could not act otherwise and had to arrest her. What will happen next no one knows, already there are suspicions that other things happened in this house, and that the death of the children's mother 15 years ago was not accidental.

DeepL Translate: The world's most accurate translator

Translate texts & full document files instantly. Accurate translations for individuals and Teams. Millions translate with DeepL every day.

http://www.deepl.com/Translator

Trevorton · 18/09/2023 16:40

I think the stuff on her face is chocolate. The article states she works in a bakery and then said it was a confectionary store so I assume chocolate. Agree that it is horrific and she is a victim rather than a suspect.

timetochangethering · 18/09/2023 16:08

BTW though I'm with you completely, She should be treated as a victim (if the reports are correct).

timetochangethering · 18/09/2023 16:00

The main defining factor I think is the "could she have walked away?" "could she have reported what was happening?"

Once she passes a point of age where she is a legal adult what did she do?....

I am very well aware of the issues, you have grooming, Stockholm syndrome, along with all the other obvious issues here...but if she could have stopped/left/reported and didn't, then she becomes complicit.

If she is right now "happily" claiming to be in a consensual relationship and is/was "free to leave" and aware of the murders....its very difficult territory.

Dizzydahlias · 18/09/2023 15:34

How could that relationship be consensual, poor woman. The man has sexually abused at least two of his daughters, sickening.

TempName247 · 18/09/2023 15:34

Exactly what I thought. She is only 20 now, of course she’s been groomed and raped from a young age.

IvorTheEngineDriver · 18/09/2023 15:28

I am sorry but I would want far more information than a report in the Mail before coming to a decision.

Webex · 18/09/2023 15:15

Yes I thought the same. Very strange reporting of this.

RockyBroadway · 18/09/2023 14:35

I thought the same thing when I read this. She is a victim too. Murdered babies, sex with two daughters, shaving her head.

This is a mess and his daughters need support too. She may think she is in a consensual relationship with her father, but she most definitely is not.

ItstimeToMoveagain · 18/09/2023 13:42

Sounds like Stockholm syndrome to me . Poor women

BonnieLisbon · 18/09/2023 13:36

Yes she's an abuse victim

Insommmmnia · 18/09/2023 13:32

@ProfessorSlocombe she's not just been charged with murder. She's been charged with having an incestuous relationship with her father

IcakethereforeIam · 18/09/2023 13:27

It'd be mitigation though. No idea about Poland either.

ProfessorSlocombe · 18/09/2023 13:24

Just to be pedantic, but in English law, duress is no defence to murder.

(I have no idea how the Polish legal system works).

IcakethereforeIam · 18/09/2023 13:21

I think (hope) that stuff is chocolate.

I can't imagine, she'd already been impregnated by him at least once, given birth without medical attention and seen her baby...what? Hopefully 😔 stillborn, killed in front of her, taken away and not brought back or was she coerced into killing it? And then it happened again, but this time she knew what to expect. And she had to watch the same thing happen to her sister. This is monstrous. I'm not a believer but this makes me wish for a hell.

Deadringer · 18/09/2023 13:11

How on earth could that girl be expected to understand what consent is, living in those circumstances?

Oioicaptain · 18/09/2023 13:09

What really fueled my sense of injustice was the tabloids using the term 'incestuous' relationship in their headlines, even if inverted commas. People always ignore the inverted commas and read it as a given. There then proceeded a barrage of comments about how sick they were or how they had never read anything as sick before in their lives! Well, actually unfortunately we do hear about hideous sexual child abuse and yet people seem to think this is different. It's just hideous!

OP posts:
Oioicaptain · 18/09/2023 13:05

Well at least I'm not the only one who feels this. I searched online to see if there was any uproar in Poland but couldn't find anything. I feel helpless over this. I'll keep looking and see if there is an online campaign of any sort. This poor young lady needs a lot of help and therapy.

OP posts:
MoonShinesBright · 18/09/2023 10:46

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.