Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Trial by media circus

644 replies

Maatandosiris · 17/09/2023 09:42

The first thing to say is anyone who has committed rape absolutely needs to be brought to justice. The criminal
justice system needs to become more effective in protecting all victims of crime.

However, AIBU unreasonable to think that this weekends story about RB has been sinister for many other reasons, none of which are to do with RB.

Firstly the SM posts whipping people into a frenzy of some big reveal like some secret album release. Clues planted through various carefully placed posts, giving just enough detail to let people work things out (plus making people suggest other names) . It was an absolute circus, in the case of rape it turned accusations of serious crime into entertainment, no thought how anyone would be affected, whether ultimately guilty or innocent (maybe c4/The Times were trying to get new stories). Extremely bad taste at one end of the spectrum, devastating for innocent people at the other.

The ultimate agenda of both The Sunday Times and C4 is to make money. That’s it, neither is set up as the states arm of justice. There’s no inbuilt checks and balances. Yet somehow they are allowed to name an individual, accuse them of crimes (and effectively say they are guilty) without any of the safeguards and checks and balances of the criminal justice system applying.

People have lost all sense of justice. We have a man accused of something, an hour and a half of heavily hyped TV which holds some accusations but mainly a character assassination, The Sunday Times probably selling many more copies/getting many more subscribers with more of the sane one sided accusations.

Even on Mumsnet we have people already calling him a Rapist, people feeding into the frenzy of “he’s a creep”, “he’s a sex pest” etc etc. in other words, convicting him in their minds before this has gone anywhere near a court or jury.

How will this ever now be a fair trial? How will they find a jury who can 100% not have their views affected by this whole circus? If he is guilty will there ever be a safe conviction, how can we be confident that real justice has been done? What’s the risk of any conviction being overturned? This is not in the interests of either the alleged victim or the alleged perpetrator.

Questions are circulating all over SM as to the agendas at play. It’s fairly clear that the Sunday Times has been searching out victims. What were they saying to these people? What promises have been made?

if a crime has been committed this should be with the criminal justice system not Saturday night prime time TV with an associated heavy advertising campaign.

Im not sure whether RB is guilty or innocent, but that’s not what this post is about. AIBU to think that the way this witch hunt (which is what it is regardless of whether RB sinks or floats) is abhorrent and flies in the face of justice and that this has far wider and scarier implications for society than just this case. Who or what is next?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Iwasafool · 18/09/2023 14:44

WarriorN · 18/09/2023 14:13

I'm wondering if Katie Perry signed an NDA 🤔

Why would she? Aren't NDAs normally about people taking money in exchange for keeping quiet, I would have thought she had her own money. Or is there something else, I don't know much about them.

Iwasafool · 18/09/2023 14:41

Drfosters · 18/09/2023 13:15

That is not my experience at all. We all know people present differently at court. It is for the prosecution to present a case beyond all reasonable doubt. If not can’t the jury will not convict. It is a failing on the prosecution if someone guilty is not convicted. Even if it were judge only they would have to follow the same principles.

It is my experience and would explain why many defendants do make an effort to change their appearance to look more "respectable" for want of a better word. Not everyone, some defendants will always have looked respectable.

You only have to read some threads on here to realise how much people are influenced e.g. he always looked dodgy to me/he just doesn't look like a serial killer.

PrincessOfTigger · 18/09/2023 14:33

I think it’s amazing the conspiracies are willing to believe over these women. RB barely had to lift a finger to make excuses, you are all doing it for him. Even Martin Bashir (remember him!) got a mention lol.

BreakfastClub80 · 18/09/2023 14:17

To my mind, investigative journalism is one of the few tools we have to bring the rich and powerful to account. It’s hard to discredit this one case without discrediting the entire back catalogue of scandals that have come to light via investigative journalism. In effect, they all involve “trial by media” and that is the whole point.

Lavender14 · 18/09/2023 14:17

Op your concern for RB getting a fair trial is actually more detrimental to the women. He's more likely to walk free as a result of this than go to prison. Bear in mind less than 2% of rapists actually see jail time and the victims of those 'falsely accused' can face conviction themselves for making the report in the first place. We had a case a few years ago where I live that was highly sensationalised in the media. The accused all walked free and the woman who accused them was vilified on social media. I don't doubt for a second they did it but the trial was a hot mess from the start thanks to their fans.

