Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why didn't they go to the police? (TW)

136 replies

CynicalUsee · 17/09/2023 09:37

I am sick of hearing this being trotted out in relation to victims of sexual assault. The only person the victim is responsible for is themselves and their own recovery, that is it. No one else. They aren't responsible for potential future victims, they aren't responsible for the rapist. If they choose not to report the crime that is 100% ok if they choose to go to the police that is 100% ok.

What anyone chooses to do with their recovery is their choice. For a group of people who have suffered due to having choice removed from them why are people so hellbent on creating more trauma by laying on guilt and removing more choice away from them?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
StBrides · 17/09/2023 11:31

Why didn't they go to the police? This is why:

Why didn't they go to the police? (TW)
StBrides · 17/09/2023 11:30

Why didn't they go to the police?

This is why:

Why didn't they go to the police? (TW)
Ponkyandthebrain · 17/09/2023 11:21

confusedmum2023 · 17/09/2023 10:57

This is my feeling too.

I’m a senior detective with RASSO as a specialism. As others have said the police experience is better than it has been though still far from perfect. But the criminal justice system is very hard on victims of sexual abuse. Cross examination is very re traumatising. It’s much worse than an anonymous interview with an understanding journalist. You can’t compare it at all. I can absolutely see why women go to the media. I have every sympathy with it.

We need specialist RASSO courts, we need to seriously reconsider the jury system for rape trials, until the criminal justice system changes substantially for sexual offences the prosecution rate will be on the floor. But the rights of men to commit rape with impunity still prevail and there’s no sign of that changing.

fitch568 · 17/09/2023 11:21

The problem here is some are conflating the view that the media should not be a substitute criminal justice system with the view that the victims are not to be believed because they've chosen this route over the police. I for one am not saying that. I am trying hard not to judge either side in the actual allegations because that's not for me to do without actually being on a jury/ having full evidence. I am judging / questioning the process. And by the process, I mean the media led process. Not the women's decision to go that route...

Thewizardbinbag · 17/09/2023 11:21

I went to the police. I was pregnant at the time. Spoken to by 2 officers, one male and one female. The male officer didn’t believe me, as it was a friend who did it. All his questions were framed around did I start if, lead the guy on, why would a friend do this to me etc etc. Female officer stayed silent. After about an hour of defending myself, I said I wanted to leave and didn’t want to take it further. He then said they’d have to have a psychologist speak to me to see if I was fit to parent the child I was pregnant with, as making false reports about that sort of thing was a red flag. That’s when the female office spoke up and said enough and let me leave.

So I went to the police and he threatened to try and have my unborn child removed from my care.

GoIdie · 17/09/2023 11:15

My perpetrator said this to me. If I didn't report, it must not have happened. Funnily enough, the police disagreed. He was arrested, bailed and charged after 7 years.

I find victim blaming so abhorrent. I'm luckily that I still have evidence but even then, people disbelieve and disbelieve.

bombastix · 17/09/2023 11:11

The attitudes on here are in the juries that decide rape cases. Nobody can read this site and be surprised that conviction rates or reporting rape is low on that basis.

The criminal justice system because of a jury trial tells you exactly what the real attitude is. The attitude is she made it up. End.

Lots impassioned talk around it, but plenty of evidence that is what most think.

supercatlady · 17/09/2023 11:09

I agree. Also sometimes you aren’t aware of just how bad it is at the time, but maturity and life experience make you realise it’s not something you have to put up with.

fitch568 · 17/09/2023 11:08

Channel 4 literally made a programme alleging one of their most famous presenters was a rapist and backed up those claims with footage of him on their channel being horrifically misogynist to put it mildly. They are the ones that hid him in plain sight & gave him a platform to play out his sctickz. They gave him the celebrity that undoubtedly fuelled his sex addiction. The nineties were a mess.

