Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Trial by media circus

644 replies

Maatandosiris · 17/09/2023 09:42

The first thing to say is anyone who has committed rape absolutely needs to be brought to justice. The criminal
justice system needs to become more effective in protecting all victims of crime.

However, AIBU unreasonable to think that this weekends story about RB has been sinister for many other reasons, none of which are to do with RB.

Firstly the SM posts whipping people into a frenzy of some big reveal like some secret album release. Clues planted through various carefully placed posts, giving just enough detail to let people work things out (plus making people suggest other names) . It was an absolute circus, in the case of rape it turned accusations of serious crime into entertainment, no thought how anyone would be affected, whether ultimately guilty or innocent (maybe c4/The Times were trying to get new stories). Extremely bad taste at one end of the spectrum, devastating for innocent people at the other.

The ultimate agenda of both The Sunday Times and C4 is to make money. That’s it, neither is set up as the states arm of justice. There’s no inbuilt checks and balances. Yet somehow they are allowed to name an individual, accuse them of crimes (and effectively say they are guilty) without any of the safeguards and checks and balances of the criminal justice system applying.

People have lost all sense of justice. We have a man accused of something, an hour and a half of heavily hyped TV which holds some accusations but mainly a character assassination, The Sunday Times probably selling many more copies/getting many more subscribers with more of the sane one sided accusations.

Even on Mumsnet we have people already calling him a Rapist, people feeding into the frenzy of “he’s a creep”, “he’s a sex pest” etc etc. in other words, convicting him in their minds before this has gone anywhere near a court or jury.

How will this ever now be a fair trial? How will they find a jury who can 100% not have their views affected by this whole circus? If he is guilty will there ever be a safe conviction, how can we be confident that real justice has been done? What’s the risk of any conviction being overturned? This is not in the interests of either the alleged victim or the alleged perpetrator.

Questions are circulating all over SM as to the agendas at play. It’s fairly clear that the Sunday Times has been searching out victims. What were they saying to these people? What promises have been made?

if a crime has been committed this should be with the criminal justice system not Saturday night prime time TV with an associated heavy advertising campaign.

Im not sure whether RB is guilty or innocent, but that’s not what this post is about. AIBU to think that the way this witch hunt (which is what it is regardless of whether RB sinks or floats) is abhorrent and flies in the face of justice and that this has far wider and scarier implications for society than just this case. Who or what is next?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 09:49

borninthe80esss · 18/09/2023 09:41

@Maatandosiris

I'm not arguing anymore.. this will be my last comment.

You're argument makes zero sense.. You think anyone who has had a good experience with Russell Brand should be able to speak out, Why?!?
My rapist is probably really nice and respectful to his wife/friends/work colleagues.. He's still a rapist! Are you seriously suggesting rape victims should have to listen to irrelevant bullshit that hammers home that it was just them he raped.. He's lovely to everyone else.
I walked into a police station covered in bruises and evidence.. He told the police I like it rough.. case fucking closed. So by your rationale because he wasn't convicted I'm making it up!!
Given the opportunity I'd go on channel 4 right now and tell my story.. and the majority wouldn't believe me. Again read the statistics.. it's not just me this happens all the time.
Also your argument about putting poor innocent men in prison.. Read the statistics.. This country is full of rapists walking the streets.. Not because there victims are not telling the truth but because our criminal justice system is completely fucked.
All of the people commenting.. Why didn't she go to the police... You! And all the hundreds like you with your ignorant opinions and comments.. You and everyone else like you are why!!!!

I’m sorry that this story is obviously affecting you greatly. I am not saying that people who have committed a crime don’t get off. Similarly, innocent people get found guilty.

But, as a society we have decided that the best way to decide on a persons guilt or innocence is through the legal system as this is the best way to ensure justice is served in the majority of cases.

This is clearly, and understandably, a very triggering story for you. I hope you have some support IRL and wish you nothing but healing on your journey.

OP posts:
Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 09:44

Cornettoninja · 18/09/2023 09:38

This is why we have courts of law to decide this

specifically who do you think decides in court? Jurors decide and they are not professionals. You’re putting a lot of weight on a process that is dependent on the opinions of your average person whilst dismissing the opinions of those in exactly that group. Especially in cases where it comes down to one word against another and there is no hard evidence it very much comes down to opinion and how the jurors ‘feel’ about the people in front of them. You’re kidding yourself if you think there’s some special element of a court room that can control that.

