Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scout camp plans excluding weak swimmers

133 replies

LostMySocks · 17/09/2023 20:27

DS scout group have announced a summer camp....surf camp. They have also linked the camps to getting the Gold award.
DD is a weak swimmer. No way should he be in the sea as there is a real risk that he will get into trouble. There doesn't seem to be an alternative plan even though there are younger children joining before summer. I'm assuming they won't all be super swimmers. I know they are all volunteers but this seems short sighted as a supposedly inclusive organisation. DS is very upset at the idea of not going but I don't want to pay for him to sit on a beach.

OP posts:
Smartiepants79 · 18/09/2023 08:50

You say he is a weak swimmer? Not a non swimmer? Can he float, doggy paddle short distances, is he water confident? Is he happy to be splashed and go under?
I would think it was likely to be that risky for him. He will be supervised and properly kitted out. I’d be doing what I could to build up his swimming ability and then letting him go.

bellac11 · 18/09/2023 08:45

So he cant swim OP?

But I bet he is shit hot on using devices and gadgets.

You need to take him swimming yourself, you dont need formal lessons specifically. You show him moves and how to float and how to strengthen his arms and legs. Take him every week. Take him down to the seaside where the natural waves mean that you learn much quicker, get him a little wet suit

Get him on the lists for formal lessons too

He might not even go on the summer camp, they might not end up doing surfing but he needs to learn how to swim and as others have pointed out, there really hasnt been any reason why this shouldnt have happened before covid, during covid and post covid.

namestevalian · 18/09/2023 08:43

You are being totally unreasonable sorry.

There will be other more relevant camps .

Get your kids swimming asap , lessons !

RedToothBrush · 18/09/2023 08:43

DinnaeFashYersel · 17/09/2023 22:31

Ask the leaders what the minimum swimming level is.

You then have a year to get him to the minimum requirement.

We did a scout canoeing expedition and the minimum requirement was 25 metres.

We could not have a a separate non canoeing program at the same.

Next year we will do a hiking one.

Just to dispell a bit of a misnomer on this.

You DO NOT need to be a swimmer to do canoeing with scouts.

Their website says the following:
Everyone should be able to swim 50m wearing the clothing or equipment for the activity. Non-swimmers will need additional support.

The advice is the same for surfing. Check the scouting UK website.

Being stricter than that depends on the actual level of canoeing activity and the adult to child ratio. So a canoeing expedition might require a higher level of ability - which will be at the permitted leaders discretion based on a risk assessment, than beavers doing a taster session with their parents.

Being able to swim 50m in a buoyancy aid on flat water is totally different to being able to swim 50m unaided too.

It is possible to be running activities at range of levels with appropriate supervision even for none swimmers.

Scout UK would not allow non swimmers to surf if it wasn't possible for them to do it safely under the right conditions.

DH is permitted for kayaking and canoeing.

HohiyiKozbevi · 18/09/2023 08:41

It's not "failing to be inclusive" if the scouts do an activity that not everyone can do. If the troop had a child as a member who was blind or deaf would you expect the whole troop to only do things that can be done without any aspect needing sight or hearing? Obviously the members who can't do a particular thing are included as far as is possible within their abilities but there are still going to be some activities and experience which they can't access.

But in this case you aren't even dealing with a disability, just a child who hasn't had enough practice yet. That can be fixed.

Stroopwaffels · 18/09/2023 08:36

LostMySocks · 17/09/2023 20:32

This is their summer camp linked to the achievement award for their section and he loves camping. But this is potentially risky. If it was an optional day activity then fine not to do it.
I'd like to see them offer something different for the weaker swimmers. Maybe rock climbing. Remember this is the cohort who have missed 2 years of swimming lessons due to Covid

This is a volunteer-run organisation, with people who are good enough to give up a weekend/week of their OWN TIME to take other people's children away to camp, and spend probably six months planning it.

You are of course free to do all the training, sign up as a leader and organise your own rock climbing trip. There are clearly enough Scouts who are confident enough in the water to benefit from and enjoy a surf camp. The fact that your child is not a strong swimmer is neither here nor there.

So glad I'm not actively involved in this sort of volunteering any more. Kids a delight. Parents, not so much.

