Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher showed 15 film to Y7

167 replies

Littlepopsicle · 17/09/2023 07:23

DS has just started Y7. All going well, loves his new school and is very settled.
Drama class last week, teacher told them the theme for this half term is something about haunted houses. She then showed them the trailer for The Woman in Black. DH and I eye rolled each other as soon as we heard this as we knew what was going to happen....no surprise, DS has been unable to sleep alone since seeing this. We are very careful about anything he watches as he has an overactive imagination, is easily scared and sleep is easily disrupted. DH is annoyed at having another disturbed night with DS and thinks we should complain to the school. Do you think we should complain and say this is inappropriate to show to 11 and 12 years olds, or at least parents should have been warned that this was going to be shown? Or would you say it's a non-issue, get over it, he's just an over sensitive child?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
PuddlesPityParty · 17/09/2023 11:40

Littlepopsicle · 17/09/2023 10:44

Sky shows it as a 15 💁‍♀️

Doesn’t really matter what sky says that’s their own rating as had been explained so it’s not the “💁‍♀️” slay you think it is to show it. No one disagreed that sky rated it a 15, they were explaining the official classification is a 12 so I wouldn’t be trying to use that in any contact with the school.

PuddlesPityParty · 17/09/2023 11:38

@aSofaNearYou yes but I imagine you were scared of the actual film / book / play not a 1 minute trailer of it.

Dragonwindow · 17/09/2023 11:32

zingally · 17/09/2023 11:18

Frankly, you - and your child - are going to look a right pair of numptys complaining about sleepless nights because of a "scwary fwilm" at HIGH SCHOOL.
The receptionist will put the phone down and laugh their head off.

I guess it would depend whether the receptionist had one ounce of empathy.

OP I work in a school - none of our office staff would laugh at a parent for any reason, especially not this.

StampOnTheGround · 17/09/2023 11:24

I think at secondary school it shouldn't warrant mentioning to the teacher, that would be embarrassing.

zingally · 17/09/2023 11:18

Frankly, you - and your child - are going to look a right pair of numptys complaining about sleepless nights because of a "scwary fwilm" at HIGH SCHOOL.
The receptionist will put the phone down and laugh their head off.

titchy · 17/09/2023 11:10

Random hint - watch stuff without the sound - just subtitles. Nowhere near as scary!

aSofaNearYou · 17/09/2023 10:59

Needing to sleep with parents is not a typical reaction at that age. Honestly. He’s in for a rough ride.

I was very scared of it at 14, and it affected my sleep. Similarly a different horror film when I was 11, I used to be terrified every night that the ghost was under my desk - I didn't ask to sleep with my parents because this was never something that was the norm but I can see why it would be for a child who was more used to sleeping with their parents. Bear in mind MN is usually full of people advocating cosleeping children only a couple of years younger than this, saying they will grow out of it at their own pace and be perfectly normal developmentally.

I was in no way an unusually young or anxious child, I was mature for my age, and this didn't mean I was in for a rough ride. I just found horror films scary, I'm struggling to understand why people think that is an abnormal response.

AnneValentine · 17/09/2023 10:51

Littlepopsicle · 17/09/2023 10:13

Thanks for all your responses, I wasn't expecting so many replies for something I thought wasn't too dramatic. But this is AIBU so I shouldn't be surprised by some of the responses!
Ok, maybe complain was the wrong word to use but more just to bring it to the teacher's attention to it. I'm certainly not up in arms about it ready to send off an explosive email. Being new to secondary school I'm not yet sure of the protocol for contacting teachers directly but I'm not intending to go to HOY about this.
Regardless of the rating my son was scared of the imagery/theme....not very helpful of pp's who say it's not that scary - not to you maybe but it was for my 11yr old! As for his resilience or other anxieties, definitely not an issue. Being scared of a scary film is a normal response, as many pp have said themselves, not the same as being anxious about day to day functioning. Although his sleep has been disrupted it certainly isn't affecting him in any other way. He is a well balanced, happy, healthy 11 year old.....who just doesn't like scary films! But well done those of you who have no problem showing horror films to your younger kids.

Needing to sleep with parents is not a typical reaction at that age. Honestly. He’s in for a rough ride.

comedownwithme · 17/09/2023 10:45

Sky is not the official classification.

