Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Trial by media circus

644 replies

Maatandosiris · 17/09/2023 09:42

The first thing to say is anyone who has committed rape absolutely needs to be brought to justice. The criminal
justice system needs to become more effective in protecting all victims of crime.

However, AIBU unreasonable to think that this weekends story about RB has been sinister for many other reasons, none of which are to do with RB.

Firstly the SM posts whipping people into a frenzy of some big reveal like some secret album release. Clues planted through various carefully placed posts, giving just enough detail to let people work things out (plus making people suggest other names) . It was an absolute circus, in the case of rape it turned accusations of serious crime into entertainment, no thought how anyone would be affected, whether ultimately guilty or innocent (maybe c4/The Times were trying to get new stories). Extremely bad taste at one end of the spectrum, devastating for innocent people at the other.

The ultimate agenda of both The Sunday Times and C4 is to make money. That’s it, neither is set up as the states arm of justice. There’s no inbuilt checks and balances. Yet somehow they are allowed to name an individual, accuse them of crimes (and effectively say they are guilty) without any of the safeguards and checks and balances of the criminal justice system applying.

People have lost all sense of justice. We have a man accused of something, an hour and a half of heavily hyped TV which holds some accusations but mainly a character assassination, The Sunday Times probably selling many more copies/getting many more subscribers with more of the sane one sided accusations.

Even on Mumsnet we have people already calling him a Rapist, people feeding into the frenzy of “he’s a creep”, “he’s a sex pest” etc etc. in other words, convicting him in their minds before this has gone anywhere near a court or jury.

How will this ever now be a fair trial? How will they find a jury who can 100% not have their views affected by this whole circus? If he is guilty will there ever be a safe conviction, how can we be confident that real justice has been done? What’s the risk of any conviction being overturned? This is not in the interests of either the alleged victim or the alleged perpetrator.

Questions are circulating all over SM as to the agendas at play. It’s fairly clear that the Sunday Times has been searching out victims. What were they saying to these people? What promises have been made?

if a crime has been committed this should be with the criminal justice system not Saturday night prime time TV with an associated heavy advertising campaign.

Im not sure whether RB is guilty or innocent, but that’s not what this post is about. AIBU to think that the way this witch hunt (which is what it is regardless of whether RB sinks or floats) is abhorrent and flies in the face of justice and that this has far wider and scarier implications for society than just this case. Who or what is next?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 12:20

greenhydrangea · 18/09/2023 12:18

I'm not sure why you keep banging on about "the rule of law". The UK has libel laws. Rusty could instruct his lawyers to sue. He is certainly not short of a crust. My understanding is his lawyers were presented with the accusations and the evidence collected prior to publication and yet made no response whatsoever.

Well, I have been specifically commenting on the criminal justice system not civil law.

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 18/09/2023 12:20

He ... held her mouth open by force and repeatedly spat in it

I know it's only one detail and hasn't been tried in court, but regarding the actual act just what sort of a creature would anyone have to be to do something like this?? And whether Brand or another, what sort of institution would offer them such a public platform? Confused

There is no such thing as a fair trial in the age of instant media - especially thanks to the rise of completely unregulated social media where lies spread like wildfire

And that's what worries me. Predictably nobody commented on the likelihood of any defence insisting Brand couldn't now have a fair trial, but sadly that's what we may be looking at

Finally, what happened to speculation supposedly being disallowed on here, as HQ have posted on various other threads? From the mass excited outpouring of initials before the news broke to this very thread with suggestions of who'll be next, it just goes on and on

WarriorN · 18/09/2023 12:19

Trial by media circus or whistleblowing?

Do we disallow whistleblowers?

Rotherham wasn't exposed till the press got hold of it.

There's been many similar cases.

It's not just Brand; it's the system post yewtree. The system still doesn't work Ffs.

Apparently a whistleblower involved with Weinstein is on world at one R4 soon.

Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 12:19

CorylusAgain · 18/09/2023 12:14

Not one person on this thread is advocating direct action against Brand which would be the alternative to the established judicial system.

You seem happy to accept inequality when it favours the defendant. Brand vs 16 year old reporting oral rape would not have been even or fair.

Edited

“You seem happy to accept inequality when it favours the defendant. Brand vs 16 year old reporting oral rape would not be even or fair.”

Where have I ever stated that? I have specifically commented (over and over) I cannot comment on the guilt or not of RB and that is not what the thread is about.

