Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I too relaxed about my child at soft play? Or are others too uptight ?

185 replies

alloverthem · 17/09/2023 11:20

I recently took my DD and DS to a small soft play that we frequent a lot.

I mean, usually several times a week.

It's small and safe and I really love it and my kids get the interaction with other kids and I actually find it easier being there than just sitting at home with them for example.

It's interesting to watch different parenting styles in there and I've noticed a few things.

There are frequent scuffles between the kids but actually not that often. The kids play well together in general I would say. Often they chase each other around and play fight too and it's nice to watch.

Sometimes there are fights and kids will snatch things from my DD or she will snatch stuff from other kids and make them cry and vice versa. I think this is all normal stuff and there are lots of parents that are ' relaxed ' about it. So will apologise if their child makes my child cry and I always say don't worry it's all good- they all do it. It will be my one that starts on yours next time or something like that.

But then there are some parents who are really precious about everything. They don't give their child any space at all ( it's a tiny soft play ) and hover around them constantly and get involved in every single little thing. The other day my DD was playing with another girl and they were chasing each other around a padded area and getting foam blocks and running into each other with them. It was totally under control and not too rough and they were having a wale of a time. I was watching the entire thing and so was the other mum, who kept telling my DD off for pushing ( which she wasn't ). It was a totally innocent scenario and it really annoyed me. It's not the first time I've seen stuff like this. Another time a mum seemed generally angry that her son was crying because my DD took a block from him- my DD cried too when her son was taking the block from her. It was a normal scuffle, you tell them to behave / remove them and apologise and move on.

Why do some mums feel so aggrieved by normal childhood play? I can't remember my parents getting upset and involved in every tiny interaction at a soft play when I was younger. Can't we let them just be a little bit ? We are there for them when it gets dangerous and comfort them when they're upset, but to actually get huffy and puffy about 3 year olds snatching foam blocks from one another - is that really how precious us millennial parents are ?

I know they'll be people who'll accuse my DD of being a bad child etc. but it's not that. She's just normal and plays normally.

Anyway, it's either that I'm too relaxed or others are way too uptight.

OP posts:
alloverthem · 17/09/2023 14:17

@Nohj ok so if I post here we can't have a debate. Got it.

OP posts:
Clefable · 17/09/2023 14:15

Our soft play is big so I wouldn't let an 18mo in the main section unsupervised, but there is an under 2 section that DD2 (14mo) will roam in happily if I am standing or sitting chatting to someone nearby. DD1 has been in the main section since about 2.5, when I was comfortable she wasn't going to get physically stuck anywhere Grin

LolaSmiles · 17/09/2023 14:14

I think there is a huge difference between children playing and working things out themselves Vs pushing, shoving, snatching and the sort of play that ends up with one or more child upset.

Mine aren't the sort of kids who cry a lot and are very resilient, but the times they've ended up upset in soft play has usually been because another child is being far too physical or domineering and their parents isn't paying any attention. Undoubtedly those parents will insist it does the children the world of good to have Lord of the Flies whilst their child grabs everything in sight, barges around, and thinks all the other children should fall in line or move.

Nohj · 17/09/2023 14:12

alloverthem · 17/09/2023 14:07

You don't know my soft play though or my 18 month old and the circumstances under which I allow it and where I am etc. I keep my kids safe. Neither have ever got hurt at soft play or otherwise.

And I do step in if behaviour isn't appropriate. Always. I just don't get angry about it if inappropriate behaviour is directed at my child. As children need to learn that things like this happen. We need to be there to support and teach them what's ok and what's not, but other children may still act out occasionally and they need to learn that unfortunately that happens too.

To be honest I’m not sure what you wanted from this thread in AIBU…no I don’t know you or your child or the specific soft play you go to..I’m a stranger on the internet?
You asked strangers on the internet are you too relaxed and some responded based on what you’ve said.
I think it is quite relaxed to let an 18 month old go off based on my experiences in the plethora of soft plays I have visited 🤷🏻‍♀️ if you don’t like the answer- why ask here?

alloverthem · 17/09/2023 14:11

Hufflemuff · 17/09/2023 14:08

OP just you wait for the fun times ahead at primary school...

I genuinely had a parent come over to me in reception asking my son to apologise because he made her daughter cry, when he ran ahead of her on the climbing frame and didn't wait behind her to finish the entire course first... "well he shouldn't have pushed ahead, she likes to do it all on her own". This kid was in HYSTERICS and no wonder, she clearly had a mum that catered to her EVERY whim and expected the whole world to do exactly the same.

Oh no. That's just awful. Thanks for the warning. I'll need to start preparing myself.

OP posts:
iamwhatiam23 · 17/09/2023 14:10

I will also add that the majority of these parents that completely overreact to kids falling out only ever seem to notice when it's their kid that's coming off worse! They mysteriously never notice when their little darling is being a brat!

iamwhatiam23 · 17/09/2023 14:09

I was never a " hovering parent" with my eldest dc and i agree with your op. However my youngest dc has ASD among other things and i hovered over him, not because i was worried for him but because i was worried what he may attempt to do to another child. He could be extremely aggressive at times and if another child had snatched something from him ( as kids do) it would have caused all out war!