The CPS is the stage where professionals determine the viability of bringing a case to court and there are huge pitfalls in that stage in cases where it’s word against word.

so how did you feel
about this kind of hounding (although to a lesser extent) of Caroline Flack. Was that ok?

whats she got to do with anything?

so how did you feel
about this kind of hounding (although to a lesser extent) of Caroline Flack. Was that ok?

whats she got to do with anything?

Because she was someone investigated for violence in a domestic setting, someone hounded by the media before trial - so I would say a very similar scenario. So how do you feel about this kind of media frenzy we’re currently seeing in the context of a woman (although in her case there were actual police charges).

Yes jurors aren’t professionals, but in court they’re armrest rules regarding evidence, what can be said. There is an appeals process. You seem to be indicating we can do away with trials and just do a vox pop on a persons guilt.

OP posts:
borninthe80esss · 18/09/2023 09:41

@Maatandosiris

I'm not arguing anymore.. this will be my last comment.

You're argument makes zero sense.. You think anyone who has had a good experience with Russell Brand should be able to speak out, Why?!?
My rapist is probably really nice and respectful to his wife/friends/work colleagues.. He's still a rapist! Are you seriously suggesting rape victims should have to listen to irrelevant bullshit that hammers home that it was just them he raped.. He's lovely to everyone else.
I walked into a police station covered in bruises and evidence.. He told the police I like it rough.. case fucking closed. So by your rationale because he wasn't convicted I'm making it up!!
Given the opportunity I'd go on channel 4 right now and tell my story.. and the majority wouldn't believe me. Again read the statistics.. it's not just me this happens all the time.
Also your argument about putting poor innocent men in prison.. Read the statistics.. This country is full of rapists walking the streets.. Not because there victims are not telling the truth but because our criminal justice system is completely fucked.
All of the people commenting.. Why didn't she go to the police... You! And all the hundreds like you with your ignorant opinions and comments.. You and everyone else like you are why!!!!

Willmafrockfit · 18/09/2023 09:41

do you think the victims should be quiet then @Maatandosiris
if they felt incapable of going to police?
they need a voice

Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 09:39

CorylusAgain · 18/09/2023 09:36

Out of interest @Maatandosiris when you watch other investigative documentaries, for example about the Grenfell disaster. When individual failings are identified in the programme, do you expect the journalists to have a segment chatting with the individual's golfing chums saying how he couldn't have turned a blind eye because he always gets a round in?

If 90% of the documentary was a character assassination, and his guilt of would be looking at his general character and there was evidence of his character not being like that which was being presented, then yes I would expect that.

OP posts:
Cornettoninja · 18/09/2023 09:38

This is why we have courts of law to decide this

specifically who do you think decides in court? Jurors decide and they are not professionals. You’re putting a lot of weight on a process that is dependent on the opinions of your average person whilst dismissing the opinions of those in exactly that group. Especially in cases where it comes down to one word against another and there is no hard evidence it very much comes down to opinion and how the jurors ‘feel’ about the people in front of them. You’re kidding yourself if you think there’s some special element of a court room that can control that.

The CPS is the stage where professionals determine the viability of bringing a case to court and there are huge pitfalls in that stage in cases where it’s word against word.

so how did you feel
about this kind of hounding (although to a lesser extent) of Caroline Flack. Was that ok?

whats she got to do with anything?

Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 09:37

waterlego · 18/09/2023 09:31

I’ve met RB a couple of times. He didn’t sexually assault me, nor did I witness him assaulting anyone else. I found him pleasant and amusing. But I believe the testimonies of the women in the programme.

And if, within the context of a trial 11 other jury members agreed with you then he would be convicted.

Unfortunately, given the media feeding frenzy it’s unlikely that a fair trial could now ever take place, I suspect any conviction will be ultimately deemed unsafe.

This media circus is serving no one. Any victims are ultimately unlikely to get justice.

Any evidence should have been handed over to police, the programme should have been aired after any conviction.

This circus is not serving anyone apart from the shareholders of The Sunday Times (and now other papers) and Channel 4.