“Not one person on this thread is advocating direct action against Brand which would be the alternative to the established judicial system. “ Yet people state accusations as fact - deciding what is fact and whether there is guilt of a specific crime is what the justice system is there for. Regarding consequences- the BBC was advocating for the removal of income sources today

OP posts:
greenhydrangea · 18/09/2023 12:18

I'm not sure why you keep banging on about "the rule of law". The UK has libel laws. Rusty could instruct his lawyers to sue. He is certainly not short of a crust. My understanding is his lawyers were presented with the accusations and the evidence collected prior to publication and yet made no response whatsoever.

CorylusAgain · 18/09/2023 12:14

Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 12:06

I don’t have sufficient evidence to decide who I believe.

I dare say the BBC would have claimed Martin Bashier dotted all the Is and crossed the ts., that lawyers went through it all with a fine tooth comb. In the current case lawyers will have been through it all with a fine tooth comb to see if there was a risk they could be sued, They will not have been deciding whether he was guilty (nor could they) lawyers work for their clients.they will protect the interests of those paying the bill.

Ultimately though it’s not about who I do and don’t believe. At the end of the day I believe in justice which society agrees should be administered through the justice system.

There is a great, long standing position that the mass
media is the new church. Do we want justice administered by the church or by the state?

Not one person on this thread is advocating direct action against Brand which would be the alternative to the established judicial system.

You seem happy to accept inequality when it favours the defendant. Brand vs 16 year old reporting oral rape would not have been even or fair.

fearfuloffluff · 18/09/2023 12:07

Innocent until proven guilty is about the exercise of state power. It's never meant that somebody's reputation has to be somehow untarnished by allegations unless they're convicted.

We all know only about 3% of rapes ever result in a conviction, with a rich celebrity the likelihood is even less. Publication of a lot of allegations at once like this helps to give a fuller picture. As with Saville.

This investigation will have been absolutely rigorously challenged by in-house lawyers and only allegations backed up with sound evidence published - I'm sure there was a huge stack of information that didn't make it into print. If Russell Brand wanted to sue, he could do so.

Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 12:06

Bingbangbongbash · 18/09/2023 11:47

This is as true about any high profile case - Lucy Letby, Harold Shipman, Weinstein, Depp…

In the latter case, he lost when the case was decided by a judge, a person used to evaluating evidence and understanding the law intimately. He was found not guilty of some (not all) of the charges when tried by a jury that was not sequestered nor asked to surrender their phones. Coincidentally, the hashtag ‘justiceforjohnny’ was seen 19 billion times during the trial.

There is no such thing as a fair trial in the age of instant media - especially thanks to the rise of completely unregulated social media where lies spread like wildfire.

But you can be very sure that the Times & Dispatches dotted every i and crossed every t before it was published.

I’m still waiting for someone to explain why they don’t believe the doc / article is telling the truth, yet they believe videos they see on social media.

Also, RB will have been aware of the investigation for a long time. They just wouldn’t have given him a dossier of the contents until it was all checked and double checked, then triple checked. At that point (8 days out from transmission), he had the opportunity to address the accusations.

I’m really surprised at how little people understand of the way the media and criminal justice system works.

Everything is about money. Yes, media outlets are for profit - so they will only put the huge resources needed for a long running investigation like this into something they feel is worthwhile.

The reverse is true for the police / CPS - they have limited resources so can’t investigate every crime thoroughly. So crimes like rape where there are supposed ‘grey areas’ or limited witnesses or inherent biases in juries (the notion of the perfect victim, the idea that the victim didn’t do enough to protect themselves or invited it) are rarely pursued.

It’s all about money.

But in a system where the bottom line is all that matters, do you believe the women who are getting no money - because they won’t be paid for any media appearances or testimony - or do you believe the man who makes millions from videos that will only be broadcast on social media where there are no regulations, professional ethics or legal checks?

I don’t have sufficient evidence to decide who I believe.

I dare say the BBC would have claimed Martin Bashier dotted all the Is and crossed the ts., that lawyers went through it all with a fine tooth comb. In the current case lawyers will have been through it all with a fine tooth comb to see if there was a risk they could be sued, They will not have been deciding whether he was guilty (nor could they) lawyers work for their clients.they will protect the interests of those paying the bill.

Ultimately though it’s not about who I do and don’t believe. At the end of the day I believe in justice which society agrees should be administered through the justice system.

