Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not invite sister in law

61 replies

Gameofphonesx · 17/09/2023 22:15

Have three sinlaws, get along great with two, kids all get along and often meet up to vent about our in laws amongst general chit chat and just because we enjoy each others company. Third sinlaw is dh sister and somewhat socially awkward(?). She didn’t speak to me for the first 7 years, her own dad said she was just jealous of us because we were happy and she went from one loser bf to another. I tried to ignore it, trying killing it with kindness but eventually just got over trying. She had her first kid then that was it, suddenly she seemed a bit more interested in speaking to me and took a lot of baby paraphernalia from us. Thing is, I don’t need to be her friend but my in laws are constantly moaning about us not inviting her anywhere- but she rarely speaks to the other two or myself unless it’s about herself and it’s just tense with her there. Her and her bf don’t invite us anywhere or make an effort to ask about the kids or us yet we’re expected to invite her on weekends away that we organised between us, because they think we’re leaving her out- she leaves herself out! She’s been invited to days out and has refused, she turns up late if she does come and then will keep her distance so it doesn’t even feel like she enjoys it herself?! I feel it’s just too little too late to have the same relationship that the rest of us have, to the point where I feel awkward if we happen to be altogether at in-laws house for example. I don’t mind her but as far as I’m concerned, she’s had numerous chances to make an effort and she just doesn’t. I do feel for her in a way, but it just feels like my in-laws are forcing her on us a bit. It’s made a bit more tense as her ds is very bitey, pushy and generally terrorises the rest of the kids and they don’t like his behaviour towards them. I wouldn’t not invite her for that alone, but equally I don’t want to make the other kids and sinlaws uncomfortable by just inviting her everywhere. I thought this ‘leaving her out’ rubbish was over in school!!

OP posts:
Gameofphonesx · 18/09/2023 07:08

With all due respect, she’s not autistic. By all accounts, she’s been a sullen, rude, selfish brat her whole life. The whole family cannot communicate effectively, preferring to talk behind backs in the hope that Chinese whispers gets them what they want. Aside from the fact that she is who she is and ignored me all that time and it’s only been a year or so that she’s been willing to talk to me, even if we really wanted her there- I wouldn’t want to invite her just because her mum and dad told me to! Id like it to be a bit more natural. I don’t want her thinking we’ve invited her somewhere but only because we’ve been told to. The other sinlaws don’t do anything with her as she doesn’t talk to them either unless she wants something from them- she’s able to talk to them then! Ideally they’d be encouraging her more, rather than forcing us. I get that she’s their daughter but this way of getting us all to be best friends isn’t working for them so why can’t they just listen to us. They’re the same, never inviting us anywhere, expecting us to organise family days out etc. it’s exhausting. The husbands are just the same, don’t say anything because they don’t want to upset their mum- because their wives can stick up for themselves!

OP posts:
weirdoboelady · 17/09/2023 23:07

She is autistic.

I'm saying this so confidently NOT because I am an expert or know that she is. My reason for saying it is that I reframe her behaviour like this in my head, it makes so much more sense, and would make it easier for me to be kind to her if she was my SIL.

I do question myself - why can I have lots of patience with friends who I know have an autism diagnosis, but can't accommodate personality quirks with people without a formal diagnosis? This has helped me accept more from friends who are obviously struggling, and I recommend it as a strategy. My own model also involves (where appropriate/possible) talking to the person who is struggling and asking them what I can do to help them feel more included or to ease any social difficulties they have.....

*Now I'm going to hunker down and wait for MN to tell me what a poor or ableist strategy this is and how I am letting myself be walked on. The objective is to be kind and inclusive, BTW.

TheCatterall · 17/09/2023 22:53

Just say no @Gameofphonesx - otherwise it will be a lifetime of misery for all concerned and life is too short.

your adults and MIL needs to accept she can no longer bully other family members into dragging sinlaw along to everything.

do the other sinlaws do things with her?

id just reiterate no. She doesn’t arrange anything herself, she doesn’t act like she enjoys days out. No MIL we aren’t dragging along an unwilling surly child in an adults body.

saraclara · 17/09/2023 22:42

Gameofphonesx · 17/09/2023 22:34

Why can’t she invite us somewhere for a change!?

Sounds like she's socially anxious.

I have a relative who is the same. She's actually lovely, and appreciates all her family members. But she never invites anyone to anything, because it's way out of her comfort zone, and she would really worry about it.
We continue to invite her, and the fact that she's much quieter than the rest of us doesn't matter

Gameofphonesx · 17/09/2023 22:34

Why can’t she invite us somewhere for a change!?

OP posts:
Gameofphonesx · 17/09/2023 22:34

Well then why would she want to be friends with me? 😂

OP posts:
Maddy70 · 17/09/2023 22:33

You dont sound very nice. Invite her when you invite the other sil. Every fucking time

.

Gameofphonesx · 17/09/2023 22:30

My problem is, we didn’t always ‘leave her out’ she’s been invited plenty of times to things and always had some excuse so naturally you know, we stopped asking- it happens! It also implies we are doing it in a spiteful way. She’s not on our radar, just as we aren’t on hers. My husband is quite quiet but has stood up for me as far as I know. He’s also my in-laws child but they treat his sister like the most important (only girl, youngest). I just want to be friends with who I want to be friends with. She does get invited to days out with our husbands and their parents, we just don’t always think about it when we’re organising it between ourselves- I don’t even invite my own sister as I just see it as my friends🤷🏼‍♀️

OP posts:
Ghastisflabbered · 17/09/2023 22:23

Well you are leaving her out aren’t you?

and of course your in-laws are going to push it - she’s their actual daughter so will be important to them.

ChubbyMorticia · 17/09/2023 22:21

“MIL, SIL has made her disinterest in a relationship with me clear. I respect her decision.”

Where’s your dh in this? Why doesn’t he tell his mother to MHOB?

theduchessofspork · 17/09/2023 22:20

Well you are leaving her out..

Just compromise and invite her to some things, but not weekends away. And if people ask why just say because she’s a PITA. The price for family life is a bit of compromise.

Can I just appreciate sinlaws I really hope that gets adopted 😈