Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher showed 15 film to Y7

167 replies

Littlepopsicle · 17/09/2023 07:23

DS has just started Y7. All going well, loves his new school and is very settled.
Drama class last week, teacher told them the theme for this half term is something about haunted houses. She then showed them the trailer for The Woman in Black. DH and I eye rolled each other as soon as we heard this as we knew what was going to happen....no surprise, DS has been unable to sleep alone since seeing this. We are very careful about anything he watches as he has an overactive imagination, is easily scared and sleep is easily disrupted. DH is annoyed at having another disturbed night with DS and thinks we should complain to the school. Do you think we should complain and say this is inappropriate to show to 11 and 12 years olds, or at least parents should have been warned that this was going to be shown? Or would you say it's a non-issue, get over it, he's just an over sensitive child?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
PuddlesPityParty · 17/09/2023 08:46

shearwater · 17/09/2023 08:43

It's much scarier than Great Expectations.

Honestly if he can’t handle the trailer for the woman in black without nightmares is he really gonna deal with a woman setting herself on fire??

PuddlesPityParty · 17/09/2023 08:45

shearwater · 17/09/2023 08:32

Woman in Black was the most complained about film ever at the time in terms of whether the BBFC classification was right at 12A.

I think it should be a 15 or 18. Loads of kids being persuaded to kill themselves and die horribly is about as mature a theme as it gets.

Yet I've seen loads of films which are a 15 or 18 where there is just a bit of bad language or sexual content or brief violence, and it doesn't stay with you half as much, or bother you remotely, as a teen or adult. So the BBFC frequently get it wrong, for me.

I watched it in high school and I don’t remember being disturbed by it?? We had read the book by time we watched it so we knew what was coming so to speak.

shearwater · 17/09/2023 08:43

PuddlesPityParty · 17/09/2023 08:42

It’s not that scary OP. It’s very mild. They will be reading the book for English. What’s he gonna be like when they do great expectations 🙄

It's much scarier than Great Expectations.

JMSA · 17/09/2023 08:43

He can't sleep after seeing the trailer for a film?Confused
Please don't complain.

Prescottdanni123 · 17/09/2023 08:42

I have the DVD. It is a 12A. Maybe film channels have given it a different rating to stop kids watching it without an adult's permission/supervision?

I don't know what I kept the DVD for. I've only ever watched half of it as I did find it quite scary (and I've watched a lot of horror films rated 15 without flinching) and I didn't like the topic. Kids being possessed by a vengeful ghost and forced to kill themselves.

PuddlesPityParty · 17/09/2023 08:42

It’s not that scary OP. It’s very mild. They will be reading the book for English. What’s he gonna be like when they do great expectations 🙄

Freesiabritney · 17/09/2023 08:41

I'd say your DS might have quite a difficult time at secondary school if it gets out that his parents complained about his bad dreams from a 12a movie.

2weekstowait · 17/09/2023 08:40

I wouldn’t say anything, he has to learn to cope with these things. It was a trailer. There are also many topics that could upset/scare children.

I know young children are different from a year 7, but my son used to be scared of any stories or books with woods in when he was little. There was also something in Wimpy Kid that kept him awake at night. It’s just part of life.

Hercisback · 17/09/2023 08:40

As a teacher if want to know how scared he was so that any other similar videos could be changed, adapted or he leaves the room. You can do this without complaining.

ActDottie · 17/09/2023 08:39

It’s a 12 not a 15 plus it was only the trailer. The teacher did nothing wrong. Instead work on assessing the over sensitive ness of your child. Tbh it sounds like they’re wrapped up in cotton wool and that’s going to impact him in later life if you keep this up.

shearwater · 17/09/2023 08:38

I think some gentle feedback to his teacher to let them know he is struggling with the theme would be in order, if he is happy for you to let them know. It's absolutely ok to be frightened by horror or spooky films.

llamadrama16 · 17/09/2023 08:32

Sausage1989 · 17/09/2023 07:50

You need to work on building your child's resilience up. That's extremely abnormal to be so scared..even my 6 year olds aren't like that..its going to taint his childhood.

JFC taint his childhood?! Because he is scared of something that is scary? Kids should be scared of scary things, it means they're probably more likely to have healthy boundaries because they haven't been desensitised.

shearwater · 17/09/2023 08:32

Woman in Black was the most complained about film ever at the time in terms of whether the BBFC classification was right at 12A.

I think it should be a 15 or 18. Loads of kids being persuaded to kill themselves and die horribly is about as mature a theme as it gets.

Yet I've seen loads of films which are a 15 or 18 where there is just a bit of bad language or sexual content or brief violence, and it doesn't stay with you half as much, or bother you remotely, as a teen or adult. So the BBFC frequently get it wrong, for me.

AnneValentine · 17/09/2023 08:28

MidnightOnceMore · 17/09/2023 08:02

Sorry this response is completely off the wall from someone claiming to work in a school.

'anxiety' my arse.

This level of upset over a trailer of a film rated 12a is not typical. On any level. It needs supporting. I’m not sure why you think my response is that off the wall or why you think a child should live with these levels of anxiety.

Trusttheprocess1 · 17/09/2023 08:27

I very much doubt they’ll be reading the play or novel. I imagine they have drama at most 1hr a week, once a fortnight is more likely. They’ll be doing a fun unit on creating suspense and working together in role. It’s more Scooby Doo than The Exorcist! I imagine she has shown the trailer ( couple of scares in it) because most children love to experience that feeling and it really is very mild. Some kids are sensitive I know and I imagine the teacher will have told them they might jump. Just give her a call and ask if you’re worried- please do not go to her boss or the pastoral team without just asking her what happened first.

comedownwithme · 17/09/2023 08:20

HolidayAtNight · 17/09/2023 07:55

Usually I'd have a different view, but this particular film scared the hell out of me and several friends when we saw it as adults. I would not even now be able to watch it all without flinching/covering my eyes at certain bits, etc. I can't imagine how scary it would have been at 11. The book is not nearly as frightening. And I love horror movies!

The child didn't watch the film though.

OP if the intent is to go on to watch parts of the film I would have a word with the teacher but if not I would say nothing.

Ricewhispies · 17/09/2023 08:20

I didn't sleep after watching a film at the cinema when I was in my 20s :D I'm generally resilient in every other aspect of my life, I don't think it's reflective of his resilience.

OP for my sins I was a teacher for many years, always welcomed parents with genuine concerns and feedback- as long as you don't go in all guns blazing and raging and rude then go for it. I agree with a PP that showing it so soon into year 7 is a bit savage as lots won't feel comfortable yet to say they are scared.

shearwater · 17/09/2023 08:19

henrysugar12 · 17/09/2023 08:12

www.bbfc.co.uk/education/case-studies/the-woman-in-black

It's a 12a.

So, should you complain? No. You do, however need to work on some resilience with your son, as to be scared to the extent of not sleeping is a little extreme reaction to a trailer, not even the whole film!

Utter bollocks.

Nothing to do with building resilience (which is mostly pseudoscience crap anyway) and sometimes clips or trailers are more scary than the whole film as they lack context.

Nothing wrong with being a highly imaginitive and sensitive person, in fact it's not wrong at all, quite the reverse. Lots of adults don't like horror films. I like some spooky ones and love a ghost story, but there are loads of films I deliberately avoid.

Willmafrockfit · 17/09/2023 08:19

it is very popular with schools, my ds saw it on stage

dottiedodah · 17/09/2023 08:18

I am over 50 and terrified of anything like this! Cant watch Horror films.Personally I would tell the teacher in private that your Son was worried and couldnt sleep properly.My Friends DD (yr10)went with her all girls school to see the play in London .They were crying all the way home ! I think Haunted Houses are an odd theme for a yr 7 .They have lots of other material surely?If he keeps waking it will impact his School work as well if hes tired.

Jifmicroliquid · 17/09/2023 08:17

Just the trailer? Perhaps if the whole film had been shown I might be a little bit frustrated if I had a sensitive child, but not a trailer.

Could you perhaps watch the trailer with your child again and kind of analyse it with him and chat about how they use the trailer to build up tension?
I say that because I was a film studies teacher and my sixth form had to study British horror one year for their AS level. All the kids were over 16 but some were very worried about it. They had to analyse 3 films in depth (I chose two over 18 films- one being Eden Lake- if you know, you know!)
I had a couple of students express concerns to me about the topic, but we had no choice as it was part of her exam board curriculum. I told them that by the end, they would have analysed the films in such detail that they would no longer be scary, but simply fascinating. Which they did. Even the most nervous kid actually enjoyed that process and they all got high grades that year. The most sensitive child told me at the end of the year that it had completely changed their take on the horror genre and they had started to really enjoy it rather than be scared.

You could apply the same principle and just have a kind of informal discussion about how they use things like lighting, sound etc in the trailer?

KittenBiscuit · 17/09/2023 08:13

If I were you OP I would suggest to the school that the timing of this text at the beginning of Y7 should be reconsidered for next academic year. The children will be quite stressed out by all the changes they are dealing with in their new school, and may not yet have a supportive friendship group around them to help process it. Giving them such a challenging text to deal with at such a time is IMO cruel, and some children are likely to be more affected by the content than they would be in a more settled state of mind. At the start of Y7 some are still very immature and they will mature a lot over the course of the year. I would gently suggest to the school that maybe the end of Y7, if they have to keep it in that year's learning plan, would be better.
Personally I would hate to be forced to watch such a scary film/play at any age, even now as an adult, and think it is unfair to force people at any stage of learning to have no choice in the material they have to watch.

shearwater · 17/09/2023 08:12

Teachers do get things wrong sometimes as kids can be highly sensitive. DD1 did a horror topic in drama in Y8 where they were shown clips of a few films and couldn't get to sleep for several nights. DD2 on the other hand would've absolutely been in her element.

I remember watching Poltergeist when I was 13. My dad was working away and though I enjoyed the film, I had to sleep in my mum's bed for a week. WiB is good but so sad and definitely disturbing as an adult. It has certainly disrupted my sleep before!

henrysugar12 · 17/09/2023 08:12

www.bbfc.co.uk/education/case-studies/the-woman-in-black

It's a 12a.

So, should you complain? No. You do, however need to work on some resilience with your son, as to be scared to the extent of not sleeping is a little extreme reaction to a trailer, not even the whole film!

Littlepopsicle · 17/09/2023 08:08

@Theraffarian I'm a 70s child and I remember that info film too!! In fact, forgetting how traumatising it was, we once started to show the kids this on youutube, after a conversation about those old public service films, but we soon switched it off!

OP posts: