Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this was thoughtless of MIL

85 replies

GotMooMilk · 17/09/2023 22:22

This weekend DC x 2 (6,4) staying with MIL overnight. For context MIL doesn’t babysit often- maybe 4 x a year for one night which we are grateful for. She works full time but never really has plans on a weekend or evening so is free a lot. This weekend while looking after our kids she took her elder GC to buy a winter coat- they are all girls and the older is only 6m older than my eldest. MIL had offered to pay for her winter coat (her mum is a single mum so I’m guessing that’s why) which is absolutely fine but she took our girls along for this shopping trip.
This in itself is fine but she keeps making comments about my eldest also wanting a coat, trying on the same coat and trying to ask her nanny to buy it for her. Now MIL said no and just bought for eldest as planned but surely this was inevitable? My DC are young so don’t understand you don’t ask to be bought things but equally won’t understand why nanny is buying their cousin a coat and not them. She could have left the kids with another family member for an hour or gone shopping for coats literally any other evening or weekend day but chose to take out kids and have them watch their cousin be bought a coat.
I dunno just feels off. I won’t say anything and I don’t want her to buy the kids coats! I just think it’s a weird thing to do.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LookItsMeAgain · 18/09/2023 13:56

JMSA · 17/09/2023 23:30

Hardly a Barbie doll. It's an essential item of clothing.

Was it essential though for the grandmother to bring ALL of the grandchildren along and to decide to buy just one of them a coat on the ONE night out of so many that she was looking after the OP's kids along with their cousin?

Was that essential?? Could that have been done before the OP's kids arrived for their sleep over or after they left?

GotMooMilk · 18/09/2023 13:31

Thanks for getting it- I don’t want to appear grabby (clearly as an adult I completely understand why a lone parent needs more financial input than a 2 parent household) or ungrateful for the childcare which is why I won’t say anything.

OP posts:
ColleenDonaghy · 18/09/2023 13:30

Gymnopedie · 18/09/2023 13:11

Yes, they sulk, but I explain it all evens out in the end. It's an important lesson to not just get everything because you want it right there and then.

But that's the key. You explain it. Not in the full on equivalent of family finances, sisingle mother, blah blah blah, but a simple 'we're going to get Lucy a new coat because hers doesn't fit her anymore'. And if the child says they want a new coat too, you say they don't need one yet because theirs still fits them. You may well still get a response of 'S'not fair', but that's when and how they learn that they don't get everything they want all the time.

From the OP it sounds like granny just said no. So it wasn't the buying of a coat for one and not the others, it was the lack of any sort of communication, which could easily lead the DCs to think that it was favouritism.

Exactly, and not only did granny not deal with it on the day but she complained to OP about the six year old. Fine not to get her something (although most would have picked up something small I think) but very normal for a six year old to wonder why granny is buying something for their cousin but not for them.

Gymnopedie · 18/09/2023 13:11

Yes, they sulk, but I explain it all evens out in the end. It's an important lesson to not just get everything because you want it right there and then.

But that's the key. You explain it. Not in the full on equivalent of family finances, sisingle mother, blah blah blah, but a simple 'we're going to get Lucy a new coat because hers doesn't fit her anymore'. And if the child says they want a new coat too, you say they don't need one yet because theirs still fits them. You may well still get a response of 'S'not fair', but that's when and how they learn that they don't get everything they want all the time.

From the OP it sounds like granny just said no. So it wasn't the buying of a coat for one and not the others, it was the lack of any sort of communication, which could easily lead the DCs to think that it was favouritism.

Ikeepmybumcheekshidden · 18/09/2023 12:18

2jacqi · 17/09/2023 22:59

and other grand daughter had a lesson that if you want or need something then go to the bank of gran!!!!!! not good at all!!

A grandmother buying a gift for their grandchild is "not good at all?" & "bank of Gran" Please explain @2jacqi

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 18/09/2023 11:22

Sorry I just re read and re the MIL comments about your daughter - you'd DH absolutely has to pick up on that. Say 'you mentioned a few times dc was asking for this, she probably didn't understand why she wasn't getting a treat. We will try to have a chat with her about our family's different financial situations if we need to but we'd prefer to not burden any of the girls with thinking about that so I wonder if it might be best to give us a heads up about shopping trips or keep them to when our kids aren't there'

But he has to tread very carefully as we don't want mil having a tantrum and refusing to babysit again

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 18/09/2023 11:18

I think it was insensitive of her. My parents wouldn't buy something for my baby in front of my nieces and not get them at least a token thing too. BUT it's not so bad that I would stop the sleepovers with the cousins too which sounds great for you dc and also must be nice for you too!

You could explain something to the girls in general like 'cousins mummy sometimes needs some help to buy things for cousin so grandma helps her. Your mummy and daddy both have jobs so we don't need grandmas help to buy your clothes- we take you shopping ourselves. If you see grandma buying her something it's not a present for cousin, it's because grandma is helping auntie to pay for things that your mummy and daddy buy for you. When it's time for you to have a new coat mummy and daddy will get you one don't worry! At Christmas and birthdays grandma buys you both similar presents (if that's true!)'

You could also ask dp to ask his mum for a heads up if there's anything like that planned as the girls might misinterpret it as them not getting a treat and not being liked as much or something but don't say anything yourself

GotMooMilk · 18/09/2023 09:06

ColleenDonaghy · 18/09/2023 09:02

I'm with you OP, I think MIL was thoughtless. Very predictable that they would be jealous of their cousin getting a new coat - mine are similar ages and love getting new clothes. And actually, because they're close in age and tend to need new stuff each season because they've outgrown the old stuff, they tend to get new stuff at the same time (even though DD2's is usually from DD1) so it doesn't actually arise that often at home. And as OP said, a trip out with granny and a cousin makes it very different to a trip out with mum.

If it needed to be done that day, fine, but very strange of MIL to be complaining about a six year old acting like a six year old. She should have dealt with it at the time.

Thank you that’s basically exactly how I feel. It’s not the situation at all really it’s the fact she made the comment about DD1 which then made me feel guilty and like she was behaving like a brat. And then I thought about it and thought actually why do that? She’s never bought the girls any clothes or anything like that before, as I explained that’s fine! Don’t expect it. But a 6 year old brain won’t understand that

OP posts:
ColleenDonaghy · 18/09/2023 09:02

I'm with you OP, I think MIL was thoughtless. Very predictable that they would be jealous of their cousin getting a new coat - mine are similar ages and love getting new clothes. And actually, because they're close in age and tend to need new stuff each season because they've outgrown the old stuff, they tend to get new stuff at the same time (even though DD2's is usually from DD1) so it doesn't actually arise that often at home. And as OP said, a trip out with granny and a cousin makes it very different to a trip out with mum.

If it needed to be done that day, fine, but very strange of MIL to be complaining about a six year old acting like a six year old. She should have dealt with it at the time.

legalseagull · 18/09/2023 08:49

I regularly take my 4 and 5 year olds shopping. Sometimes I'll buy one something and not the other - because the other doesn't NEED it. Yes, they sulk, but I explain it all evens out in the end. It's an important lesson to not just get everything because you want it right there and then.

FamBae · 18/09/2023 08:30

I agree OP it was thoughtless, and if she mentions it again, just reiterate what you say in your post, she's only 6 and doesn't understand family finances or need.

VenusClapTrap · 18/09/2023 08:25

Those saying that coats are a boring purchase to children - depends entirely on the child. One of mine wouldn’t be interested and wouldn’t bat an eyelid in this situation, but my other loves clothes and would have felt this keenly at six years old (and he’s male, to even out the comment above about girls!)

Ikeepmybumcheekshidden · 18/09/2023 08:20

How cruel. Especially when your DC are girls too. I'll be ripped apart for sexism but (most) girls love buying clothes and will see the other GDC being treated and them not. My DM would've bought them all coats and then probably apologised to me for overstepping and doing so without asking! (Even though obviously I'd just be bloody grateful but you get my point!)

I think she comes into it also. If your DDs were, say, 13+ then they'd probably have fully understood

Parlourgames · 18/09/2023 08:15

She sounds unwise and yes this is likely to cause jealousy. However, I don’t think there’s any point saying anything.

My FIL favours one set of grandchildren more than the others but the only consequence of that is that the ones who aren’t favoured don’t really like him so much. It’s all so obvious. He can’t see it but his grandchildren do.

I am not sure it matters too much in the long run. The relationship that is slightly damaged is not your responsibility.

SallyWD · 18/09/2023 08:11

One grandchild needed a coat. I'm assuming your two didn't need a coat. I think it's fine that they all went. Sounds like she doesn't have the grandchildren very frequently so probably doesn't have many opportunities to buy a coat. She probably wanted to get it before the temperatures drop.
It's not like she bought the girl a really exciting toy - that would have been insensitive. My children find coats a very boring purchase.

GnomeDePlume · 18/09/2023 08:06

Rookie mistake by MIL not managing expectations.

When DCs were small we learned to make clear to them what each outing of any sort would contain. This would then be repeated at regular intervals.

Loubelle70 · 18/09/2023 07:54

@GotMooMilk your MIL is sucking up to her partners daughter, thats all this is. Wanting to appear 'nice'. My mother rarely helped me out and i was the one struggling, the other siblings she helped out. She was horrible to me. You know her, her stepdaughter doesn't, shes trying to paint herself as someone she isn't to win favour. Manipulative technique.
Explain to your kids about the other child needing a coat as family doesn't have much money..and if they need anything you'll get it them. Does gran ever treat your kids? X

user1492757084 · 18/09/2023 07:54

I think the timing was just opportunistic (when it suited cousin's mother best). The MIL included your kids for the joy of the girls being good company for one another.
They might too have bought groceries?

It's possible that the MIL told you out of humour.
It is funny that your little one needed a new coat when her other one was fine.

Vinrouge4 · 18/09/2023 07:45

Thoughtless in my opinion. Of course a six year old wouldn’t understand why only one child was being bought a coat. Nothing to do with being spoiled.

GotMooMilk · 18/09/2023 07:42

@Butchyrestingface she was- it’s actually the daughter of MILs partner rather than her daughter directly but her partner had offered to buy the school shoes and as he’s a man he deferred the task to MIL.
Of course I don’t just buy my kids the same in the name of fairness I’m not crazy 😂 but when you’re staying with your nanny once in a blue moon and get taken shopping to buy your cousin something just seems a bit odd.
And the whole ‘if you needed something nanny would get it’ isn’t really true as MIL hasn’t bought them anything like that before. Again fine but I wouldn’t say that as then DC might think she would buy them something in future which I wouldn’t expect from her- I’m happy to sort their clothes etc myself obviously!

OP posts:
user1492757084 · 18/09/2023 07:35

Your children are old enough to understand that their cousin needed a coat and they did not. It was a fun shopping trip to all choose a coat for cousin.

If the third child had been their sibling (who needed a coat) surely your other children would have understood that kids don't have new coats unless they need them. You, OP, would sometimes take your own kids to buy some shoes etc. just for the child who needs them. It is logical and if your children don't understand then explain that concept to them.

I have no problem with MIL and I would not be whispering to prepare them. If a child has what they need they should be happy, grateful and excited for another child to have what they need.

Simple logical explanations should suffice...
Cousin needed a coat.
Their Mum asked her Mum to buy it as a fun thing to do.
Granny thought you would like the shopping trip to help cousin buy a coat.

Fair is fair but fair is rarely exactly equal - kids need to feel lucky, content and well cared for regardless of equality of possessions, attention lavished on them etc.
I would be saying - "How fun to shop for cousin's coat. What colour did she choose. You don't need a coat. If you pooped your knickers or split your shoes Granny would have got you some more but you didn't. There was no need for you to have another coat."

And perhaps cousin will hand down the coat to her younger cousins when she has grown out of it.

impromptusundayluncheon · 18/09/2023 07:35

But surely you don't buy your children the same thing every time you take them out? If your child needs shoes you don't buy the other one shoes surely? So this must have happened multiple times before in their lives? Plus she would have done the same thing when she was a parent? She wouldn't buy all her children a coat because one of them needed one?

Loubelle70 · 18/09/2023 07:24

I don't buy one grandchild more than another. Gran should have just taken the DGC on her own to buy her a coat if she couldn't afford something for all.

Butchyrestingface · 18/09/2023 07:20

@JMSA in fairness she wasn’t alone with the kids as the eldest GC mum was there too

So the child’s mother was there too, @GotMooMilk ? Is this your MiL’s daughter? I wonder if maybe in case this was the only/most convenient time for them to shop together.

In any case, it’s a minor issue. Perhaps your MiL commented on your daughter’s reaction because she feels, rightly or wrongly, her granddaughter’s mother was somehow embarrassed by the situation.

Tilllly · 18/09/2023 07:15

I think the only issue here is MIL commenting about it

It's easily explained to 6 yr old that her mummy will sort her winter coat, no big deal
But to make comments to OP about her asking for one is a bit unkind