Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher showed 15 film to Y7

167 replies

Littlepopsicle · 17/09/2023 07:23

DS has just started Y7. All going well, loves his new school and is very settled.
Drama class last week, teacher told them the theme for this half term is something about haunted houses. She then showed them the trailer for The Woman in Black. DH and I eye rolled each other as soon as we heard this as we knew what was going to happen....no surprise, DS has been unable to sleep alone since seeing this. We are very careful about anything he watches as he has an overactive imagination, is easily scared and sleep is easily disrupted. DH is annoyed at having another disturbed night with DS and thinks we should complain to the school. Do you think we should complain and say this is inappropriate to show to 11 and 12 years olds, or at least parents should have been warned that this was going to be shown? Or would you say it's a non-issue, get over it, he's just an over sensitive child?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
thiswasabadone · 18/09/2023 13:12

aSofaNearYou · 17/09/2023 15:31

It's Christmas coming soon they will possibly show you story or the grinch and then he won't sleep until Easter 🙄

What is the need for these kind of comments? TWIB is a horror film designed to scare adults, the grinch is obviously not.

😂

jcyclops · 18/09/2023 00:56

Woman in Black starring Daniel Radcliffe is rated 12A by the BBFC. The original edit obtained a PG-13 in the USA, but the makers made cuts to two scenes (totalling 7 seconds), and also darkened the detail in some scenes and reduced the volume in places in order to secure a 12A rating from the BBFC rather than the 15 the original edit would have received.

After a few complaints about the 12A rating, the BBFC conducted a public test in which 89% agreed with the 12A rating and 11% thought it should be 15. The DVD release of the cinema edit was given a 12 rating, and the original edit was given a 15 rating. Details from www.bbfc.co.uk/education/case-studies/the-woman-in-black

The cinematic trailer was rated 12 for the 12A film see:
www.bbfc.co.uk/release/the-woman-in-black-trailer-qxnzzxq6vlgtodq2mjuw

Note there is also a 1989 version made for ITV and starring Adrian Rawlins and Bernard Hepton for which the DVD has a 15 rating.

Piggywaspushed · 17/09/2023 21:48

No, but I don't think I know better then the BBFC who rate that film at 12A. I don't teach WIB. But I do know I do not need to seek parental consent for 12A films when an entire class is 12+.

Goodness, only a few weeks ago many on MN were taking 5 year olds to Barbie.

DragonFly98 · 17/09/2023 21:43

Piggywaspushed · 17/09/2023 13:35

I don't need your permission, though, if students are of appropriate age! Year 12s and 9s will all be 12 and over. I'd warn them, to acknowledge different reactions.

It's not about what you legally need to do , you don't know each individual child parents do so you do the right thing and check. Do you feel superior because you can choose to give a child nightmare?

TeenDivided · 17/09/2023 15:51

I do find on MN there are often posters who think their children are superior for not being sensitive, for being able to watch over age films / play over age games without impact, and somehow that those of us whose children could not cope have somehow failed as parents.

Personally I feel that, if a child can watch a significantly over age film (which I know is not the case here before people jump on me) without impact, maybe that child has been desensitized by seeing other things at too young an age.

Children mature at very different rates, especially between the ages of say 10-14. Parents of less mature, or more sensitive kids should not be made out to have failed in their parenting or that their children are 'lesser'.

aSofaNearYou · 17/09/2023 15:31

It's Christmas coming soon they will possibly show you story or the grinch and then he won't sleep until Easter 🙄

What is the need for these kind of comments? TWIB is a horror film designed to scare adults, the grinch is obviously not.

thiswasabadone · 17/09/2023 14:51

Just youtubed the trailer. All the comments on it saying how everyone apparently watched it in school lessons and they are traumatised from it. That was the whole film though not the trailer. So your not the only one who has a child that overthinks these kind of things. Just beat in future to tell your child if there's a movie going to be shown to excuse himself from the class. Give him a note if needs be. It's Christmas coming soon they will possibly show you story or the grinch and then he won't sleep until Easter 🙄

Piggywaspushed · 17/09/2023 14:40

Tend to agree PT but it was a drama lesson. I don't think they were studying the text.

Princessandthepea0 · 17/09/2023 14:40

My year 8 child would die with embarrassment and call you a neek for being that parent.

PermanentTemporary · 17/09/2023 14:36

It just seems completely unnecessary to me. Reading a book and watching a film are separate experiences and age ratings are part of that. If a book doesn't make sense unless you show a frightening film to children in school, study something else.

TheLightProgramme · 17/09/2023 14:07

My dd is year 8 and absolutely not "fine with warnings" yes it's a 12 A but you should me asking for parental permission to show that film it's highly inappropriate

Well no. A y8 child is at least 12, and so it is not highly inappropriate to show a 12 rated film as part of an educational topic.

A young person that age should have the sense/maturity to look away/ask the teacher if they can step outside if they are finding something really uncomfortable. Processing negative emotions like fear, disgust, sadness, anxiety is a really important skill for young people.

TheLightProgramme · 17/09/2023 14:03

There's a directors cut type version which rated 15, and the widely distributed version which is rated 12A on BBFC. School will have shown only the material from the 12A and the trailer likely isn't even as scary as that.

It sounds like you baby your DS op. "Sweet"? This is a secondary age kid!

If he's getting very affected by a scary film it sounds like generally you've sheltered him a lot - at his age he really does need to have the resilience to be able to cope with a scary film without a run of sleepless nights.

Boomboom22 · 17/09/2023 13:52

Piggy is right. Generally primary schools show pg from year 1 up and don't tell you. Yr 7 to 8 12 amd 12a. Yr 9 depends but if head of year has authorised or possibly parents told could watch a relevant 15 or clip of 15. Yr10 on 15 is fine, year 12 18 is fine but I'd expect it to be clear on sign up, eg film studies a level your child will watch 18s.