OP posts:
CorylusAgain · 18/09/2023 09:36

Out of interest @Maatandosiris when you watch other investigative documentaries, for example about the Grenfell disaster. When individual failings are identified in the programme, do you expect the journalists to have a segment chatting with the individual's golfing chums saying how he couldn't have turned a blind eye because he always gets a round in?

Topee · 18/09/2023 09:34

We’ll if there’s no truth to the stories then RB will sue them.

My money says he won’t.

Bingbangbongbash · 18/09/2023 09:32

beatrix1234 · 17/09/2023 17:59

Let’s say I sell stocks, been doing that for a while, let’s say I have a long time feud with someone who happens to own a newspaper. Said editor starts investigating me for a long period of time trying to dig dirt on me because we have a personal long time vendetta. He finds a few ex clients of mine who were very dissatisfied with my services, he writes a long article exposing me as being a fraudster. Said clients never went to the police accusing me of fraud when they felt wronged, I have never been charged with fraud either and have a long standing clientele happy with my financial services, yet I find myself in the newspaper being accused of fraud. Now everyone is talking on social media of what a fraudster I am and the newspaper editor is very happy for my character assesination.

Sorry but IMO there is something quite wrong with this picture.

You missed out the bit where the journo investigates the claims of your former clients, goes through them with lawyers who sign them, determining there is both significant public interest and a robust defence from any incoming defamation lawsuit.

Or the bit where you successfully sue them for defamation.

Social media is a different beast - the platforms don’t bear any responsibility for what’s published on them (thanks to the deep pockets of the SM giants lobbying hard against changes in the law) and it’s not usually worth going after Angrymom87 for her lies because it’s hard to prove loss when dealing with small fry.

CorylusAgain · 18/09/2023 09:32

Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 09:26

Maybe also people supporting RB, saying they had met him many times and found him a really nice bloke or they hadn’t seen any issues?

What a bizarre response.

waterlego · 18/09/2023 09:31

Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 09:26

Maybe also people supporting RB, saying they had met him many times and found him a really nice bloke or they hadn’t seen any issues?

I’ve met RB a couple of times. He didn’t sexually assault me, nor did I witness him assaulting anyone else. I found him pleasant and amusing. But I believe the testimonies of the women in the programme.

waterlego · 18/09/2023 09:29

I mean, why not go to the police, there and then?

@HollaWithDaRisinSound did you ask the same question when Saville’s victims eventually spoke out?

There have been so many threads about this over the weekend. None of those defending Brand seem to want to answer the Saville question, unless I’ve missed it.

Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 09:27

borninthe80esss · 18/09/2023 09:26

The police are looking into it now and hopefully the women who have been brave enough to speak out get some justice.
I also wouldn't be surprised if more women come forward.
I've read some disgusting comments over the weekend.. utterly depressing.
Russell Brands days as a free man are hopefully numbered.

Ah so he’s guilty, Do you normally advocate imprisoning people who haven’t been tried?

OP posts:
Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 09:26

DoDoDoD · 18/09/2023 09:24

please explain what exactly a ‘balanced’ view would be

Maybe also people supporting RB, saying they had met him many times and found him a really nice bloke or they hadn’t seen any issues?

OP posts:
borninthe80esss · 18/09/2023 09:26

The police are looking into it now and hopefully the women who have been brave enough to speak out get some justice.
I also wouldn't be surprised if more women come forward.
I've read some disgusting comments over the weekend.. utterly depressing.
Russell Brands days as a free man are hopefully numbered.

Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 09:25

IClaudine · 18/09/2023 09:19

So you think the women are lying, even the woman who went to a rape crisis centre? Why would she do that if she wasn't raped?

No I’m not saying the woman was lying, nor am I saying she is telling the truth. I, together with everyone else don’t know. I have repeatedly stated on this thread that I don’t know if TB is guilty or innocent. This is why we have courts of law to decide this. The fact people keep ignoring this clearly shows that people see what they want to see, not what is actually there. I don’t know how to spell this out any clearer.

Are you saying RB is guilty? Do you normally advocate convicting people without a trial?

Why did she go to a rape crisis centre, I don’t know. She might have been raped, who raped her? could have been RB could have been someone else.