It doesn't serve women to make false allegations. And for me the things he said and did by his own account are vile enough that he should have been held accountable. Offering his assistant naked to Jimmy Saville live on air? Why did he still have a job after that? There's big questions to ask about the culture around celebrities who are inappropriate and unsafe and those that quietly say nothing or enable them in order to share in the profits. There's a large degree of being complicit that needs explored and that's why I think the dispatches investigation was appropriate because it calls all of that into question as well. Rb was sexually abused himself as a child and unfortunately some men who experience this do go on to abuse others because they haven't resolved that trauma or been able to form healthy relationship blueprints as a result. That doesn't excuse his behaviour, there are many survivors of childhood sexual abuse who don't do this to other people. Accountability is important and there's big questions to be asked about why someone who is sexuality harassing staff and fans is consistently given more power to abuse.

WarriorN · 18/09/2023 14:13

I'm wondering if Katie Perry signed an NDA 🤔

Cornettoninja · 18/09/2023 14:08

Aquarius1234 · 18/09/2023 14:03

Dies anyone find it weird or creepy that RBs wife first briefly dated him at 18.
And now is totally standing by him. Like she's not bothered about his past or the fact he probably took advantage of girls even without rape being thrown in.

I genuinely feel sorry for the woman. His crimes are not hers. She has two (soon to be three) young children with him and her world is likely shattered. If she does choose to untangle herself from him then it’ll be in her own time and after, I imagine, serious consideration.

Speculation about her shouldn’t be part of any conversation about the allegations as far as I’m concerned. If she comments and brings herself into the conversation that’s one thing but until that point it’s not ethical imho.

Cornettoninja · 18/09/2023 14:04

Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 13:27

I perhaps should have expanded but thought it was clear. Your belief doesn’t matter in the context of whether RB is guilty or not as that isn’t the measure of reality.

It does matter in the context of whether someone is affected by accusations which have not been proven in a court of law

A court of law is constructed by the society it operates in and is a constant state of flux dependent on the ethics (also in flux) of that society.

Courts issue punishments and sanctions on hearing all sides, society is free to judge by whatever standards they want to as long as they don’t issue punishment/sanctions already agreed to be the preserve of the legal system.

Reports such as the RB one highlight issues within existing frameworks that don’t quite fit within society as it exists today for many, many people.

The problem with your very heavy reliance on the legal system is the fact that theres a sizeable group who don’t agree with you that it is in fact reliable. Specifically in the case of prolific and routine sexual crimes.

So no, I don’t feel inclined to wait until the legal system catches up with reality when the reality involves people being actively attacked on a regular basis. The legal system can only be reactive and it’s slow. I have faith it will catch up, but not if everyone sits back and waits to be told that actually, all this stuff is really wrong.

Aquarius1234 · 18/09/2023 14:04

Does *

Aquarius1234 · 18/09/2023 14:03

Dies anyone find it weird or creepy that RBs wife first briefly dated him at 18.
And now is totally standing by him. Like she's not bothered about his past or the fact he probably took advantage of girls even without rape being thrown in.

TooBigForMyBoots · 18/09/2023 13:56

YABU OP. There's no way the victims would have got justice if they'd gone to the police.

However, Brand can get justice. He can sue C4 and the Times. Get his day in court and tell his story in Civil court rather than Criminal. I'm OK with that.Smile

Bingbangbongbash · 18/09/2023 13:44

Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 13:03

“What you seem to be doing is conflating traditional media with social media. That’s a very silly thing to do. “ this is not what I am doing at all. I would like you to provide evidence of where I have done that.

Martin Bashir used lies and falsified information to coerce someone to give an interview - what guarantees do we have this hasn’t occurred again?

” I believe that the claims in the documentary and article(s) have been checked to a very high standard and are true, whether or not they reach a courtroom. “ Tbf it doesn’t matter what you believe or not. What is important is the whether a court of law has decided whether RB is guilty or not. What high standards have they been checked to? How can I verify this? Who had set these standards? Who had verified whether these rules have been followed. Are they adequate to protect the accused?

Most importantly who has checked the accusations to ensure they are true. My understanding is that in the UK the only mechanism by which we can decide if criminal accusations are true or not is through the court system. You’ve really just proved my point.

In your very first post you talk about the SM posts whipping up a frenzy and how the documentary / article was a character assassination - as if they are interchangeable. You don't understand what hearsay is, you don't believe that broadcast tv and print media have checks & balances. All in the first post.

So again, let me spell it out for you:

Social media: the 'broadcasters' are not held legally responsible for the content - so anyone can basically say anything and they can't sue Twitter or YT or whatever for distributing the lies.

Traditional media: the broadcasters / papers can be held accountable for any defamation or other legal issues (like copyright infringement) that may arise from the content they put out, as can the production companies and potentially (depending on role, contract specifics) the programme makers / journalists.