Hufflemuff · 17/09/2023 14:08

OP just you wait for the fun times ahead at primary school...

I genuinely had a parent come over to me in reception asking my son to apologise because he made her daughter cry, when he ran ahead of her on the climbing frame and didn't wait behind her to finish the entire course first... "well he shouldn't have pushed ahead, she likes to do it all on her own". This kid was in HYSTERICS and no wonder, she clearly had a mum that catered to her EVERY whim and expected the whole world to do exactly the same.

Clefable · 17/09/2023 14:08

Yeah I think I manage a decent balance. I definitely don't follow DC around soft play once they are past baby/young toddler age. It's annoying for the kids when there are giant adults blocking tunnels and stuff in the play areas (SEN children excluded of course). I know roughly where DD is in the apparatus and have an ear out for anything that requires help, but normal child interactions I wouldn't intervene unless needed. And yes I do have a cup of tea and a cake Grin

DD1 isn't a rough player particularly though, I wouldn't worry about her hitting other children for example as that wouldn't happen, it would more be conflict over who was using something first or something, but she will come to find me if she feels particularly maligned and needs my help with something.

alloverthem · 17/09/2023 14:07

Nohj · 17/09/2023 14:02

I think snatching and ‘play fighting’ is behaviour that needs parental intervention to be honest. I wouldn’t get annoyed that it had happened but would expect the children to be re-directed. I do think children probably 4 and under are going to need various amount of support at times in soft play. I think it’s quite confident to let an 18 month old toddle off, I do follow my 20 month old and play with her.

At least part of the point for me is spending time with her, I often find us attracting other kids who want to join in and play games with us.
When she had had stuff snatched or older kids with no parents watching have got a bit shovy, I re direct them, explain we don’t do that and make a game or give them something else.

I definitely do internally judge a bit though because it might be sold as being relaxed parenting but so many of the kids seem to love adult attention and input, it seems a bit of a shame that it’s not their parents giving it! I get a little gaggle going whilst they are all having a coffee 😬

You don't know my soft play though or my 18 month old and the circumstances under which I allow it and where I am etc. I keep my kids safe. Neither have ever got hurt at soft play or otherwise.

And I do step in if behaviour isn't appropriate. Always. I just don't get angry about it if inappropriate behaviour is directed at my child. As children need to learn that things like this happen. We need to be there to support and teach them what's ok and what's not, but other children may still act out occasionally and they need to learn that unfortunately that happens too.

OP posts:
Conkersinautumn · 17/09/2023 14:06

I'm not sure why you're advocating for normal childhood experience but taking children to a risk free, indoor facility? Surely fresh air and reasonable awareness of hazards in the real world and understanding of the natural environment would be preferable for this normal childhood you're in favour of? It's not normal to be indoors most days of the week with children. At a soft play it's demographic is inevitably going to be for risk averse parents

alloverthem · 17/09/2023 14:03

I don't have an issue. I'm not the one starting threads judging other parents and then defensive when I don't agree with the opinions I'm getting back. 🤷🏻‍♀️

I'm not defensive at a normal opinion though- for example - ' I disagree OP, I think we need to stay close by our children at all times and it's absolutely fine to get annoyed with other parents and their children if their child acts out of turn. Even if the parent apologises / stops the behaviour immediately. I think it's out of line and I have the right to be angry'

Not : OP you sound like the worst parent in the world. I bet you don't even look at your children when they play. I bet your children are disgusting feral beings who hurt all the other children at soft play. I bet that you just sit there like a lazy cow. I know types like you OP.

The second response is just making a load of unkind assumptions about me. It's not really an opinion about what the post was initially about..

OP posts:
Nohj · 17/09/2023 14:02

I think snatching and ‘play fighting’ is behaviour that needs parental intervention to be honest. I wouldn’t get annoyed that it had happened but would expect the children to be re-directed. I do think children probably 4 and under are going to need various amount of support at times in soft play. I think it’s quite confident to let an 18 month old toddle off, I do follow my 20 month old and play with her.

At least part of the point for me is spending time with her, I often find us attracting other kids who want to join in and play games with us.
When she had had stuff snatched or older kids with no parents watching have got a bit shovy, I re direct them, explain we don’t do that and make a game or give them something else.

I definitely do internally judge a bit though because it might be sold as being relaxed parenting but so many of the kids seem to love adult attention and input, it seems a bit of a shame that it’s not their parents giving it! I get a little gaggle going whilst they are all having a coffee 😬

Sparklybutold · 17/09/2023 14:01

I also feel I have too often had to find the carers because a child has gotten upset and wants comfort…

Sparklybutold · 17/09/2023 14:00

You're always going to see different parenting style, and there will be reasons for this. A woman I met a year or so ago and we met a few times as our DD were around the same age, was extremely anxious. But her daughter had a rare autoimmune disease that completely depleted her of her immune system so she was very susceptible to infection. So although she was getting better and docs had given approval and encouraged mum to take out her DD, this was combined with being a first time mum and we were just coming out of covid and kids can be gross - I totally empathised with her position.

