Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not invite sister in law

61 replies

Gameofphonesx · 17/09/2023 22:15

Have three sinlaws, get along great with two, kids all get along and often meet up to vent about our in laws amongst general chit chat and just because we enjoy each others company. Third sinlaw is dh sister and somewhat socially awkward(?). She didn’t speak to me for the first 7 years, her own dad said she was just jealous of us because we were happy and she went from one loser bf to another. I tried to ignore it, trying killing it with kindness but eventually just got over trying. She had her first kid then that was it, suddenly she seemed a bit more interested in speaking to me and took a lot of baby paraphernalia from us. Thing is, I don’t need to be her friend but my in laws are constantly moaning about us not inviting her anywhere- but she rarely speaks to the other two or myself unless it’s about herself and it’s just tense with her there. Her and her bf don’t invite us anywhere or make an effort to ask about the kids or us yet we’re expected to invite her on weekends away that we organised between us, because they think we’re leaving her out- she leaves herself out! She’s been invited to days out and has refused, she turns up late if she does come and then will keep her distance so it doesn’t even feel like she enjoys it herself?! I feel it’s just too little too late to have the same relationship that the rest of us have, to the point where I feel awkward if we happen to be altogether at in-laws house for example. I don’t mind her but as far as I’m concerned, she’s had numerous chances to make an effort and she just doesn’t. I do feel for her in a way, but it just feels like my in-laws are forcing her on us a bit. It’s made a bit more tense as her ds is very bitey, pushy and generally terrorises the rest of the kids and they don’t like his behaviour towards them. I wouldn’t not invite her for that alone, but equally I don’t want to make the other kids and sinlaws uncomfortable by just inviting her everywhere. I thought this ‘leaving her out’ rubbish was over in school!!

OP posts:
actualpuffins · 18/09/2023 10:03

No-one is obliged to be best mates with relatives or invite them along to weekends away- you didn't choose them, and especially not by dint of marrying her brother. If anything DH should be making the effort with his sister, she's not your sister.

I wouldn't give this any energy at all and just crack on as you are. It's great that you get on so well with two people out of your extended family.

Ikeatears · 18/09/2023 10:02

At the last count, I have 9 sil's. One is one of my best friends (dh's sister) and in the two years I've known her, my brother's wife is fast becoming a close friend. Some of the others I socialise with, some I don't. Some I like, some are not my kind of person.

If it's something for the family or the children, then the invitation is usually extended to all (children range from babies to adults so it depends on the event). If I'm just socialising with who I consider to be my friends then I invite the people I want to spend time with.

Dh has two other sisters and all three are close. I don't see one of them much but me and the sister I'm closest to and one of the other sisters occasionally all get together.

I won't have anyone, in laws or not, dictate to me who I spend my free time with, I'm pleasant and kind to all of the sils and have always gone out of my way to include them in my family life but my personal friendships are my business, sil or no sil.

Gameofphonesx · 18/09/2023 09:54

@Duckskitbank nice to get a reply from ‘the other side’. My PIL don’t realise they’re the problem.

OP posts:
Duckskitbank · 18/09/2023 09:41

YANBU.
And I say that as ‘the odd one out’ with my in laws. They all love going on holiday together and I really don’t! I make an effort for big occasions but then they immediately start planning the next one and we bow out. The women organise days out and weekends away together. They didn’t used to invite me and I was fine with it. Now they sometimes invite me and I make my polite excuses! I don’t dislike them but I have my own friends and I don’t need these forced friendships.
It either works naturally or it doesn’t, what’s the point in forcing it?

Gameofphonesx · 18/09/2023 09:30

@Ragwort she involves herself! Gets a sniff that we might all have a day off together and starts complaining that we’re not inviting sinlaw before we’ve even planned anything 😂 Doesn’t complain to us though- one of my BILs gets it in the neck, it causes aggro between him and his wife, then we’re all pissed off. Ideal scenario would be sinlaw just sends a ‘going out to soft play, anyone wanna come?’ Then we would make an effort to meet her- she’s not a bad person. Just too much like her mother 😂.
@AnIndianWoman I don’t invite my own sister either, nor do the other sinlaws. My sister isn’t the slightest bit concerned??

OP posts:
SherbetLemonn · 18/09/2023 09:27

I wouldn’t have bothered with her after she ignored you for seven years to be honest, so you’re doing better than me already. I wouldn’t be pressured into inviting her everywhere, I’d carry on as I chose. She opts to decline, to be late, to be distant and that’s her call but I wouldn’t be changing my plans for her.

Gameofphonesx · 18/09/2023 09:25

@coconutpie finally somebody gets it 😂👏🏻 In all honesty, I just don’t have the time or energy for all this and would just like my PIL to butt out and let us invite her when we want to. It won’t be every time we meet no, but I have my own crap going on and can’t be bothered with worrying about someone else.