Social media: there is no regulation or professional standards body at all

Traditional media: Ofcom & IPSO oversee professional standards and offer a place for complaints. Every programme goes through a process of compliance & legal where each line & shot is checked against what is 'allowed'. Allowed might mean legally or it might mean ethically. Anything dodgy is removed or re-written. Low risk programmes like Bake Off will have a lighter touch review, but something like the RB doc will have been checked multiple times by experts including lawyers, and everything within it will have been robustly sourced.

You keep saying 'Ch4 lawyers will only check if they can be sued, not if RB is guilty' - well of course they will. But one of the the benchmarks for whether they can be sued is 'are the statements true in substance and in fact'.

You keep referring to Bashir - as I have said, his methods for getting the interview were abhorrent - but is there doubt about the content of the interview? Are you saying Di was coerced into lying?

Because otherwise it's a false equivalence.

There are some bad actors in every profession, including the police and justice system you seem to idolise.

WarriorN · 18/09/2023 13:40

Zelda Perkins at 1:13 on world at 1 radio 4 explains very clearly why this is all the right course of action.

They've (journalists and any involved) have whistle blown to their and RB's employers here.

He's still mainstream media as well as 6m followers on social media.

Alice went to his management and lawyers; they ignored.

Brand used legal threats a lot.

Perkins explains how legal processes are used by those in power to silence.

So you use the platform of free speech and actually, the growing transparency of some media companies who are now holding themselves to account

DoDoDoD · 18/09/2023 13:40

Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 12:06

I don’t have sufficient evidence to decide who I believe.

I dare say the BBC would have claimed Martin Bashier dotted all the Is and crossed the ts., that lawyers went through it all with a fine tooth comb. In the current case lawyers will have been through it all with a fine tooth comb to see if there was a risk they could be sued, They will not have been deciding whether he was guilty (nor could they) lawyers work for their clients.they will protect the interests of those paying the bill.

Ultimately though it’s not about who I do and don’t believe. At the end of the day I believe in justice which society agrees should be administered through the justice system.

There is a great, long standing position that the mass
media is the new church. Do we want justice administered by the church or by the state?

Again with the weird mixed metaphors - church/state!
Investigative journalism is perfectly legal. If the journalists broke any laws, go report them to the police rather than create your own circus of trial by anonymous posting on the internet.

lifeturnsonadime · 18/09/2023 13:39

It does matter in the context of whether someone is affected by accusations which have not been proven in a court of law

Are you expecting us to feel sorry for RB?

Good grief, as someone said up thread if it walks like a duck......

He arranged for a BBC car to collect a 16 year old from school to take her to his home, he has not denied that this is true. Are you suggesting he wanted to help her with her maths homework? FGS, this man is vile whether he is convicted or not.

I can't believe you are defending him.

CorylusAgain · 18/09/2023 13:39

Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 13:29

“There are dedicated journalists who are motivated by the exposure of wrong doing and who don't resort to coercion or falsehoods.” So we have no guarantee over anything, apart from the fact these journalists won’t resort to the tactics proven to have been employed by similar journalists previously- I see!

I didn't say that!

You are the one seeking guarantees not me. You are the one dismissing information out of hand on the basis that because Martin Bashir was dodgy we should never listen to a journalist again.

I'm saying that's as ridiculous as never trusting another police officer or never querying whether there has been a miscarriage of justice.

Even your precious legal system accepts the balance of probability not just certainty.

Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 13:29

CorylusAgain · 18/09/2023 13:24

Martin Bashir used lies and falsified information to coerce someone to give an interview - what guarantees do we have this hasn’t occurred again?

We have no guarantees about anything!

No guarantee that the police officer who turns up when you report a crime isn't currupt or bigoted.

No guarantee that the jury members selected in a trial are up to the job and have no personal bias

There are dedicated journalists who are motivated by the exposure of wrong doing and who don't resort to coercion or falsehoods.

“There are dedicated journalists who are motivated by the exposure of wrong doing and who don't resort to coercion or falsehoods.” So we have no guarantee over anything, apart from the fact these journalists won’t resort to the tactics proven to have been employed by similar journalists previously- I see!

OP posts:
Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 13:27

Cornettoninja · 18/09/2023 13:05

Tbf it doesn’t matter what you believe or not

@Maatandosiris if that’s true why is anything you’re arguing of any importance?

I perhaps should have expanded but thought it was clear. Your belief doesn’t matter in the context of whether RB is guilty or not as that isn’t the measure of reality.

It does matter in the context of whether someone is affected by accusations which have not been proven in a court of law

OP posts:
CorylusAgain · 18/09/2023 13:24

Martin Bashir used lies and falsified information to coerce someone to give an interview - what guarantees do we have this hasn’t occurred again?

We have no guarantees about anything!