IHateLegDay · 17/09/2023 11:01

100% agree. I didn't bother reporting because I knew nothing would come of it except more trauma for me.
9 years on and a ton of therapy later, I'm healing and he's playing happy family with his wife and child.

fitch568 · 17/09/2023 10:59

@donkra where have I dismissed the allegations in my posts? I have explicitly said the opposite. You're trotting out the usual lines without questioning THE MEDIA's motive in all this.. I feel if anything these women are being made victims of all over again by the media. I hope they have someone protecting & advising them. The legal system is not meant to be 'supportive of women' sadly.. it's meant to be impartial.. prob there of course is it's of course male-led. The media are not whiter than white though - they always have an agenda. But again, for the record you've misconstrued my line of debate. I am absolutely not dismissing the victims. I'm not gonna throw my story out there to back that up. We all have one though.

confusedmum2023 · 17/09/2023 10:57

Tinkerbyebye · 17/09/2023 10:04

I agree with you, until they go to the media instead

This is my feeling too.

Comtesse · 17/09/2023 10:48

When the official channels aren’t working (the police, the CPS, the courts) then other routes are used. It isn’t how it’s supposed to be, but what is the alternative?

donkra · 17/09/2023 10:43

fitch568 · 17/09/2023 10:40

@donkra why are you angry at me..?! I'm not doubting the allegations...just questioning the whole process.

Because you're trotting out a long-established line of whataboutery that essentially dismisses a victim by questioning her motives unless she behaves in a perfect, unrealistic, and very rigidly defined way.

Notsadaboutit · 17/09/2023 10:42

I understand completely why people choose not to go to the Police having been through the process myself.

But I also I agree with those querying why they choose to speak to the media instead. I don't believe subjecting yourself to the media circus is in anyway any better than subjecting yourself to the judicial circus.

I also flatly disagree with those saying the media listen. Do the Murdoch Press really listen? Or do they just want to leech off the misfortune of others to make money and push their own agenda? They're not interested really in these women and their lives. They just want a story to sell.

Aliceinunderland · 17/09/2023 10:42

I did go to the police
I did go to the SARC for a physical examination
I did give a statement. In fact several
I cooperated with the police for 2 years
I was one of the lucky one because the officer in charge of my case fought hard with the CPS and they agreed to charge him
I had to move because someone threw petrol over my front door whilst me and my son were asleep
I attended court to give evidence and was torn apart by a barrister who would have forgotten my name by the end of the trial
I was confused when my attacker got to sit in court and not be questioned after I went through 2 days of having every aspect of my life analysed
I sat and cried with the officer when he was found not guilty after 20 minutes

I would never tell anyone that they should go to the police and I had a fantastic experience with the kind and determined officers who worked with me. But the trial itself left me with emotional wounds that are left healing and that was 20 years ago.

Nevermind202020 · 17/09/2023 10:41

We cannot tell women how they must react after they have been raped.

We can however do all we can to make sure every rape claim is taken seriously, and that women feel adequately supported to do whatever they feel they need to do in terms of potentially seeking prosecution and attempting to deal with the horrific and long-lasting effects of such a horrible event!

If a man rapes/assaults a woman, then while 'innocent until proven guilty' of course stands in law, he also must understand this his actions toward the woman are what is responsible for any media coverage/frenzy because he CHOOSE to rape/assault! Actions have consequences.

Of course there are a few false accusations of rape, however these really are in the minority and there are thousands (millions) more cases where the victim is too scared to report anything/does report it and it isn't taken seriously/person isn't convicted!

fitch568 · 17/09/2023 10:40

@donkra why are you angry at me..?! I'm not doubting the allegations...just questioning the whole process.

donkra · 17/09/2023 10:38

what about the millions of women raped by non-celebs

As someone raped by a nonceleb who is pretty confident he has other victims, I feel deeply happy every time a rapey celeb gets nailed to the wall.

I've moved on and accepted that the criminal justice system will probably never come for the fuckface who did it to me, but it makes me happy when it comes for others.

donkra · 17/09/2023 10:36

fitch568 · 17/09/2023 10:26

@donkra I get that but what persuades the women to share their experiences on this platform & now? Power in numbers maybe. Or are they just pawns in a media ratings race?? I watched the She Said film and there shadows of this here.

...Are you fucking serious? So, having lived through being raped by a famous man, knowing they have essentially nil chance of legal justice, they also better make sure they talk about it at the exsct right future time, else their motives are suspect?