Littlepopsicle · 17/09/2023 10:44

Sky shows it as a 15 💁‍♀️

Teacher showed 15 film to Y7
OP posts:
Marblessolveeverything · 17/09/2023 10:29

I think your Aibu are a little off. For example I don't think it is unsuitable but nor is your son overly sensitive. There is a multi billion industry making things to scare us, because some like it .

Here 11 year olds would be in their second last year of primary and Harry Potter is the go to.

aSofaNearYou · 17/09/2023 10:24

Newnamefor23 · 17/09/2023 10:15

Not withstanding film ratings the effect of a film can depend on the context in which it is shown, explanations etc.

I taught y7 1 lesson of English/week. I did the class reader. We read The boy in striped Pyjamas.

About 1 chapter/week. We talked about the context of the book, what it was based on etc. We did this slowly and had time to reflect.

At the end of the book we watched the film, over about 2-3 weeks. Again with gaps for discussion. The film is a bit more in your face than the book. Pupils were told they could leave the room if they wanted.

Looking back we probably pushed the ratings. But then we weren’t covering this book for frivolous reasons.

Whilst I wouldn’t have wished nightmares on my former pupils I hope they were shocked and went home thinking.

Other work I was responsible for with Y11’s caused tears, shock and silence.
(Google ‘Wasted Lives’ It’s down a couple)

Life isn’t all cuddly kittens and puppies, children can’t be kept from this. Life and its events can hit you hard.

These are the group who are likely to be or with drunken drivers. We as teachers can bang on about it - but what do we know.

But to see the father of a dead son speak about his death brings it home. To see the car, on a trailer, that he was killed in.

So if I caused upset. Sorry, not sorry.

(One or two including staff didn’t attend due to past events in their lives.)

Don't you think this is all quite different to a ghost story, though? That has no bearing on real life, there's nothing for them to think about and learn from it. It's just frightening, that's it. It's designed throughout to be as unsettling as possible, just for fun.

MariaVT65 · 17/09/2023 10:17

op do you know if there is any actual intention to show the whole film in class, instead of just the trailer?

I think we are reasonable in saying his reaction to just a trailer may be a bit concerning. It’s all very well raising this with school, but your son will also be exposed to similar trailers at the cinema, on tv and as ads ahead of youtube videos for example.

Newnamefor23 · 17/09/2023 10:15

Not withstanding film ratings the effect of a film can depend on the context in which it is shown, explanations etc.

I taught y7 1 lesson of English/week. I did the class reader. We read The boy in striped Pyjamas.

About 1 chapter/week. We talked about the context of the book, what it was based on etc. We did this slowly and had time to reflect.

At the end of the book we watched the film, over about 2-3 weeks. Again with gaps for discussion. The film is a bit more in your face than the book. Pupils were told they could leave the room if they wanted.

Looking back we probably pushed the ratings. But then we weren’t covering this book for frivolous reasons.

Whilst I wouldn’t have wished nightmares on my former pupils I hope they were shocked and went home thinking.

Other work I was responsible for with Y11’s caused tears, shock and silence.
(Google ‘Wasted Lives’ It’s down a couple)

Life isn’t all cuddly kittens and puppies, children can’t be kept from this. Life and its events can hit you hard.

These are the group who are likely to be or with drunken drivers. We as teachers can bang on about it - but what do we know.

But to see the father of a dead son speak about his death brings it home. To see the car, on a trailer, that he was killed in.

So if I caused upset. Sorry, not sorry.

(One or two including staff didn’t attend due to past events in their lives.)

Littlepopsicle · 17/09/2023 10:13

Thanks for all your responses, I wasn't expecting so many replies for something I thought wasn't too dramatic. But this is AIBU so I shouldn't be surprised by some of the responses!
Ok, maybe complain was the wrong word to use but more just to bring it to the teacher's attention to it. I'm certainly not up in arms about it ready to send off an explosive email. Being new to secondary school I'm not yet sure of the protocol for contacting teachers directly but I'm not intending to go to HOY about this.
Regardless of the rating my son was scared of the imagery/theme....not very helpful of pp's who say it's not that scary - not to you maybe but it was for my 11yr old! As for his resilience or other anxieties, definitely not an issue. Being scared of a scary film is a normal response, as many pp have said themselves, not the same as being anxious about day to day functioning. Although his sleep has been disrupted it certainly isn't affecting him in any other way. He is a well balanced, happy, healthy 11 year old.....who just doesn't like scary films! But well done those of you who have no problem showing horror films to your younger kids.

OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 17/09/2023 10:10

It always seems to be this film - I studied TWIB at GCSE drama as well, must be because of the stage play. I don't think YABU to complain, personally I think 11/12 is too young for this kind of ghost story, it would be too scary for most kids that age and teachers should really see that coming. In a few years things would be different, it's definitely a GCSE age story in my opinion.

Boomboom22 · 17/09/2023 09:54

Resilience develops through exposure and ability to manage situations. Not through exposure to trauma but through experience kind of in a scaffolded way.

NewName122 · 17/09/2023 09:44

I can't even watch horrors myself, I actually close my eyes if it's late and a horror trailer comes on 🤣 I dream every night, sometimes multiple times and I know 100% if I watch it my over active imagination is bringing that back to me as a nightmare

Iwishicouldflyhigh · 17/09/2023 09:44

So no 'IT' for your child then???!!!!

In all seriousness, sleep overs and scaring the shit out of ourselves was one of the highlights for me at school, so it'd be a shame if he can't watch them.

NewName122 · 17/09/2023 09:41

My son is very sensitive to stuff like this aswell. I'd mention it atleast in case there is a next time.

KrisAkabusi · 17/09/2023 09:37

I saw the film and stage play a few years ago but couldn't remember the rating, so looked it up on Sky and it says it's a 15

15 is what Sky rated it themselves. It has nothing to do with the BBFC. A 15 rating on sky means it can't be shown free to air before 8 o'clock unless its on a channel that needs a PIN to stop kids accidentally seeing it.

MariaVT65 · 17/09/2023 09:32

notmetodayagain · 17/09/2023 09:25

I was that age when I went to a sleepover at a friend's house and someone found a VHS (yeah, I'm that old) of a movie called Cats eyes. Can't remember what it was about but it scared the crap out of me. I couldn't sleep for two nights and drove my parents spare but on the third night, after repeatedly reassuring me it wasn't real and I was safe, they told me no more creeping into their bed in the middle of the night. They left the hall light on and reassured me they were next door but otherwise I had to battle this one out alone. Remarkably I survived and a monster didn't eat me.

I also started learning self-regulation and resilience. So I wonder if really this is the time to start that? If he's getting scared of a Halloween episode on a sitcom, then he might need to toughen this one out. He's quite likely to see pretty scary stuff on phones belonging to his friends etc so this is a good time to start with this life skill.

Good luck!

Maybe there is also a difference between psychological horrors and more physical violence.

I also remember being at a year 7 birthday party aged 12 and being shown Scream 2 on VHS (woohoo!). Our parents were called for permission first, but I absolutely loved it and have been a huge scream fan ever since.

The Woman in Black did scare me more even as an adult, like with the rocking chair scene, but I am still of the opinion that this reaction to a trailer is on the extreme.

AnneValentine · 17/09/2023 09:26

BBno4 · 17/09/2023 09:14

100% serious and she is a normal, well adjusted child.

I'm shocked that a y7 child would react over a trailer like this.

Don't you watch YouTube trailers with your kids? They loved watching I.T trailers on YouTube and jump scares.

Lots of kids enjoy horror genre. I’m amazed anyone is concerned re your situation but can’t see the issue with a year 7 kid sleeping in parents beds over a trailer.

notmetodayagain · 17/09/2023 09:25

I was that age when I went to a sleepover at a friend's house and someone found a VHS (yeah, I'm that old) of a movie called Cats eyes. Can't remember what it was about but it scared the crap out of me. I couldn't sleep for two nights and drove my parents spare but on the third night, after repeatedly reassuring me it wasn't real and I was safe, they told me no more creeping into their bed in the middle of the night. They left the hall light on and reassured me they were next door but otherwise I had to battle this one out alone. Remarkably I survived and a monster didn't eat me.

I also started learning self-regulation and resilience. So I wonder if really this is the time to start that? If he's getting scared of a Halloween episode on a sitcom, then he might need to toughen this one out. He's quite likely to see pretty scary stuff on phones belonging to his friends etc so this is a good time to start with this life skill.

Good luck!