No guarantee that the police officer who turns up when you report a crime isn't currupt or bigoted.

No guarantee that the jury members selected in a trial are up to the job and have no personal bias

There are dedicated journalists who are motivated by the exposure of wrong doing and who don't resort to coercion or falsehoods.

greenhydrangea · 18/09/2023 13:20

Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 12:20

Well, I have been specifically commenting on the criminal justice system not civil law.

Here is wiki on "The rule of law".

The rule of law is a political ideal that all citizens and institutions within a country, state, or community are accountable to the same laws, including lawmakers and leaders.[2][3] The term rule of law is closely related to constitutionalism as well as Rechtsstaat. It refers to a political situation, not to any specific legal rule.[4][5][6] The rule of law is defined in the Encyclopedia Britannica as "the mechanism, process, institution, practice, or norm that supports the equality of all citizens before the law, secures a nonarbitrary form of government, and more generally prevents the arbitrary use of power."[7]

It doesn't seem to me to be particularly relevant to this discussion.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 18/09/2023 13:18

Iwasafool · 18/09/2023 12:38

It is difficult isn't it, particularly when the alleged rapist is a friend/former friend/partner/former partner. It does make it hard for an outsider to be sure what has actually happened.

I honestly don't know what the answer would be that was fair to all parties.

I suppose the issue with not proven is that it does damage the alleged rapist who might be totally innocent. Seems like a Judgement of Solomon situation and I honestly wouldn't like to be on the jury.

I guess it comes down to the old "is it better to let a hundred guilty men walk free than one innocent man suffer" question doesn't it?

We know that men rape and assault on an industrial scale and that while not all men do so, almost all that do commit those crimes are men.

We know that as things stand the justice system doesn't work in cases of SA and rape.

We also know that on occasion women make false allegations but, we know that this is a rare occurance at best, and that it's not a sex specific issue.

So do you keep the status quo and let men continue to rape and assault your daughters, sisters, mothers, and friends with little fear of facing justice or do you change the way you tackle the issue?

Bingbangbongbash · 18/09/2023 13:18

notmetodayagain · 18/09/2023 12:56

The Sunday Times and C4 seem like very unlikely bedfellows. Why on earth would they collaborate on this?

As OP says, the media does not exist to give justice to victims, it exists to make money for its shareholders or protect itself.

This is a terrible overview of the media.

It also exists to inform, educate, highlight, expose and offer a voice to the voiceless. There are countless examples throughout history of investigations and campaigns that have uncovered wrongs and helped to change laws.

It's not perfect, but neither is it a homogenous group hellbent on holding up the status quo for the 1%. And there are some excellent journalists within the organisations - just as there are some total pricks (but they seem to end up on GB News and You Tube).

greenhydrangea · 18/09/2023 13:18

Most importantly who has checked the accusations to ensure they are true.

Four years of investigation. Legal clearance. And Rusty's lawyers have looked them over prior to publication. I would say they have been thoroughly examined and reviewed by both sides.

Cornettoninja · 18/09/2023 13:16

It's very far from ideal, but I'm not sure any of the current alternatives are any better - though working to combat m isogyny in all its forms certainly would be

which I believe is what the RB reports are doing. Even RB isn’t attempting to minimise the claims, he’s outright called them what they are - egregious and aggressive. For anyone paying attention to his career this is a direct contradiction to how he has presented similar (if not identical) sexual situations in the past.

Progress of sorts maybe? It’s not like we’re subject to ‘boys will be boys and these women were sluts who loved it’, he’s at least recognised that the content of the accusations is horrific if not accepting any culpability.

I have a lot of issues with the media (particularly the control and influence one walking corpse seems to have) but I do have faith in lots of journalists whose motivations are to provide quality information where it’s otherwise held back. Even the nuttier conspiracy led ones - I’m happy that they float or sink on the quality of their own reporting. I don’t think it was this thread but there’s a reason that tyrannical regimes target journalists - I don’t entirely trust anyone trying to tell me that all media = automatically bad.

Drfosters · 18/09/2023 13:15

Iwasafool · 18/09/2023 13:07

Juries are swayed by all sorts. Not unusual for the police involved to barely recognise the accused in court, he's had a haircut, he's even had a wash, his mum has bought him a nice suit and she's ironed his shirt. He suddenly looks like a model citizen and people are influenced by appearances. Maybe the jury system has had its day.

That is not my experience at all. We all know people present differently at court. It is for the prosecution to present a case beyond all reasonable doubt. If not can’t the jury will not convict. It is a failing on the prosecution if someone guilty is not convicted. Even if it were judge only they would have to follow the same principles.

Swipe left for the next trending thread