Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scout camp plans excluding weak swimmers

133 replies

LostMySocks · 17/09/2023 20:27

DS scout group have announced a summer camp....surf camp. They have also linked the camps to getting the Gold award.
DD is a weak swimmer. No way should he be in the sea as there is a real risk that he will get into trouble. There doesn't seem to be an alternative plan even though there are younger children joining before summer. I'm assuming they won't all be super swimmers. I know they are all volunteers but this seems short sighted as a supposedly inclusive organisation. DS is very upset at the idea of not going but I don't want to pay for him to sit on a beach.

OP posts:
Riverlee · 17/09/2023 21:29

Sorry, but I think you’re being bit over critical of the scout leaders. They’re obviously seen this camp and decided to offer to the scouts. They could have chosen canoeing, sailing, rock climbing etc but opted for this. Unfortunately, they can’t please everyone at all times.

However, as you’ve identified a gap in the market, I presume you’re going to volunteer as a scout leader, so you can run a camp your dc would enjoy.

Mummyme87 · 17/09/2023 21:24

Don’t blame Covid for not being able to swim. Lessons have been running for the last 2years… my 9year old started his lessons again as leisure centres reopened. Your son has got almost a year to learn.

Inyournightgarden · 17/09/2023 21:18

LostMySocks · 17/09/2023 20:32

This is their summer camp linked to the achievement award for their section and he loves camping. But this is potentially risky. If it was an optional day activity then fine not to do it.
I'd like to see them offer something different for the weaker swimmers. Maybe rock climbing. Remember this is the cohort who have missed 2 years of swimming lessons due to Covid

What if the weak swimmers are also weak rock climbers?

sorry but you are pretty pathetic

Seashor · 17/09/2023 21:16

They will have to have qualified surf instructors at a ratio of 1 to 8 and they will all have to be over eight years of age. Your child won’t need to be able to swim but they must be water confident e.g able to put their head under. They won’t be taken out far at all . You have plenty of time to take your child swimming before the trip.

D1nopawus · 17/09/2023 21:15

If anyone can't imagine why volunteers put restrictions in place, there is a wee clue here.

Son needs an operation following camp, is there negligence www.mumsnet.com/Talk/legal_matters/4896180-son-needs-an-operation-following-camp-is-there-negligence

canonlydoblue · 17/09/2023 21:12

Sign him up to an intensive course. He'll be swimming in a week.

D1nopawus · 17/09/2023 21:09

Hazarding a guess here. When you go to do the mandatory risk assessments for any activity as a cub leader you need to identify what mitigation you are putting in place to reduce the risk of harm.

Making sure that DC have a basic swimming ability before tackling any other water activities is a pragmatic solution.

If you can't get your DS into lessons OP, are you able to commit to regular sessions as a family to boost his confidence?

ChristmasKraken · 17/09/2023 21:05

LostMySocks · 17/09/2023 20:32

This is their summer camp linked to the achievement award for their section and he loves camping. But this is potentially risky. If it was an optional day activity then fine not to do it.
I'd like to see them offer something different for the weaker swimmers. Maybe rock climbing. Remember this is the cohort who have missed 2 years of swimming lessons due to Covid

I just wanted to add, swimming lessons didn't stop for 2 years due to covid, at least in England. They were a bit stop start, but my son had lessons every time the pools opened. They only closed during the lockdowns.

sadaboutmycat · 17/09/2023 21:02

LostMySocks · 17/09/2023 20:32

This is their summer camp linked to the achievement award for their section and he loves camping. But this is potentially risky. If it was an optional day activity then fine not to do it.
I'd like to see them offer something different for the weaker swimmers. Maybe rock climbing. Remember this is the cohort who have missed 2 years of swimming lessons due to Covid

Have you offered to volunteer to run the rock climbing?
What about the kids who are afraid of heights?
What about the kids who can't climb even if they're not afraid of heights.
Not everyone can be included in everything!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 17/09/2023 21:02

LostMySocks · 17/09/2023 20:48

Those saying book swimming lessons or take him swimming. Sadly our local pools have long waiting lists
We do swim regularly but they keep weak swimmers in a small area.
I'll speak to the group leader. They're likely to have younger boys joining by then.
I'm happy not to send him but the leaders are stressing that the need to go to get programme awards.

There’s nowhere near you, or reachable, where your ds could practice swimming proper lengths, supervised by you in the water? I find that really hard to believe.

I think calling him a “weak swimmer” is part of the issue - it’s not something inherent to him, it’s just he hasn’t been taught or given the chance to practice.

AvengedQuince · 17/09/2023 21:01

I think that's perfectly reasonable for Scouts, as they are 10+. Scouts do a lot of water based activities so they really should have learnt at Cubs/Beavers age. Even if two years delayed that should be enough time for most children.

Hayliebells · 17/09/2023 21:01

I think I’d be more concerned about my child’s inability to swim than the inability to attend a scout camp! Unless there’s some reason like disability why he can’t, I’d use this as a good reason to book in some intensive lessons. And as for Covid, sorry, but lessons have been running without disruption for at least two years. Pull your finger out OP! He doesn’t even need to go to scouts, but he needs to be able to swim.

Titerama · 17/09/2023 21:00

You really don’t need to be a strong swimmer to do beginners surf lessons.

It’s waist height water at most.

And you can wear a buoyancy aid if wanted, as well as having the buoyancy of the wetsuit.

Just make sure the instructor knows he isn’t a strong swimmer, and tell him not to mess about or go beyond waist depth.

Teaching ratio is usually 1:6 for beginners, in shallow water. Weak swimming is not a bar to beginner surfing.

Nowthenhere · 17/09/2023 21:00

If they're doing risk assessments for water activities then they can add canoeing and kyaking.

Your child can then get their badges for water safety or even boating qualifications.

They will need a qualified lifeguard available and someone who can teach surfing. Most water babies know another water baby who can teach different skills.

Challenge the leadership team and ask what other skills can be learnt on water whilst the surfers are training.

Alternatively keep sending your child into scouts with latest research on shark sightings in the uk and they may suddenly find a land alternative.

modgepodge · 17/09/2023 21:00

I take kids on a school residential and we do surfing. Last year for the first time we had a child who was a non swimmer (could manage 25m just about with a float or noodle or similar). I told the leaders and they said it was fine, we didn’t go in deeper than thigh deep anyway. She was fine.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 17/09/2023 20:59

Getting your child to be a good swimmer is one of the best things you can do for them, imo. You never know when they might need it.

Sailawaytocromer · 17/09/2023 20:59

Next summer? And scouts start at age 10 or 11? Most children that age are strong enough swimmers to cope with surf camp. I’m a neurotic parent about the sea and both mine were ok by age 8 (under close supervision) and that was only just post covid.

You’ve got masses of time to fit in 2 or 3 intensive courses plus lots of practice with you. It’s an essential life skill you should prioritise anyway if you can afford it.

hugely limiting for secondary school age children not to be reasonable competent swimmers.

KvotheTheBloodless · 17/09/2023 20:59

It's crap that you've not got him swimming lessons since covid, it's been years, do better - get him on those waiting lists, keep ringing around places to see if there's free space yet. Yes, it'll suck that he's in a class with much younger children, but it's better that than him never learning, the problem will just get worse the older he gets.

If you can afford it, get him private 121 lessons, and make sure you take him swimming yourself too so he can practise what he's learning.

Floralnomad · 17/09/2023 20:58

You’ve got about 10 months to sort out his swimming , which should be a priority for you anyway . The leaders are volunteers leave them alone .

sanityisamyth · 17/09/2023 20:56

Hesma · 17/09/2023 20:55

I don’t see why the others should miss out because your scout can’t swim. Rather than moaning online ask the leaders or better still help them organise it

This.

Hesma · 17/09/2023 20:55

I don’t see why the others should miss out because your scout can’t swim. Rather than moaning online ask the leaders or better still help them organise it

JussathoB · 17/09/2023 20:55

I absolutely sympathise with you that it is a shame that DS is going to miss out on this trip.
On the other hand water can be dangerous and if your child is not a good swimmer it may be too bad but he’s not up to the trip and nobody should take risks in the sea.
So set a good example. This trip is not suitable, let the others who are stronger in the water go and enjoy it with good grace. There might be a different or better opportunity for your child in the future. A camping trip perhaps, where swimming ability is not a priority!
in the meantime continue the swimming lessons and other development opportunities for your child, everything from activities which build his physical confidence to his planning abilities and can he safely produce his own beans on toast independently etc etc

sanityisamyth · 17/09/2023 20:54

I organised sailing for Cubs last summer. POR states that they must be swimmers (scouts' definition is able to swim 50m and float for 5 minutes in a buoyancy aid) or they need 1:1 supervision. There may well not be enough Leaders. It's a volunteer run organisation (at group level) so it's up to them and their risk assessment.

Yourebeingtooloud · 17/09/2023 20:54

Climbing isn’t necessarily inclusive either. My DS has a crippling fear of heights. Neither he nor I think that’s a reason his scout group shouldn’t do climbing & abseiling. He just joins in the bits he can bear and cheers his friends on for the rest. Surf camp sounds great, especially if you don’t live that near a beach so it’s a chance for new experiences. Plus you’ve got ages to get his swimming up to scratch - the missing it due to covid excuse is a bit lame, that was 2 years ago now! My 9yo had to stop his lessons but is perfectly competent to swim the 50m required for scout water activities now.

Oysterbabe · 17/09/2023 20:52

If it's right that scouts start at 10, the younger kids joining will very likely be able to swim. Most 10 year olds can.