OP posts:
AnIndianWoman · 18/09/2023 09:24

They’re not friends, they’re family. That’s the mistake you’re making here. When it come to family you shouldn’t be leaving anyone out especially when kids are involved - invite all or none.

Ragwort · 18/09/2023 09:23

moose makes a good point, why is your MIL so involved in your plans ... you all sound totally enmeshed with each other?

moose62 · 18/09/2023 09:20

I agree with the family chat....then you can say " anyone free to meet up on Tuesday?"....if she doesn't respond then your MIL can't say you didn't invite her! Perhaps engage less with the MIL as well!

coconutpie · 18/09/2023 09:18

You are getting a very hard time here OP. So you are friends with your two SILs (the wives of the two brothers of your DH) but your DH's sister has always been rude and ignored you and not nice to you for years and now you are expected to include her in your plans just because she is your DH's sister? You are friends with the other SILs. Why should you ruin your interactions with your two friends just because your ILs said to invite her along? That's ridiculous.

I'd imagine that she'd totally change the dynamic anyway if she's that difficult and rude - could you even trust that she wouldn't divulge anything that the three of you talked about in confidence to PIL? It's different for you and the other two SIL as you all married the sons of PIL. You aren't obliged to invite her out on friendship days out when she is not a friend.

Gameofphonesx · 18/09/2023 09:16

@Spareus thats my point- we do have the family group chat and nobody uses it to chat except us! 😂
@Nosleepforthismum my main concern then is why do I have to change my behaviour, when she can’t try to change hers? I’m not an unkind person- if I was, I wouldn’t be doubting myself enough to ask a forum of strangers whether I was been an arse or not. Seemingly I’m an arsehole for giving up after almost 10 years of trying and getting nothing back. Rude, sullen, selfish people don’t have to bother obviously.

OP posts:
BrawnWild · 18/09/2023 09:13

I think you need to decide which it is:

You would invite her under your own steam for the sake of the family if given the chance

OR

You dont like her and as an adult you can make your own decisions about who you invite.

I actually get what you mean, you see your other in law sils as friends and she makes a fun gathering awkward. But what you have to remember is that family complicates things and if push came to shove, you could be excluded if you and DH broke up, so the family element IS relevant because you arent just friends.

In your shoes I'd set up a new WhatsApp an try to make alternating plans to include her through it. Invite her one week in the group and put up with it - you know she wont come every time, and the times that she doesnt come you can arrange another meeting without her and just say it was planned when she wasnt there.

But there is a real risk the others might cave if they are under pressure and you'll be seen in a bad light because you were asked to do the same and you didnt. Families are weird. You can pick your friends but not your family.

Spareus · 18/09/2023 09:04

@Gameofphonesx family chat sounds like a great idea, drop in the open invite next time then you can’t be accused of not inviting her. Doesn’t stop you organising other things without her, but maybe limit the fb audience if you post those - or better still don’t post, send pics to anyone who might want to see tha (top tip - it’s not most of your friends and family who do 😜)

She sounds hard work. Empathise totally in having in-laws who communicate via Chinese whispers, so draining. I just opted out of comms altogether and let the DH deal with his lot!

Nosleepforthismum · 18/09/2023 09:02

I have to say that you aren’t coming across particularly kind on this thread. She may well have been jealous when she was younger to see her brothers settling down and having kids but she’s your DH’s sister and your children’s aunt and I’d really be trying to make an effort with her even if it’s not reciprocated all the time. It sounds really quite teenage and bitchy by deliberately meeting up with all the other SIL’s and excluding her. No one will believe the whole “we just didn’t think” excuse btw. I’m almost certain she will know how you all feel about her so I’m not surprised she’s awkward when you do all meet up. Try setting a good example for your children and actually be warm and welcoming to her on the next group meet-up and shut down any negative comments from your other SIL’s.

Gameofphonesx · 18/09/2023 08:57

@ittakes2 if it were my child, honestly I first of all wouldn’t let her get to this point. Doesn’t sound like she’s been told she’s wrong very often. Everything is just ignored. She definitely isn’t neurodiverse and even if she was, I’d be encouraging her as a parent, to go out when we asked, and turn up on time, to ask us if we want to go with them when they’re going out, to actually respond when we do ask. I personally would think a family group chat would be an ideal place to just pop on and say ‘going swimming today if anybody fancies it?’. It’s low key, you’re going swimming anyway, you don’t have to make plans around other people, you don’t have to organise anything, but she just doesn’t and when we do- she takes ages to respond, or doesn’t at all. I don’t even think she wants to involve herself- it’s all coming from MIL!

OP posts:
ittakes2 · 18/09/2023 08:50

I have three sisters and one of them is tricky - she would feel hurt if we organised for all our kids to go swimming during school holidays (ages 2-10) and then not think to invite her because it never occurred to us she would want to take a day off to work to come too (she has an adult child). To be honest your s’n’law sounds neurodiverse and is likely to have trouble with social communication. Just because her body language is displaying one thing she might be feeling something else. I don’t have the right answer but all I can say if one of your children was neurodiverse how would you feel if they were left out? No judgements from my sister drives me so insane with her behaviour of sulking etc we are now low contact.

Gameofphonesx · 18/09/2023 08:39

We do invite her to some days, just others we just don’t think, but we just don’t see why she gets away with being so rude to us and then still gets us running around after her. A simple sorry would’ve gotten her so far years ago but we’re just past it I think. I prefer doing a one to one with her as I can bring her out of her shell a bit but if it’s all of us together she can just be a bit ‘me, me, me’. We’ve known her since her mid-20s. You can see where she gets it from- my mil is just the same. I’m just exhausted from having to think about other peoples feeling all the time- nobody appears to give a crap about how I felt all that time when I was being ignored and disregarded. She just got away with it because they enable her. If she was my kid or sister I’d have been telling her years ago!

OP posts:
saraclara · 18/09/2023 08:36

Yeah, it would hurt to constantly see SM posts with you and the other SILs out together. Personally I'd limit the audience for those.

harriethoyle · 18/09/2023 08:32

Hmmmm. I've three sil, two of whom I love, one of whom I struggle with. I would never organise a SIL group meet and leave the third out. It's soooo mean. Just meet the others one on one rather than excluding her from a family group. She won't come 90% of the time from what you've written but you get the brownie points.

maddening · 18/09/2023 08:24

And how old were you all and how old was she when you all met her brothers?

maddening · 18/09/2023 08:23

Invite her for the kids, her.kids have done nothing wrong and it would be nice for them to grown up with their cousins, where you have days out with the kids invite her. The more this happens the more likely you are to get to know her and that natural building of some sort of relationship might build - not necessarily as best buddies but.as family at least.

Gameofphonesx · 18/09/2023 08:18

I’ll just add, I’m only this bothered because I don’t want my nieces and nephews thinking I didn’t bother with them. I want my children to think I have actively tried to have a relationship with all of their cousins. If she didn’t have children, she probably still wouldn’t talk to us at all!

OP posts:
Gameofphonesx · 18/09/2023 08:14

@DoDoDoD we’re at this point because of them. If she’d just been a welcoming, even just polite person when we met her brothers then maybe we would all get along. She’s always been jealous of her brothers settling down before her, she makes it so obvious, stomping off whenever we’d mention houses, weddings, kids etc. I’ve tried my hardest to just say to her, speak to us if you want to engage with us. A friendship can’t be all one sided can it?? There are other issues between the in laws and each sinlaw which deserve their own threads so that skews our thinking when it comes to them anyway, but we just want the chance to invite her without them getting involved: is that really too much to ask? If I was her, I wouldn’t want to be invited somewhere because my mum had told them to invite me! It’s getting to the point where I’m being told- via somebody else of course- that I shouldn’t be posting photos to my Facebook in case it upsets her?!? Maybe if I thought she’d be sat there looking at my photos thinking ‘I wish I’d been invited, it’s because I don’t bother with them’ instead of ‘why haven’t they invited me, I deserve to be there even though I don’t talk to them’ , then I’d have more sympathy but she’s not. She wants us all to run around after her instead of doing something about it herself. Remember this person only started talking to me when it was convenient for her, when she wanted my things for her baby.

OP posts:
DoDoDoD · 18/09/2023 08:00

Gameofphonesx · 18/09/2023 07:08

With all due respect, she’s not autistic. By all accounts, she’s been a sullen, rude, selfish brat her whole life. The whole family cannot communicate effectively, preferring to talk behind backs in the hope that Chinese whispers gets them what they want. Aside from the fact that she is who she is and ignored me all that time and it’s only been a year or so that she’s been willing to talk to me, even if we really wanted her there- I wouldn’t want to invite her just because her mum and dad told me to! Id like it to be a bit more natural. I don’t want her thinking we’ve invited her somewhere but only because we’ve been told to. The other sinlaws don’t do anything with her as she doesn’t talk to them either unless she wants something from them- she’s able to talk to them then! Ideally they’d be encouraging her more, rather than forcing us. I get that she’s their daughter but this way of getting us all to be best friends isn’t working for them so why can’t they just listen to us. They’re the same, never inviting us anywhere, expecting us to organise family days out etc. it’s exhausting. The husbands are just the same, don’t say anything because they don’t want to upset their mum- because their wives can stick up for themselves!

Wow - so you and the other ILs get together for a bitchfest about the family you married into and your SIL being there would cramp your style? Sounds like she's better off out of it. She clearly has issues with social communication and seeing as your relationship with the others is through the family then yes, you should invite her every time. It might change the dynamic so you spend less time bitching.