CurlsLDN · 18/09/2023 08:34

I have previously volunteered with Wave Project, they take groups of teens with physical disabilities and learning difficulties surfing. Many of those can’t swim at all. It is a very accessible activity with the right supervision.

rather than immediately assume he is excluded, ask them how he will be included, it could be a fantastic opportunity for him to try something completely new in a safe and structured environment

PuttingDownRoots · 18/09/2023 08:33

What criteria is the camp meeting? I'm guessing the nights away (8 in total over 3.5 years) and Adventurous activities. Missing one camp shouldn't completely compromise the first activity... my 10yo Scout has had 11 NA since moving up to Scouts already but she's an extreme example! Its 4 weekend camps in 3.5 years. And the adventurous activities don't actually have to be with Scouts.

RedToothBrush · 18/09/2023 08:30

Motherofacertainage · 17/09/2023 20:29

It's run by volunteers. If you don't like what they are planning, how about getting involved and running a trip yourself? They're always looking for more helpers.

This.

The leaders will do events based on the permits they have too. If they have a swimming permit they will lean to activities like that because that's the adventure stuff they have the skills in. Learning a new skill and getting permitted in it is a huge commitment which goes way beyond simply being a leader which is a big enough commitment in its own right.

Why should other kids lose out on that activity because of yours? It shouldn't be a race to the bottom either.

Being inclusive can just mean it will be giving the opportunity for kids to do that activity who would not normally get that chance - because they wouldn't have thought of it and don't have adults to enable it.

YOU have made the decision he can't take part, not the leaders though. You've assessed it's too risky. That's a lack of trust in the leaders - who will have to do a bunch of risk assessments to do anything with the kids.

With the correct supervision and equipment even weak swimmers should be fine. If they are surfing they will not be allowed in the sea without buoyancy aids and sufficient supervision.

As for doing rock climbing. They either would probably have to pay for several instructors (which gets very expensive very quickly and thus is much more excluding than surfing) or have a rock climbing permit.

DH has spent about three years jumping through ridiculous district hoops to get his, even though he is a very experienced and competent climber. More so than others who had permits. It's not an easy process.

Heyhoherewegoagain · 18/09/2023 08:22

At 10 he doesn’t need lessons to improve he just needs to swim-get him to the pool!

horseymum · 18/09/2023 08:19

You have plenty of time to help him improve his swimming and water confidence before then, it's a great target for him. Some one to one lessons to improve technique then weekly swimming lengths together and some visits to the beach in the run up if possible and he'll have a great time and be set up as a stronger swimmer for life.

queenMab99 · 18/09/2023 08:12

Have the scout group excluded him, because he is not a proficient swimmer, or are you excluding him due to your worries?

jackstini · 18/09/2023 08:03

I would book one to one lessons (or two to one if he has a friend of similar ability)

Group lessons they spend 80% of the time watching others - really slow progress and very poor value. Ds spent 2 years getting not v far, then switched to two on one lessons and completed 4 stages in 6 months!

I would still send him. Check with leaders what the activities will be, they won't all be swimming

sweeneytoddsrazor · 18/09/2023 00:04

There will be other camps he can go on that will be linked to awards. However at his age he should be able to swim. Scouts do a huge range of activities surf camp is just one of many. They hike, cycle, learn archery, abseil, build rafts, canoe, every camp they build a bivouac, they learn to cook outdoors. The volunteers who run these groups are a great group of people who give up a lot of their time so your kids can learn skills and enjoy different things. The last thing they need is berating because they are offering and activity that a child cant do because its parents haven't been arsed to do the basics necessary to take part in the activity.

UsingChangeofName · 17/09/2023 23:37

@Blinkingbonkers several posters have already pointed out that Scouts need to be able to swim 50m to be allowed to take part in water activities. No-one doing a water based activity with scouts "is sorted" by putting a life jacket on if they are a non-swimmer.

Blinkingbonkers · 17/09/2023 23:20

He’ll be attached to a very big float!!…and stick a life jacket/life preserver on and he’s sorted🤷🏼‍♀️. If swimming lessons are full take him for a fun session yourself and help him build confidence and stamina. They will be with surf school staff who will be used to catering for all abilities. You’re overthinking this I reckon.