10HailMarys · 17/09/2023 13:51

Littlepopsicle · 17/09/2023 10:44

Sky shows it as a 15 💁‍♀️

That’s Sky’s own classification, not the BBFC rating. I don’t think Sky actually recognises 12A as a rating at all. The DVD is rated 12.

In any case, if your son only saw the trailer, the trailer will likely have a lower rating than the film itself. It’s very common for 15/12 films to have a PG trailer.

Piggywaspushed · 17/09/2023 13:35

DragonFly98 · 17/09/2023 12:11

My dd is year 8 and absolutely not "fine with warnings" yes it's a 12 A but you should me asking for parental permission to show that film it's highly inappropriate. I am still affected as an adult by horror films I was exposed to as a young teen.

I don't need your permission, though, if students are of appropriate age! Year 12s and 9s will all be 12 and over. I'd warn them, to acknowledge different reactions.

Delpf · 17/09/2023 12:33

I'm mid thirties and avoid horror trailers at all cost as I know they'll freak me out for months. I'm a perfectly sensible and capable person - I just have an overactive imagination. 🤷🏻‍♀️

It's good for him to recognise that he's sensitive to horror films and that he should avoid watching them. Next time he'll know to cover his eyes!

DragonFly98 · 17/09/2023 12:11

Piggywaspushed · 17/09/2023 08:59

Woman In Black is a 12 A. The BBFC, that said, use it as a case study. A few years later, ratings were modified slightly to reflect intensity of response, largely off the back of complaints about WIB. It remains a 12 A notwithstanding. Sky ratings are pretty arbitrary.

Just to be clear, someone upthread mentioned 'educational purposes' and 15s , perfectly appropriately mentioning year 10. If a teacher were showing a full 15, the students need to be within a year of their 15th birthdays. Within a year of 18th for 18s, so year 12 upwards.

I wouldn't show the whole of WIB to year 7 personally as I know some students are quite scared by it. Year 8 or 9...fine with warnings.

My dd is year 8 and absolutely not "fine with warnings" yes it's a 12 A but you should me asking for parental permission to show that film it's highly inappropriate. I am still affected as an adult by horror films I was exposed to as a young teen.

aSofaNearYou · 17/09/2023 12:07

Obviously if you don’t like horror don’t, but if you watch the trailer for the woman in black it’s really not that scary. Mainly the use of creepy music lol! Doesn’t allude to much of the more horror bits that happens in the film

I'll watch it later but I vaguely remember it from the time - the worst thing for me in horror films has always been shots where something slowly comes out of the shadows, and TWIB was full of that, I'm pretty sure it featured in the trailer too. Must have had the classic rocking chair and music box too, which would have creeped me out.

WonderingWanda · 17/09/2023 12:02

I'm a teacher and parent of a 11yo and 13yo. I've just watched the trailer and age rating aside it is fucking creepy and I wouldn't have shown it to a class full of brand new year 7's. My 11yo is scared by lots of things but the older one isn't so had watched lots of quite scary things. Not all y7's are 12 so I wouldn't have shown a 12 without checking with parents first either. I don't think it would hurt to point that out to th teacher. Maybe they could move that particular unit to the end of y7's for example.

SoupDragon · 17/09/2023 12:02

https://www.bbfc.co.uk/education/case-studies/the-woman-in-black

This is interesting. There are two different versions - one that had about 6 seconds cut to make it a 12A and one uncut is a 15. The one on Sky must be the uncut version.

The Woman In Black

The Woman In Black

The Woman In Black is a film version of the 1983 ghost story by Susan Hill, written in the style of a traditional gothic novel.

https://www.bbfc.co.uk/education/case-studies/the-woman-in-black

SoupDragon · 17/09/2023 11:57

She then showed them the trailer for The Woman in Black

What did she show them, the film or the trailer? Sometimes the trailer isn't rated the same as the film.

Mumof118 · 17/09/2023 11:47

I just watched the trailer and think it’s a good example of drama/ suspense building/ atmosphere etc for a drama class. It will likely have inspired a lot of the class in ways perhaps Toy Story 2 might not have.

In my opinion, it’s silly to complain about and a message about ‘sensitivity to children who get scared easily’, is also quite ridiculous.

Perhaps remind your son that the acting is pretend and then ignore it any further so he doesn’t see your reaction as validating his fear.

PuddlesPityParty · 17/09/2023 11:45

aSofaNearYou · 17/09/2023 11:41

Hmmm in this case yes, but there were certain horror film trailers that really freaked me out growing up. Often when I saw the actual film it was less scary than the trailer, because the trailer is all the scariest bits plus you don't get to see the silly prosthetics at the end that take away the sense of dread.

Obviously if you don’t like horror don’t, but if you watch the trailer for the woman in black it’s really not that scary. Mainly the use of creepy music lol! Doesn’t allude to much of the more horror bits that happens in the film

Cheeesus · 17/09/2023 11:45

I just watched the trailer - it’s fairly creepy.

And he won’t necessarily see that sort of trailer at the cinema. They don’t tend to advertise a film that’s very different from the main feature.

aSofaNearYou · 17/09/2023 11:41

PuddlesPityParty · 17/09/2023 11:38

@aSofaNearYou yes but I imagine you were scared of the actual film / book / play not a 1 minute trailer of it.

Hmmm in this case yes, but there were certain horror film trailers that really freaked me out growing up. Often when I saw the actual film it was less scary than the trailer, because the trailer is all the scariest bits plus you don't get to see the silly prosthetics at the end that take away the sense of dread.