Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher showed 15 film to Y7

167 replies

Littlepopsicle · 17/09/2023 07:23

DS has just started Y7. All going well, loves his new school and is very settled.
Drama class last week, teacher told them the theme for this half term is something about haunted houses. She then showed them the trailer for The Woman in Black. DH and I eye rolled each other as soon as we heard this as we knew what was going to happen....no surprise, DS has been unable to sleep alone since seeing this. We are very careful about anything he watches as he has an overactive imagination, is easily scared and sleep is easily disrupted. DH is annoyed at having another disturbed night with DS and thinks we should complain to the school. Do you think we should complain and say this is inappropriate to show to 11 and 12 years olds, or at least parents should have been warned that this was going to be shown? Or would you say it's a non-issue, get over it, he's just an over sensitive child?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
comedownwithme · 17/09/2023 09:02

TheOutlaws · 17/09/2023 08:56

@Littlepopsicle

Is your DS often scared of images, and does he catastrophise about them? I ask because, when I filled out the Childhood Depression and Anxiety Questionnaire for my DS1’s ADHD assessment, this was a clear marker for ADHD. I was the same as a child, I had terrible phobias of various images.

Perhaps instead of filing a complaint, you might ask school to keep an eye on your DS and feed back if they have any concerns that he might not be ‘typically’ developing?

I think the questions are to mark the level of anxiety and depression and not indicative of ADHD at all as ADHD has its own, very separate criteria.

Russooooo · 17/09/2023 09:01

I’m a teacher. If I want to show a 12 in year 7
or a 15 in year 10, I generally send a quick email home to forewarn parents and so they can let me know if there’s likely to be an issue.

in this case, where that ship has already sailed, my concern would be that if they’ve started with haunted houses, maybe other lessons will show other clips. Because of that, I think a friendly, calm email to the teacher (maybe asking which other clips will be shown so that you can watch them together at home first?) is appropriate. Not a complaint, just so that the teacher is aware and can support your son.

Piggywaspushed · 17/09/2023 09:01

MariaVT65 · 17/09/2023 08:54

Hi OP

I’ve just checked my DVD and it says 12, not 12a or 15. So yes, maybe a bit premature to be showing this at the start of year 7, and should probably be moved to year 8.

I get it as the film itself did scare me as an adult. I also remember seeing films like the Ring (15) at 14 years old and I shit my pants.

However, do you take your son to the cinema? If so, it may be worth talking this thing through with him, going through the trailer with him as he’ll be exposed to lots of certificate-appropriate trailers at the cinema, regardless of genre, so i’d say this reaction to a trailer may be a bit extreme.

Personally I don’t think horror films are for everyone and there isn’t a need to teach the horror genre at school. If the school is wanting to teach that particular play technique (with the same cast playing multiple roles etc), I’m sure there are other examples.

DVDs are rated 12. There is no 12A rating for DVDs. That's about purchasing.

2023forme · 17/09/2023 09:00

@Littlepopsicle i think some posters are giving you a bit of a hard time. It’s refreshing to hear that some parents are still trying to help their child navigate the growing up journey and not just exposing them to “everything” without a thought - some DC are more sensitive than others and that’s ok. I remember not allowing my DS to play certain video games which were violent / misogynistic and being told by others that “he will see it eventually and much worse”. My DS is also a sensitive soul and got very upset over things his peers didn’t- it wasn’t about us being precious, it was about supporting a child who is very empathic.

But I do think YWBU to complain about it. And I do agree that you need to help your DS build resilience but it sounds like you are already doing that and you sound like a thoughtful, sensible parent.

comedownwithme · 17/09/2023 09:00

I think the issue here is that OP has talked about complaining, had the thread been asking for advice I'm sure the replies would be speak to the teacher about your DS going forward.

It's not a complaint to the school that's needed as they haven't done anything wrong but OPDS clearly has a support need when it comes to sensitive material and that needs to be fed back

shearwater · 17/09/2023 09:00

TheOutlaws · 17/09/2023 08:56

@Littlepopsicle

Is your DS often scared of images, and does he catastrophise about them? I ask because, when I filled out the Childhood Depression and Anxiety Questionnaire for my DS1’s ADHD assessment, this was a clear marker for ADHD. I was the same as a child, I had terrible phobias of various images.

Perhaps instead of filing a complaint, you might ask school to keep an eye on your DS and feed back if they have any concerns that he might not be ‘typically’ developing?