There is a great, long standing position that the mass
media is the new church. Do we want justice administered by the church or by the state?

OP posts:
Iamnotastick · 18/09/2023 12:04

Cornettoninja · 18/09/2023 12:00

@Iamnotastick careful now, JS never stood trial and had a court confirm he was a nonce to his face. The dead can’t defend themselves so I don’t think any findings are conclusive.

(very heavily on the sarcasm in case it’s missed)

Sarcasm detected and appreciated.

Cornettoninja · 18/09/2023 12:00

@Iamnotastick careful now, JS never stood trial and had a court confirm he was a nonce to his face. The dead can’t defend themselves so I don’t think any findings are conclusive.

(very heavily on the sarcasm in case it’s missed)

Iamnotastick · 18/09/2023 11:55

ghostyslovesheets · 18/09/2023 11:52

Does anyone think Jimmy Saville was innocent?

The difference is its very hard to try and defend a nonce, because no one wants to be seen as one.

Women and teen girls tho are fair fucking game in society though. Those who defend are the type to abuse or be abused.

Cornettoninja · 18/09/2023 11:55

Chocolatchip · 18/09/2023 11:51

Sexual assault (forced BJ), emotional abuse and abuse of power are not fluff.

Oral rape is a legitimate crime in itself. It’s not assault.

Pinkdelight3 · 18/09/2023 11:55

I believe them but tbh it's all a storm in a teacup, will be forgotten in 2 weeks.

Nice. No wonder women don't report rapes with this shitty attitude still around.

Cornettoninja · 18/09/2023 11:54

As far as I can tell there were 2 accounts of rape in the documentary, the rest was fluff. I doubt those accounts would have him convicted tbh, because it's a terrible state of affairs, hardly anyone is convicted of rape. I believe them but tbh it's all a storm in a teacup, will be forgotten in 2 weeks

@Calistano and yet the ‘fluff’ (I didn’t notice any fluff but did hear accounts of abuse) adds to the legitimacy of the rape claims. Sadly the courts don’t accept ‘fluff’ as evidence either. They bloody should. Sexual crimes are often a character trial for both the accuser and the accused, the media didn’t invent this basis.

You need evidence, he was there, you need evidence the deed occurred and you need evidence there was no consent

@Drfosters so in a case that is word vs word what would you accept as evidence? If we accept that tangible evidence is an impossibility in the majority of cases then we are faced with a choice - do we find a way to evidence or do we essentially deny that these crimes ever take place?

ghostyslovesheets · 18/09/2023 11:52

Does anyone think Jimmy Saville was innocent?

Chocolatchip · 18/09/2023 11:51

Calistano · 18/09/2023 11:34

As far as I can tell there were 2 accounts of rape in the documentary, the rest was fluff. I doubt those accounts would have him convicted tbh, because it's a terrible state of affairs, hardly anyone is convicted of rape. I believe them but tbh it's all a storm in a teacup, will be forgotten in 2 weeks.

Dunno why people are saying its because of his controversial views, he's hardly David icke, havent watched much of him, but he is quite milquetoast in his views.

Sexual assault (forced BJ), emotional abuse and abuse of power are not fluff.

Bingbangbongbash · 18/09/2023 11:47

Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 11:25

None of which had been found true ina court of law. He might or might not have done that. But you have clearly decided he’s guilty. If you were chosen to sit on a jury what chance would RB have of a fair trial? This is the very point I’m raising.

This is as true about any high profile case - Lucy Letby, Harold Shipman, Weinstein, Depp…

In the latter case, he lost when the case was decided by a judge, a person used to evaluating evidence and understanding the law intimately. He was found not guilty of some (not all) of the charges when tried by a jury that was not sequestered nor asked to surrender their phones. Coincidentally, the hashtag ‘justiceforjohnny’ was seen 19 billion times during the trial.

There is no such thing as a fair trial in the age of instant media - especially thanks to the rise of completely unregulated social media where lies spread like wildfire.

But you can be very sure that the Times & Dispatches dotted every i and crossed every t before it was published.

I’m still waiting for someone to explain why they don’t believe the doc / article is telling the truth, yet they believe videos they see on social media.

Also, RB will have been aware of the investigation for a long time. They just wouldn’t have given him a dossier of the contents until it was all checked and double checked, then triple checked. At that point (8 days out from transmission), he had the opportunity to address the accusations.

I’m really surprised at how little people understand of the way the media and criminal justice system works.

Everything is about money. Yes, media outlets are for profit - so they will only put the huge resources needed for a long running investigation like this into something they feel is worthwhile.

The reverse is true for the police / CPS - they have limited resources so can’t investigate every crime thoroughly. So crimes like rape where there are supposed ‘grey areas’ or limited witnesses or inherent biases in juries (the notion of the perfect victim, the idea that the victim didn’t do enough to protect themselves or invited it) are rarely pursued.

It’s all about money.

But in a system where the bottom line is all that matters, do you believe the women who are getting no money - because they won’t be paid for any media appearances or testimony - or do you believe the man who makes millions from videos that will only be broadcast on social media where there are no regulations, professional ethics or legal checks?

Iamnotastick · 18/09/2023 11:42

Felding will be next.

Calistano · 18/09/2023 11:39

I'm quite surprised Ickey hasn't been mettood. Read something online about him from an ex that was none too flattering.

CorylusAgain · 18/09/2023 11:38

Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 11:25

None of which had been found true ina court of law. He might or might not have done that. But you have clearly decided he’s guilty. If you were chosen to sit on a jury what chance would RB have of a fair trial? This is the very point I’m raising.

But Brand already has a massive media presence and self publicity which can be argued tips the inequality in his favour! He wasn't a private individual. If he is an abuser he has had decades to gaslight the public from which a jury will be selected. Is that a level playing field for the alleged victims?

Calistano · 18/09/2023 11:34

As far as I can tell there were 2 accounts of rape in the documentary, the rest was fluff. I doubt those accounts would have him convicted tbh, because it's a terrible state of affairs, hardly anyone is convicted of rape. I believe them but tbh it's all a storm in a teacup, will be forgotten in 2 weeks.

Dunno why people are saying its because of his controversial views, he's hardly David icke, havent watched much of him, but he is quite milquetoast in his views.

juice92 · 18/09/2023 11:31

I have never liked RB, I have always found him creepy and sexist. I feel like his behaviour over the radio and on screen, shows someone who has a low opinion of women, sees them as objects and could have the capacity to be even worse than that. These stories from these women are not surprising to me.

Dispatches and The Times are hardly sensationalist media outlets, and they will have made sure they did their proper due diligence before releasing the story. I saw a lot of proof on that documentary and I personally believe the women and the stories that were told. I also believe in the right to tell them, whether they have gone through the courts/justice system or not.

Drfosters · 18/09/2023 11:26

ghostyslovesheets · 18/09/2023 10:56

Erm well several women accused him of rape which is illegal

with regard to the 16 year old , her age is an issue as he was much older and more powerful BUT the main issue is that he forced her into a sex act against her will and Also held her mouth open by force and repeatedly spat in it which is assault

her age is an issue but it doesn’t detract from the sexual assault

100% assault if it can be proved beyond reasonable doubt. If I was on a jury I would want to be 100% sure everything was corroborated. I have absolutely no reason to doubt the victim’s account (and it is very harrowing) but ultimately it is that, an account all presented from the side of the prosecution. You need evidence, he was there, you need evidence the deed occurred and you need evidence there was no consent. This can only come after seeing the victim cross examined, RB’s diary checked he was where she alleged he was, and any other evidence at the time. Witness corroboration would also help from people around her. This all builds a picture. Maybe they have all this (apologies if they provided all this and I missed it).

Maatandosiris · 18/09/2023 11:25

ghostyslovesheets · 18/09/2023 10:56

Erm well several women accused him of rape which is illegal

with regard to the 16 year old , her age is an issue as he was much older and more powerful BUT the main issue is that he forced her into a sex act against her will and Also held her mouth open by force and repeatedly spat in it which is assault

her age is an issue but it doesn’t detract from the sexual assault

None of which had been found true ina court of law. He might or might not have done that. But you have clearly decided he’s guilty. If you were chosen to sit on a jury what chance would RB have of a fair trial? This is the very point I’m raising.

OP posts:
WarriorN · 18/09/2023 11:23

Safeguarding is about the ongoing process. Not a DBS piece of paper past on the past.

Transparency. Ongoing reflection.

Acknowledging mistakes and making changes to stop further mistakes. (So yes, we know how bad the bbc is because it has some transparency.)

When none of that happens, whistleblowing is the last resort.

Sometimes the authorities STILL don't act (slander etc) so people resort to the press.

Swipe left for the next trending thread