Yes, most likely the backing of major media sources and the existence of multiple other victims has helped them decide they can deal with being part of the story, just as it did for Savile's many victims. Some of them have also probably spent many years recovering and rebuilding themselves and now feel strong enough to deal with the onslaught that no doubt awaits them. Others will have decided it's not worth it to them and opted out. That is an intensely personal decision, and one I fully understand either way.

Fruitynutcase · 17/09/2023 10:33

I can tell you why people don't go to the police, because it's your word against theirs .Most sexual offenders are known to the victim. Often these creeps have planned / reasoned that nothing will happen to them even if it's reported. They also select their targets and will spread round rumours that the target was easy and willing . They prepare the ground . They don't hassle people if they think there will be some comeback on them . People do what they think they can get away with .

fitch568 · 17/09/2023 10:32

Livingoncaffeine · 17/09/2023 10:27

I have been dwelling on this all morning. I can completely understand why the victims haven’t gone to the police. I’m fortunate to have never been sexually assaulted so I don’t know what I would do, but I think in these circumstances I’d also be reluctant to go to the police.

But I feel very uncomfortable with the media can just be used as an alternative to a broken criminal justice system.

For what it’s worth I completely believe these victims and agree RB is guilty. But it’s not actually for me to decide that in this country, it’s for a jury and then for a judge to decide the punishment. I don’t know where that leaves us though when the criminal justice system is so dire. I don’t know if the times could take their evidence to the police and if the police could press charges without the victim’s support / giving evidence? I’m guessing not.

I think I err on the side of thinking that if you’re willing to open up to the media then you should be willing to give the same evidence to the police so that actual justice can be done. But I also understand that the police and court process is so much more intrusive and that you rightly don’t want every single aspect of your life examined.

So I don’t really know what the answer is but yes I agree it’s reasonable to not to to the police, I just don’t feel entirely comfortable with the media aspect. Although how then you raise awareness of such a predator without the media I don’t know. Sorry for the jumbled response, have been turning it over on my head for a few hours trying to see what I think of it all!

This is exactly how I feel. It's the media over the broken legal system element that's so wrong. Not least because the media can choose which 'stories' they tell.. what about the millions of women raped by non-celebs.. I am s as k ok so hugely wary of the media's agenda, even when seemingly reporting important stuff like this.

PuttingDownRoots · 17/09/2023 10:29

The only responsibility a victim has is to their own recovery. Not to be ripped to shreds by the friends of the perpetrator, the police and randomers.

Livingoncaffeine · 17/09/2023 10:29

Dippydinosaurus · 17/09/2023 10:01

It's taken 3 years for The Times/Dispatches to get to this point to (hopefully) get a conviction. And this is one man. How would individual women reporting it to the police do anything. Instead of saying why didn't women report it, why aren't they actually looking at the reasons why women feel like they can't report it

Can the police get a conviction based on this? Would they not have to basically start the same investigation from scratch? (Genuinely don’t know!)

Livingoncaffeine · 17/09/2023 10:27

I have been dwelling on this all morning. I can completely understand why the victims haven’t gone to the police. I’m fortunate to have never been sexually assaulted so I don’t know what I would do, but I think in these circumstances I’d also be reluctant to go to the police.

But I feel very uncomfortable with the media can just be used as an alternative to a broken criminal justice system.

For what it’s worth I completely believe these victims and agree RB is guilty. But it’s not actually for me to decide that in this country, it’s for a jury and then for a judge to decide the punishment. I don’t know where that leaves us though when the criminal justice system is so dire. I don’t know if the times could take their evidence to the police and if the police could press charges without the victim’s support / giving evidence? I’m guessing not.

I think I err on the side of thinking that if you’re willing to open up to the media then you should be willing to give the same evidence to the police so that actual justice can be done. But I also understand that the police and court process is so much more intrusive and that you rightly don’t want every single aspect of your life examined.

So I don’t really know what the answer is but yes I agree it’s reasonable to not to to the police, I just don’t feel entirely comfortable with the media aspect. Although how then you raise awareness of such a predator without the media I don’t know. Sorry for the jumbled response, have been turning it over on my head for a few hours trying to see what I think of it all!