Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why didn't they go to the police? (TW)

136 replies

CynicalUsee · 17/09/2023 09:37

I am sick of hearing this being trotted out in relation to victims of sexual assault. The only person the victim is responsible for is themselves and their own recovery, that is it. No one else. They aren't responsible for potential future victims, they aren't responsible for the rapist. If they choose not to report the crime that is 100% ok if they choose to go to the police that is 100% ok.

What anyone chooses to do with their recovery is their choice. For a group of people who have suffered due to having choice removed from them why are people so hellbent on creating more trauma by laying on guilt and removing more choice away from them?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
13
Lippysoutherner · 18/09/2023 14:33

Just wanting to add my utmost admiration for anyone brave enough to tell their stories, wherever they manage to do it. And to gently remind folk that weeks like this leave many of us raw and struggling, with no choice but to remember and relive our worst moments..Not generally in the #bekind movement, but I think today it's an appropriate sentiment.

henlee · 18/09/2023 13:32

PenhillDarkMonarch · 17/09/2023 19:31

PP have eloquently shared why women are so traumatised and afraid that they do not report a crime.

To add to their words, since these crimes happened...

  • the world has changed, and there has been a marked reduction in everyone thinking sexual harrasment is just banter and/or young women played a role in 'asking for' their assaults by being in the presence of perpertrators
  • the young women involved have grown older and quite possibly grown in confidence and shrunk in tolerence for bullshit
  • Harvey Weinstein was convicted of several cases of rape - trials that were themselves triggered by a newspaper article and investgative journalism, possibly leading to a greater confidence you will be believed over the powerful celebrity
  • Brand himself has lost any mainstream protection - he might still have a lot of followers but he is clearly outside of the protective wing of the TV channels etc.

All of this ^^

And to add, there will be empowerment in hearing that someone else experienced the same thing as you and are being taking seriously. When I experienced a (relatively minor) assault, I convinced myself I must have imagined it. When I heard another girl had reported him it gave me the confidence to speak out about it.

The ill-informed comments about "confirmation bias" are really enraging tbh.

ChateauMargaux · 18/09/2023 13:27

I am sorry for those who reported and were not treated with kindness.

I dislike the pressure that victims are placed under to 'do right' when it is not them who have done wrong.

I see it in the counselling / psychiatry professions.. 'if you disclose something to me, I have an obligation to report it'..

I understand that where the outcome can be to prevent ongoing harm to the individual making the report.. but when someone is seeking help, threatening them with the weight of the law can in many cases be harmful.

PenhillDarkMonarch · 17/09/2023 19:31

PP have eloquently shared why women are so traumatised and afraid that they do not report a crime.

To add to their words, since these crimes happened...

  • the world has changed, and there has been a marked reduction in everyone thinking sexual harrasment is just banter and/or young women played a role in 'asking for' their assaults by being in the presence of perpertrators
  • the young women involved have grown older and quite possibly grown in confidence and shrunk in tolerence for bullshit
  • Harvey Weinstein was convicted of several cases of rape - trials that were themselves triggered by a newspaper article and investgative journalism, possibly leading to a greater confidence you will be believed over the powerful celebrity
  • Brand himself has lost any mainstream protection - he might still have a lot of followers but he is clearly outside of the protective wing of the TV channels etc.
ArabeIIaScott · 17/09/2023 18:31

Christmas202 · 17/09/2023 17:35

My story is slightly different in the fact I had a witness to the whole thing. I was 11 and my friend and I were told to pick which one by person a and b . I obviously protected my friend. What makes it more complicated is that it was her family. I had no choice but to choose me. After my attack, we were then locked up like dogs by person c . We were eventually released after what felt like a lifetime with a warning to keep our mouths shut. I never told anyone til I was 18. The shrink I accidentally told reported to the police without my say so. I was forced into giving a statement and was pressured into pressing charges, which I didn’t by a male police officer. I’m still haunted to this day, it’s been 19 years.

My god, that made my stomach lurch. I'm so very, very sorry. I hope you can find a way to heal.

OneTwoThreeShake · 17/09/2023 18:08

The criminal justice system is massively weighted in favour of the rich and powerful. When considering sexual crimes, it is even more prevalent and compounded by the absolutely miniscule conviction rate.

This is not the case in the mainstream media, when these women are approached by investigative journalists who are motivated to expose the criminal. Its a much more level platform.

Christmas202 · 17/09/2023 17:35

My story is slightly different in the fact I had a witness to the whole thing. I was 11 and my friend and I were told to pick which one by person a and b . I obviously protected my friend. What makes it more complicated is that it was her family. I had no choice but to choose me. After my attack, we were then locked up like dogs by person c . We were eventually released after what felt like a lifetime with a warning to keep our mouths shut. I never told anyone til I was 18. The shrink I accidentally told reported to the police without my say so. I was forced into giving a statement and was pressured into pressing charges, which I didn’t by a male police officer. I’m still haunted to this day, it’s been 19 years.

Mrburnshound · 17/09/2023 14:27

Also it's not a quick 'report and then done' i actually complained but then had to keep going back to identify people when tbh I was over it and wanted to just move on (im totally fine now). Im not saying the police were wrong as they had a job to do but it is something to take into consideration that it might be easier to forget and move on.

dottyshihtzu · 17/09/2023 14:24

I don’t understand why they then are able to speak to the press

Because they want to be heard.

''Alice'' says she had contacted Brand's representatives looking for an apology, but instead got a reply from lawyers basically calling her a liar and implying that what she was doing (telling them about Brand) was 'blackmail'.

I imagine being told by a lawyer that you're 'blackmailing' someone with a lot more money and power than you is terrifying if you don't have the eye-watering amount of money you'd need to defend yourself in court.

However, Channel 4 and the Times are lawyered up, their lawyers will have been all over this investigation doing their best to make it as solid as possible in case there's legal action, so I don't blame the women for getting it out there in this way, with C4 and the Times (and their lawyers) behind them. Going against a millionaire alone would be daunting. Going against a millionaire with two wealthy organisations behind you probably makes it less so, it takes some of the power imbalance away.

ArabeIIaScott · 17/09/2023 14:13

jlpth · 17/09/2023 14:12

Well, I'm glad the police are good. But you'll still be at the mercy of the courts. And beware that by the time that happens (years), the police involved may have moved on from the job and might not be able to testify.

Yes, absolutely.

jlpth · 17/09/2023 14:12

ArabeIIaScott · 17/09/2023 14:03

Just noting - two friends have recently reported abuse and coercive control/dv to the police. Both have been well supported, listened, to, and offered good advice. Both have praised the police response. It may of course vary from area to area, but I'm reassured that at least here, police seem to be on the case and to have women's backs.

Well, I'm glad the police are good. But you'll still be at the mercy of the courts. And beware that by the time that happens (years), the police involved may have moved on from the job and might not be able to testify.

jlpth · 17/09/2023 14:10

Aliceinunderland · 17/09/2023 10:42

I did go to the police
I did go to the SARC for a physical examination
I did give a statement. In fact several
I cooperated with the police for 2 years
I was one of the lucky one because the officer in charge of my case fought hard with the CPS and they agreed to charge him
I had to move because someone threw petrol over my front door whilst me and my son were asleep
I attended court to give evidence and was torn apart by a barrister who would have forgotten my name by the end of the trial
I was confused when my attacker got to sit in court and not be questioned after I went through 2 days of having every aspect of my life analysed
I sat and cried with the officer when he was found not guilty after 20 minutes

I would never tell anyone that they should go to the police and I had a fantastic experience with the kind and determined officers who worked with me. But the trial itself left me with emotional wounds that are left healing and that was 20 years ago.

The not guilty is terrible.
I was on a jury recently where we could not reach a verdict in a series of sexual assaults, despite nearly all of us knowing he was beyond guilty. It only takes a small minority of jurors who are either assaulters themselves or some sort of pacifist idiots who refuse to convict anyone of anything. I was pretty scarred just being the juror, let alone the victim. Both were ripped apart by an utterly wicked defence barrister. I don't know how those people sleep at night. It's a sick broken system and I know full well I'd never report any kind of sexual assault or rape.

ArabeIIaScott · 17/09/2023 14:03

Just noting - two friends have recently reported abuse and coercive control/dv to the police. Both have been well supported, listened, to, and offered good advice. Both have praised the police response. It may of course vary from area to area, but I'm reassured that at least here, police seem to be on the case and to have women's backs.

toadasoda · 17/09/2023 14:02

ArabeIIaScott · 17/09/2023 13:15

I was imagining this morning what might happen if every woman who had ever experienced abuse, assault and/or rape were to turn up to her local police station on International Women's Day, at nine a.m., and report every instance.

There is no 'statute of limitations' in the UK. So every woman is entitled to do so, for every instance throughout her life.

That's an amazing idea!!!

I'm so sorry to read all these accounts. Truth is no way would I report if it was me, I wouldn't have the strength.

Recently there was an attempted rape case heard in my local court. Someone dragged a man off a girl down an alleyway just in time, she was 17 or 18. The defence used her underwear as suggestive of consent, it was a lacy g string type thing. The (female) barrister argued that a girl wouldn't wear that unless she planned having sex with someone. Thankfully the local media picked up on it and the solicitor and barrister were publicly torn to shreds. They will of course argue that they were just doing their jobs. From what I've heard rape defence cases tend to use younger female barristers as its suggestive of 'well if she didn't believe the victim...' not realising that's nothing to do with it. I guess the point I'm making is I think the legal team do have some moral responsibility too, I wholly agree with innocent until proven guilty but certain arguments should not be allowed or be inadmissible.

Escapetofrance · 17/09/2023 13:53

As I said, I can see understand the trauma and that’s why people don’t/can’t go to the police. The lack of being heard & being able to get in touch with the police is appalling. If people are going to the press because the police don’t answer the phone or emails, something is seriously wrong.
I am very sorry you have been through that ordeal.

TheGhostofLoganRoy · 17/09/2023 13:40

Also it's damn near impossible to actually make contact with the police nowadays, other than by dialling 999 which can't be used unless your life is in active danger.

I was assaulted two years ago, dialled 101, no one answered. Just rang and rang for more than 30 minutes. Never answered.

I filled in two online forms on 101 online, reporting the assault, never heard a word back. Police just totally ignored my assault report.

Other than take a day off work, pick a random police station and just march in and refuse to leave without speaking to someone, the police are not contactable.

ArabeIIaScott · 17/09/2023 13:15

I was imagining this morning what might happen if every woman who had ever experienced abuse, assault and/or rape were to turn up to her local police station on International Women's Day, at nine a.m., and report every instance.

There is no 'statute of limitations' in the UK. So every woman is entitled to do so, for every instance throughout her life.

ghostyslovesheets · 17/09/2023 13:10

Escapetofrance · 17/09/2023 13:07

I understand why people may not feel they can go to the police because of the trauma they are suffering.
I don’t understand why they then are able to speak to the press. I realise they may feel safety in numbers, and perhaps together they will or have gone to the police.
Things are not that simple.

Read my post below - it took me YEARS to process what had happened and to speak out

Women try and bury it and move on - it doesn't stay buried. Maybe at 16 you feel powerless but at 30+ you finally feel safe enough to talk

it's not something that comes easily.

ghostyslovesheets · 17/09/2023 13:08

I was 4 - I didn't have the words - by the time I understood I was filled with shame and couldn't use the words. At 16 I finally spoke out and found support - I went on to work with Rape Crisis for years - but those years of shame and silence where awful.

When I did speak out I triggered my own mother to realise the same man had done it to her (he was a relative) and she then had enormous guilt that she had 'allowed it to happen' to me - it took a long time for her to grasp that is was HIS fault - she had blocked it completely, piecing things together we are fairly sure he also targeted other family members through the years.

But speaking up comes with a cost - women aren't believed, don't get justice, and families aren't always supportive.

I totally understand why women, including the women in last night dispatches, stay silent (at least to the authorities) because very often when they try to report - to bosses, managers etc they are silenced.

In the case of RB these where junior staff - who's jobs where on the line - working for companies that KNEW he was an issue - they KNEW that their bosses KNEW and did NOTHING - what did they think would happen if they said anything - NOTHING - protect the 'talent' and protect the men - women are expendable

Escapetofrance · 17/09/2023 13:07

I understand why people may not feel they can go to the police because of the trauma they are suffering.
I don’t understand why they then are able to speak to the press. I realise they may feel safety in numbers, and perhaps together they will or have gone to the police.
Things are not that simple.

Justletpeopleenjoythings · 17/09/2023 13:05

Because the first time he raped me I was 13 and he was my father.

ArabeIIaScott · 17/09/2023 13:04

RicherThanYews · 17/09/2023 09:44

Agreed Op. My counsellor told me (at 19, very shortly after it happened) that as I hadn't reported the incident, the perpetrator was free to hurt someone else and it would be my fault. That is how victims of rape are treated.

My god. I hope this person isn't still working as a counsellor. I'm so very sorry.

SummerDawn2000 · 17/09/2023 13:01

Or like me they convince themselves they haven’t been raped. Or just block it out. I told a counsellor and she said I don’t know. I put myself in those positions I wanted sex. I didn’t want to be raped. Years ago now. Being over powered is horrendous.

nopuppiesallowed · 17/09/2023 12:59

I was around 13 when someone tried to rape me. I completely blocked it out, until one day, I was watching one of my granddaughters who was around the same age I had been when I was attacked. She was just mooching around with some of her friends when, suddenly, it all came flooding back. I could see the light filtering in through the shed windows, the shadows on the walls. I could tell you exactly what I was wearing, his name and the colour of his hair; how I froze and didn't even scream or push him away. I can tell you what stopped him. But I'd blocked it all out completely until I recognised me in my young granddaughter and realised it hadn't been my fault. I will never judge any girl or woman who doesn't accuse the perpetrator until many years after the attack. She may have buried it completely until something triggers the memory.

Mary1234567 · 17/09/2023 12:57

The consequences of the actions of a rapist are the fault of the rapist only