I don't so mind the different styles, it's the parents that sit too far away and are not interacting with there child(ten). I have frequently ended up feeling like a childminder as kids will start to want me to start playing with them or they start saying ‘watch me?!?’ as they are hungry for attention, I don't mind the odd interaction but when it feels I have adopted another child! I will ask them to go find there mummy/daddy etc.

AprQ · 17/09/2023 13:59

I could see myself being a helicopter parent in the eyes of others who don't realise why I'm doing what I'm doing.

Oh yep 100%. DD was only 2 in May however she’s quite tall and people always assume that she’s older than she is. Uses reins whenever she’s not in the buggy and is Autistic.

She’s a wild child and runs all about the place, has no sense of danger too. If a child was to push her over or whatever, I’d be annoyed. I’m not gonna risk by Autistic 2 year old getting hurt by another child just so that people like the OP don’t think I’m THAT parent. I’ll forever be THAT parent where both of my toddlers with additional needs are involved😅

Bringbackniles · 17/09/2023 13:51

I think it's important and healthy for kids to interact with each other and have some freedom.

However, I may well be a bit like you describe. I have a very tall, well built 2 year old who is the size of children 2 or 3 years older. I have to watch him closely as the kids and parents don't realise how young he is.

Also, he is a wild runner so I have to get in-between him and the swings sometimes as he would get knocked clean over! Another mum did say to me I should just let it happen as he will the learn but I'm perfecrly happy not to let my 2 year old be whacked over by a big kid on a swing - just in the name of teaching him a lesson.

He also has to be on reins near any kind of road as he is so fast and strong, I don't trust I can keep hold of his hand when needed.

Different examples to the softplay one I know but overall, I could see myself being a helicopter parent in the eyes of others who don't realise why I'm doing what I'm doing. I see little ones walking sedately with their parents or sitting and having picnics. Not a chance with mine. He's got ant in his pants!

Spinet · 17/09/2023 13:48

I'm completely with you on this but I also think that just as your kids have to learn to coexist with kids with a different playing style to them, so you have to learn to coexist with people with different parenting styles to you.

(But so do they, I'm not supporting people being unpleasant for the sake of it).

Boomboom22 · 17/09/2023 13:48

Thr soft plays I still go to are massive so I sit and mark work or read and they occasionally appear. So I wouldn't know what they are doing, I shout for them if I need them and can't see them and they appear, or they come to the table if upset. Prob from 4. At 2 I hovered and at 3 sent a big brother with the younger.

bakewellbride · 17/09/2023 13:46

My 5 year old has never once snatched, pushed or made another child cry. And I'd be annoyed if a child did that to him but it was just brushed off as normal kid stuff or whatever. I don't agree with helicopter parenting but I do think we need to discipline children and teach them how to get along with other kids. All this kind of thing is of course incredibly subjective though - op would probably brand me as 'precious' as the original post suggests.

caerdydd12 · 17/09/2023 13:44

alloverthem · 17/09/2023 13:41

@caerdydd12 and all I did was give you my opinion back. What's your issue ? All is said was ' okay wow'..

What do you want me to say ? That I'm all the horrible adjectives you used to describe me ?

I don't have an issue. I'm not the one starting threads judging other parents and then defensive when I don't agree with the opinions I'm getting back. 🤷🏻‍♀️

alloverthem · 17/09/2023 13:41

@caerdydd12 and all I did was give you my opinion back. What's your issue ? All is said was ' okay wow'..

What do you want me to say ? That I'm all the horrible adjectives you used to describe me ?

OP posts:
Untilitsleeps1 · 17/09/2023 13:38

caerdydd12 · 17/09/2023 13:21

I think your responses are showing exactly what type of person you are; defensive, aggressive, judgemental and downright nasty.

💯

caerdydd12 · 17/09/2023 13:36

alloverthem · 17/09/2023 13:34

So you're allowed to make a thread judging other parents but don't seem to like it when someone else gives you their opinion? I agree with that poster it sounds like they struck a nerve.

Everyone can make judgements and everyone can also respond and defend themselves. Which is all I've done here and I have every right to, as does everyone else !

And all I did was give you my opinion... funny how threads work isn't it, you don't get to control the responses.

JasperHale · 17/09/2023 13:36

I'm a nanny, have been for a very long time, and once here on Mumsnet I mentioned that my 3yo charges play sometime by themselves, without me interacting with them, or telling them what to play. I got all sort of messages how lazy nanny I am, irresponsible, and thank God I don't work for them. Well yes, thank God for that. Still with my nanny kids 6 years later.