I have one DD2 with ADHD and ASD diagnosed and she loves horror films - she does still find WiB scary though.

DD1 had an adverse reaction to a horror topic at school and is as far as we know, NT, but is highly sensitive and imaginitive.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 17/09/2023 08:59

Rather than the whole school having to accommodate your child, it would make more sense for him to remove himself from lessons when it has been sign-posted that they're about to do something scary.

You have no grounds for complaint about your child bring shown age-appropriate resources
,

Piggywaspushed · 17/09/2023 08:59

Woman In Black is a 12 A. The BBFC, that said, use it as a case study. A few years later, ratings were modified slightly to reflect intensity of response, largely off the back of complaints about WIB. It remains a 12 A notwithstanding. Sky ratings are pretty arbitrary.

Just to be clear, someone upthread mentioned 'educational purposes' and 15s , perfectly appropriately mentioning year 10. If a teacher were showing a full 15, the students need to be within a year of their 15th birthdays. Within a year of 18th for 18s, so year 12 upwards.

I wouldn't show the whole of WIB to year 7 personally as I know some students are quite scared by it. Year 8 or 9...fine with warnings.

AnneValentine · 17/09/2023 08:58

shearwater · 17/09/2023 08:32

Woman in Black was the most complained about film ever at the time in terms of whether the BBFC classification was right at 12A.

I think it should be a 15 or 18. Loads of kids being persuaded to kill themselves and die horribly is about as mature a theme as it gets.

Yet I've seen loads of films which are a 15 or 18 where there is just a bit of bad language or sexual content or brief violence, and it doesn't stay with you half as much, or bother you remotely, as a teen or adult. So the BBFC frequently get it wrong, for me.

120 complaints for perspective. Complaints in this context are irrelevant.

PuddlesPityParty · 17/09/2023 08:58

shearwater · 17/09/2023 08:56

No-one has had hysterics. A boy has had trouble sleeping due to a scary film trailer. It's ok to let the teacher know he is struggling with it. Education is very much one size fits all, and often it is not a fit, for many people. It's not ok to minimise someone else's reaction to a film clip because you were ok with it.

The hysterics is about you not the OPs son.

OPs son is probably being a bit sensitive but she’s had good advice from teachers and others and I’m sure she’ll speak to his teacher in a polite way. Jumping straight to complaining isn’t on though, especially when she doesn’t have her facts right (ie it being a 12 not a 15).

Emeraldrings · 17/09/2023 08:57

People keep saying it's a scary film but he didn't watch the film, just a trailer.
Your DS is obviously sensitive but if you make a fuss about this you are going to find secondary school very hard going. Perhaps you need a more general chat with his tutor or year head about how anxious /sensitive your son is. I say this because letting just one teacher know isn't going to help if he gets affected by things in other lessons. At least if all his subject teachers know they're in a better place to support him

shearwater · 17/09/2023 08:56

PuddlesPityParty · 17/09/2023 08:51

@shearwater also wtaf, I absolutely hate this current government and their policies.

imagine saying something like that because as a teen in high school I didn’t have hysterics over a FILM that isn’t real 🙄 some of us can separate real life and fiction.

No-one has had hysterics. A boy has had trouble sleeping due to a scary film trailer. It's ok to let the teacher know he is struggling with it. Education is very much one size fits all, and often it is not a fit, for many people. It's not ok to minimise someone else's reaction to a film clip because you were ok with it.

TheOutlaws · 17/09/2023 08:56

@Littlepopsicle

Is your DS often scared of images, and does he catastrophise about them? I ask because, when I filled out the Childhood Depression and Anxiety Questionnaire for my DS1’s ADHD assessment, this was a clear marker for ADHD. I was the same as a child, I had terrible phobias of various images.

Perhaps instead of filing a complaint, you might ask school to keep an eye on your DS and feed back if they have any concerns that he might not be ‘typically’ developing?

Christmasusernamepending · 17/09/2023 08:55

I actually watched the whole film ( well as much as you can watch in an hour) in year 7. I don't think my maths teacher really knew what it was and it was the last day of term before Christmas and he just stuck on the dvd.

PuddlesPityParty · 17/09/2023 08:55

shearwater · 17/09/2023 08:51

Still not as frightening or disturbing as a young child drinking bleach to kill herself.

And if you gave it a moment's thought, you'd realise that a trailer or clip, lacking the context of an entire film, could be scary. Maybe stop worrying about how sensitive other people are and start working on your own levels of empathy and tolerance.

That’s not in the trailer? I’ve just watched it. The scariest thing in it is probs seeing someone come out of the marsh. Have you watched the trailer - the thing the OPs son watched???? It’s not the film, it doesn’t show dead kids and everything your spouting on about. Maybe watch it.

TheLongGloriesOfTheWinterMoon · 17/09/2023 08:54

I'm an English teacher.

I'd want to know so that the pastoral team and class tutor can keep an eye on him and help him with strategies to overcome his anxiety.

It isn't usual for a Y7 to be upset over something like a film trailer, but that doesn't mean that his reaction should be invalidated.

So, yes, @Littlepopsicle I think you should tell the teacher, placing the emphasis on your son, and his reaction, and not on the school curriculum and choices of the teacher in applying it. The teacher won't have gone rogue in showing it, in an attempt to scare or shock. As it's drama, they'll have shown it to show acting skills, cinematography etc.

MariaVT65 · 17/09/2023 08:54

Hi OP

I’ve just checked my DVD and it says 12, not 12a or 15. So yes, maybe a bit premature to be showing this at the start of year 7, and should probably be moved to year 8.

I get it as the film itself did scare me as an adult. I also remember seeing films like the Ring (15) at 14 years old and I shit my pants.

However, do you take your son to the cinema? If so, it may be worth talking this thing through with him, going through the trailer with him as he’ll be exposed to lots of certificate-appropriate trailers at the cinema, regardless of genre, so i’d say this reaction to a trailer may be a bit extreme.

Personally I don’t think horror films are for everyone and there isn’t a need to teach the horror genre at school. If the school is wanting to teach that particular play technique (with the same cast playing multiple roles etc), I’m sure there are other examples.

Theimpossiblegirl · 17/09/2023 08:54

In primary we can't show anything above a u without permission.

Secondary schools have different rules I think. Both my girls watched Woman in Black at school, The Others and War Horse. Probably others. They were fine.

PuddlesPityParty · 17/09/2023 08:51

@shearwater also wtaf, I absolutely hate this current government and their policies.

imagine saying something like that because as a teen in high school I didn’t have hysterics over a FILM that isn’t real 🙄 some of us can separate real life and fiction.

whatnext3 · 17/09/2023 08:51

if it bothered you that much but it won't be logged as complaint. it will be reframed as DS has difficulties around certain things (which is fine).

shearwater · 17/09/2023 08:51

PuddlesPityParty · 17/09/2023 08:46

Honestly if he can’t handle the trailer for the woman in black without nightmares is he really gonna deal with a woman setting herself on fire??

Still not as frightening or disturbing as a young child drinking bleach to kill herself.

And if you gave it a moment's thought, you'd realise that a trailer or clip, lacking the context of an entire film, could be scary. Maybe stop worrying about how sensitive other people are and start working on your own levels of empathy and tolerance.

zeibesaffron · 17/09/2023 08:50

Its a 12a both mine did some study related to it in drama and english. I would mention it to the teacher.

PuddlesPityParty · 17/09/2023 08:49

shearwater · 17/09/2023 08:47

I'd be more worried about people who don't find WIB upsetting or scary. Loads of kids dying horribly is "mild"?

Mind you, perhaps if you are a government minister for immigration perhaps the desensitisation to such matters helps.

The trailer is mild. which is what OPs DS saw.

The film isn’t that disturbing though, especially when you’ve read the book (which I assume with it being for English they will do) and know what’s coming.

shearwater · 17/09/2023 08:47

PuddlesPityParty · 17/09/2023 08:42

It’s not that scary OP. It’s very mild. They will be reading the book for English. What’s he gonna be like when they do great expectations 🙄

I'd be more worried about people who don't find WIB upsetting or scary. Loads of kids dying horribly is "mild"?

Mind you, perhaps if you are a government minister for immigration perhaps the desensitisation to such matters helps.

43ontherocksporfavor · 17/09/2023 08:47

Probably batter to work on your son’s sensitivity to scary films. I never watch horror for the same reason and I’m 52!! It’s ok. But maybe emphasis on it being acting and how they would have laughed between takes etc Schools have rules around such things but it can still be shocking to certain pupils and there will be more to come.

Swipe left for the next trending thread