Insommmmnia · 17/09/2023 23:01

Rock climbing is hardly inclusive

Sounds like inclusive to you means "things my children can do" not "things all children can do"

If your child was a good swimmer would you still be complaining it wasn't inclusive?

Youcancallmeirrelevant · 17/09/2023 22:57

LostMySocks · 17/09/2023 20:48

Those saying book swimming lessons or take him swimming. Sadly our local pools have long waiting lists
We do swim regularly but they keep weak swimmers in a small area.
I'll speak to the group leader. They're likely to have younger boys joining by then.
I'm happy not to send him but the leaders are stressing that the need to go to get programme awards.

Presume you are on the waiting lists? Spaces become available as kids move up. Lessons have been back and running for ages now, if you put him on the waitong list as sokn as they opened back up he would be in a class by now

Wibblywobblylikejelly · 17/09/2023 22:56

Sounds like you've massively dropped the ball and you're now looking to pass blame that belongs to you.

You're going to add him to the waiting list? So you never actually did it after Covid rules were lifted? Which was a long time ago.
.
He's 10. More than old enough to have practiced and caught up for this type of event had you been more proactive.

You need to put the work in now to stop him being excluded and to learn a valuable lesson! He can't not learn to swim!

BogRollBOGOF · 17/09/2023 22:51

I was a non-swimmer at 10 and into my teen years and it was a bloody nuisence. DM didn't prioritise swimming lessons and she certainly didn't bother taking me swimming because it's cold 🙄
Things like school camp always ended up with the tedious left overs like pony trekking because I couldn't tick the "swim 50m" box. I'd have loved to have done the gorge walk, but wasn't allowed knee-deep in the stream because of it.

I took matters into my own hands, learned at 16 as part of my DoE award and went to adult lessons filled with anxious pensioners who frequently moaned about the whippersnapper daring to learn to swim and heaven forbid splashing around a bit.
Fortunately a year later I could swim a mile, had a collection of water skills awards, and had a fantastic time at the sixth-form/ Gold DoE watersports residential trip.

Get your child swimming. There are often intensive courses in school holidays and older children tend to learn quicker than younger ones as they have more stamina, bodily awareness and follow instructions better.
If that's not a viable option, go to the pool regularly and watch youtube videos on technique. Swim England have videos thar go through the stages and the skills needed and there's lots of videos about improving technique.

ActDottie · 17/09/2023 22:38

Book him some lessons then. Scouts is 10+ it’s not like they’re taking a bunch of four year olds.

DinnaeFashYersel · 17/09/2023 22:33

DinnaeFashYersel · 17/09/2023 22:31

Ask the leaders what the minimum swimming level is.

You then have a year to get him to the minimum requirement.

We did a scout canoeing expedition and the minimum requirement was 25 metres.

We could not have a a separate non canoeing program at the same.

Next year we will do a hiking one.

Sorry I meant 50m.

DinnaeFashYersel · 17/09/2023 22:31

Ask the leaders what the minimum swimming level is.

You then have a year to get him to the minimum requirement.

We did a scout canoeing expedition and the minimum requirement was 25 metres.

We could not have a a separate non canoeing program at the same.

Next year we will do a hiking one.

Rewis · 17/09/2023 22:19

We have hiking camps that those who can't walk long distances can't attend. We also have cycling camps that everyone can't attend. But we aim to have something for everyone through out the year.

whatkatydid2013 · 17/09/2023 22:19

It’s not really covid related to be fair as he would have been old enough to already be swimming to a decent level pre covid. Mine are 9 & 7 (5 1/2 & 3 1/2 at start of covid). Eldest was already a decent swimmer before the first lockdown & even youngest had been to various lessons. Your DS has to be older if in scouts so no reason the leaders would expect people to be unable to swim. I’d look for an intensive course in the school holidays & see if you can get him booked in or just go and swim with him at your local pool regularly for practice. Our local beavers do surfing and various other water sports regularly. Kids love it and lots of parents volunteer and go in with them so always have high ratios. They’ll most likely have life jackets as well as wet suits. How far can he swim/us he ok going underwater?

Swipe left for the next trending thread