OP posts:
DoDoDoD · 18/09/2023 09:24

Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 09:12

I make perfect sense, you’re just not understanding the point. the journalists had no intention on presenting a balanced view and they were clearly ringing round trying to find people who after the call claimed to be victims.

please explain what exactly a ‘balanced’ view would be

Katrinawaves · 18/09/2023 09:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

HollaWithDaRisinSound · 18/09/2023 09:24

I find it hard to believe that someone would wait 20 years to out a rapist - and do it via mainstream media.

I mean, why not go to the police, there and then?

This is what creates a level of doubt in my mind. I am not saying that he is innocent, but it all makes it seem less credible to some degree, to me.

I won't throw someone to the wolves just because of hear-say.

And come on, - lets be real - RB in his heyday, had no shortage of willing participants

CorylusAgain · 18/09/2023 09:24

Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 09:17

Proper journalists like Martin Bashir for Panorama on the BBC you mean?

Or maybe real investigative techniques like phone hacking?

But you want abused women to trust the police and justice system? Do you want a list of the former police officers convicted of serious abuse, rape and murder of women?

No organisation or institution can claim to be pure, but it's grotesque to cite journalistic failings without acknowledging the utter failings of law enforcement bodies.

Bingbangbongbash · 18/09/2023 09:23

BonnyHonny · 17/09/2023 16:46

Sorry, are you saying the women weren't coming forward but were 'tracked down' by programme makers? Programme makers with an agenda? And potentially vulnerable women being tracked down by them?

That sounds shit and exploitative? And all the other things that may have occurred like fear and harassment by people making a story.

I hadn't considered that element till you raised it. But if victims were tracked down as you say, by programme makers, that's not okay at all.

Putting aside that this is exactly what the police would do - speak to anyone and everyone connected to a suspected criminal to find out if they had seen, heard or experienced anything relevant to the investigation - why would these women be ‘potentially vulnerable’ if they hadn’t been abused by him?

There’s some video going round of a women who ‘spent a weekend’ with Brand, saying that she was contacted by the journos but didn’t respond because he had been a gentleman to her. It’s being used like some sort of proof that they are digging dirt - they aren’t. They are doing their job by following leads and asking for information. That she had a fun, consensual weekend with him isn’t relevant to the investigation into his alleged sexual assaults and rapes, so wasn’t included in a story about that.

Gall10 · 18/09/2023 09:21

Puffypuffin · 17/09/2023 10:00

I believe them.

I really can't understand these disciples who slavishly follow every work Brand utters like he's some kind of prophet. That, in my opinion, is far more sinister.

OP you say that people have lost all sense of justice. Is it just famous people who should have justice or can the women involved not expect justice too? No one is untouchable, no matter how much they (and their followers) may believe they are.

Totally agree with this…..it’s like Trump all over again. He’s claiming this is ‘fake news’ and ‘mainstream media is out to get him’
His ‘followers’ will never believe any of the allegations against him.
perhaps he’s known about the investigations which must have taken years…and tried to reinvent himself as this self-styled ‘guru’. Seems to have worked with some sections of the public.

TerryOrange1w2 · 18/09/2023 09:20

Bingbangbongbash · 18/09/2023 09:12

Exactly - a load of lies whipped up on social media which has none of the checks, balances and regulations that the traditional mainstream media has.

At the time, I remember threads where people were saying ‘why aren’t the BBC reporting this? Why is she being ignored in the MSM? It’s a conspiracy etc etc’.

But no, it was all bollocks. It’s pretty likely proper journalists (not TY / X / Rumble) looked into the Elle story, couldn’t find any evidence and so didn’t publish.

Damned if they do and damned if they don’t…

I remember that too. MNHQ was accused of all sorts during that time because they were deleting threads where people were posting the FB posts of Ellie Williams.

They explained several times that there was an investigation underway and the discussions couldn't take place but you still had posters accusing them of a cover-up or not caring about VAWG or something dodgy going on behind the scenes.

I thought it was bollocks the minute I saw the FB posts.

Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 09:19

CorylusAgain · 18/09/2023 09:14

They weren't making a biopic!

It was an investigation into allegations.
The accounts of other people with different experiences are irrelevant to the investigation.

Edited

Ah I see, 90% of the programme was dedicated to people wittering on how awful the man was. But obviously this was nothing about presenting a picture of his character🤦‍♀️

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread